December 15, 2025

"To commemorate the abolition of slavery, the [Citizens Coinage Advisory Committee] had recommended an image of Frederick Douglass on the obverse and shackled and unshackled hands on the reverse."

"To honor women’s suffrage, a World War I-era protester carrying a 'Votes for Women' flag. And to evoke the civil rights movement, a 6-year-old Ruby Bridges, books in hand, helping to desegregate the New Orleans school system in 1960. [Secretary of the Treasury Scott Bessent, authorized by law to make final decisions about coin designs] opted instead for the more general, and much whiter. For the Mayflower Compact, a Pilgrim couple staring into the distance. For the Revolutionary War, a profile of Washington. For the Declaration of Independence, a profile of Thomas Jefferson. For the Constitution, a profile of James Madison. And for the Gettysburg Address, a profile of Lincoln on the obverse, and on the reverse, a pair of interlocking hands. No shackles."

From "The War on ‘Wokeness’ Comes to the U.S. Mint/The Treasury Department unveiled new coins celebrating America’s 250th anniversary. They failed to include planned designs featuring abolition, women’s suffrage and the civil rights movement" (NYT).

It does seem that the celebration of the 250th anniversary should concentrate on things that happened around 250 years ago, not on later events, but even Bessent's 5 choices include 2 that are not from the era of the founding. The Mayflower Compact is over a century earlier, and the Gettysburg Address is almost a century later. 

This sentence bothered me: "Mr. Bessent opted instead for the more general, and much whiter." What's with the comma? I'd get rid of it and replace it with either nothing or an em dash. Or put "and much whiter" in parentheses.

You can see Bessent's coins here, and go here to see what the committee recommended, including this:


Those shackles! (And that fist.)

Are negative things put on coins?

ADDED: I believe it has been the practice of the U.S. government, throughout its history, never to put something negative on a coin. Consider the history of the "Chain cent" of 1793. It showed a 15-link chain that was meant to represent the 15 states, but after some people interpreted the chain to mean slavery, it was replaced. It only lasted from February to March of 1793. The idea that it might depict something negative was enough to kill it. The tradition of positivity should be recognized and adhered to — especially for a coin that celebrates an anniversary.

81 comments:

rehajm said...

We must reject bigotry in all its forms, including the ones the left likes…

Truthavenger said...

Good. Stop the wokeness.

Beasts of England said...

That proposed quarter is horrific, and the fist is absurd.

Bob B said...

It would have been nice to see a Frederick Douglass coin. He is noted for a statement true both then and today for Black Republicans:
“"I am a Republican, a black, dyed in the wool Republican, and I never intend to belong to any other party than the party of freedom and progress."”

rhhardin said...

How do you pick cotton with shackles on?

rhhardin said...

Disparate impact returns to coins. No more Sasquatch dollars.

Birches said...

Just reading the description made me think it was one of the most tone deaf ideas of woke ever conceived. But it actually was sincere! So bad. Thank goodness competent people are in charge right now.

rhhardin said...

Reissue the penny with some woke hero on it.

Beasts of England said...

The ‘Emerging Liberty’ dime is nice looking. And good on little Jimmy Madison for getting some coinage cred - very well deserved!!

tim maguire said...

I have nothing against honoring Frederick Douglas, but the shackles image looks like something you’d see in a twitter meme. That the author can’t see how inappropriate it is for a coin in circulation tells me they have no judgment.

R C Belaire said...

What the hell is a "Citizens Coinage Advisory Committee", and who picks its members? Sounds like a feel-good operation set up by some progressives years ago and more/less forgotten, and I'll bet money is involved.

rehajm said...

I like birds on coins. cats doing silly things would be fun

rehajm said...

The Far Side cartoons would be perfect. I’d collect them all…

Saint Croix said...

So I googled the Citizen's Advisory Coinage Committee. Never heard of it. They have 11 members. Ten of them got the job in the Biden administration.

Saint Croix said...

I'm a big fan of Frederick Douglass. Very patriotic. Loved our Constitution. I have zero objections to him on a coin. But putting a black power salute on the reverse is clearly a bad idea. How about a photocopy of the Declaration of Independence? (Jefferson's original draft!).

Breezy said...

I’m bothered by the “and much whiter” phrase in and of itself. There’s no proof race was a factor in the decision.

Saint Croix said...

And it's not just a black power salute. First, you show slavery, a huge negative from our history. And then you show the black power salute? Why would we celebrate either of those things?

I don't think any of the people on the committee were Douglass scholars. And if they were, they missed some obvious stuff.

Saint Croix said...

