September 8, 2025

"This was a demise foretold. Fatalistic in the face of a parliamentary impasse, Mr. Bayrou had, even before the debate began, invited his entourage to a 'convivial moment'..."

"... or farewell soirée, this evening. With four prime ministers in the past 20 months, and a fifth likely to be appointed now, the fall of French governments, once unusual, has become close to mundane.... 'Domination by military force, or domination by our creditors as a result of debts that drown us, produces the same result: The loss of our liberty,' Mr. Bayrou said, to opposition cries of 'It’s not the same thing!' His appeal fell on deaf ears. The far right of Marine Le Pen and a group of left and far-left parties, holding a clear majority between them, rejected the freezing of welfare payments, cutting two national holidays and other austerity measures proposed by Mr. Bayrou. Ms. Le Pen, true to her National Rally party’s doctrine, suggested cutting spending on immigrants instead...."

From "French Government Collapses, Again, Deepening Paralysis/Prime Minister François Bayrou failed a confidence vote aimed at breaking an impasse over the budget, adding more pressure on President Emmanuel Macron" (NYT).

29 comments:

FormerLawClerk said...

Le Pen didn't suggest cutting spending on immigrants.

She suggested taking that money and instead giving it to the French people from whom it was stolen.

Hassayamper said...

I recall that Italy was like this in the 70's and 80's, to the point that it became something of a joke.

Narr said...

France for the French!

What a concept.

RideSpaceMountain said...

"Domination by military"

Newsflash, a military solution is coming whether you like it or not if you can't cease making the hard decisions tomorrow you should be making today.

Hard decisions today can still prevent tomorrow's bloodshed, le choix por vous.

Peachy said...

At some point - you run out of other peoples money.
someone said that once.
French like their posh social safety net.

FormerLawClerk said...

Interesting to hear the Prime Minister talk of "domination" by banks producing the exact same loss of liberty as that by an enemy at war.

So who are the mystery people who own these banks which control France? What are their names?

narciso said...

it's ironic because macron, in his previous life was a banker,
who seems to have ignored every rule of proper finance

narciso said...

Bayrou was a school teacher before he entered the parliament,

RCOCEAN II said...

Macron is a french Romney/McCain. Who knows what will happen. The patriotic thing to do would be for Macron to resign and have a new Presidental election. The sensible thing to do would be to have a snap parlimentary election. Let the voters decide.

The problem is the voters have given National Rally a lot of votes but not enough for a majority. They persist is electing a divided parliment that is about 1/3 Right, 1/3 center, and 1/3 left. Maybe now that they've seen the result, they will swing one way or the other.

But since since Macron in true center-right, mccain-romney fashion only cares about big business and himself, look for him to negotiate some half-ass deal with the more reasonable portion of the Left. "We'll only cut one holiday not two. We'll cut welfare by 1 percent and not 5 percent" Paper it over till the next scheduled election.

RCOCEAN II said...

Le Pen wants to cut spending on immigration and cut immigration so they "pay their way". She also wants to stop money going to Ukraine and the EU general fund.

But oh horrors. Anything but that. Better to force french workers to go work two extra days a year and cut their benefits. LOL.

FormerLawClerk said...

It's ironic because Macron, in his previous life, was a child sexual assault victim of his own pedophile teacher.

Who is now his wife.

narciso said...

this is the problem, with parliamentary politics, I suppose he will have to declare a new election or not

Kakistocracy said...

We can laugh but this will be us in a couple years. Outright refusal to face economic reality that we cannot run huge deficits to fund social spending with a rapidly aging population.

Kakistocracy said...

If the ECB hadn't intervened over the last decade to keep spreads contained, the useless French politicians would have been forced by the markets to cut their absurd spending.

rehajm said...

mäis non!

Dude1394 said...

It is hard to keep suppressing your political opponent that has answers.

Lance said...

This is what happened to Paul Ryan. He suggested the barest first steps to dealing with unsustainable US liabilities, and "conservatives" and "liberals" joined to throw him out.

Ampersand said...

You can kick the can down the road, until you run out of road. Can the EU bail France out, a la Greece?

narciso said...

they lost out, when they gamed enough seats, to put pelosi in charge,

Achilles said...

The French Government is very unpopular.

The French Government wants war with Russia. If you oppose that war you are a Russian sympathizer.

No votrs in France wants to go to war with Russia. They want the US to do it for them at most.

One of the more repetitive patters in history.

Achilles said...

France spending money on illegals imported to supplant the native population and keep wages down is unpopular.

If you oppose giving money to "asylum speakers" you are racist.

It is almost like they are all the same.

Lazarus said...

Macron = French-fried McCain French Fry?
Romney = 'Merican Macaroon
»
We haven't head the last of François Bayrou.
He's coming back some day.
Come what may.
Blue Bayrou.

Clyde said...

When your body is badly infested with parasites, the first step toward healing is to purge your body of the parasites.

RCOCEAN II said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
RCOCEAN II said...

The problem is not the french deficits. And is Macron NOT "the only adult in the room" trying to "Solve the problem".

Conservatives or I should say "Big Business Republicans" always try to cast the problem as "Controlling Government spending on average people". No, you can also raise taxes. And you can also cut foreign aid, defense spending, and other things. And you can try to solve the problem right now with a meat axe, or you solve it over time with less drastic cuts.

When Paul Ryan starts crying about the deficit, you need to ask "If the deficit was so important, why did you cut taxes?"

n.n said...

Europe's inglorious appropriation of South Africa's progressive rape capital title was, in hindsight, a wicked solution of a poor choice.

Enigma said...

The French are drunk on wine, distracted by their affairs, and snoozing because their foreign servants do whatever work gets done.

The post-WW2 eurozone public-safety-net-immigrant-utopia is cracking up like spring ice on a river. It should have happened 30 years ago.

Kakistocracy said...

I think it was Junker who said “it’s not that we don’t know what must be done, it’s that we don’t know how to get re-elected after we do it”

wildswan said...

Look at all the initiatives which Trump is pushing to get the US going. Perhaps part of the French problem is that a wide social overhaul is needed but the French parties are merely conducting a tug of war of one tiny section of the needed overhaul - the section concerned with taxes and discretionary spending. What about a French Doge - Le Doge? - to end waste fraud and abuse? What about closing the border? What about no special services for migrants? How much is going to Ukraine? How much is the EU getting? What about ending expensive green energy mandates and credits? What about collecting taxes?

Post a Comment

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.