February 1, 2021

"Unlike standard ice, it doesn’t clink; instead, it makes a soothing, gently percussive shuffling sound, like someone shaking an afuche-cabasa in the apartment next door."

From "Pellet Ice Is the Good Ice" (The New Yorker).
Pellet ice is cylindrical, with smooth sides and rough ends, as if each piece had been snapped off of a long dowel of ice. Unlike most ice, which is either carved from a larger block or frozen in a mold, it is made from paper-thin flakes of ice that are pressed into a solid mass—a method familiar to anyone who’s packed soft fresh snow into a dense, compact snowball—and then pushed through round holes punched in a metal sheet, creating a fragile cylinder that breaks off into pieces. Here’s where pellet ice differs from crushed ice, with which it is often erroneously conflated: the compression of the nuggets creates flaky layers, which, as in a well-laminated pastry, render the ice pellets lightweight and airy, with crevices and tiny caves into which your drink can penetrate, and a yielding texture perfect for chewing. The ice is small, each piece only about a centimetre long and narrower in diameter, so it fills a glass more efficiently than lumbering cubes or half-moons, and somehow, in a quirk of thermodynamics, it allegedly melts more slowly.
It's the part about the sound that interests me the most. I have a quirky dislike for the sound of ice cubes clinking in a glass. I'm familiar with the alternative of omitting ice altogether, but this soothing, gently percussive shuffling sound is revelatory. Given my very low sense of taste and smell, I care more than most people about the texture and temperature of things I eat and drink, but rarely use ice, so I sacrifice a dimension of coldness because of a mild aversion to ice. But if ice brought cold and not merely silence but a soothing, gently percussive shuffling sound.... 

69 comments:

Sydney said...

What about crushed ice? Does it make any sound? I have never noticed. Ice sounds are something I tune out.

Kai Akker said...

Gosh, that reminds me that my neighbor hasn't shaken his gauche-cabasa in weeks now. What's the proper etiquette for handling too long an gauche-cabasa silence?

rehajm said...

Pellet ice is great for an arnold palmer, soft drinks or cocktails where you don't mind melt and high dilution. It's bad for beverages where you want cold and minimal dilution, like straight bourbon or scotch or when like a manhattan you're mixing to blend and make cold and dispensing without ice into a glass. Though pellets give you those nice floaties on top of a martini or cosmo.

Word is pellet ice makers are a bit less temperamental than the big cube top hat ones (aka my nemesis).

Kai Akker said...

Ho ho that autocorrect made a Freudian slip.

Mr. O. Possum said...

I can remember when The New Yorker ran massive articles on corn production, geology, and countless serious subjects.

Now it's all 'news' for Eloi.

Morlocks live in China.

stevew said...

The sound made with that instrument, as played in the video, has a soft abrasive quality that reminds me of sanding hard wood with fine (220 & higher) sandpaper.

Does a single ice cube, or ball, make the offending sound? If not, here is an item you might consider:

Macallan Ice Ball Maker

A little pricey but if it does the trick, right?

tim maguire said...

Crushed ice has a tendency to fuse together into a big blob. It's still quieter than ice cubes, but it's unpleasant, as the blob interferes with comfortable drinking. I rarely use ice cubes, but out of disinterest, not distaste, so if I ever have a glass with pellet ice in it, it will have been someone else's doing.

Still, I am curious abut the description of the sound.

gilbar said...

my favorite part of being in a hospital is a glass of ice chips, which seem like these pellets

When i was with my mom last fall, waiting for her cancer surgery to start...
the nurse asked me if she could get me anything; so, Of Course i asked for a ice chips,
and she was like: With water? and i was like "NO! just the chips!"

don't know HOW they make hospital ice chips, which are pellet shaped, but they're Easily crunchable; unlike a regular ice cube.

They are SO GOOD! I suppose one of the reasons i like them is that back in 2012 i spent 2 days living on ice chips and Ringers Lactate (with dextrose) IVs
IF you aren't allowed to eat ANYTHING else, you develop a Real Craving for ice chips

Temujin said...