The ‘Emerging Liberty’ dime is nice looking. And good on little Jimmy Madison for getting some coinage cred - very well deserved!!

It's weird how Madison has been kept off our currency. The architect of our Constitution! I've always thought that the Article 1 and Article 2 branches must be subconsciously mad at him.

Leland said...

If they made a coin “"To commemorate the abolition of slavery”, shouldn’t it be positive of the new young country that ended much of the ancient world wide activity?

Temujin said...

Oh for the love of God, stop the madness. When will it ever be enough for the left? Do we all need to parade around the streets, generation after generation flogging our own backs until bloody?
Commemorate the nation with a coin bearing shackles? Please. That entire mentality needs to dry up and blow away.

Beasts of England said...

’I've always thought that the Article 1 and Article 2 branches must be subconsciously mad at him.’

It’s the only explanation! :)

Howard said...

It's this type of anti-woke antics that Trump trumps because he has completely sold out MAGA to the globalist billionaires. Does this help you forget Marjorie Taylor Greene? How about the fact that no regulatory reform or curbing of the administrative state has taken place? I guess he figures that it's enough for him to just call people garbage and to keep garbage people off our money.

narciso said...

Yes they were clueless and evil

Eric the Fruit Bat said...

What's important to remember is so many Black children went on to become architects and civil engineers once they learned the ancient Egyptians were Black, same as them.

boatbuilder said...

Frederick Douglass probably should have been on a coin a long time ago (maybe instead of Sacajawea). That cartoon black power salute is BS.

rehajm said...

I’m okay with a rock paper scissors coin..:

narciso said...

You see how they went with the 1619 fallacy then burns went with the iriquois foolishness

Enigma said...

Way back in 1989, the Italian fashion brand Benetton ran ads showing a white guy handcuffed to a black guy. It was 'meant' to show that we are all in this together and be proto-PC, proto-woke, and anti-racist. The ad got skewered by the left for showing a white guy (e.g., police) hancuffing a black guy (e.g., criminal).

Projection never goes away. Global attitudes toward black people never change, despite the left routinely protesting too much. Putting chained fist symbolism on a coin would rehash the 1968 Olympics fists and this 1989 ad. The left has no memory for its own denials, projections, and screwups.

https://artsandculture.google.com/asset/archivio-benetton-handcuffs-institutional-advertisement-oliviero-toscani/wQGtuCBwksIxnw?hl=en

Kevin said...

What's with the comma?

Gru: Pause for effect…

Achilles said...

Those shackles! (And that fist.)

The point here is to lie and say that the black man freed himself.

Rather than tell the truth that thousands of white men died going to war with the Democrat Party to free the slaves and create the second place in the world where slavery was illegal.

Democrats are just evil people.

G. Poulin said...

I'm looking forward to the new Francisco Franco half dollar coin.

Christopher B said...

The Gettysburg Address coin doesn't address the abolition of slavery? Why do people think a 5 minute speech by a country lawyer has been remembered for 160 years?

rehajm said...

We got pretty good with stamps for a while. In my drawer are lawn games, even Jarts!, Arnold Palmer, hummingbirds, Jeopardy!….

Rusty said...

Go back to putting lady liberty on our coinage. The standing liberty quarter and the walking liberty half dollar are some of the most beautiful in the world.

Achilles said...


Howard said...

It's this type of anti-woke antics that Trump trumps because he has completely sold out MAGA to the globalist billionaires. Does this help you forget Marjorie Taylor Greene?

Howard is more likely to be right than not.

On his present path Trump will still have Larry Fink in meetings around the world.

Then during the primaries the desantis wing republicans will start with Desantis. Rage when nobody supports him. They will move to Larry Thiel's protege who will have all of the money and support.

Then everyone will wonder why the working class republicans start supporting someone who is "groyper adjacent." This person will say we need to stop sending money to Israel and we need to stop bombing people. He will promise to break the hold blackrock/vanguard/statestreet have on single family homes. There could even be talk of banning robots taking people's jobs. They will promise to end H1b's and promise to deport ALL illegals as fast as possible. Not this less than a million a year bullshit we are getting.

If people were smart they would address this now. But they aren't smart. Desantis wing republicans want to do the same thing to the groypers that democrats did to black people.

Democrats at least promised to give black people stuff. Romney wing Republicans will just call them antisemitic.

Michael said...


Check out that Chad George Washington. Based.

CJinPA said...

"Let's define our nation as its people's struggle against it."

"How does that fit into the celebration?"

"The struggle is the only thing WORTH celebrating."

narciso said...

The Times are a self hating gang of misfits proppec up by a Mexican oligarch the notion they ever accidentally have a clue is the first time

Remember 'every day is January 6th'

Kevin said...

