January 9, 2024

Lloyd Austin only just got out of intensive care yesterday.

I'm surprised to read (in The Washington Post).

Austin, 70, remains under doctors’ supervision at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center in Maryland. He was taken there by ambulance Jan. 1, while in “severe pain” with undisclosed complications from a Dec. 22 medical procedure that included an overnight stay, administration officials said.

He's still in the hospital, and we still don't know what the original procedure was. Something that includes an overnight stay, so, I'm thinking... not a colonoscopy. Why would they withhold this information, with so much attention aimed at this case? Perhaps they are bolstering the argument that it's something so private that it justified the initial failure to disclose? I can think of some things like that, but I won't put them in writing. Too private!

But their halting explanation of the situation, and Austin’s lack of transparency about what led to his health crisis, have only amplified the scrutiny following revelations that Austin’s senior staff declined to disclose the issue to the White House for days. The Pentagon said Monday night that it remains unclear when he may be released but that officials intend to provide daily updates so long as he remains at Walter Reed.... 

It was unclear, though, whether even Biden, who spoke with Austin on Saturday evening, now knows specifics about his condition, or how enduring it could be. 

“That would really be between the two men,” [said John Kirby, a spokesman for the White House’s National Security Council].

Imagine saying that, when you know there is criticism for lack of transparency.

[A spokesman, Maj. Gen. Patrick Ryder] acknowledged during an hour-long back-and-forth with reporters that he first learned of Austin’s hospitalization Jan. 2, two days before that information was transmitted to the National Security Council and three days before it was disclosed to Congress and the public. A handful of other Defense Department officials, including Gen. Charles Q. Brown Jr., chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff; Kelly Magsamen, Austin’s chief of staff; and Lt. Gen. Ronald Clark, Austin’s senior military assistant; also were apprised of the secretary’s medical situation before the White House was made aware.

Still, no one at the Pentagon notified Congress or Austin’s No. 2, Deputy Defense Secretary Kathleen Hicks, even after Hicks assumed some of Austin’s duties during a previously planned vacation to Puerto Rico, Pentagon officials said. Ryder blamed the breakdown on Magsamen having contracted the flu, requiring her to miss work. It remains unclear whether Magsamen delegated any responsibilities to subordinates while she was ill. Ryder said it was the chief of staff who ultimately notified Biden’s national security adviser, Jake Sullivan, at the White House on Jan. 4.

Who's in control there? Who should be in control? We, the people, rely on the Defense Department. These are people who've been avoiding transparency, and what they are letting us see looks bad.

Ryder offered no explanation for why another Pentagon official did not notify the White House sooner.... 

Republicans have seized on the issue....

Seized? The issue was foisted on them... and all of us. 

61 comments:

wendybar said...

So he lied when he claimed he was working from home?? FIRE HIS ASS!!!

Matt Whitlock
@mattdizwhitlock

The Secretary of Defense told the President he was “working from home” when he was at the hospital having surgery for a week.

These guys aren’t even being transparent with each other.

rehajm said...

The only proper conclusion is the people in power concluded disclosure is bad for the people in power. Unfortunately for the people in power that leads to speculation.

Playing percentages…probably a gerbilectomy.

Big Mike said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Kevin said...

USA Today calls it “complications following a recent elective medical procedure.”

Over the holidays?

My first thought: plastic surgery.

Big Mike said...

It was unclear, though, whether even Biden, who spoke with Austin on Saturday evening, now knows specifics or gives a damn about his condition, or how enduring it could be.

There. Fixed it.

Money Manger said...

Boy, this must really be bad for the administration. How can you tell ? Search this morning’s NYT, the story just DOES NOT EXIST.

Kevin said...

If it was penile reduction surgery, we’d all know.

Bruce Hayden said...

“These guys aren’t even being transparent with each other.”

This just reinforces my belief that the FJB Administration is being run as a bunch of mostly independent fiefdoms, with the exception of the law enforcement (DOJ, HSA, etc) which are being run as a private WH Gestapo, aimed at quelling dissent, in particular against those who questioned the legitimacy of his becoming President.

From that point of view, Austin‘s actions make sense - it was really none of the WH’s business. It was his fiefdom.

Josephbleau said...

I figured he had a gastric bypass and was embarrassed about being overweight. He should have stuck with Ozympic.

Humperdink said...

Secretary of Defense? It use to be labelled Secretary of War, but President Truman, a democrat, changed it to Secretary of Defense. This would be a golden opportunity for the Biden-Obama administration to change it something even more peaceful. Maybe Secretary of Peace, Inclusion and Capitulation.

As an aside, the presidential seal has been changed over the years, but it typically had an eagle holding an olive branch (peace) in one talon and arrows (war) in the other. The eagle only looks to one side. Up to to Truman administration the eagle looked to the arrows. He approved the change so the eagle faces the olive branch. Haven't won a war since.

