October 8, 2020

"Six men charged in alleged plot to kidnap Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer."

"At a meeting, the men discussed attacking a Michigan State Police facility, and in a separate conversation one defendant suggested shooting up the governor’s vacation home, authorities allege" — NBC reports.
At a meeting in July, allegedly attended and recorded by one of the informants, the men “discussed attacking a Michigan State Police facility, and in a separate conversation after the meeting, Garbin suggested shooting up the Governor’s vacation home," authorities said. Then at a July 27 meeting, Fox and an informant discussed a possible kidnapping of Whitmer, with the defendant allegedly saying: “Snatch and grab, man. Grab the f---ing governor. Just grab the b----. Because at that point, we do that, dude — it’s over.”

191 comments:

MayBee said...

What gross weirdos.

The idea of attacking the police AND Whitmer makes them seem like a bit of an oddball group.
Let's not kidnap the governor, guys. Similarly, let's not throw flaming objects at the mayor's condo. Let's not try to storm police headquarters or courthouses. Let's just not.

Chris said...

Whitmer is the worst thing to happen to Michigan, but I am very glad they infiltrated and broke this up. What a bunch of shitheads.

R C Belaire said...

Trump will be blamed for inciting this in 3, 2, 1, ...

wild chicken said...

So far to the right they came out over on the left.

Or vice versa.

Lyle said...

Did they do any acts in furtherance of this conversation?

Browndog said...

Total set-up and orchestrated by the FBI. They can't find any right-wing terrorists so they invent them with their own agents.

Look up "Hutari" from the Obama years. FBI may be more rogue under Wray than they were under Mueller or Comey.

"Bi-partisan support" is deep state every single time.

doctrev said...

From the upcoming evidence reveal:

[FBI Agent] Hey guys we should do something about Whitmer.

[Guy 1] Yeah we should protest!

[Guy 2] Pretty sure she banned that.

[FBI Agent] No I mean we could take her out. You guys aren't some pussies who don't have guns right?

[Guy 1+2] Hell no! We have awesome manly guns! With the thing that goes up and everything!


[FBI Agent] So its decided we are formally going to overthrow the governor right!

[FBI Agent] Left the chat


[Guy 1] You're friend is weird. Anyway I gotta get back to work

[Guy 2] My friend?!?

Mike Sylwester said...

That seems like a good idea.

tim maguire said...

Lyle said...Did they do any acts in furtherance of this conversation?

Was wondering that myself. Where's the crime here? Is the crime that we are a few weeks out from an election and Michigan is not reliably locked up by the Dems yet?

mockturtle said...

So they knew about the conspiracy all year but decided--just now--to file charges. I smell a rat. Make that a pack of rats.

Kevin said...

So the FBI can catch these people but not the rogue agents in their own building?

Howard said...

Defund the FBI

Drago said...

This seems alot like that strange dude living in his van in Florida arrested in 2018 for supposedly sending pipebombs to politicians.....

....and whaddya know, that arrest occurred in Oct just before the election too.

What a coincidence! And both times it feeds directly into the democratical talking points.....hmmmmm

Howard said...

Trump pulls out of debate. Afraid to wheeze on national TV

n.n said...

Probable? Actionable? Thought crime?

Francisco D said...

A key piece of evidence was missing from the report:

They were wearing Hawaiian shirts

steve uhr said...

Trump will be blamed for inciting this because he did incite this. Waiting for the pictures of these goons at his rallies. Think they’re Biden supporters RC?

WWIII Joe Biden, Husk-Puppet + America's Putin said...

fishy.

I'm Full of Soup said...

I suspect there will be no convictions from this "crime".

The Vault Dweller said...

I'm skeptical about this one. Sounds a bit more like people blowing off steam than seriously plotting to kidnap a governor of a state. Especially given the delay between the alleged 'plotting' and the police action to arrest now. If police found a credible plan back in July for someone to kidnap a governor but waited for three months to act to arrest, it sounds like the police didn't really think it was serious but some dopey 27 year old, politically ambitious, lawyer in the DA's office pushed the case and didn't realize how weird the 3 month delay looks to all normal people.

Yancey Ward said...

The story describes a lot of talking, but I am missing the evidence of an actual crime here. It isn't like they were arrested on their way to shoot up a police station or kidnap the governor. Really- is talking about a crime enough to send someone to jail? It isn't even inciting of a crime that I can tell. Is this really the state of the law in this day and age- that talking not doing can send you to jail?

Mattman26 said...

Will Trump he asked if he condemns? (And if so will he say yes?)

Charlie Currie said...

Are we sure these so called perpetrators aren't Michigan supreme court justices?

I'm Full of Soup said...

Althouse - this is OT but are the hospitals in WI overflowing with Covid patients?

5M - Eckstine said...

All sizzle no steak.

How many ex cons and associates fantasize aloud future crimes to FBI informants when sharing meth? All of them. And these days isn't the FBI the less reputable then crackpot extremists on drugs? I'd have to see where they have an actual plan and spent some time and money on it.

I'm Full of Soup said...

Althouse - this is OT but are the hospitals in WI overflowing with Covid patients?

5M - Eckstine said...

