February 21, 2026

"Don’t allow this broken culture to send you a message that you’re a bad person because you’re a man, because you like to tell a joke, because you like to have a beer with your friends or because you’re competitive."

Said JD Vance, last year, quoted today in "Bench Presses, Pull Ups … Kid Rock? The White House Had a Very Manly Week/President Trump’s top cabinet officials are pumping iron in public" (NYT).

The Vance quote appears near the end of the article, right after: "Mr. Trump’s latest masculinity proclamations sum up this administration’s hard-line approach to maleness, where the most powerful men in the country can just relax and be men who appreciate other men — in a strictly manly way, of course."

Right after the Vance quote, we get: "All of this hints at a powerful political current that politicians like Mr. Vance and Mr. Trump instinctively know how to channel."

The article ends with 2 quotes from law professor Joan C. Williams: "One of the only arrows in [Trump's] quiver is being the man" and "Picking wars all around the world, that’s what’s really going on."

It's not fair to judge the NYT article — by Katie Rogers — without watching this for context:
ADDED: "Let’s Talk About RFK Jr.’s Workout Pants/Our health secretary is a jeans guy, and he knows it" (The Atlantic)(gift link).
Why was the HHS secretary bathing in a pair of pants? The video never provides an answer for this question, even as Kennedy plays pickleball, then mugs for the camera, then soaks in a Jacuzzi with a glass of milk, all while still in jeans. It’s just bizarre—a PSA that presumably has been dialed in by his staff to maximize its WTF effect.... 
The secretary’s jeans are self-aware. Kennedy’s proclivity for working out in belted denim long predates the knowing wink with which it’s now displayed.... Kennedy is a jeans guy.

I’ve worked out, off and on, for more than 30 years—and for all of that time, the jeans guys have remained a steady presence on the rubber floors. They are sometimes taciturn, sometimes chatty. They often pair their jeans with boots, as Kennedy will do, and with a T-shirt or a tank top or a hoodie....

Not everyone enjoys the company of the jeans guy. Some see him as a threat. Planet Fitness once made a point of banning denim in the gym.... 
What motivates the jeans guy? No one knows....

64 comments:

Money Manger said...

The Venn diagram intersection between people who regularly bench press, and people who are in the NY Times target reader demographic, is an empty set.

Lazarus said...

Surely, Trump has more than two arrows in his quiver. How many did other presidents have? But if you only have two arrows, wouldn't you want one to be being a take-charge guy? Isn't that the one that makes the difference?

Nancy said...

RFK Jr looks incredible!

Lem Vibe Bandit said...

You never see RFK Jr in shorts. Althouse nods.

Birches said...

That video is hilarious. They knew what they were doing when they made it.

Ampersand said...

The NYT could start selling daily calendars with entries highlighting yet one more reason to despise Trump and his allies. The only problem is that its customers would then have no need for the newspaper.

ronetc said...

Can an archer have more than one "only arrow"?: "One of the only arrows in [Trump's] quiver." Maybe one of the few in the NYT enemy view; or a quiverfull to supporters.

tcrosse said...

The NYT would be fine with it if it was a couple of gay guys at the proverbial YMCA.

Eric the Fruit Bat said...

Professor Williams needs to be rebuked for using a combat metaphor. Or a sports metaphor. Or a hunting metaphor.

Take your pick.

Curious George said...

"Lem Vibe Bandit said...
You never see RFK Jr in shorts. "

That's because he skips "legs day."

Aggie said...

LOL RFK working the leg machine with his dress shoes on. Honestly this video is ridiculous, which was their intention I guess. Kid Rock, known fitness maven.

Dogma and Pony Show said...

His father and uncle were Norma Jean's guys.

Eric the Fruit Bat said...

Where I work we're not allowed to have too many irons in the fire. Somehow it got to be sexual harassment.

Eric the Fruit Bat said...

We're also not allowed to say some days you get the shaft. Okay, I can see the problem there.

The judge said...