The sound of ice dropping into a glass triggers my scotch reflex. It's weird.

I had an afuche/cabasa for years coming out of college (along with a variety of percussion toys). I got rid of everything a few years after college except for the cabasa. I had a dog just after college who, as a puppy, chewed on the cabasa and left large teeth marks in the head and handle. I kept it as a memento for years. Finally got rid of it when I realized that it came from another life, in another universe, a long way from here. Gave it to a friend who is a musician now living in Nashville. I sometimes wonder if it'll show up on some televised event, someone along the back row, a percussionist working his afuche/cabasa with dog teeth marks.

rehajm said...

Inviting an ice machine in your house is like inviting a ghost to haunt it. It frightens overnight guests. There was this noise... Yah, it's the ice machine...

Dan from Madison said...

I don't really care about the first world problem of having the correct type of ice in one's drink and rehajm above nails the chemistry. I have always been attracted to a well manicured and feminine looking pair of hands. The hand model in the New Yorker article gets high marks.

tim maguire said...

stevew said...Macallan Ice Ball Maker

A little pricey but if it does the trick, right?


I'm not willing to pay much for an ice cube maker, but I checked the link anyway just to see what upper-class twits can be fleeced out of. You have to give them your birthdate and confirm you are over 21 just to enter the website!

(1) Couldn't they have calculated the second from the first? and
(2) How old do you have to be to make an ice cube where this thing is sold?

Dust Bunny Queen said...

Althouse It's the part about the sound that interests me the most. I have a quirky dislike for the sound of ice cubes clinking in a glass.

In the movie Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf...the production of the movie, emphasized the sound of ice cubes clinking in the glass. When Elizabeth Taylor would move across the room with a cocktail glass (which was often in the movie) the sound of the clinking cubes was amplified louder.

This sound was a brilliant subliminal move to emphasize her constant drinking and was meant to be irritating. Clink clink clink...argue argue argue... and the friction of the couple's relationship enhanced by the sound.

Sounds are important.

mezzrow said...

"this soothing, gently percussive shuffling sound is revelatory."

Indeed. My position - it's all a matter of context. Some of us hear a gently percussive sound in our personal cabeza and find a different place entirely.

Here are some words from a prominent twentieth century philosopher as an example. Unlike Buck, I've learned to trust but verify.

Oh, I must have had rocks in my head
Well, I believed anything that you said
Like a puppy I rolled over and played dead
Oh, I must have had rocks in my head.
Yes, I must have had rocks in my head...


Buck Owens - Rocks In My Head

Mikey NTH said...

There is nothing so simple that we cannot complicate it.

Mary Beth said...

Sonic has ice like that. It's my favorite ice. Not favorite enough for me to make a special trip to Sonic, favorite enough to make me wish more other places had it too. The only other place I remember finding it was a Little League baseball field concession stand.

policraticus said...

There was a lot to like about the pellet ice machine. But it was expensive to run and very expensive to repair. It also required a pricey filtration system keep our mineral rich water from bending the finely machined auger that forms the pellets. Also, the layers and crevices in the ice tended to precipitate out the carbonation from soda drinks much more quickly than standard cubes. So, we didn’t replace it with another, went with a more affordable air cooled cube machine.

rehajm said...

It's popular with golf courses. Back when there weren't laws mandating fear of cooties many place in Florida had machines cranking that ice out. Pull up to the comfort station, make a satisfying pull from the stack of disturbingly large styrofoam cups, push in the lever under the dispenser and a few clunks later you've summoned an oasis from the humid swelter.

rehajm said...

I don't really care about the first world problem of having the correct type of ice in one's drink...

Don't blame us- we voted for the first world guy and not for the team turning first world to third.

J. Farmer said...

I love the sound of ice cubes clinking in a glass. My favorite kind of ice is cylindrical with a hole through the center. Crushed ice melts too fast and dilutes your drink. I like my beverages stinging cold.

I think the most sublime beverage is a bottle of Mexican Coca-Cola chilled in the freezer and then poured into a chilled highball glass. If done right, there should be a thin layer of ice crystals on the top. Perfection. One of the reasons Coke tastes so much better at McDonald's is they invest a lot of effort into keeping it very cold.