Blogger Howard said...
Trump pulls out of debate. Afraid to wheeze on national TV

Fake news and mindreading.

The Vault Dweller said...

I wonder if this is hold overs in the FBI who dislike Trump who pushed this prosecution? Seeing the lurid details about Strzok and Page there are certainly horrendously awful people in the FBI who would be willing to force a prosecution for 'political' gain. Maybe this is one of them?

Yancey Ward said...

I pretty much guarantee you that "furtherance" evidence will consist of buying ammo or guns.

FullMoon said...

No alcohol or encouragement by law enforcement or informants involved. Again.
At least the govt agents did not provide the bomb for the terrorist this time.

D.D. Driver said...

There's a boy-who-cried-wolf element about this:

https://www.cnn.com/2012/03/28/justice/michigan-militia-trial/index.html

steve uhr said...

Let’s all pay close attention and see which of the extremist commentators here are suddenly absent.

bleh said...

Trump's anti-lockdown "LIBERATE MICHIGAN" tweet from back in April is going to be blamed for this. Just watch.

Temujin said...

Crazy is oozing out of both ends.

Leland said...

FBI also had evidence that Trump hired two hookers in Russia and had them pee on a bed. The original source of the evidence was a drunk at a Russian bar, but it was laundered through a UK spy and later through US media, so supposedly intelligent people thought it was real.

Darrell said...

Reminds me of the time I was going to bomb Chuck with Flounders. Then the price went up 3 cents per pound.

Mike of Snoqualmie said...

So, the FBI can penetrate a conspiracy to kidnap Michigan's governor, but they can't penetrate either Antifa or BLM? The can't follow the money chain of either group to their backers? What has the FBI been doing for the last 4 months? Nothing.

Wilbur said...

It would be unusual, to say the least, for an indictment or information to be filed under these facts and circumstances without the knowledge and approval of the highest level of the prosecutor's office.

Jason said...

Plotting to kidnap her at her vacation home is a nice touch.

Are they sure this isn't a troll?

Achilles said...

Howard said...

Trump pulls out of debate. Afraid to wheeze on national TV

Democrats are just stupid people.

Nonapod said...

So way back in July a small group of irascible idiots suggest this at a meeting with an FBI informant present. Beyond that this story is pretty thin on details. Did this informant egg them on, entraping them? How likely were they to be able to actually pull something like this off? Was this just blowing off steam or was there an actual concrete plan that was realistic? And if this all happened back in July, why are we just hearing about this now... in October... mere weeks before the election?

Jim at said...

It was a mostly peaceful kidnapping plot, right?

Mikey NTH said...

It would end up being The Ransom of Red Chief.

NorthOfTheOneOhOne said...

From the NBC article:

n a YouTube video from May, Caserta claimed in a 30-minute diatribe that “the enemy is government.” He shot the video in front of an anarchist’s flag and a map of Michigan.

Wait! Michigan Militia group? Anarchist flag? Something doesn't smell right!

Kai Akker said...

---Did they do any acts in furtherance of this conversation?

Yes, they did. They told each other to talk to their neighbors to enlist them for the project. It would be easier with 200 than with six. Neighbors are a good source of accomplices for terroristic actions. These people are clearly evil and clearly geniuses. That makes them evil geniuses, correct?

rehajm said...

The arrests grew out of an FBI investigation...

All I hear is The arrests grew out of an lying-asshole-coup-enablers investigation...

BUMBLE BEE said...

Whitmer is right up there with Kamala in the "sympathetic" league. This "plot" sounds so fucked up it must be Whitmer's home Brew. Soros gettin his money's worth out of her. One might think a governor would live by the state's constitution, maybe even read it?

Mark O said...

Quick. They caught Hillary and Brennan. Kamala bombed. We need a diversion.

YoungHegelian said...

Wake me up when a militia lays siege to the downtown area of a mid-sized city in a Republican district for months at a time.

When I phrase it like that, it shows just how weird Portland is, right? I mean, shouldn't the Antifa guys be trying to take over a Republican stronghold, and not targeting one of the most progressive cities in the country? Trust me, I surrounded by liberals. They never believe how much the Far Left hates them. Portland Antifa is trying to build the next Paris Commune on the bodies of liberals.

hombre said...

Don’t look for a conviction on this one. Democrats needed a pre-election “militia” or “white supremacist” bust. The FBI delivered.

Curious George said...

From the story:

"Six men are under arrest for "conspiring to kidnap" Michigan's Democratic governor, Gretchen Whitmer...."

Later:

"Based on court documents, the FBI was well aware of the activities of the six men charged Thursday and there does not seem to have been an imminent threat posed to Gov. Whitmer, a Democrat.

Yeah we get it. What a bunch of crap.

Kai Akker said...

--Trump will be blamed for inciting this because he did incite this. [steve uhr]

Yes, stupid. Everybody knows overthrowing government execs is reserved for the top brass only.

WisRich said...

So Antifa on a Tuesday. Of course, Antifa actually followed through and did destroy a couple of police headquarters.

West Texas Intermediate Crude said...

They would have brought her back in like 20 minutes.

John Clifford said...

