November 7, 2025

"[T]he character of Mr. Obama, played by T.J. Wilkins, is the near-perfect embodiment of the American ideal — a noble, caring patriot who could catch a beat."

"(The only character more perfect, it goes without saying, is Michelle.) Part revival meeting, part endangered species preserve for normie Democrats who can afford theater tickets, by the end, the show prompted audience members to put their hands in the air. I was less ecstatic...."

Writes David Litt about a "Hamilton"-like theater production about Obama, in "The New Obama Musical Made Me Feel Old" (NYT).

As the headline suggests, Litt, a former speechwriter for Obama, goes on and on about himself, which makes me assume the play isn't much of a play. It's no "Hamilton"... and it actually begins with an announcement "This is not 'Hamilton.'" The name of the new musical is "44: The Musical."

I was a bit taken aback by "a noble, caring patriot who could catch a beat." I think "could catch a beat" means about the same thing as "had rhythm." That's a stereotype about black people that sophisticated people learned to stop vocalizing back in the 1970s.

Litt continues: "While I’m not proud to admit it, watching Mr. Obama receive the cherry-tree treatment awakened my inner curmudgeon.... 'This was so much more difficult than you make it look!' I inwardly grumped...." I'm not sure what "cherry-tree treatment" is supposed to mean. Treated like a legendary hero (George Washington)? That would make me grumpy too... except it wouldn't because I can see from a thousand miles away this show is not for me. It's hard to understand Litt, a person who would go to this show but is nevertheless displeased.

74 comments:

Iman said...

“My favorite part about the Obama era is all the racial healing.”

—— Jon Gabriel

Iman said...

A fucking film-flam artiste if there ever was one.

Mike (MJB Wolf) said...

But it's NOT a cult. It's not I tell you! Sure we sing songs about him and write plays about him and photograph him with halos and pretend that girls swoon and pass out when he speaks.

But it's not a cult!

mezzrow said...

If you are a theatre kid, Barack Obama is the answer to almost every question. They loved him before they ever met him.

A love like this does not fade.

Jamie said...

I think it's hilarious, and then wearying, that "it goes without saying" that the Michelle character is the only one more perfect than the Barack one.

rhhardin said...

Obama as an obvious piece of shit was my impression, back as far as the 2008 estrogen rallies. Needs a musical.

Disparity of Cult said...

Who did they cast for Tony Rezko, Bill Ayers, and Bernardine Dohrn?

Valerie Jarrett seems a little too uptight to catch a beat.

Disparity of Cult said...

"Sparklefarts!! The Musical"

Wince said...

That Obama needs Ozempic®!

Spiros said...

I wonder if Michelle loathes her husband because he's a disgusting piece of shit or if she's at that stage in her life when she resents her husband for no obvious reason and longs for freedom?

Sydney said...

Blech.

Peachy said...

Obama opened up the door to massive corruption and radical left policies - polices that do not work.
then he and his wife made millions and live large - while no one in the black community was aided at all.
In fact - the first thing on Obama's agenda was to cancel school choice .
Obama is a slick talked, no doubt. Why the hollywood left and dedicated loyalists on the left adore him.

Peachy said...

talker

Peachy said...

Leftist truly love to slobber over each other. It is gross.

Peachy said...

cult.

robother said...

"I got rhythm, who could ask for anything more!" brings down the house.

Iman said...

What… Keenan Thompson had a scheduling conflict?

Wince said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Wince said...

"Clap kids. Pretending to enjoy something you actually didn't is an important adult social skill. ."

chuck said...

"Thou shalt have no other gods before me."

Who's talking here?

CJinPA said...

In 5 seconds, the trailer sounded like an updated version of the creepy 2008 Children for Obama song. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TW9b0xr06qA&pp=ygUTT2JhbWEgY2hpbGRyZW4gc29uZ9IHCQkDCgGHKiGM7w%3D%3D

doctrev said...

Guys. The love is already fading. Barack Obama probably could have beaten Donald Trump, but not after 2016. Now we have President Trump, and neither Obama wants to seriously face him again because they would get WRECKED. Which is why the NYT critic can afford to be lukewarm about this.

tim maguire said...

Another left-wing hagiography that not even left-wingers will go see. Closed in a week, loses millions.

tim maguire said...

rhhardin said...Obama as an obvious piece of shit was my impression, back as far as the 2008 estrogen rallies.

A petty, thoroughly mediocre man whose only talent was getting influential people excited about him.

Which says more about how we create influence than it does about Obama.

Aggie said...

Obama confidently predicted 'Donald Trump will never be President,' and then dropped the mic, to the full-throated appreciation of the audience. And, consistent with his record, was wrong - twice.

Two-eyed Jack said...