Good one, Dogma

baghdadbob said...

William Tell had two arrows in his quiver.

wild chicken said...

That's funny, one of the Epstein "victims" said that she thinks Epstein was taking too much testosterone because he was ripped, but his junk had shrunk.

I don't know what made me think of that

Dave Begley said...

Does law professor emerita Althouse have a reply to Joan C. Willams?

Sydney said...

I always assumed he worked out in jeans to hide track marks.

SGT Ted said...

Better than a picture of Rachel Levine and Sam Brinton at the gym.

Smilin' Jack said...

“That's because he skips "legs day."”

Yeah, you always suspect that of guys who wear long pants in the gym.

Sydney said...

OK, I watched the video and now I am even more convinced he wears jeans to hide needle track marks. Why else would you jump into water wearing jeans?

rehajm said...

WHOLE MILK is a great caption for just about any photo…

Dave Begley said...

“Described as having “something approaching rock star status” in her field by The New York Times Magazine, Joan C. Williams is a scholar of social inequality and a prominent public intellectual. Williams is the author of 12 books and 116 academic articles in law, sociology, psychology, medical and management journals.”

And I’m sure not a word worth reading in those 12 books and 116 academic articles. Liberal, identity politics trash.

Saint Croix said...

Don't allow this broken culture to send you a message that you're a bad person because you're a man.

Out on the mean streets, it's a man's world.

On the internet, it's Mean Girls, 24/7.

imTay said...

I was just in a little shop and they had a pink hat for sale with "Dump Him" emblazoned on it in even brighter letters. It's conditioning, and it's affecting me too, this morning I played Casablanca again, and it's a great movie, but you know what my thought was at the end? No way that tart is worth it, Lazarus and Rick should have got on the plane together.

What feminism indoctrinated women to believe is that love is transactional, and you know what? We men are getting the hint. Maybe a pre-feminism Ilsa was worth the sacrifice, but today? Fend for yourself, honey.

Earnest Prole said...

“One of the only arrows in [Trump's] quiver is being the man"

Donald Trump is manly in an ornately fabulous, puffy-orange sort of way, not that there’s anything wrong with that.

rehajm said...

There used to be this print and tv ad for some lab with this doctor guy who was RFKJ’s age and ripped like him. Looks funny. Old guys look good lean and fit, not jacked…

rehajm said...

…speaking of Venn diagrams, if I may be catty for a moment, the union of the inguinal crease and old man gut sets…

imTay said...

A man needs a woman like a fish needs a bicycle.

Dave Begley said...

No tag for Joan C. Williams.

A tag is the ultimate currency.

n.n said...

Is it diversity or Diversity? Sex or sex-correlated gender? All's fair in lust and abortion... some bray to relieve 'burdens"... a summary judgment of pride and prejudice.

Matt said...

Why are woman allowed to write about men’s issues? Pretty sure that’s a no-no when it goes the other way.

mccullough said...

The Matriarchy has made a hash of the culture

tommyesq said...

quotes from law professor Joan C. Williams: "One of the only arrows in [Trump's] quiver is being the man"

And you and yours, Professor Williams, made things so bad that Trump still won the election. Think about that...

Wince said...

I see this as continuing the legacy of Jack Lalanne, minus the one-piece jumpsuit.

Unhealthy Eating Habits and Diseases

paminwi said...

Why do people obsess about RFK’s jeans? It’s just his way. Just like Trump’s is to wear a suit all the time. He’s not going to be caught shuffling across the sand flipping into a beach chair napping like Old Joe did?
Another Althouse nitpick about someone she may think is traitor to the cause.

Old and slow said...

Sydney, IV drug use rarely leaves lasting marks, and if he had visible scars on his legs, he'd sure as hell have them on his arms as well.

Jupiter said...

"It's not fair to judge the NYT article — by Katie Rogers — without watching this for context: ..."
Unfair it may be, but if it was printed in the NYT, and it was not a paid advertisement, then it is a pack of lies. And Katie Rogers is a doody-head.