I'm skeptical, too. First, what would be the point? A kidnap implies a ransom... what could they possibly get for releasing her besides life inside a federal prison? Second, if they were really angry at her, there were more practical alternatives. I think this was a bunch of idiots venting, not realizing they were in the presence of a federal undercover agent. I also have to wonder if the agent egged them on (as per one of the comments above). I'd give even odds that they aren't convicted of any of the current charges... wouldn't be surprised if someone pleads because they're scared and the federal prosecutor will load up the charges.

John Borell said...

As with most of these plots, I'm skeptical about how much was encouraged by the informant.

That said, I totally disavow any plot of this nature, if real. If you disagree with Michigan's governor, use the courts (as was successfully done) or vote her out of office.

Iman said...

Give me a call when people like these start rioting, murdering, looting and burning America down like the shock troops of the Democrats do.

Chennaul said...

Blogger Browndog said...
Total set-up and orchestrated by the FBI. They can't find any right-wing terrorists so they invent them with their own agents.

..............

Find the report and read it for yourself. Sounds like Bugaloo Boys. It is the press labeling them as right wing, IIRC the FBI does not do that.

Honestly if you think kidnapping her during Election Day would have worked well for Trump you would be wrong,

Honestly all of the conspiracy shit reminds me of The Left with the steel doesn’t melt crap, 9/11 was an inside job hysteria.

Then the Coronavirus is a world wide conspiracy, which makes some Righties sound like OJ Simpson defenders.

Chennaul said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
TheOne Who Is Not Obeyed said...

So the rule is lefties can actually attack police stations and federal buildings, but alt-righties cannot even talk about it? Did I get that right?

Most likely the FBI trying to undercut Trump again. Time to disband them and move their responsibilities to less corrupt agencies.

Kevin said...

Then at a July 27 meeting, Fox and an informant discussed a possible kidnapping of Whitmer, with the defendant allegedly saying: “Snatch and grab, man. Grab the f---ing governor. Just grab the b----. Because at that point, we do that, dude — it’s over.”

You could induce this same conversation at Althouse Blog.

If you substitute "Trump" for "the f---ing governor", it probably already happened.

mtrobertslaw said...

If true, this woman is so obnoxious that after 2 minutes in captivity her captors would ask her to please leave and would even call a cab for her.

ga6 said...

OK Wray; now get the organizers in Wauwatosa last night. Or maybe Kenosha.

I'm Full of Soup said...

And the state of Michigan's AG is far far left staunch lockdown-defending lesbian so I'm not believing much out of her office.

Static Ping said...

Normally, I would be glad that the FBI was doing its job and that would be the end of it.
However, the FBI has proven itself to be unreliable to a degree that I would never have believed possible, so who the heck knows.

exiledonmainstreet, green-eyed devil said...

mtrobertslaw said...
If true, this woman is so obnoxious that after 2 minutes in captivity her captors would ask her to please leave and would even call a cab for her.

10/8/20, 1:55 PM

My thoughts exactly.

Whitmer is even more unlikable like Kamala Harris and that's saying something.

iowan2 said...

Trump will be blamed for inciting this in 3, 2, 1, ...

Live on TV 2:03 CDT

walter said...

Gotta be Boogerloo Boyz.

exiledonmainstreet, green-eyed devil said...

Opps! "unlikable than"

Now, where did I put my reading glasses?

daskol said...

1. chances of the FBI using an "informant" to encourage this group of idiots approaches 100%. Chances it was straight up entrapment, given the timing, probably similar.
2. if there were one person I could think of who most embodies what is most hateful about government, it would be Cuomo. He combines a similar autocratic attitude with a tough guy attitude and mafia tactics that I find both more irritating and more alarming. But if you gave me two, she'd make the list.

This is an attempted October surprise to bolster the narrative of dangerous and violent right-wingers. Let's see how quickly it falls apart. They did choose the right target because as a woman, if you're not familiar with her, Whitmer is more sympathetic than Cuomo

daskol said...

This is like a northern states version of a Justified episode, and I wish Elmore Leonard were around to read and chuckle about it. I can't wait to learn more about these knuckleheads, including all the law enforcement folks involved.

Dave Begley said...

Has a recall petition been filed against her?

Rt41Rebel said...

A kidnapping is infinitely more difficult to pull off than an assassination. Something doesn't add up just on this fact.

mockturtle said...

I'm Full of Soup asks: Althouse - this is OT but are the hospitals in WI overflowing with Covid patients?

Good question. Remember when we were told that we 'just need to flatten the curve' to avoid overwhelming the hospitals? Fauci rightly acknowledged that the virus would have to run its course. But now the mantra seems to be: Prevent anyone from ever getting the virus. By the time this is over, we'll have no immunity to anything and will probably start dropping like flies from assorted other infections.

Curious George said...

"mtrobertslaw said...
If true, this woman is so obnoxious that after 2 minutes in captivity her captors would ask her to please leave and would even call a cab for her."

Haha a modern day Ransom of Red Chief

exiledonmainstreet, green-eyed devil said...

These idiots are "right-wing militia?" Yeah, sure:

https://twitter.com/julie_kelly2/status/1314274751746052098?s=21

The ringleader has an anarchist flag hanging behind him.

Joe Smith said...