Let's do the Timewarp again:

Hey b, it's me. if you're there, pick up.
I was just watching you on c-span. [sigh] anyway, call me back.

You seem to float onto the floor
Democratic convention 2004
I never wanted anybody more
Than i want you
So i put down my kerry sign
Knew i had to make you mine
So black and sexy, you're so fine
'cause i've got a crush on obama

I cannot wait, 'til 2008
Baby you're the best candidate
I like it when you get hard
On hillary in debate
Why don't you pick up your phone?
'cause i've got a crush on obama
I cannot wait, 'til 2008
Baby you're the best candidate
Of the new oval office
You'll get your head of state
I can't leave you alone
'cause i've got a crush on obama

You're into border security
Let's break this border between you and me
Universal healthcare reform
It makes me warm
You tell the truth unlike the right
You can love but you can fight
You can barack me tonight
I've got a crush on obama

I cannot wait, 'til 2008
Baby you're the best candidate
I like it when you get hard
On hillary in debate
Why don't you pick up your phone?
'cause i've got a crush on obama
I cannot wait, 'til 2008
Baby you're the best candidate
Of the new oval office
You'll get your head of state
I can't leave you alone
'cause i've got a crush on obama

B to the a to the r-a-c-k-o-b-a-m-a (barack obama)
'cause i've got a crush on obama


D.D. Driver said...

Yuck it up all you like, but the Obama cringefest is still not as embarrassing as this.

n.n said...

So, it's a fake rendition of a rap around the fire.

Jamie said...

I suppose it depends on how it's meant, Triple D. I doubt very much that this musical is meant as a self-deprecating joke.

Derve said...

Professor? You VOTED for Obama! You were under the spell... went to his rally at UW Madison before he won... You and your boys were all in.

Check the post the day after Obama's election to the presidency? You and your son could not believe it... It went something like this:

Obama?
Obama.
Obama?!
OBAMA!!!

You are such a liberal feminist, enjoyed a tenured career of silencing others/questions, and collected you pay, took in a kept man "commoner", and now are disavowing all that YOU and your gay sons built... (Jonny could not do better than UW-Eau Claire out of high school, but ended up a Cornell Law grad thanks to his law prof mommy, and now lives in... New York City (lol) where he still doesn't drive a car...)

Please stop all this pretending.
You love David Sedaris, and you LOVED Barry Obama. You fell for it, prof. We realists from Chicago did not, but oh you overeducated arty hippies from UMichigan fell for it...LOLOL.

Derve said...

The lede looks like Big Mike: waaaay too fat to be Obama, who looks aged and like he's suffering from cancer he's such a lightweight now. Maybe the cigarettes are catching up? He and Bill C. and all the Washington folk just do not look healthy. Even Trump is starting to hunch over, but at least he can keep some meat on the bones...

Iman said...

Cheer up, DeeDee. The Rock ‘em/Sock ‘em 0bama toy will be released in time for Christmas.

Aggie said...

...'but the Obama cringefest is still not as embarrassing as this.'...

The distinction is, nobody voted for the jokey pictures (which nearly all of us think are adolescent, but understand the joke), but a sizeable portion of the country voted for the hokey, glib candidate preaching that the 'oceans will stop rising, and the earth will begin to heal', because they were gullible enough to believe it, thinking it would prove they weren't racist.

Howard said...

This is the ticket! I'm sure the pending resurgence of the Obama feel good vibes will inspire the millions of working class people of all the colours of Benetton to get behind Chuck Schumer, Pete Buttegegs, Cory Booker and AOC whom will lead the sweep to dominate the midterm elections.

There will be so much Democratic winning, it will be almost embarrassing. Trump will fail so hard, we'll actually feel sorry for him.

tommyesq said...

What could the show possibly be about? What has Obama ever done, other than gives condescending speeches through his nose? Is it about the exciting process of ramming a health care bill through by refusing to seat Scott Brown before the vote? From a theatrical point of view, Obama seems pretty dull.

Kevin said...

They’re trying to martyr Obama, lest he be erased.

Kevin said...

“Clinton: The Musical” would have been so much more entertaining.

D.D. Driver said...

"The distinction is..."

The distinction is its totally different when the Obamaclowns act clowny than when the Trumptards act tardy.

bagoh20 said...

Did it reveal Obama's greatest accomplishment as President?
That secret has been kept too long.

bagoh20 said...

Obama did have rhythm, but only on odd numbered days.

Lazarus said...

The actor looks nothing like Barack Obama. The actor is too heavy and doesn't move like the ex-president. Is it racist that they thought "generic black" was the way to go? I'd say he's too black too, but that might be racist.

Temujin said...

And the swooning continues...

In my life, I've never seen such an empty suit get such universal praise and adoration as Barack Obama. Clearly, I'm not seeing the magic that others are fainting over.

