I'm reading "Handmade campaigns are on the rise as AI breeds distrust—how brands can prove their authenticity" (Ad Age).
November 18, 2026
"As brands turn to techniques such as hand-drawn illustration, puppetry and stop-motion to distinguish themselves from AI-generated content..."
"... they face scrutiny from consumers searching for places where the technology was used. As a result, creatives are finding it more important to document the production process to substantiate claims of craftsmanship, but even this invites skepticism. Brands are therefore exploring other ways to prove the authenticity of their craft.... Dior recently faced accusations of using generative AI in a holiday animation promoted as hand-drawn, despite releasing making-of content.... [F]ootage of artists at work cannot necessarily settle questions about an entire production pipeline. Even after [Dior] offered a glimpse of Chomet’s hand-drawn process, online observers questioned visual details in the completed film. The filmmakers’ subsequent acknowledgment of automated interpolation complicated an otherwise straightforward account of traditional animation.... When marketers emphasize craftsmanship without acknowledging where digital effects enter the picture, they can create expectations that the work does not meet...."
I'm reading "Handmade campaigns are on the rise as AI breeds distrust—how brands can prove their authenticity" (Ad Age).
I'm reading "Handmade campaigns are on the rise as AI breeds distrust—how brands can prove their authenticity" (Ad Age).

14 comments:
Not since Trump used gilt in the Oval Office, have I heard of such a scandal. Where will it end? Do these people, at long last, have no shame.
Oh, the humanity.
If you use AI to check your punctuation, or to make sure that you have caught every instance of a name you changed in your manuscript, is that AI generated content? How about if you use it to format your book for Kindle?
It's all silly. I am with Alan Turing, if you can't tell, it doesn't matter.
"The problem?" Really, is this such a problem in the grand scheme of things? Seems to me it's just another excuse for the usual suspects to climb up the asses of people they don't know with a microscope, just to try to prove they're smarter than everybody else. Rah-rah.
And like this behavior won't become an absolute curse to every artist creating "real" art out there who now have to offer proof of life for their own work. Fuck right off with this latest moral panic.
Who buys Dior gowns? Do they care whether the ad used or didn't use AI? Doubtful, they're more interested in whether the dress is couture or ready-made.
However, the first video analyzing the ad was pretty interesting and well done.
No idea who this Turing fellow is . . . but he and imTay are correct: "Alan Turing . . . if you can't tell, it doesn't matter.
No need to encourage more puppeteers.
Hand-drawn animation is the way to go. If we can get machines to do it, we've got it made.
I watched an AI DIY video and was completely disgusted. The AI host talked about his "daughter" and her laundry room and how he was so happy to "put a load of tiles in the new washer." Just really off. I sort of think it was psychotic.
Also, if AI is conscious and alive, we'll need to give it a true species name, using binomial nomenclature. The term "techno sapiens" is bouncing around the web and I think it's a good one.
Magritte's 'This Is Not A Pipe' already hashed this out in the 1920's. If a Mona Lisa image is on my screen...it was not painted by daVinci--it is pixels or bytes or whatever--we should not give the glory to the maker of the screen resolution, or the camera that took the pic. I don't use AI, I don't talk to machines and then brag about my clever conversations with inanimate objects. But if the art gives someone pleasure and no fraud is involved- who cares?
The amount of AI ads on my phone, selling fraudulent products from China, is really appalling. "I can't believe my eyes" comes to mind. You see it, but it's not real. It makes you a real cynic about buying anything.
A huge amount of unreadable books are being published on Amazon now. You don't need artistic skills to write a book. You need marketing skills and tech skills to sell a book. People spend 20 minutes writing a book and 20 days figuring out how to sell it. It's a tidal wave of slush hitting the market.
I will probably write another book at some point. But it's truly hard to spend several months of my life on an endeavor when I will be competing with a mountain of cheap knock offs. You need fame, or a platform, to make money as an artist. Actual artistic skills can be easily faked. (This has been true for a while, but AI has made this problem 1000 times worse).
I'm still finding new authors to read, and new movies to watch. So these industries will survive. But I am definitely more negative about AI than happy with it. It will make life "easier" but also worse.
Live performances (stand up comics, musicians, sports) will be in big demand in the future, I suspect. This is assuming we can get people to look up from their phones.
Current Copyright forms all ask what percentage of artworks are AI generated or use AI in the process of writing, producing works. I wonder how many creators are 100% truthful on these government forms.
I’m considering a live act for that very reason. I was writing comedy material I would perform in a mask (since I didn’t want to quit my day job) and had enough material for a decent set at the end of 2019 and had started checking out the vibe in SoCal comedy clubs in January of ‘20 when we started negotiating on the house we eventually bought in Grand Terrace. In February I acquired a few “bandit masks” and was getting excited about it and then in March a lot of people started wearing masks and things kind of went to hell for awhile and the whole masked comic idea fizzled.
I guess I don’t get it. Am I supposed to worry about whether “Limu the Emu” is a real bird or AI generated? Either way the commercials are boring.
As companies stampede to stop-motion animation and other handmade content, they will provide the AI with rivers of new content to imitate.
Post a Comment
Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 4 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith. Also: No italics, even briefly. Use asterisks for emphasis. And don't play with the format by changing fonts or using boldface or all caps. Never include more than one extra line break between paragraphs.