"Trump pulls out of debate. Afraid to wheeze on national TV"

Biden hasn't had his daily fluff yet...Howard and readering can fight for the 'honor.'

May the best Marxist win...

iowan2 said...

These guys are all released on their own recognizance right? No bail. That's the latest leftist talking point, cant be locking up people not convicted of anything, and bail is discrimination. I can't wait until these guys are back in their club house by sundown.

I'd like to believe the FBI, but they have proven themselves to be political operatives that have take sides.

Humperdink said...

The Uhrinal convinced me, I'm all in for Biden now!

Mattman26 said...

West Texas Intermediate Crude and mtrobertslaw both working on the "Ransom of Redchief" theory. Makes sense.

Michael K said...

Blogger steve uhr said...
Trump will be blamed for inciting this because he did incite this. Waiting for the pictures of these goons at his rallies. Think they’re Biden supporters RC?


More likely Bernie bros. Remember how 50% of the 14 year old girls in internet chat rooms are FBI agents? This has FBI sting all over it.

Leland said...

In other news, Katie Hill's staffers take over her Twitter account to note how sophisticated she is about sex and abusing her staffers.

Michael K said...

Blogger Mike of Snoqualmie said...
So, the FBI can penetrate a conspiracy to kidnap Michigan's governor, but they can't penetrate either Antifa or BLM? The can't follow the money chain of either group to their backers? What has the FBI been doing for the last 4 months? Nothing.


That is the DoJ and the US Marshall's Service. Nobody trusts the FBI anymore. The Marshall's Service will be the new FBI

Bay Area Guy said...

It'd be really nice if the Feds took such initiative with BLM and Antifa -- groups that actually COMMIT VIOLENT CRIMES rather than talk about it loosely, like these bozos.

Charlotte Allen said...

I smell a movie plot: ham-handed militia yokels kidnap liberal woman who is so obnoxious that no one wants to ransom her. They can't very well set her free (she has figured out where their hideaway is), so they decide to human-traffic her as a domestic servant and fall in with a Serbian gang....

Mark said...

6 less to 'stand by'.

M said...

So they talked about doing things ANTIFA and BLM have already done? Where was the FBI when ANTIFA and BLM were planning their reign of destruction?

Francisco D said...

This is a laughable "plot". If it were lefties, the media would be saying it it was completely peaceful.

However, I will give Chris Wray credit. His people are ace detectives able to find needles in haystacks (aka right wing extremists in their mommy's basements).

Jason said...

Did they try to set a whole apartment building on fire with the Governor in it?

Because Antifa did just that with a big city mayor.

Freeman Hunt said...

Weird that law enforcement can track down crazy right-wingers *talking* about attacking police headquarters and government officials but seems to have a rough time tracking down crazy left-wingers who are actually doing it!

MountainMan said...

Howard said..."Trump pulls out of debate. Afraid to wheeze on national TV"

Hear Trump give a pretty long interview with Maria Bartiromo very early this morning. No ad breaks, no interruptions. No wheezing, he sounded completely normal.

No, the reason he pulled out of the debate is Biden and he Dems cannot be trusted to do a video debate. I don't blame him.

Chennaul said...

So if you want to make the argument that police are not all bad apples then the same would apply to the FBI.

They saved Trump from this Election Day plot and somehow it is their conspiracy doesn’t work. It has been observed that The October Surprise due to the speed of the internet—now has to come as late as November, and this is exactly what these guys were plotting.

Yet somehow the FBI stopping this a good few weeks of this is supposedly them trying to time things against Trump.

You guys have become just as sheltered from logic as The Left....well not quite but it is getting there

Marc in Eugene said...

They would have brought her back in like 20 minutes.

I laughed aloud at this. But I wonder that there have not been serious attempts on Mr Trump's life, given the vitriol and actual violence on the Left.

Rusty said...

: “Snatch and grab, man. Grab the f---ing governor. Just grab the b----. Because at that point, we do that, dude — it’s over.”
It is now.
I'd like to hear those tapes. I bet the FBI were pissing themselves laughing.

Mark said...

LIBERATE MICHIGAN!

Trump, April 17, 2020

Spiros said...

These are Trump's "Second Amendment people." The Second Amendment reinforces our right to defend ourselves against a tyrannical government. These people (heck, it's scary just how many people) believe that the government no longer has the consent of the governed. The government is the enemy.

Paul said...

But but but... surely these were "Mostly Peaceful" kidnappers!

Wince said...

So, they were going to kidnap her and then what... hold her for random?

Isn't this the plot of Saving Silverrman?

"Michigan is my puppet, and I'm its puppet master."

Narr said...

The grapevine says that one of their demands was for one MILLION dollars . . .

Clowns enough to go around.

Narr
Public-private partnership!

Fernandinande said...

Snatch and grab, man.

Grab her by the snatch.

Mr Wibble said...

Honestly, it sounds like the plot of a comedy: “A group of inept militia kidnap an unpopular a state governor, only to discover that her obnoxious attitude drives them crazy. State officials conduct a half-hearted ‘search’, while secretly glad that she’s gone and fighting for control in the power vacuum. A local sheriff eventually begins to suspect the militia members and begins to investigate.”

Browndog said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
rcocean said...

