October 12, 2023

"The Green Party-Cornel West link-up promised to be a fusion of the largely white environmental movement and the social justice activism of West, author of the foundational tome Race Matters."

"And for Joe Biden and Democrats, the pairing could have quickly turned into a nightmare, forcing him to protect his left flank from an organized Green Party running a demi-celebrity with decades of progressive bona fides. But to hear West tell it, any cords holding this relationship together had frayed beyond repair."


"Race Matters" — paid link — is not a "tome." It was only 105 pages long as originally published in 1994 — 159 pages if you buy the version available today. I paid the hardcover book price — $15 — for the slim volume — $31 in today's money. Here's Wikipedia's discussion including the a quick summary of reviews that appeared in the NYT — "ferocious moral vision and astute intellect" — and The Washington Post — "moving... profound... exhilarating" — which must have influenced my decision to buy the book. And here's that negative review in Commentary, which says his discussion of the relationship between blacks and Jews is "deeply flawed, evasive, and less than honest."

Back to that long Politico article. We're told that West analyzed the pros and cons of leaving the Green Party:
Cons: ballot access headaches; continued questions about his seriousness as a political figure; the destruction of a potentially mutually beneficial coalition.

Pros: getting to set your own agenda; removing yourself from some of the intractable and unserious elements of the party; crucially, for West, no more need to kiss any ass. 
“The moment of transition became clear, given the internal dynamics of the Green Party,” West said. “The procedures and requirements for debate, you have to go to various Green Party events in a variety of different states. … I said, ‘Oh my God, this is a lot of energy and time and effort.’” 

Ha ha. The whole running-for-President thing is a lot of energy and time and effort. If you didn't like all the dull procedures and events when you were in the Party, how can you run a serious campaign without any party structure?

“[The Green Party] has had a whole host of different campaigns,” West said. “It’s still very difficult to see the ways in which the movement has flowed from the campaign. … Young people have not been that tied to the Greens at all. Black people have not been that tied to the Greens at all. Brown people, trade union people, they haven’t been that tied to the Greens at all.”

West thinks the Greens can’t take him where he wants to go. The Greens think West is throwing away movement politics and blowing up his own campaign to boot. With some remove, it’s easy to see the split as the latest example of the narcissism of small differences that’s plagued segments of the modern left in recent years. (Think of liberals attacking Bernie Sanders for his support of American aid to Ukraine, or DSA-backed politicians condemning fringe DSA members supporting the actions of Hamas this week.)

25 comments:

Sebastian said...

"how can you run a serious campaign without any party structure"

Or perhaps he doesn't want to run a "serious" campaign. Perhaps all the structure he cares about is the radiance of his own persona.

Mike (MJB Wolf) said...

This confused me and the Politico article was a tough slog for the basic reason I don’t closely follow Green Party politics nor has much Cornel West news has seeped through the embargo enforced by the DNC-Media Complex. it was news to me he abandoned his first choice of political party last year. Bad writing and poor reporting and West’s campaign seems lame and unlikely to repeat or surpass the effect Stein had on 2016’s.

RideSpaceMountain said...

I love how Google describes Cornel West as a "philosopher". What can you say, some people read everything on their cereal box in the morning, while the rest just scan the cartoons.

cassandra lite said...

Can't help but think of The Wonders, the band in Tom Hanks's movie That Thing You Do, breaking up just on the verge of making it big.

rehajm said...

crucially, for West, no more need to kiss any ass.

...well there's a big part of his problem right there- a politician is supposed to kiss babies...

The Crack Emcee said...

I don't personally know a single black person who gives a shit about Cornel West.

Sternhammer said...

Cornell doesn't want to run a campaign. He doesn't want to run a government. He just wants to go on TV and run his mouth. This decision makes it easier to do that. This is like when Harvard told him to do some work instead of doing poems on jazz albums and he immediately quit. The dude is a narcissist.

AlbertAnonymous said...

Why does this guy get ANY press?

Roger Sweeny said...

It's a small difference whether you support Hamas or not?

Wow! Too many still believe "no enemies on the left".

wild chicken said...

Successful pols are tireless and go to a crapload of events.

He needs to do like everyone else and up his pharma stack.

Lars Porsena said...

If you like run-on polysyllabic nonsense, Cornel's your man.

Bob Boyd said...

for Joe Biden and Democrats, the pairing could have quickly turned into a nightmare

If that's true, it was probably easy for the Dems to sabotage this alliance.

Kate said...

My definition of "tome" includes size. It's a big book. A door stopper.