Kenya Barris wrote a hilarious 8-episode comedy series about a Nouveau riche black family in Beverly Hills coming to terms with their wealth and their blackness. He called it #BlackAF.

Here are the episode titles:

S1.E1 ∙ because of slavery
S1.E2 ∙ because of slavery too
S1.E3 ∙ still... because of slavery
S1.E4 ∙ yup, you guessed it. again, this is because of slavery
S1.E5 ∙ yo, between you and me... this is because of slavery
S1.E6 ∙ hard to believe, but still because of slavery
S1.E7 ∙ i know this is going to sound crazy... but this, too, is because of slavery
S1.E8 ∙ i know you may not get this, but the reason we deserve a vacation is... because of slavery

Kai Akker said...

---- How about the fact that no regulatory reform or curbing of the administrative state has taken place?

So far, true. Got another 12 months, nitwit Rs.

----The left has no memory for its own denials, projections, and screwups.

Weirdly true. It works on them, so it should work on everyone. They have to keep blowing all the time to keep that balloon up. Or, perhaps any noise is good, it distracts a few from the plain truth.

Big Mike said...

and the Gettysburg Address is almost a century later.

Fourscore and seven years later.

narciso said...

Howard isnt serious about anything except whatever tripe talking point he is given

Kevin said...

I’m bothered by the “and much whiter” phrase in and of itself. There’s no proof race was a factor in the decision.

Disparate impact.

Kai Akker said...

---- This sentence bothered me: "Mr. Bessent opted instead for the more general, and much whiter." What's with the comma?

What's wrong with the comma? And maybe we should use that "whiter" more often. A reminder of who did the vast majority of the seeing, shaping, and creating. British traditions are good, too. Some societies are better than others.

Bob Boyd said...

US Mint issues commemorative coins. Women and minorities hardest hit.

Aggie said...

"...They failed to include planned designs featuring abolition, women’s suffrage and the civil rights movement" (NYT)...."

Don't think of it as a 'War'. Think of it as a restructuring. The Democrats have always been stuck on the theme of emancipation, because it allows them to claim to be leaders without any of the heavy lifting or liability of consequence to others.

Whiskeybum said...

That fist image looks like something straight out of DC Comics.

William said...

Many reputable scholars and historians claim that white men were instrumental in the founding of this nation. However, as the anniversary draws near, it is important for us to take a moment and remember all the things they got wrong. If slaves and women had been adequately represented at the Constitutional Convention, I'm sure none of these mistakes would have happened.

boatbuilder said...

Golf clap for Big Mike 8:28.

Kevin said...

"...They failed to include planned designs featuring abolition, women’s suffrage and the civil rights movement" (NYT)...."

Love the language here by the NYT. "Failed to include" goes beyond "didn't," or "chose not to".

No they "failed" in their implied duty by the NYT to do so, making their decisions wrong and themselves unworthy of choosing.

Beasts of England said...

’If slaves and women had been adequately represented at the Constitutional Convention, I'm sure none of these mistakes would have happened.’

Maybe four-fifths would have helped…

Ambrose said...

Coins? How quaint.

rehajm said...

I'm looking forward to the new Francisco Franco half dollar coin

…though I appreciate the restraint in memorializing him prematurely…

john mosby said...

Should have done an Obergefell coin, showing a cock with a wedding ring on it penetrating a nice classical man's butt, like the one on the Discobulus. CC, JSM

Paul said...

The war is over... 250 years ago we had a discussion on slavery in the USA...it was settled... now get a life.

RCOCEAN II said...

Thank God. Enough the fucking leftism and anti-Americanism being shoved down our throats. We have enough things celebrating and centering 13 percent of the population. And if you want to put a woman on the coin - put Phyliss Schafly on it.

RCOCEAN II said...

The reason the Left is always bringing up slavery, racism, and segregation, isnt' because they love black folks, its because they always want to keep racial tensions boiling and induce race solidatrity among blacks. Having blacks vote 80-90 percent Democrat is the key to the keeping Leftists in power in many states.

RCOCEAN II said...

They're not "Clueless" they're anti-American.

gspencer said...

RCOCEAN II has it right. Enough. MLK Day, February, June 19th, and plenty of TV advertising & oodles more.

So why aren't their SAT scores better?

Lazarus said...

The country's on an uncomfortable slope -- wanting to be "inclusive" without tearing itself apart. We can't think about our history in the sunny or heroic terms we once did, but reducing it to "Selma, Seneca Falls, and Stonewall" is also a distortion as well as a slighting of our past.

Achilles said...