It never got past the talking stage and the whole "plot" seems rather fuzzy and based on one informant's word. Basically, a couple of nuts and 2-3 others who just seem be fantasizing. The "plan" (based on the FBI affidavit) was to set off an explosion near the bridge of Whitmer's vacation home as a distraction, and then kidnap her and escape by boat.

Of course, they had no explosives, and no boat, and didn't have the Governor's schedule or any idea how many bodyguards, etc. she had. They had "surveilled" the house but had no idea if there were alarms or security systems. After they kidnapped her they were going to go to a "safe house" for a trial.

Simply absurd. They also discussed, damaging her house or damaging the Michagan State Police Hq building.

Titus said...

Do you know everyone wears a mask here? Even the homeless!

rcocean said...

The FBI doesn't seem to have done much on their own. There was one member of the group who went to the FBI in April 2000 and then forwarded audio tapes and phone call tapes to them. He or she, also provided the FBI with descriptions of all their meetings. You wonder why the FBI waited till now, since the Affidavit says the activity stopped in mid September.

rcocean said...

You have to wonder why Antifa and BLM which are injuring people and destroying property FOR REAL, aren't being infiltrated and monitored and arrested for conspiracy to commit crimes.

Jersey Fled said...

I'm confused. Isn't Whitmer white? So if you want to kidnap a white person you are a white supremacist? And if you're Black and kidnap a Black person, you're a Black supremacists?

Very confusing.

Chuck said...

It’s as if the Coen brothers drafted a screenplay inspired by the comments pages of the Althouse blog.

roesch/voltaire said...

Let's see they staked out her vacation home, blew up bombs with shrapnel to see how effective it would be against people, were hoping others would join them to over-throw the state gov..humm now we know why the FBI and others have warned that the biggest threat of domestic terrorism will come from militia groups and far-right organizations.

Browndog said...

It didn't take long for Gretchen Whitmer to get in front of a camera to blame Trump:

“Hate groups heard the president’s words as a rallying cry, as a call to action.”

mikee said...

White right wing militias need to recall that old truism from the counterculture 1960s: If someone at your political meeting is advocating violence, trying to get you to plant a bomb or assassinate someone, you've found the FBI mole.

PubliusFlavius said...

Waiting for the failed bullshit investigators to bust some of the left wing violence.....I won't hold my breath.

DINKY DAU 45 said...

trump "typhoid Mary" chickens out of debate after saying Biden afraid to debate..I wouldnt go anywhere near this steroid incompetent,,good for you Joe..You should do the TOWN HALL by yourself...let trump tweet away the day WE NEED A LEADER NOT A TWEETER..

Rana said...

Wonder if they're going to start rounding up all the people with the "Save Michigan, Impeach Whitmer" and "Our Governor is an Idiot. Pure Moron" (a play on the Pure Michigan ad campaign) signs that I see in abundance in my neck of the Michigan woods?

rehajm said...

The rule is if they don't mention the political party of the perpetrators they're Democrats. Antifa is close enough...

pete 23 said...

Trump's anti-lockdown "LIBERATE MICHIGAN" tweet from back in April is going to be blamed for this. Just watch.

Yep. See NBC news article.

Gospace said...

Any effective violence from the anti-government right is going to come from lone wolves, who aren't going to discuss it with anyone, nor post on Facebook, Twitter, or Althouse. They'll have their escape route planned, and have more targets in mind.

Static Ping said...

For the record, at least one of the guys is an anarchist. This is not your "standard" right-wing militia.

So, yes, I would believe anarchists would do something like this, because that's what anarchists do. See Portland, Seattle. I am somewhat doubtful that they got beyond the bitching stage though.

madAsHell said...

The FBI was involved??

Kidnap her?? I guess these guys didn't know much about hunting rifles.

This kinda smells like drama for the sake of drama. The Reichstag fire. Is she up for re-election??

Matt said...

Why can't these clowns ever practice better opsec?? Would be so exciting if one of these plots every actually got pulled off. How cool would it be to see the scumbag politicos actually in fear from citizens they've finally pushed over the edge, instead of those citizens fighting each other in the streets?

I would totally trade a David Dorn for a Gretchen Whitmer or a Jake Gardner for a Kim Gardner.

whitney said...

I'm glad they were able to stop the extremely vague but very convenient plot seeing as Homeland Security just decided that white people where is dangerous as China and Russia, two hostile nuclear superpowers. It makes them seem so competent. Why can't they stop these riots every night

Jupiter said...

Very disappointing. It's already October, and things have been so peaceful I had hoped we would get all the way through 2020 without anyone committing any crimes. Now this happens! This is why we can't have freedom of speech.

Drago said...

This reeks of COINTELPRO.

DanTheMan said...

>>trump "typhoid Mary" chickens out of debate

You have it exactly backwards.

Biden backed out of an in-person debate, and proposed a virtual one instead.

Trump is willing to have the debate in person. In other words, to keep to the original plan.

It's Biden who is refusing to honor his commitment.

Orwell would be proud of your efforts.

Howard said...

You must be Proud, Boys, of your obesity army.

TheOne Who Is Not Obeyed said...

"So if you want to make the argument that police are not all bad apples then the same would apply to the FBI."