How boomer of me. If a slim book wants to identify as a tome, shouldn't I use its preferred adjectives?

Amadeus 48 said...

For all the praise he receives, Cornel West has always seemed to me to be a slightly confused guy running a personal con game. Remember when he waltzed out of Harvard when Larry Summers suggested that he do some actual scholarship?

who-knew said...

I found this interesting "DSA-backed politicians condemning fringe DSA members supporting the actions of Hamas this week." Fringe? I doubt it. The pro-Hamas rally was promoted by the NYC chapter of the DSA that appears to include 10% or more of the total nationwide DSA membership. (exact numbers are hard to come by). Their mealy-mouthed attempt to distance themselves from the blowback that the rally caused merely parrots the Hamas line, blaming Israel for all the problems and only apologizes for the "tone and riming" of the call to rally in support of Hamas

Michael said...


Peter Daou, remember that name.

He was a chief aide to Hillary in 2016. Early in 2023 Daou lands as principal advisor to Marianne Williamson when she announced her run. Then suddenly quits a few months into the campaign citing personal reasons with scuttlebutt saying he worried about Williamson's impact upon Biden's reelection chances.

Resurfaces a few weeks later as campaign manager for Cornet West's Green Party run. Then, bam!, West leaves the Green Party thus ensuring he'll have no significant impact on the 2024 election.

Guy has snake written all over him.

JAORE said...

Feh.

He isn't running for POTUS. He's polishing his resume, hoping tto increase his (very limited) viability/appeal.

Not unlike most of the GOP POTUS candidates.

Michelle Dulak Thomson said...

RideSpaceMountain,

I love how Google describes Cornel West as a "philosopher".

[Are you outside the US? I notice that your period is outside the quotation marks.]

Heh. I remember Susan McClary (feminist musicologist extraordinaire) descending on us at Cal to deliver the Bloch Lectures that year; she also presided over a seminar on feminist musicology. One of the first readings we received was a passage by Cornel West on his philosophy. Very complex and (to non-philosophers) intimidating. I know a great deal more now than I did then, and might be able to make serious sense of the passage; as it was, I was in my early twenties, and had no clue at all. I remember pragmatism, and William James, but that's about all that's left.

McClary herself was OK. We all had to choose what we thought of as a postmodern musical performance and write about it. I picked a Red Byrd recording of Monteverdi's "Zefiro torna," complete with electric fretless bass and occasional other technology irruptions (extra reverb, echoes, that sort of thing). It didn't go over very well. A colleague's DEVO talk was much better.

And the Bloch Lectures -- I think they were finally published, as they have to be, but it was an awfully long time -- were interesting. My eventual doctoral advisor, Dan Heartz, a man who very nearly lived in the 18th century, sat through all of them stoically, even the last one, which featured Public Enemy (or was it NWA? Or both?) played at the appropriate ear-blistering volume. This is on the same stage where Heartz and a female grad student, a gifted soprano, later gave a performance of Mozart's K. 505: "I'll be Mozart, and you be Nancy Storace." (Pronounced as Mozart would've: stor-AHT-shay, not STOR-us, which since Nancy Storace was English, would be what she knew.) Good times!

Tina Trent said...

Hard to believe anything West says, but he's probably right in observing that any time spent with the Green Party feels too long.

n.n said...

I like the girls in white dresses, but I feel it is a burden to dance.

Yancey Ward said...

West and the Green Party never made sense as a hook-up. The Green Party candidate, to reflect its voters needs to be white, female, and dumb as shit.

Free Manure While You Wait! said...

"The Crack Emcee said...
I don't personally know a single black person who gives a shit about Cornel West."

"I can’t believe Nixon won. I don’t know anyone who voted for him.”

- Pauline Kael (1972)

Fish in a barrel. Fish in a barrel.

Free Manure While You Wait! said...

"My definition of "tome" includes size. It's a big book. A door stopper."

It was a large book the size of a small book.

Wilbur said...

Sternhammer said...
Cornell doesn't want to run a campaign. He doesn't want to run a government. He just wants to go on TV and run his mouth. This decision makes it easier to do that. This is like when Harvard told him to do some work instead of doing poems on jazz albums and he immediately quit. The dude is a narcissist.
------------------------------------------------------------

This gets to the nub of the matter.

Michelle Dulak Thomson said...

Damn! I mention DEVO for the first time in at least twenty years, thirty more likely, and the same day Althouse runs a thread on DEVO. And of course it was "Satisfaction" that my fellow-student chose as her (there-is-nothing-outside-the) text :-)