Mike (MJB Wolf) said...

The snap and crackle of cubes fracturing when the liquid is introduced is a nice sound.

Ann Althouse said...

"don't know HOW they make hospital ice chips, which are pellet shaped, but they're Easily crunchable; unlike a regular ice cube."

The article talks about this. It's a special machine, something too big and expensive to have at home (maybe Nancy Pelosi could have one in her kitchen). Hospitals do have them, and they have them because they work very well for people who aren't supposed to drink too much water.

Churchy LaFemme: said...

Sounds like it should be easily chewable, which is a big plus for ice in my book.

Hardee's years ago had the best, chewy, ice, but they apparently didn't realize it was a plus factor and dumped it.

Ann Althouse said...

"Sonic has ice like that. It's my favorite ice. Not favorite enough for me to make a special trip to Sonic, favorite enough to make me wish more other places had it too. The only other place I remember finding it was a Little League baseball field concession stand."

The article talks about this, mentions Sonic and the search for other restaurants that do pellet ice.

J. Farmer said...

p.s. I can still remember being shocked when I learned that hot tea was a thing. I had always thought tea only came in two varieties: sweetened or unsweetened.

Also, fun fact: one of the most common sources of health code violations for restaurants are ice machines.

NorthOfTheOneOhOne said...

Ann Althouse said...

The article talks about this. It's a special machine, something too big and expensive to have at home (maybe Nancy Pelosi could have one in her kitchen). Hospitals do have them, and they have them because they work very well for people who aren't supposed to drink too much water.

Not really. We have one of the GE Opal ice makers. It's big, but it does fit on the counter top. The phone app is ridiculously bad, though.

stevew said...

@tim maguire: good and funny questions. The device goes for about $1500. Are sold out (and may not be shipped to Japan). Amazon lists ice ball molds for $20 - $40 (brief search). My refrigerator ice maker (included) makes 1-inch ice nuggets that are square, flat on one side, and domed on the other. I'm not aware of the noise they make in a glass. They certainly melt faster than the ones made with that Macallan thing. Oh well, I won't be hosting any single malt sipping events any time soon anyway.

Rusty said...

"It's the part about the sound that interests me the most. I have a quirky dislike for the sound of ice cubes clinking in a glass."
I always thought that the sound of ice in a cocktail was a jolly, anticipatory sound.

Amexpat said...

I have a quirky dislike for the sound of ice cubes clinking in a glass.

I like it. There's a festive association for me and perhaps a bit of a Pavlovian reaction.

Joe Smith said...

If it's filling a glass more efficiently then that's great news for those selling drinks.

More ice, less booze.

Profit!

Freeman Hunt said...

We have had one of those Opal ice machines since 2017. Excellent ice. Highly recommended.

Freeman Hunt said...

"The phone app is ridiculously bad, though."

What is the app for? I've never downloaded it. It's a singlr-button machine with one function. Why is there an app?

Nancy said...

Ice dilutes the drink! I hates it! I always ask for a spoon with my Sangria so I can take out all but one of the ice cubes. But I suppose the restaurant is entitled to economize by giving me a drink that is 3/4 ice.

NorthOfTheOneOhOne said...

Freeman Hunt said...

What is the app for? I've never downloaded it. It's a singlr-button machine with one function. Why is there an app?

Basically so you can control it remotely. You can also do things like set up the ice making on a schedule via the app, except the scheduling function of the app doesn't work and constantly wipes out your schedule. Personally, I don't particularly think there's a need to have ice made on a schedule, but Mrs. NorthOfTheOneOhOne has a flair for over complicating simple things and thinks it should be so. As an IT professional I am offended that GE would put out such a piece of shit app, though.

NorthOfTheOneOhOne said...

@Freeman Hunt:

We've got the 2.0 version, purchased late last year. Different model from yours. Also, Opal is owned by GE now.

Howard said...

Aired up ice always seems polluted to me. I like it crystal clear. I love the sound of ice and Scotch in a heavy tumbler at first while the viscosity is high. After the ice melts, the sounds are too high pitched. This is motivation to down the drink before the whiskey water ratio drops.