Not really. There are many, many police departments with many, many different views and perspectives on how to police their very different communities. There are some bad apples but most are good.

There is one, single FBI agency, controlled from a central bureaucracy in Washington DC, that builds a single culture and ethos. Are there "good people" in the FBI? Sure? I know one. But as an institution, its leadership and culture are part of the toxic, self-aggrandizing stew of our Administrative Overlords in Washington. By its participation in the attempted coup against Trump, the entity we know as the FBI has shown itself to no longer be of service to the Nation or the Constitution. We had warning signs as early as the Clinton regime, but it's now become quite clear the FBI as we know it is beyond salvage and needs to be removed from our Republic.

walter said...

I'm Full of Soup asks: Althouse - this is OT but are the hospitals in WI overflowing with Covid patients?
--
WHA data

Unknown said...

Who makes up these stories?

mockturtle said...

The Deep State is deeper even than our President realized when he took office. And, as the Babylon Bee observed, those claiming to 'resist' are really thoroughly in agreement with universities, the elite globalists and the media. So the only thing they are 'resisting' is Trump. And his supporters, of course.

Unknown said...

SO SOME HACK MAKES UP A STORY PUTS IT ON A BLOG OR NEWS SITE AND IT BECOMES REAL?
IF THE AUDIENCE HAD ANY BRAINS IT WOULD STOP FROM INATTENTION!

TheOne Who Is Not Obeyed said...

Someone needs to dial back Dinky Dau's meds. Can we do a consult with Xer handlers in Shanghai?

Amadeus 48 said...

After Oklahoma City, it is a mistake to dismiss these fringe lunatics as obvious incompetents. But they are fringe lunatics. The big mistake that these characters are making is that Gretchen Whitmer is ready, willing, and able to destroy her own career by her unrelenting and extreme bossiness. Why create sympathy for her? Now SHE trots out the lie that Trump doesn’t denounce white supremacists at the debate.

But they really don’t want to take out Whitmer. They want to commit acts of terrorism in what they believe is an important cause. Doesn’t anyone read history? John Brown was a failure and a lunatic even though his cause was abolition.

Politics is about persuasion.

Sheesh.

FullMoon said...

mikee said...

White right wing militias need to recall that old truism from the counterculture 1960s: If someone at your political meeting is advocating violence, trying to get you to plant a bomb or assassinate someone, you've found the FBI mole.

10/8/20, 3:35 PM


Yeah, like the new guy who buys small quantities of weed all of a sudden wants to buy a dozen kilos-at above market rates.

Unknown said...

R/v
But they're not far-right, they're narchists.

exiledonmainstreet, green-eyed devil said...

MountainMan said...
Howard said..."Trump pulls out of debate. Afraid to wheeze on national TV"

He's co-hosting the Rush Limbaugh show tomorrow. That's 3 hours on the radio.

He's obviously not afraid of "wheezing."

n.n said...

Alleged? No professorship for you.

n.n said...

“Hate groups heard the president’s words as a rallying cry, as a call to action.”

Probable? Actionable? Thought crime? Alleged "hate" group. #HateLovesAbortion

50 shades of projection.

Jim at said...

6 less to 'stand by'.

Lefty Mark is too dumb to realize if the shit ever hits the fan, we're not targeting government officials. It'll be antifa shitheads like you.

bagoh20 said...

"Suspect Charged in Gretchen Whitmer Kidnap Plot Had Anarchist Flag, Hates Police"

https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2020/10/08/suspect-charged-in-gretchen-whitmer-kidnap-plot-had-anarchist-flag-hates-police/?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+breitbart+%28Breitbart+News%29

mockturtle said...

Per Browndog quoting Whitmer: “Hate groups heard the president’s words as a rallying cry, as a call to action.”

The only hate groups widely operative in the US today are Antifa and BLM. Why can't someone call them what they are?

Leland said...

So a few anarchist threaten to create their own autonomous zone in Michigan that may require harming the governor, and they are called a militia? So, those guys in Seattle, that destroyed a police precinct headquarters and occupied part of the city (that the Washington governor denied happened for weeks), what are they? Has the FBI announced any arrests of them? How about the peaceful protestors that tried burning down the mayor of Portland's condo?

Just last week, a couple of members of a rap band were identified as inciting the riot and looting of a Providence Rhode Island mall. They, the entire 4 person band, was called a "gang".

effinayright said...

roesch/voltaire said...
Let's see they staked out her vacation home, blew up bombs with shrapnel to see how effective it would be against people, were hoping others would join them to over-throw the state gov..humm now we know why the FBI and others have warned that the biggest threat of domestic terrorism will come from militia groups and far-right organizations.
*************

Funny....one of them is identified as an "anarchist".

Such folk aren't "right-wingers" by any stretch of the imagination. There's a helluva difference between believing in small and limited government, and no government at all.

And, of course, anarchists and Antifa are joined at the hip. "Overthrow the government? Let's start with the police." does that sound like "right-wing" thinking?

Are you just coming out of that induced coma the docs put you into last January, when Trump beat that faux impeachment? Because you seem to know jack shit.

Tom said...

Meal Force Six

bagoh20 said...

"It's Biden who is refusing to honor his commitment."