Maynard said...

All hail the King!

Obama is the Light Bringer and our savior!

bagoh20 said...

"The actor looks nothing like Barack Obama."
To Democrats, who only saw his Black half as significant and enough to cover all shortcomings, he looks identical.

Kevin said...

The actor is too heavy and doesn't move like the ex-president.

Was Mick Jagger in blackface unavailable?

Mike (MJB Wolf) said...

Definitely not a cult.

Big Mike said...

Lazarus said...

The actor looks nothing like Barack Obama.


All black people look alike to New York City theater-goers.

Gerda Sprinchorn said...

Obama's election was such a missed opportunity. We could have put America's racial problems behind us, but instead got a double helping of non-stop racism in every facet of American life.

Sigh.

Mike (MJB Wolf) said...

So if I want to do a reverse-Hamilton and produce "44: The Punk Rock Musical" with guys that look like Jonny Rotten and Henry Rollins playing Obama and his wife that's cool because "art"?

Anne-I-Am said...

My mixed-race son and his black dad an I joke all the time about black v white in all things musical and dance-related. It is only verboten if you're a liberal with no real connection to actual black people.

bagoh20 said...

George Hamilton would be a more convincing Obama.

Yancey Ward said...

Well, if it were going to mimic "Hamilton", Obama would be portrayed by a white guy.........oh......wait.....

john mosby said...

The dude playing Obama is a bit chubby. I would have tried to get Adrian Lester. Dunno if he can sing, but plenty of good musicals have marginal singers: the Les Miz and Mamma Mia movies, Ben Daniels in JCS Live, etc. CC, JSM

John henry said...

Why not go really Hamilton and have white actors portraying Barrak and Big Mike?

John Henry

John henry said...

oops, I see Yancy got there first.

Sorry.

John Henry

Derve said...

It is only verboten if you're a liberal with no real connection to actual black people.
------
ann thinks herself sophisticated like that. Always deferring and demuring to Others. lol

boatbuilder said...

Hey, DD--wait until "TRUMP, THE MUSICAL!!!" You're gonna love it. I'm going to line up Begley for the screenplay, and Kid Rock for the musical numbers. A cameo by the Village People.

narciso said...

Yes either lester or david owelowo, (the latter was a villain ik jack reacher so it fits

Ice Nine said...

>Ann Althouse said...
I think "could catch a beat" means about the same thing as "had rhythm." That's a stereotype about black people that sophisticated people learned to stop vocalizing back in the 1970s.<

And most people with even minimal sophistication - and functioning eyes - know that it is absolutely true (as with most stereotypes).

Oh, and they wonder why certain groups of people find this indisputable fact to be offensive...

D.D. Driver said...

@boatbuilder That's the delicious irony to all of this. If there was a Trump musical all of these tools would be in the front row. They are literally blind to the fact that they are every ounce as stupid and childish as the Obamaclowns. Derpy derp derp.

narciso said...

And good gravy that review is full of treakle keith david is about a generation older but he does a very good obama impression

RCOCEAN II said...

There's a big book of Hamilton lyrics for sale at my local library. Price? 3 dollars. Been sitting there for 2 weeks. Will probably end up in the "Books for Free" section.

Anyway, Obama strikes me an incredibly dull subject for a musical or play. They should have done "Hillary - Unelected". That would've had it all, comedy, pathos, drama.

n.n said...

Character or color?

RCOCEAN II said...

Yes, Trump the comedy musical. It writes itself. The songs by Trump could have lyrics based solely on his own words.

narciso said...

The most incisive depiction was in kingsman where he depicted as colloborating with the bill gatesque tech mogul in trying to cull the world

narciso said...

Yeah the thuggies say dial it back

narciso said...

We saw the way they depicted trump in the 'apprentice' before that in the comey docudrama on showtime

Kevin said...

I think "could catch a beat" means about the same thing as "had rhythm."

Gimme a Beat! -- Janet Jackson, Nasty

Disparity of Cult said...

A few years ago, the Second City improv group in Chicago had a show "Dance Like There's Black People Watching".

bagoh20 said...

I don't see MAGA people going to a Trump musical. They would expect it to suck even worse than this embarrassment. Now do a Hillary week on Forensic Files and you got us.

john mosby said...

There's so much rap name-checking Trump that you could already to a jukebox musical on him without writing any original songs. CC, JSM

BarrySanders20 said...

Should be named "Yes We Con"
Runtime: 2 hours 45 minutes. Features non-stop hip-hop battles, zero earned achievements, and one very satisfied star who never breaks a sweat.

Jim at said...

We should be grateful for Obama. If he hadn't run his fucking mouth, Donald Trump would've never entered the race.

Bunkypotatohead said...

People who annoy you.

Post a Comment

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.