Clyde said...

I'm betting he shows up in a dress and makeup. Just being a Black male isn't diverse enough these days...

typingtalker said...

My experience in the real world and love of unenlightened speculation suggests that this hospitalization may be related to the consumption of adult beverages and/or illegal substances.

Or maybe, as my father used to say, his blood sugar was low.

RMc said...

Republicans have seized on the issue

The word is "pounced"! Everybody knows that! (Geez, does nobody read the Journolist anymore...?)

jaydub said...

He's still in the hospital? Must be that it's harder to extract a gerbil than anyone thought.

Leland said...

I watched a good video discussion of this situation by two former Navy commanders. I enjoyed it mostly because they seemed to share my understanding that the SecDef can have some medical privacy, but that we should be informed as we are now of where he is and his capacity to perform his duties.

They also made a note that they were upset that civilian leadership put the military leader In a position of having to keep this secret. This may not be obvious to some upfront, but when you think it through, it is a problem. It gives the appearance of the military intending to take advantage of the situation when the reality is they work for the civilians withholding the information from the public. Keep in mind there are two spokesmen, one a Major General representing the military side and another is an assistant Secretary of Defense that is a civilian spokesperson. The latter should have been handling communications on the civilian side.

Chris Meager is the Assistant to the Secretary of Defense for Public Affairs. His previous role was national press secretary for the Pete Buttigieg campaign and later worked as Buttigieg press secretary at DOT. Before working for Buttigieg, Meagher was a press secretary for Gov. Whitmer. Meager took the post at DoD when John Kirby became press secretary for the National Security Council. Why isn’t this guy having the hour long back and forth with reporters?

AMDG said...

jaydub said...
He's still in the hospital? Must be that it's harder to extract a gerbil than anyone thought.

1/9/24, 6:52 AM
————————

That or they had to pump,a large amount of semen out of his stomach.

I am sure we all have a friend of a friend who knows the nurse that worked on him.

Temujin said...

Our country is in the best of hands.
Ah...hell. You all know that's bullshit. We've somehow managed to allow the most incompetent, mediocre people I've ever seen in my life, take over our government.

Jamie said...

It's none of my beeswax what surgery Austin had nor of the complications resulting in his long hospitalization. But he should have explicitly and properly delegated his authority and the President should have known the delegation was happening, and that it was due to temporary medical incapacity.

Where this would get sticky is in the case of unanticipated incapacity. But no one would blame him for that, even if it caused terrible confusion.

I don't support hounding him or his staff for specifics about his condition or treatment, now that - I'm presuming! - delegation has taken place.

Howard said...

I predict sometime very soon he is going to tell us all that he needs to spend more time with his family

AndrewV said...

Humperdink said...
Secretary of Defense? It use to be labelled Secretary of War, but President Truman, a democrat, changed it to Secretary of Defense.

The Secretary of War was the cabinet Secretary for the US Army. The US Navy was an independent branch represented in the cabinet by the Secretary of the Navy.

The Department of Defense was created to have a single Secretary of Defense representing all of the branches of the military, the Army, the Navy, and the newly independent Air Force in the cabinet. That was authorized in the National Security Act of 1947.

Milo Minderbinder said...

Never fear, our unelected bureaucracy remains in charge.

Yet another perfect illustration of how liberals cannot, could not and are not able to run even a lemonade stand. They are a rare (hopefully) combination of incompetence and corruption.

Tom T. said...

My thought is prostate surgery. They did it before Christmas because it was quiet and he'd be home in a day. They kept it secret because no one wants to think about a fat old man ejaculating, much less go to war behind him. Then he developed a blood clot and had to go to the ICU.

Alternatively, it was cancer surgery, and nothing we've been told so far has been true.

Tom T. said...

By the way, now we don't know who's making the nuclear decisions at either the White House or the Pentagon.

Does the Deputy Secretary now have the football?

Humperdink said...

Andrew V said: "The Department of Defense was created to have a single Secretary of Defense representing all of the branches of the military, the Army, the Navy, and the newly independent Air Force in the cabinet. That was authorized in the National Security Act of 1947."

A name change was not necessary to execute the consolidation.

Creola Soul said...

Austin should be fired for the throwing his Chief of Staff under the bus. You delegate authority but not responsibility. This is an unpardonable breach of trust with the men in ranks.
Not unexpected from this Administration though.

JRoberts said...

I know this comment will upset some, but the incompetence shown in this (and many other) situations cause me to long for the days of Robert McNamara and the other "Whiz Kids"

Sebastian said...

"These are people who've been avoiding transparency, and what they are letting us see looks bad.