Of course, and his excuse was that Trump had the Covid, but Trump will be virus free by then, and immune. So there will be much less reason to avoid an in-person debate now than there was with the first one.

Did you know that Biden graduated near he top of his class, and went to school on a full scholarship, and gave a Navy Captain a medal in Afghanistan? Don't feel bad. Biden is the only one who knew those "facts".

Drago said...

mikee: "White right wing militias need to recall that old truism from the counterculture 1960s: If someone at your political meeting is advocating violence, trying to get you to plant a bomb or assassinate someone, you've found the FBI mole."

The same FBI who manufactured the russia collusion hoax with a hoax dossier and covered up for Hillary's unsecured server would never dream to do anything so untoward as manufacture a case that is timed to support the democratical narrative........would they?

Cesar Sayoc, a guy with a drug habit and mental issues, says hello and still wonders why he mailed "pipe bombs" that did not contain actual explosive and were not actually capable of exploding to prominent democrats just a week or so before the 2018 election...just in time to marry up with democratical narratives....

effinayright said...

@r/v:

Right-winger?

I got yer right-winger right HERE:

https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2020/10/08/suspect-charged-in-gretchen-whitmer-kidnap-plot-had-anarchist-flag-hates-police/

In case this news has caused you to...become incontinent... you can always use the old Joe Biden trick of using a shoehorm to clean out your tighty-whities.

FullMoon said...

Diff case but interesting article from 2012:
In numerous similar setups where the FBI has persuaded dupes to help plot “terror” attacks, the government offered big money in an effort to get the schemes off the ground. It remains unclear whether Nafis was given any cash reward for his “services.” However, most everything else was supplied by law enforcement — including the bogus bombs.
https://thenewamerican.com/fbi-celebrates-foiling-its-own-terror-plot-again/

bagoh20 said...

That thing that there is never any evidence of just seems to keep happening.

"Report: Progressive TX Mayoral Candidate Zul Mirza Mohamed Arrested and Charged With 109 Counts Of Voter Fraud"

https://www.waynedupree.com/2020/10/zul-mirza-mohamed-voter-fraud-texas/

I Callahan said...

Up yours, Howard. You haven’t added an intelligent comment to any thread in a long time.

Drago said...

LLR-lefty Chuck: "It’s as if the Coen brothers drafted a screenplay inspired by the comments pages of the Althouse blog."

LLR-lefty Chuck takes time out from coordinating democratical Detroit precinct election fraud to comment favorably on the latest deep state hit against a republican.

Since he is a "lawyer", when he's not providing detailed professional golf violation reports to the PGA, he really ought to be explaining why his magnificent Whitmer was smacked down 7 - 0 by the Michigan Supreme Court after LLR-lefty Chuck had vehemently declared Whitmer to be on solid legal ground with her orders.

bagoh20 said...

I'm sure that Antifa and BLM are kind of jealous they hadn't planned this, but these guys are their least effective allies. The average 18 year-old Antifa with a skateboard gets more violence done on a nightly basis than these guys.

WWIII Joe Biden, Husk-Puppet + America's Putin said...

Hate groups heard Nancy and Maxine's rally call for hate - and poof- Antifa Brownshirt arson.

Media not interested

zipity said...

One small problem people. The ring-leader has posted videos online.

With an Anarchist flag hanging on the wall in the background.

Unless you are asserting that Anarchists are now supporting Republicans and Trump.

At which point I would recommend you get your tiny little pin-head examined.

eric said...

This guy's youtube videos are pretty interesting, I'm glad I got to watch them before they're memory holed.

He seems like your pretty typical anarchist/AntiFa type. He even thought of attacking the police.

This is what our news media breeds by not calling these people out.

bagoh20 said...

The thing that makes Democrats think these guys are Trumpers is because they expressed respect for the Bill of Rights and the Constitution. Just because that's antithetical to Democrats doesn't mean it makes them Trumpers.

The Godfather said...

Are there a lot of "new" anti-Trump commenters here? Maybe I'm all wrong, but I sure think I'm seeing quite a few new names. @Althouse: Maybe you've become an "influencer". If you can monetize it, now's the time.

Drago said...

We've seen this stuff before, haven't we?

"WASHINGTON — The Justice Department moved on Monday to drop charges against two Russian shell companies accused of financing schemes to interfere in the 2016 election, saying that they were exploiting the case to gain access to delicate information that Russia could weaponize."

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/16/us/politics/concord-case-russian-interference.html

The Mueller/Weissman team of hacks that LLR-lefty Chuck praised as the best of the best never expected anyone to push back on bogus charges and as soon as pushback came LLR-lefty Chuck's magnificent Weissman and team folded like a house of cards.

As you read the article notice how the FBI/Mueller-Weissman hacks pretend they just have to drop the case to preserve national security, otherwise they'd have them for sure!

LOL

BUMBLE BEE said...

She has been flailing about with the Right Wing Extremist conspiracy ever since she tasted the "spotlight". Building herself up during her series of over reaches. Take a look at the Covid Stats for the state... ain't shit happening. She called out Hydroxy-Zinc and was made a fool of by the two largest hospital concerns who have been using the combo for some time now. Called for thousands of emergency beds, fewer than 100 ever used. Trying to puff up her "Fightin Image". She is on everybody's shit list. Had to learn how to dress for TV appearances too.