I love having first world problems because the alternative sucks.

Charlie Currie said...

The distinction between Coffee Bean and Starbucks.
Between the local, once Greek owned, burger joint and most chain joints.

My wife would love one of these ice machines in our home. She'll order a large drink with extra ice - especially in a styrofoam cup - just so she can add more diet coke to it at home.

Freeman Hunt said...

"We've got the 2.0 version, purchased late last year. Different model from yours. Also, Opal is owned by GE now."

Right, but I'm guessing the apps do the same thing. The ice maker always shows up as an available bluetooth connection and makes me laugh.

Freeman Hunt said...

NorthOfTheOneOhOne, I read your comments out of order. I think it's funny that there are so many apps to control things remotely around the house. I'd have preferred that the ice maker had been cheaper instead.

Joe Smith said...

"She'll order a large drink with extra ice - especially in a styrofoam cup - just so she can add more diet coke to it at home."

So she's buying frozen water at the price of soda?

wildswan said...

Third Way ice. Cracked ice with (Mexican) Coke. Neither the cube nor the crush. You only need a bag, and a hammer or rolling pin. Or an old-time soda fountain plus a nickel but time travel is harder.

NorthOfTheOneOhOne said...

Freeman Hunt said...

NorthOfTheOneOhOne, I read your comments out of order. I think it's funny that there are so many apps to control things remotely around the house. I'd have preferred that the ice maker had been cheaper instead.

@Freeman:

Yes, I agree.

What's ironic about our situation is that two feet away from the Opal, we have a Dualit toaster that's so simple it doesn't even pop up when the bread's done toasting! Does a great job and is 100% repairable. 1940's tech for me when it comes to home appliances! Whoo hoo!

rcocean said...

Really? I LOVE ice cubes clinking in my glass. Especially if I have some Gin or whisky in it.

rehajm said...

I love having first world problems because the alternative sucks.

I'll drink to that with two fingers of bourbon with two large top hat cubes of ice, in a tub.

gilbar said...

Mary Beth said...
Sonic has ice like that.


Really? i'll have to check that out, thanx!

rehajm said...

Sonic has ice like that.

In fact people often refer to pellet ice as Sonic ice. Good call by the ice machine buyer at Sonic!

Joe Smith said...

I prefer the ice that comes in tubes with holes in the middle...

Jaq said...

MOMA in Manhattan has the best ice cubes, IMHO.

Ann Althouse said...

"We have one of the GE Opal ice makers. It's big, but it does fit on the counter top."

If it's pellet ice, why do they refer to it as "nugget ice." I'm not convinced it's the same thing. In any case, it's $500. Not *that* expensive. Not prohibitively expensive. But the main thing I'd like to know is whether this is the same thing the New Yorker writer is raving about.

Ann Althouse said...

"Really? I LOVE ice cubes clinking in my glass. Especially if I have some Gin or whisky in it."

People who drink glassfuls of alcoholic beverages with ice in it tend to drink too much. That's what it sounds like to me. Idiots getting sloshed.

Jaq said...

"I love the sound of ice and Scotch in a heavy tumbler at first while the viscosity is high”

Almost got one right. A crystal whisky tumbler is the way to elevate the experience. I don’t even know why, but I only drink spirits out of plain glass as a last resort. I don’t think it’s a signalling thing, as I do it even when having a wee dram watching a movie alone at night.

On the other hand, red wine is fine out of a coffee mug. Go figure.

Ann Althouse said...

Our refrigerator has an ice-maker. It's been working for 30 years! I don't use the ice very often. Most likely to use it as a smoothie ingredient. But if we ever have to buy a new refrigerator, I wish I could get one with a pellet ice-maker!

Jaq said...

"People who drink glassfuls of alcoholic beverages with ice in it tend to drink too much.”

Um no. The selection of the ice for a glass of scotch is very important. You don’t want too much water in the mix, so you need a slow melting cube, or a very small amount of ice. If you are drinking your drinks like a coke from McDonalds as if you are at a frat party, that’s different, I guess.

rehajm said...