Jupiter said...

"One of the only arrows in [Trump's] quiver is being the man"

Yeah, Joanie, he's pretty much a one-trick pony. You ditzy broad. Drop and give me 20!

boatbuilder said...

Wait. I thought Trump was our gay president. I guess that was Yesterday.

Jupiter said...

Now, this is impressive. To me anyway.

Rustygrommet said...

"One of the only arrows in [Trump's] quiver is being the man"

And don't you ever forget it.

chuck said...

Doing squats in jeans is at best uncomfortable. They are too tight and stiff when your butt gets near the floor.

Aggie said...

What they really need are some of Jack Lalanne's jumpsuits from the 50's, the ones cut to show off that rugged 'V', and those manly biceps.

J Scott said...

The "jeans guy" seems to be some sort of myth. Or at least something created in the last year or two. The Atlantic article that references a NYTs article that supposedly talks about PF banning denim, the wayback machines shows it has no references to 'denim' or 'jeans' so more mythical bullshit.

chuck said...

I think overalls are better general purpose work clothes than jeans. Looser, don't need a belt to stay up, and cover the front. I see old pictures of workers and they are in overalls. Jeans are more connected to riding horses. You can squat in overalls, you can probably sit a horse better in jeans.

Rabel said...

"The Venn diagram intersection between people who regularly bench press, and people who are in the NY Times target reader demographic, is an empty set."

You underestimate the gay set.

baghdadbob said...

Richard Simmons worked out in a felching, er, fetching outfit

Rabel said...

What sets Kennedy apart for me is not the muscular development which is impressive and commendable for his age but rather the extremely low body fat.

That's really hard to achieve and maintain without a strong genetic tendency.

By really hard, I mean really, really fucking hard for most people despite even maximum efforts at exercise and diet.

Marty said...

NYT excerpts are just click bait for the Althouse commentariat.

WK said...

And Hegseth pushing up 315 in the bench press this week. Healthy cabinet.

Little Excursion™️ said...

MAHA was always a con, driven solely by the ego and ambition of a drug-addled narcissistic fraud.

mccullough said...

Kennedy looks good because he doesn’t have tattoos.

Craig Mc said...

Planet Fitness lets troons invade women's changerooms, so let's not rely on their moral compass.

RCOCEAN II said...

Carl on six-pac abs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5WzKDdj0CxY

Greg The Class Traitor said...

The Vance quote appears near the end of the article, right after: "Mr. Trump’s latest masculinity proclamations sum up this administration’s hard-line approach to maleness, where the most powerful men in the country can just relax and be men who appreciate other men — in a strictly manly way, of course."

Right after the Vance quote, we get: "All of this hints at a powerful political current that politicians like Mr. Vance and Mr. Trump instinctively know how to channel."


That's because they're men, and not ashamed f it.

The article ends with 2 quotes from law professor Joan C. Williams:
Because of course the only person the NYT can find to comment on masculinity is a female law professor (no offense intended, Prof Althouse)

"One of the only arrows in [Trump's] quiver is being the man" and "Picking wars all around the world, that’s what’s really going on."
"Picking wars"? So not only is she not qualified to discuss the subject, but she doesn't have anything meaningful to say/ honest to say about it.

Got it

n.n said...

Trump is a man. Melania is a woman. Together they are a couple. Now I know my sex and group nouns, next time won't you sing along with me.

n.n said...

Geriatric striving with sense and sensibility.

Old and slow said...

"Trump is a man. Melania is a woman" The first coherent post I've ever seen you make. It was amusing. Thanks.

Beasts of England said...

I don’t understand the jeans thing, re: his age or background.

David53 said...

Who cares about the jeans? RFJ is in freakishly good shape for his age.

walter said...

Biden can ride a bike!!;

J Scott said...

The jeans things could be simply explained by the tv show the Incredible Hulk. You are MASSIVE if you can split your jeans while weightlifting. It's aspirational!

Post a Comment

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.