September 26, 2026

"But critics argue the bare nails trend actually says something about class, the hamster wheel of beauty standards, and who gets to define what is considered tasteful."

"Nail art's historical and creative roots are linked back to black, Latino, and Asian communities and the suggestion that bare nails are now a sign of high status could stigmatise bold manicures, they say. 'That trend really promotes blankness and this kind of sameness and erasure of culture and identity that is so important to black and brown communities,' beauty journalist Kristina Rodulfo tells the BBC. 'They are often called elegant or tasteful, and these are often usually euphemisms that perpetuate white supremacist standards of beauty.'"



Anyone who thinks the nails in that photo are unpolished must be the kind of person who thinks vanilla doesn't count as a flavor. But vanilla is a great flavor, and a thin coat of light pink nail polish is great way to paint your nails.

Anyway, if I prefer vanilla ice cream, it takes nothing away from your enjoyment of Rocky Road. If you want to be a maximalist, just be a maximalist. Don't try to bully minimalists into promoting the maximalist agenda. We're not "erasing" you! But maybe that's a hint about why people are drawn to maximalism: Is there a fear that unless you go big and bold and loud you might cease to exist? Quietness is not "blankness."

48 comments:

Sydney said...

Amen, Althouse. Amen!

Big Mike said...

“But vanilla is a great flavor”

Althouse and I agree on something!

“and a thin coat of light pink nail polish is great way to paint your nails.”

And she even agrees with my wife!

imTay said...

Wasn't this a theme in Player Piano by Kurt Vonnegut, where the higher the status, the less one was required by law to consume? So a senior executive might have a simple desk of maple or oak, and a lower clerk would have a desk so embroidered with all. kind of filigree and friezes and bas relief that it looked like one of those harps in the Judy Garland movie "The Good Old Summertime."

The theory was that since robots did all of the work, the excess production had to be consumed somehow, and so it fell on the lower classes to consume the output. This is also the novel where the AI robots decided that the directive to "never harm a human" required them to lock the entire human race into individual padded cells.

Achilles said...

Those fingernails are not natural. They are covered with something that turned to enamel.

john mosby said...

In his last few battles, Wellington dressed in civilian clothes. Part of this was because he saw warfare as almost an industrial process and disdained pomp/circumstance. Part was because he perversely became more conspicuous for his simplicity. A courier looking for the Field Marshal might ride to the flashiest guy on the battlefield and find he was talking to the assistant shit-shoveler. But once they knew Wellington was in that era's equivalent of the grey flannel suit, they could zoom in on him. CC, JSM

john mosby said...

Grant similarly wore the plainest possible blue frock coat that qualified as a uniform. He showed up for meetings with Lincoln and didn't bother to brush the mud off his boots. CC, JSM

rehajm said...

It’s gel polish. Acrylic that’s uv hardened. I use it to paint lettering on watch bezels and cases…

Lem Vibe Bandit said...

I thought "diversity" was our strength.
Next thing you know, bare nails wont be allowed at the lunch counter. Crying about it will only encourage more.
Can we picture a bare nails only beach?

n.n said...

Nude nails with an acrylic coat.

Iman said...

Q: What’s the BBC’s favorite garden?

A: Kindergarten

That outfit can go proper rodger themselves…

Dr Weevil said...

How long before the accusation is extended to men who don't paint their nails? Am I a white-cis-male supremacist because I don't paint my nails, never have, and never will? It does seem likely that men - sorry, born-male human beings - who paint their nails are disproportionately gay, bisexual, cis, whatever.

Original Mike said...

Can't we worry about important stuff?

Mason G said...

"Can't we worry about important stuff?"

Such as- Why did the woman in that photo pick out a sweater to wear that has sleeves that are way too long?

Aggie said...

'OhMiGod ! You're doing nothing, and it's offensive !' The oppressive, tyrannical horror of whiteness.

Fred Drinkwater said...

You can get a polish like that with just a set of fine buffing blocks. No paints. But, doing that to often seriously thins and weakens the nail.

Fred Drinkwater said...

There's nothing new since Veblen.

Also I was wrong about those nails. Buffed, sure, but also obviously painted.

Fred Drinkwater said...

Although Fussell's book "Class" is decent.

Just an old country lawyer said...

Lord above! Blighty has much bigger problems right now than the imperial blankness of white women's fingernails. Of course, listening to the BBC one would think that the imperialism of white people was their biggest problem.

FullMoon said...

Boring. I like the custom nails with expensive low rider type paint jobs.
Everytime you compliment a womans nails, she will hold her hand out for you to get a closer look.
I hold their hand and say "I want a paint job like that on my Impala.
Still embarrassed about kissing the pretty cashiers hand, but she was flattered
I avoid that store now..

baghdadbob said...

Vanilla is the White Supremacist of flavors.

FullMoon said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Deep State Reformer said...

It's not a class marker so much as a racial preference. Either/or but fancy expensive nails are kind of lame.

Indefinitely Extended Excursion™️ said...



Bare nails have become a manicure flex. Long decorated nails were never a status symbol among the chic. Bare nails can also be predicated on the demands of some types of hard work. Rather than seeking inferences about status or culture from our nails, perhaps we should understand that it is normal and healthy to have different preferences.

Lazarus said...

