Write Matthew Gwyther — producer of the BBC documentary, "Sucking Up: A Guide to Sycophancy Through the Ages" — in "From the Garden of Eden to the president's Cabinet meetings, apple-polishing has a sorry history" (WaPo).
Yes, I know this is one more example of kicking Trump around over an oft-noted character flaw, but the essay is well-written, it refers not only to Dickens but also to Milton, Shakespeare, and Machiavelli, and I'm interested in this theory that the numerosity of synonyms signifies the importance of the concept.
In that light, here's an excerpt from Geoffrey K. Pullum's 1991 book "The Great Eskimo Vocabulary Hoax":
Some time in the future, and it may be soon, you will be told by someone that the Eskimos have many or dozens or scores or hundreds of words for snow. You, gentle reader, must decide here and now whether you are going to let them get away with it, or whether you are going to be true to your position as an Expert On Language by calling them on it.
The last time it happened (other than through the medium of print) was in July 1988 at the University of California's Irvine campus, where I was attending the university's annual Management Institute. Not just one lecturer but two of them somehow (don't ask me how) worked the Eskimological falsehood into their tedious presentations on management psychology and administrative problem-solving. The first time I attempted to demur and was glared at by lecturer and classmates alike; the second time, discretion for once getting the upper hand over valor, I just held my face in my hands for a minute, then quietly closed my binder and crept out of the room.
Don't be a coward like me. Stand up and tell the speaker this: C.W. Schult-Lorentzen's Dictionary of the West Greenlandic Eskimo Language (1927) gives just two possible relevant roots: qanik, meaning 'snow in the air', or 'snowflake', and aput, meaning 'snow on the ground.' Then add that you would be interested to know if the speaker can cite any more.
This will not make you the most popular person in the room. It will have an effect roughly comparable to pouring fifty gallons of thick oatmeal into a harpsichord during a baroque recital. But it will strike a blow for truth, responsibility, and standards of evidence in linguistics.
Speaking of alternative words, do I need a synonym for "Eskimo" to talk about this trope? I would think that to discuss a conventional idea, I would need to put it in the conventional form, not paraphrase it for politeness. People haven't been saying the Inuit have dozens of words for snow.
But, anyway, that's getting into the problem of whether the synonyms are numerous. I want to look at the question of the meaningfulness of the numerosity of synonyms. In English.
I see "English has 3,000 words for being drunk" (BBC). We can start there.
54 comments:
yeah - no one ever sucked up to Bill Clinton , Obama and Crook Joe.
No one - ever.
What are these people going to do when Trump is gone? Amping up this kind of TDS rhetoric against Vance or Rubio just isn't going to work. I really think that they are going to collapse into nothingness.
Surely the Eskimos have a third word to describe "Yellow Snow."
h/t F. Zappa.
I'm old, so I know for the left, the next guy is always worse than the last guy. But Trump has taken them to a whole new level that they can't really amplify for the "next" guy.
The biggest boot lickers in history are the current crop of American media soviet democraticals who refuse to say or report any negative news about their party.
...and go all in for censorship on behalf of that party (D)
I knew there were a lot of different words to describe being drunk. No look up how many there are for genitalia -- male and/or female.
Trump's cabinet support him.
OH NO!
The corrupt global left expect leakers, back stabbers and Vindmans all over the place.
A little self-reflection by the TDS sufferers would go a long way in lessening their mental affliction and foaming at the mouth.
Let's have a serious talk about what's still going on with Obama.
Obama didn't have sycophants, he had "wingmen."
kowtowing is Bad, and Horrible, and WRONG..
IF the person you are doing it to is an Evil Republican.
Being in Awestruck Awe of a lightbringer is Just EXPECTED..
https://www.nationalreview.com/the-campaign-spot/magic-lightbringer-messiah-not-new-terms-obama-jim-geraghty/
The rare kind of attuned being who has the ability to lead us not merely to new foreign policies or health care plans or whatnot, but who can actually help usher in a new way of being on the planet, of relating and connecting and engaging with this bizarre earthly experiment. These kinds of people actually help us evolve. They are philosophers and peacemakers of a very high order, and they speak not just to reason or emotion, but to the soul…
https://obamamessiah.blogspot.com/#google_vignette
Is Barack Obama the Messiah?
"... a light will shine through that window, a beam of light will come down upon you, you will experience an epiphany ... and you will suddenly realize that you must go to the polls and vote for Obama" -
Barack Obama Lebanon, New Hampshire. January 7, 2008.
Oprah wasn't bootlicking when she declared Obama to be "The One." She was just IDing the Messiah.
Would a female "journalist" offering to fellate Bill Clinton be considered sucking up?
Distasteful and unimaginative but well written . . . so more of the same.
'...Trump can’t resist a temptation known since the fall of man....' The rest of the article hides behind a paywall demanding subscription, but fortunately I ๐๐๐ able to resist this temptation.
Do not get sucked too deeply into Inuit vocabulary. Medicare won't cover another CAT scan.