Right. Doesn't that apply to the entire federal government, the FBI especially?

"Republicans have seized on the issue."

The mindless repetition of the prog Republicans-pounce cliche, laughable among us deplorables, just shows how strong the bubble is. They have no clue, but can afford to wallow in their cluelessness.

Humperdink said...

Tom T. said: "My thought is prostate surgery. They did it before Christmas because it was quiet and he'd be home in a day. They kept it secret because no one wants to think about a fat old man ejaculating, much less go to war behind him. Then he developed a blood clot and had to go to the ICU."

I had prostate surgery three weeks ago. Overnight and then home with a catheter. What great fun with a bag strapped for three days (sarc alert!). I could see where there could be complications. I only experienced minor issues and dealt with them at home. I'm back to playing pickleball with no residual effects. Austin is two years younger than me.

We will continue to speculate until the the truth surfaces. Where is intrepid media? Woodward, Bernstein, Acosta, Stephanopolis, Dan Rather? *cough*

Rusty said...

Citizen! If you were meant to know we would have told you.
Trump is evil, citizen.

narciso said...

https://www.dossier.today/p/who-actually-commands-the-american

rcocean said...

Must have been a boob job gone wrong.

Iman said...

Perhaps the next election will facilitate the return of the adults taking charge.

Yancey Ward said...

Here are the issues that he might have had to address with an elective surgery for a 70 year-old man:

(1) Prostate surgery;
(2) Plastic surgery on the face;
(3) Hernia;
(4) Joint replacement (my guess).

Of course, perhaps there was no elective surgery at all, and it was one that medically required, but embarrassing because it is linked with the m-RNA vaccines with which he was active in mandating for every U.S. military employee.

Joe Smith said...

Am guessing hemorrhoids...

mutecypher said...

My speculation is that the initial event was a sex change operation and the complication was that he actually grew a pair. So a second removal was required.

Rabel said...

Somewhat surprised to find that Kelly Magsamen, Austin’s chief of staff, is a political creature with Podesta and Soros connections and a Trump hater.

mikee said...

I guess I'm getting soft in my old age, or maybe just a bit less horrible a person. Here's wishing the old guy a full and speedy recovery. I suggest he can be hung, drawn and quartered for his political deeds and misdeeds at leisure after he is healthy enough for it to be more than almost beating a dead horse. Let the guy heal up before you go after him with your mob.

Rabel said...

Somewhat surprised to find that Kelly Magsamen, Austin’s chief of staff, is a political creature with Podesta and Soros connections and a Trump hater.

JAORE said...

SOP for this fluster cluck administration.

I have a pretty high placed contact in the US DOT. That person informs me that when Mayor Pete was on maternity leave he neglected to appoint an acting Secretary of Transportation.

Confusion, inaction and maneuvering for power followed.

What could go wrong? A brief search of headlines for that period shows things could, and did, go wrong. Of course when Pete is on the job things don't go any righter....

JAORE said...

Austin takes "full responsibility".

Gawd I hate that phrase when not followed by, I therefore resign...



Michael said...


Same as rehajm

Was reading news report to my wife this morning. She set her coffee down, let out a sigh, then muttered, Oh God, it was a gerbil

Bruce Hayden said...

“ (4) Joint replacement (my guess)”

Not mine. Both my parents had knees replaced. They were in decently good shape, and recovery wasn’t overnight. Austen appears morbidly obese, and greatly increases the length and depth of the recovery from joint replacement surgery. That’s why my vote is for Prostate surgery. Most of the time, it’s pretty quick and easy. In and out in maybe one day. One of the problems with the sort of excess weight carried by Austen is that surgeries are often more dangerous. No doubt, Dr K here could expand on the issues involved, but my partner’s spine surgeon says that dealing with large slabs of fat is neither fun nor easy.

Humperdink said...

Prostate surgery it is.

Bruce Hayden said...

It apparently was prostate surgery.

Static Ping said...

An enlisted soldier would be court marshalled for this sort of behavior. He's sixth in the Presidential succession order and he couldn't be bothered? Seriously?

My assumption is he does not actually do anything so no one cared. He can keep secrets because he's a DEI figurehead who is just there to collect a paycheck. He probably has no idea what is going on.

Greg the Class Traitor said...

Republicans have seized on the issue

The WaPo just can't help themselves, can they?


Greg the Class Traitor said...

Jamie said...
It's none of my beeswax what surgery Austin had nor of the complications resulting in his long hospitalization.

Wrong.

When:
A: He stops being able to perform his job, and
B: He fails to correctly handle the issues, then it all becomes "our beeswax."

He's a "public servant", not a "public master". He can have his "privacy", or he can have the power. But he only gets one

Aggie said...