Tough decision. Insult BIPOC culture by culturally appropriating nail painting or insult BIPOC culture by slighting nail painting? It's like you can't win.

Indefinitely Extended Excursion™️ said...

It’s like the minimal make-up look: backed by pricey treatments and potions. A class statement.

I wonder if the ubiquitous hair extensions will be the next thing to look “cheap”, now that they are more affordable.

I think there’s also a rejection of the Mar-a-Lago look here too. Those women will not be going bare-nailed, minimizing their injectables and make-up or taking off their extensions.

Iman said...

“I hold their hand and say "I want a paint job like that on my Impala.”

A funny name for a schwanzstucker!

Big Mike said...

“john mosby said...

Grant similarly wore the plainest possible blue frock coat that qualified as a uniform”

The fact that it did not identify him as a high value target for Confederate sharpshooters was helpful too. Never forget the famous last words of Union Major General Sedgwick as he came up some troops cowering behind over from the fire of a distant Confederate sharpshooter: “Get up boys, get up. The Rebs couldn’t hit an elephant at this dist …”

Iman said...

Nails? Now do eyelashes.

Peachy+2 said...

Everything is a fight - when you work for the corrupt left.
F the BBC. They are Jew hating toads, too.

Not an oldster. said...

Silence is death.

Not an oldster. said...

If you believed what you were saying, you'd practice it.

Minimalists dont bleach their hair and brag of spending hundreds on sephora lipstick and creams. They dont post so many pictures of themselves and their sons either.

We dont have to brag or compare. We know our worth. You are the one sucking up to this crowd... Dave begley grrl? Come on.

Not an oldster. said...

Next thing ann will be preaching about the beauty of a flat white ass...lol.

Rocco said...

From the article…
“Nail art's historical and creative roots are linked back to black, Latino, and Asian communities…”

Confirmed nail art goes back at least 5,000 years across cultures across the globe.

Rocco said...

In addition one of the ancient civilizations - Babylonians, IIRC - used the colors of nail polish as rank insignia.

n.n said...

Girls with long, toned, shielded... fingernails. The feminine aesthetic is dynamic, but not unlimited. Forewarned is forearmed. We need reasonable arms control.

rhhardin said...

The important modern thing is nail polish remover, which takes off superglue.

gspencer said...

Black females don't just have their nails done. They get a set of ten slashing stilettos. To the point that they can't use the keypads on their phones (which actually is a good side benefit for the rest of us).

Dude1394 said...

Democrats are silly and stupid.

Dr Weevil said...

Iman (4:24pm):
"Impala" is a perfectly cromulent name for a schwanzstucker! It's a non-rhotic (e.g. Bostonian) dialect variant of "Impaler".

john mosby said...

Fullmoon, Weevil and Iman - for convergence with the other post, "Hi, I'm Irwin. The Impala." CC, JSM

Rocco said...

gspencer said...
“Black females don't just have their nails done. They get a set of ten slashing stilettos. To the point that they can't use the keypads on their phones (which actually is a good side benefit for the rest of us).”

Several decades ago, I saw a billboard ad that had a beautifully manicured female hand with inch long nails wrapped around the neck of a bass guitar. No way she could play that thing.

J Scott said...

I seem to recall a related controversy around lower status health care professionals pushing back at the mandate that they trim their nails so as to not puncture their nitrile gloves that they HAD to wear.

wildswan said...

"Faultily faultless, icily regular, spendidly null." Tennyson on an English upper class woman at a party, sitting.

Bunkypotatohead said...

It's a good thing if white women are starting to reject that ghetto gov't employee look.

Nancy Reyes said...

most physicians don't use nail polish because of worry about spreading infection
But from a practical standpoint, washing one's hands with a scrubber and/or using alcohol based hand cleaners thirty times a day does tend to mess up your nail polish.

Not an oldster. said...

I like black women.
I like their hair, nails and ways of proudly carrying themselves... lashes, loudness and all.

Men like meade will still prefer hypocritical "plain janes" like Ann. You dont see strong confident black women poundeing down on aging, sick in the head white ladies who want to impress you with their daily physical efforts but who still have time to lecture and punch down at other people personal style....

Your hair, ann.
Until you fix that, dont talk about the attention seeking aesthetic. Don't serve them up as negative fodder for your old boys assembled here.

Stick with public figures like Obama who have unjustly enriched themselves, not working black women looking good... )and yes boys, you CAN work with long nails using ypur finger pads...no black women here to correct you... thrpese debates and discussions ann is hosting is like shooting at fleeing children... there is nobody left here to play defense.Ann and meade killed off honest open comments years ago... and claimed she felt doooo threatened she had to buy a gun and contact police even reported false charges publicly because she doesn't know who is commenting and manipulating her blog... Jeremy freese springs to mind but it's easier to publicly accuse and point fingers at... lessers.


Do you try to be non likeable, ann, or have you always been such a judgemental bitch?

Kassaar said...

https://spectator.com/article/why-the-bbc-is-so-obsessed-with-drag-queens/?edition=us

Mr. D said...

"Not our kind, dear" is a full-time gig.

Post a Comment

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 4 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith. Also: No italics, even briefly. Use asterisks for emphasis. And don't play with the format by changing fonts or using boldface or all caps. Never include more than one extra line break between paragraphs.