Not so sure. The most valuable member of a command team is the one who's not a yes man. The trick to it is A) being diplomatic about it and/or B) providing solution, not just critique, in private. Be willing to let leadership pass your idea off as their own. Do it more than once and most of the time you'll see your star rise...unless the boss is a certified dick in which case watching their face eat rake is uniquely gratifying.
Plus, I notice there's only one word for 'synonym'.
All of the massive Fraud that occurs under blue-watch - and the media (D-soviet) are silent.
on 2nd thought; i see what the WaPoo is saying..
O'Bama (and Biden (AND Clinton)) had people to tell them..
what to do, what to say, which way to pose, everything.
They were clothes horses that did what they were instructed to do.
Trump, on the Other Hand, does NOT take orders..
Certainly not orders from the Mainstream Media.
This is their problem with Trump.. and why they MUST Destroy him
Hugh Hewitt
@hughhewitt
"Imagine millions of Americans believing the U.S. was not winning the battle with Germany in March of 1945. That’s where we are today vis-a-vis Iran. Incredible. And it’s not for lack of actual facts reported widely. It is the consequence of the mental prison of TDS."
…one Thanksgiving in Vermont after fried turkey and a few Rieslings we decided Vermonters had a strong dozen or so…
Considering how Trump's first administration was derailed by officeholders who subverted his initiatives would it be any surprise if he wanted more loyal and obliging subordinates this time around?
But do we really know the inside workings of the Trump White House? It sounds like DJT does get pushback and then goes on to do what he intends to do. Does he listen to the feedback? Is he ever dissuaded by it? I don't know, but I doubt that Rubio and the others are just yes men and yes women.
Televising Trump's cabinet meetings does two things libtard Death To America Democrat Party members hate:
1) Presents actual transparency in governance
2) Shows the charm, humor, command and intelligence of President Trump
Anyone else remember during Trump's first term when the schmucks and scumbags of congress were deadlocked on some stupid shit, so President Trump brought the leaders including Pelosi, Schumer, and McConnell to a meeting at the White House and had it broadcast live? Trump ran the meeting like a boss, treated everyone fairly and respectfully and gave everyone a fair hearing, asking what their individual concerns and desires were. Huge contrast to pussy-ass Purple Lips who dismissed his political opponents with a snide "I won", and gave them the finger.
Peachy+2 said...
"Hugh Hewitt
@hughhewitt
"Imagine millions of Americans believing the U.S. was not winning the battle with Germany in March of 1945. "
Or more recently, being told by Cronkite -- after our victory in the Tet Offensive -- that the Vietnam War was (removes glasses thoughtfully) a stalemate.
"We'll frolic and play, the Inuit way, walking in a winter wonderland."
Peggy Noonan, Obama goonin'
The real boot lickers and sycophants are the corrupt leftist media. They bootlick false narratives for the Soviet left.
non-stop hate rage and lie fuel.
Molly Bloom
or shall I wear a red yes and how he kissed me under the Moorish wall and I thought well as well him as another and then I asked him with my eyes to ask again yes and then he asked me would I yes to say yes my mountain flower and first I put my arms around him yes and drew him down to me so he could feel my breasts all perfume yes and his heart was going like mad and yes I said yes I will Yes.
These guys must have missed the entire Obama presidency. Fancy that!
Yes has a signature effect. You say yes, and then you have to say yes to that yes. A wedding band that goes next to the ring.
>"the more vindictive he is toward those not inclined toward Uriah Heepishness,<
"Uriah Heepishness" - really, Matthew Gwyther? It took some work to come up with that ostentatiously overwrought phrase instead of using "obsequiousness," the obvious word. Your Holofernesness is showing, Matt.
I have a Pixel Watch. It uses Google Health for its phone interface. Google Health was always terrible, but recently they rolled out an AI "improved" version of the app that was just dreadful and everyone hated it. They're allegedly working on it. One of the specific things they're trying to fix is "excessive sycophancy".
Daily - there are probably hundreds of examples of MEDIA (D) lies.
Here is Just ONE example of the leftwing media (D) - lying.
Heck, skiiers have more words for snow than Inuit - powder,
corduroy, packed powder, corn snow (and its larger, icier variant death cookies), slush, ice, blue ice, hardpack, crud, probably more that I am missing.
Maybe Trump actually sees the bootlickers as sniveling, cowardly bootlickers, something that may be useful to him down the road. Remember what he did to Romney? Justin Trudeau? All the left and much of the old school right are incapable of the thought that Trump knows how to manipulate people at a high level.
Booze, money and sex. If we humans are really made in the image of God..... it must be a very material universe.
There are things that are important, and there are things, perhaps not so important, whose very concept fills and expands the mind. Life would be very challenging without our elbows. To some extent our very existence hinges on it. Despite its importance how many synonyms and nicknames exist for the word elbow. In contrast to the word elbow, let us ponder tits. Pondering tits is one of mankind's most cherished activities. There are over 600 synonyms and slang words for breasts in stark contrast to the elbow which doesn't have a single slang term..........Toadyism inspires all sorts of gestures from courtly bows to abject kow-tows. The care and feeding of our superior's ego is part of the workday and has an outsized importance to the actual work.. Thank God, AI will soon replace us in the evolutionary chain. We're a failed experiment..
