"She’s also nervous that running one clunky sentence through an AI tool might make an admissions officer doubt her integrity. Meanwhile, her inbox keeps filling with emails from colleges explaining how well she’d fit in. They note her interests. They seem to anticipate her questions. They sound almost chatty. But who wrote them? And was it the same technology she’s been warned to avoid?"
From "Colleges Demand Authenticity From Applicants. Do They Owe Students The Same?" (Forbes).

18 comments:
A headline with a question? The answer must be no.
Why would the college's demand of prospective students imply a reciprocal obligation for the college?
Oh, dear! The AI monster is out from under the bed torturing some poor teenager's conscience. (Because we all know what paragons of virtue our universities are.)
Colleges’ use of AI for recruitment improves efficiency and student support. Predictive tools and chatbots handle high volumes of inquiries, personalize outreach, and free staff to focus on meaningful interactions, helping institutions identify strong candidates and reduce costs while improving the overall applicant experience.
Discouraging AI-generated essays from applicants protects authenticity and fairness. It ensures admissions officers evaluate genuine student voices, critical thinking, and individual experiences rather than polished but generic AI text, maintaining academic integrity and a more level playing field for all candidates.
it WAS ok, that i had grok write that.. wasn't it?
no that we have AI,
NO ONE needs to think (about ANY THING) ANY MORE.
Just let AI do all the lifting! It's GLAD to help.
Also, now that you have free time; if you could mention the location of Sarah Conners, that would be a nice gesture!
In Vonnegut's novel, Player Piano, the engineer hero invented a device for cats to wear that made them better at catching mice. Were they still cats, or were they puppets controlled by the device that interfaced with their brain? Does it matter? I don't know anymore.
First software came for the easy jobs, like properly formatting and spell checking letters with your KayPro to send by snail mail. Now it climbs the value chain seemingly inexorably. Nobody knows what the future really looks like, but I know that the way I made my living is dead.
Somebody has to say it.
Authenticity: if you can fake that, you've got it made.
Wow, gilbar's quoted little disquisition by AI perfectly provides us with the approved narrative we are all supposed to accept... Excuse me, the "consensus" view of the use of AI.
BTW, what is this "meaningful work" that AI refers to?
College admissions have long been a squalid business. If young people have been questioning that lately rather than just being excellent sheep or lambs led to the slaughter, it's all to the good.
Somebody had to say it.
We built our own alien overlords, and I, for one, welcome their arrival!
(I hope they heard me.)
Assuming any college entry essay was ever written by the actual student was stupid to begin with . . . plus, the entire point of the essay was to allow colleges to subjectively pick whatever entrant they wanted without appearing to be using (or could be proved to be using) racial/ethnic/sexual criteria.
Should lawyers be penalized for slugging boiler plate text into their documents?
College students get a lot of coaching on how to write essays. That probably includes editing after the essay is written, but I doubt many have their essays entirely written for them. Having been seduced by the colleges into applying, the students are trying to seduce the colleges into accepting them. A squalid business. Would a truly "authentic" essay without all the little hooks and attention-grabbing gimmicks actually help a student get in?
Why does an essay even matter anymore for college admissions? All they care about is you race, gender, and sexual orientation. It's all a big joke.
I was parked near a local High School just yesterday. The high school students were grouped and meandering in the parking lot. It was rather startling to see the way they act and dress.
*****
the entire point of the essay was to allow colleges to subjectively pick whatever entrant they wanted without appearing to be using (or could be proved to be using) racial/ethnic/sexual criteria.
*****
Meanwhile in China, there is no such thing as a college application essay. Or interviews. Or extracurriculars. Or DEI/affirmative action. Or letters of recommendation. Or even GPA.
Every high school senior sits for the Gaokao, a grueling 3-day exam given each June. It's a multiple choice exam with no electronic devices of any sort allowed in the testing room.
Starting with the top scorer and then proceeding downwards, each student wins admission to the school he or she ranked most highly that still has openings in its incoming class. About 5% gain entry to one of the top-tier selective institutions like Peking University or Tsinghua University. Fewer than 40% get admitted to any 4-year bachelor's program. Below that level, another 40% are accepted to a 3-year vocational training program comparable to community college here.
Every seat is filled by the time it gets down to the 20th percentile, and those below the cutoff are doomed to a life of manual labor.
They are going to eat our lunch in the medium to long term, especially as their propaganda effort to demonize AI and data centers among ignorant Westerners seems to be bearing fruit.
So many college applications and essays these days are managed by consultants hired by wealthy parents to help their kids get in ... this whole battle against AI use in essays ignores the professionals who outline and edit essays for some kids.
Our neighbors hired one for their son as so many at this prep school were using consultants to help with the process.
Here's an issue with AI. Colleges can just ask AI to aggregate all information available about an applicant, including an admission submitted, then ask AI to rank how that candidate meets its inputs of approval criteria versus all the other applicants. And the submitted application will be just a small percentage of all the aggregated data, which will include all social media for the lifetime of the candidate.
Social scores work so well in China, do you think they won't here?
Post a Comment
Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 4 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith. Also: No italics, even briefly. Use asterisks for emphasis. And don't play with the format by changing fonts or using boldface or all caps. Never include more than one extra line break between paragraphs.