So, prostate surgery. They do it robotically now, with a 5-arm DaVinci machine, leaving a few little incisions around the abdomen. You rest for a day, then go home with a drain tube and a Texas catheter, which are removed about 10 days later. Infection was the problem apparently, so he probably showed up in Emergency burning up and sick.

I think we still haven't gotten to the bottom of whether his original Dec 22nd surgery went through the proper channels with notifications, delegations of authority and so on. So far, I haven't heard anybody saying this didn't actually happen (maybe I missed it), although there's still lots of bombastic talk about nobody knew ! in that same, dire kind of mode that teenage daughters use when they're thrilled about something. If he went to Emergency in a medical state, and his Chief of Staff was out of the loop because she was out of the country, then I can maybe see how it happened. It's a problem that needs fixing procedurally, but I wouldn't say it rises to the level that is being broadcast right now. I'm not a fan of this joke, but I try to be fair, and the Fox crowd just seems to enjoy showing its *ss.

Yancey Ward said...

I bet it was a turbo-charged prostate cancer- I bet surgery wasn't elective, but was the only option.

Jamie said...

So, I said:

It's none of my beeswax what surgery Austin had nor of the complications resulting in his long hospitalization.

And the reply was,

Wrong.

When:
A: He stops being able to perform his job, and
B: He fails to correctly handle the issues, then it all becomes "our beeswax."

He's a "public servant", not a "public master". He can have his "privacy", or he can have the power. But he only gets one


My point, in my next sentence, was that he should have delegated his authority appropriately and informed the president, and the fact that he didn't do so is the problem - not what he's in for. And that now the president is aware of his situation and presumably authority is now properly delegated, so, again, what he's in for is none of my beeswax.

He has no expectation of privacy in his official capacity - he can't, for instance, set up a server in his bathroom for his own convenience (or, ahem, for fun and profit) and use it to email all and sundry all over the world as SecDef. (Ahem, again.) But can he have prostate surgery without sharing the gory details with MSNBC? I don't see why not - as long as he has taken care of his business appropriately. Which he didn't.

Jamie said...

I'm not a fan of this joke, but I try to be fair, and the Fox crowd just seems to enjoy showing its *ss.

I'm with Aggie... even though my daughter is a Longhorn.

Tom T. said...

Dammit, I'm probably headed for prostate surgery this year, and this will make my wife worry. There are apparently a dozen different kinds of procedures, though, so hopefully he had a different one.

If memory serves, SecDef has to concur in any nuclear launch. Worst case scenario for him going AWOL is if we're attacked and can't respond because no one in the White House knows who has the nuclear codes at the Pentagon.

Iman said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
curt said...

Tom T. - Surgery is not the best option in most instances. Check out proton. I had it 15 years ago. No pain, no complications, no loss of function. At the time it was only available a few places. Now it’s everywhere.

curt said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
curt said...

Tom T. - Surgery is not the best option in most instances. Check out proton. I had it 15 years ago. No pain, no complications, no loss of function. At the time it was only available a few places. Now it’s everywhere.

Anthony said...

When the story was journalists b***hing that they hadn't been told and weren't able to inform the public, I wasn't worked up about it. Sometimes there are reasons to keep things like that secret. But there's not a good reason to keep it secret from the #2 or the boss. That's when the story begins to stink.

tim in vermont said...

One theory put forth by a guy who does a podcast and grew up in a diplomatic family and has worked in the field is that during a power struggle between factions in a government, one must never show weakness or your enemies will grab onto it. If you seem tired, they will start suggesting that maybe you need fewer responsibilities, and if you are unavailable, they will start dealing directly with your subordinates, giving them orders.

His speculation is that one faction wants war in Lebanon and with Iran, and Austin wants deescalation in the Middle East in order to focus on Ukraine.

tim in vermont said...

Oh yeah, and Joe is not in charge of much at all.

Bunkypotatohead said...

"We, the people, rely on the Defense Department."

The only time in my life the USA was attacked was 9/11. Our Defense Dept sat there while flight 77 crashed into their headquarters. They have never protected civilians in the US, so don't rely on them. It should be renamed the Dept of Foreign Entanglements.

Greg the Class Traitor said...

Jamie said...
So, I said:

It's none of my beeswax what surgery Austin had nor of the complications resulting in his long hospitalization.

And the reply was,

Wrong.

...
My point, in my next sentence,


Missed the point. The point is this: No, you do NOT get to be a "very private person" AND a "US Presidential Cabinet Secretary"

Period. Dot. End of sentence.

If you want to "keep your privacy", you don't get to have power over us. You want to swim nude in your pool? Then you don't get to have a job where you have gov't provided bodyguards / Secret Service protection during the time you'd be swimming.

Life is full of choices, and they are not free. If you chose "power", you dont' get to bitch about the costs that come with that power.