Instead of "Eskimo", how about DEAP. They are not early American people, since they are alive in the present. However they are Descendants of Early American People.
In Canada they like to refer to them as "Indigenous People" but indigenous really refers to their ancestors. Properly speaking, they are descendants of indiginous people. Or DIPs
John Henry
Any person in Trump's cabinet who wishes to criticize the boss can. He might lose his job, but that's it. Then he'll move on to a big book deal and maybe a Nobel Peace Prize. There's toadyism, but it's voluntary and you can choose to go rogue. Compare that to what happens to, say, an academic who thinks, say, Jason Arday is a humbug. His career is over.
Good leaders ask for honest feedback and ideas. Good followers, once a decision that is not their preferred one has been made, disagree and commit.
Diversity of empathetic, sympathetic, selfie euphemisms.
They lived throuugh the obama years right
"I want to look at the question of the meaningfulness of the numerosity of synonyms."
ai "In an article about Yiddish and Language Ideologies, the author (Language Jones) explains that because Yiddish is a contact language blending Hebrew, German, and Slavic languages, it naturally results in having more than one word for the same concept or object."
Begs the question; how much "contact" has English had?
I think we can all agree it’s contemptibly, appallingly despicable when their narcissist demands his bunghole be meticulously serviced with loving tongue-baths, but deliciously, compellingly appealing when our narcissist demands the same.
As for the credibility of the BBC, remember when they demanded justice at the highest levels for the children of Rotherham? Me neither. Or how about the recent video of their correspondent cowering under a “Russian bombardment” stirring the Ukrainian women walking her dog nearby to ask if he was all right? Britain is toast. The BBC is a symptom.
The insistence on using Inuit instead of Eskimo is an example of the "hypercorrection" phenomenon.
"Eskimo" is an Algonquian word that is not found in the native languages of any of the related circumpolar indigenous people of Siberia, Alaska, Canada, and Greenland, the major divisions of which are the Aleuts, Yupik, Inuit, and Inupiat. The Aleuts have usually been distinguished from the other three tribes, which came under the umbrella term "Eskimo" .
In recent times the populous Inuit tribe has come to deprecate the exonym of "Eskimo" in favor of their native endonym of "Inuit", and their close relatives the Inupiat have gone along with it. Woe to the Canadian university professor or government functionary who disregards the politically correct term and uses "Eskimo" instead.
But their more distant Alaskan and Siberian cousins in the Yupik tribe, like Todd Palin, embrace the term Eskimo and dislike being called Inuit, which they are not. Aleuts are also insistent on not being lumped with the Inuit. "Alaska Native" is an acceptable term for either, as well as the Inuits, if one cannot go to the trouble of actually finding out the relevant tribal name. Woke white liberals who are conspicuously politically correct in their usage of "Inuit" to refer to Yupiks and Aleuts are committing a faux pas at least as grave as using "Eskimo" for an Inuit.
In my view, any group of people has the right to be called by the name they prefer. Our own endonym is "American", and I very much dislike being told by Latin American MEChA types and patronizing white leftist wokesters that we have to call ourselves "Unitedstatesians" because Spanish-speakers consider "America" to be one entire continent comprised of North and South America together.
So by the same token, in my limited interaction with Alaska Natives, I've tried to call them by the specific tribal name they prefer. Likewise with the tribes close to me in Arizona, many more of whom I am personally acquainted with. I try to use "Dine" for the Navajo, "Ndee" for Apache, "Moqui" for the Hopi, "Yavpe" for the Yavapai, and so on. Although the Hopi are famously easygoing people and don't really care, in fact the tribe makes some money off selling "Don't Worry, Be Hopi" T-shirts in visitor centers and souvenir stores on the rez.
“Now look up how many there are for genitalia -- male and/or female.”
There is a pretty good list in this vlog from Nikki Osborne interviewing Colin Mochrie.
" I am the law. When I speak, that is the law. When I present my backside, it is etiquette to smile and to apply the lips respectfully. It is more than etiquette; it is a cherished national privilege, guaranteed by the Constitution." - from the play, The Madwoman of Chaillot, by Jean Giraudoux (1943)
***
powder,
corduroy, packed powder, corn snow (and its larger, icier variant death cookies), slush, ice, blue ice, hardpack, crud, probably more that I am missing.
***
Let's see, off the top of my head there's Sierra cement, mashed potatoes, sastrugi, hoar, wind crust/wind slab, graupel, and if you get into the terminology that ski patrolmen and avalanche control pros use, it gets much more technical and complicated.
Does it cover how the press sucked up to Obama, Biden, and Harris?
No?
Then, as always from the Left when the subject is Trump, the article is worthless shit
Post a Comment
Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 4 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith. Also: No italics, even briefly. Use asterisks for emphasis. And don't play with the format by changing fonts or using boldface or all caps. Never include more than one extra line break between paragraphs.