William said...
Many reputable scholars and historians claim that white men were instrumental in the founding of this nation. However, as the anniversary draws near, it is important for us to take a moment and remember all the things they got wrong. If slaves and women had been adequately represented at the Constitutional Convention, I'm sure none of these mistakes would have happened.

I know you were making this point in a nicer way but it is time to say things out loud.

White Men were responsible for the freedom and massive wealth that has been created over the last few centuries.

Women and “minorities” were along for the ride.

There are two options. One is to respect everyone including white men and respect what white men built.

The other option is a revenge tour.

Women and “diverse peoples” should choose wisely.

Clyde said...

I’ll take Bessent’s patriotic versions, thank you very much.

RCOCEAN II said...

Maybe he went with "Much whiter" because every important poltical figure until MLK was white. And because blacks make up 13 percent of the country.

MadTownGuy said...

Saint Croix said...

"I'm a big fan of Frederick Douglass. Very patriotic. Loved our Constitution. I have zero objections to him on a coin. But putting a black power salute on the reverse is clearly a bad idea. How about a photocopy of the Declaration of Independence? (Jefferson's original draft!)."

Why not the Emancipation Proclamation?

RCOCEAN II said...

Here's another good woman for a coin: Mary lease populist political leader and the author of the saying: "Raise less corn and more hell"

RCOCEAN II said...

Or Claire booth Luce. Or Jeanette Rankin. Who said - "As a woman, I can't go to war, and I refuse to send anyone else".

Enigma said...

Just yesterday VisualCapitalist released a chart showing the full history of European colonialism (1450 to 2000).

https://www.visualcapitalist.com/charted-the-number-of-european-colonies-by-country-1450-2000/

Without European boat technology and colonialism there'd be no white people in North America and no post-colonial home-ruled USA to follow. The white people alone brought Greco-Roman, Christian, and post-English Civil War philosophies and government systems here. So, any memorial of the USA must address simple history.

Diverse Chinese, Middle-Eastern, and African people had literally nothing to do with the USA's founding or ideology. Oliver Cromwell and Martin Luther were highly relevant. This coin outcome is shocking only to the wishful and ignorant.

Greg The Class Traitor said...

So, let's just get this straight:
The Dem plans for the 250th Anniversary of the Declaration of Independence was to commemorate many things, but NOT the Declaration of Independence?

Yeah, every single one of their coins has to be dumped, no exceptions.

People who hate America shouldn't be given a voice, and the Dems hate America

Mason G said...

If the coins are supposed to celebrate the country's 250th anniversary, is it really too much to ask that an effort be made to develop designs that represent the country as a whole and not selected, favored groups within it?

Big Mike said...

@boatbuilder, a golf clap is more than I expected.

Enigma said...

@Mason G: designs that represent the country as a whole

Are we marking what happened 250 years ago (all white men from Europe) or a contemporary DEI program? Do you want rainbow flags and gender diversity flags and Google's AI black Nazis on these coins?

IMO, the ONLY point in marking a calendar event, i.e., 250 years after the revolution of 1776, is to look back to history for what happened exactly 250 years ago. There's a time and place for inclusion and a time and place for remembering the past with precision.

Christopher B said...

It seems to me entirely appropriate to commemorate events that inspired and represent the preservation as well as perfection of the Constitution, in addition to events specific to its adoption.

The whining that you don't think it was/is perfect, not so much

Stephen said...

How on earth is the abolition of slavery, even if inspired by righteous anger (his terrible swift sword) not positive?

Greg The Class Traitor said...

Stephen said...
How on earth is the abolition of slavery, even if inspired by righteous anger (his terrible swift sword) not positive?

We got that, with Lincoln.

Making a coin to commemorate slavery, OTOH, which is what they did, is bad

Greg The Class Traitor said...

G. Poulin said...
I'm looking forward to the new Francisco Franco half dollar coin.

Will that one have a helicopter dumping communists out of it on the backside?

boatbuilder said...

Big Mike--a golf clap from me is the highest of accolades.

Stephen said...

How about those other terrible negative things, women's suffrage and Ruby Bridges? If abolition is bad, we've got to nix them, too. Meanwhile, of course, plans proceed for a Donald Trump sesquicentennial coin. Everyone is positive about him!

Known Unknown said...

We are in a Woke Recession

gadfly said...

rhhardin said...
How do you pick cotton with shackles on?

Use a mechanical cotton picker. The machines have been around for a long time.

Ralph L said...

Two other rejects: TWEET

Ampersand said...

The Mayflower Compact is widely regarded as a forerunner of the US Constitution. It emodied self government, consent of the governed, and commitment to just and equal laws.

Post a Comment

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.