If it's pellet ice, why do they refer to it as "nugget ice." I'm not convinced it's the same thing

I believe they both refer to an ice cube that's shaped like the stuff you shovel into a pellet stove. Or a rabbits food hopper...

Freeman Hunt said...

"But the main thing I'd like to know is whether this is the same thing the New Yorker writer is raving about."

The writer seems to think so.

rehajm said...

People who drink glassfuls of alcoholic beverages with ice in it tend to drink too much. That's what it sounds like to me. Idiots getting sloshed.

A mint julep is the perfect drink for pellet ice. So yes, idiots getting sloshed, but well dressed idiots. With fancy hats.

Joe Smith said...

"Idiots getting sloshed."

I thought you were a law professor, not a judge : )

Joe Smith said...

"People who drink glassfuls of alcoholic beverages with ice in it tend to drink too much."

Except for the fact that hundreds of cocktails require ice...try getting a brandy old fashioned in WI and get back to me...

rehajm said...

I thought you were a law professor, not a judge : )

...and I thought Wisconsin was a land of professional drinkers? You seem to have protocol for alcohol in any situation. I figured you needed to pass some kind of drinking test go get your high school diploma.

Cheryl said...

I have a Scotsman ice maker that makes this pellet ice. We installed it when we built our house five years ago...probably one of my favorite purchases ever. I keep a Tervis tumbler of ice water around all day and it makes the water much colder, very fast (which I admit should not be an issue if I'm keeping the water around all day). I absolutely love it. I am not proud and often put the ice in a glass of white wine in the summer. Very cold and refreshing on a hot and humid Georgia afternoon!

My husband doesn't like it--he's not an ice guy. We have the large silicone molds for his large cubes that he occasionally puts in a glass of rum or bourbon at night. Something for everyone!

Churchy LaFemme: said...

I have a Scotsman ice maker that makes this pellet ice.

Ah then it's not a true Scotsman!

Known Unknown said...

Pellet ice is the bomb. My daughter and I call it crunchy ice. Our new fridge makes pellet ice.

Whiskeybum said...

Whiskey :)

Gin :(

I take my whiskey neat.

I never get ‘sloshed’.

Known Unknown said...

"It's bad for beverages where you want cold and minimal dilution, like straight bourbon or scotch or when like a manhattan you're mixing to blend and make cold and dispensing without ice into a glass."

I can see this. For those, you need one of those golf-ball style ice "cube."

rcocean said...

"People who drink glassfuls of alcoholic beverages with ice in it tend to drink too much. That's what it sounds like to me. Idiots getting sloshed."

Yes, it would be idiotic to drink "Glassfuls" of whiskey or gin, with or without ice. Who does that? No one I know. I thought we were talking Ice CUBES. in a whisky glass clinking. Or some gin and tonic over several ice CUBES - clinking.

Sorry, if I brought out the inner prude or inner carry nation in you.

rcocean said...

BTW, Some peeps think ice/water with scotch is heresy. Because it dilutes the scotch. They think club soda is even worse. FYI, I think a small amount of ice, not too much, is OK. Besides I don't really buy super expensive whiskey because I can't tell the difference.

Gin and vermouth goes well over ice. So does Gin and a squeeze of lemon or lime. frankly, I'm not much of a gin drinker except in these two cases. FDR used to delight in happy hour cocktails done right around 5 PM. However, most people say that FDR made them too sweet, and used too much ice. Eleanor, of course, didn't drink Martinis.

rcocean said...

One Martini is alright, two is too many, and three is not enough." -

ken in tx said...

In high school I had a part time job as a soda jerk at an old time soda fountain. I had to shave ice chips off a block of ice for the drinks. The shaver was a hand tool with 4 prongs and a blade between the prongs. It made thin flakes sort of like cornflakes in size. I haven't seen ice like that since.

ken in tx said...

Instead of scotch and soda, try scotch and Coors lite. It brings out the malt flavor of both and is the only practical use for Coors Lite that I have found. I discovered this at a party when they ran out of club soda.