Drago said...

This little ploy by the FBI is no different than what the CIA pulled by sending Joseph Wilson to Africa to "investigate" whether or not Iraq had sought uranium yellow cake in Africa (Spoiler: They had) but good old Wilson, appointed by his wife Valerie Plame who recommended him to her CIA bosses (wink wink: they were all in on it).

The point was to completely undermine W Bush in the lead up to the 2004 election.

And to think that, in the end, these deep staters would have W so cowed and beaten down that he would basically agree to whatever they wanted by the last 2 years of his administration and would later be part of the pro-obama Bush family faction.

You'd think the deep staters would have known what a pushover W Bush was and taken it a bit easier on him.

Drago said...

Unknown: "R/v But they're not far-right, they're narchists."

Correct.

Now that we've had more than an hour or 2 to flesh this out it appears the ringleader is indeed an anarchist who hates Trump and calls Trump a tyrant.

That makes this guy....wait for it....wait for it....

...one of Howard's Heroes!!

LOL

Tell the truth, didn't you just have a feeling something like this was going to happen?

Robert Cook said...

"So the rule is lefties can actually attack police stations and federal buildings, but alt-righties cannot even talk about it? Did I get that right?"

If people attack police stations and there are no dragnets or mass arrests, one can fairly assume the attackers were agents provocateurs, and not real protesters.

Matt Sablan said...

"If people attack police stations and there are no dragnets or mass arrests, one can fairly assume the attackers were agents provocateurs, and not real protesters."

-- Ah, another classic unfalsifiable, "Heads I win, tails you lose," style argument.

Greg The Class Traitor said...

Robert Cook said...
"So the rule is lefties can actually attack police stations and federal buildings, but alt-righties cannot even talk about it? Did I get that right?"

If people attack police stations and there are no dragnets or mass arrests, one can fairly assume the attackers were agents provocateurs, and not real protesters.


Really? That's the story now? That Antifa and BLM are "agents provocateurs, and not real protesters"?

Exactly who are they "agents provocateurs" for? The Democrat Party?

WWIII Joe Biden, Husk-Puppet + America's Putin said...

- please ignore these freaks and the bad stuff they deliver

released again.

Greg The Class Traitor said...

Kai Akker said...
Lyle: Did they do any acts in furtherance of this conversation?

Yes, they did. They told each other to talk to their neighbors to enlist them for the project. It would be easier with 200 than with six. Neighbors are a good source of accomplices for terroristic actions. These people are clearly evil and clearly geniuses. That makes them evil geniuses, correct?


That was sarcasm, right?

Because in Federal law "conspiracy" requires an overt act. Talking is not, IIRC, an overt act. Did they rent a car ro be used? Did they discuss needing particular guns for this, and then go out and buy one?

Because w/o an overt act, this case should fall apart pretty quickly

Third Coast said...

A similar case involving a Michigan militia occurred 8 years ago. It resulted in the Feds having to drop charges because they had no case. In fact even the AP described it as an embarrassment for the government: "The Tuesday decision is an embarrassment for the government, which secretly planted an informant and an FBI agent inside the Hutaree militia and claimed members were armed for war in rural
southern Michigan."
https://www.michiganradio.org/post/key-charges-dismissed-against-michigan-militia-members-federal-court

Michael K said...

If people attack police stations and there are no dragnets or mass arrests, one can fairly assume the attackers were agents provocateurs, and not real protesters.

Cook hugs his delusions to himself. He is probably pleased that the declared Antifa member is leading in the Mayor election in Portland.

Drago said...

Robert Cook: "If people attack police stations and there are no dragnets or mass arrests, one can fairly assume the attackers were agents provocateurs, and not real protesters."

Tsk tsk tsk

Reality check: the authorities in the area where the rioters are attacking police stations are politically aligned with the rioters and the rioters know they have carte blanche.

Yancey Ward said...

I am not surprised to find they were anarchists and not right winger militia- the "plot" to attack a police station sounded far more left wing than right wing.

n.n said...

The left-right, totalitarian-anarchist nexus is leftist.

narciso said...

well the whole christopher steele affair with danchenko seems to be something out of the coen brothers, some burned british hack pays a drunk russian, who only 5 years earlier had been suspected of being a russian spy, to have his drinking circle, which includes an oligarch's secretary, who libeled her boss and incurred damages for that, this was the basis of the dossier, and the fisa warrant,

cubanbob said...

Howard said..."Trump pulls out of debate. Afraid to wheeze on national TV"

Tell Senile China Joe to man up and show up to the debate in its original format.

rcocean said...

Like their communist friends, the leftists here minimize or even cheer left-wing violence while hysterically exaggerating Right wing extremism. Its laughable and its boring. The Double standard is so obvious and never ending, its not worth responding to.

rcocean said...

BTW, these characters were NOT a "Militia" and the "Militia" they were associated with had ZERO to do with their hare-brained scheme. Nothing was ever going to happen in any case. Its a big fuss over nothing.

iowan2 said...

Another leftist narrative that's not making it to the next news cycle. But the narrative is already set. Trump planned the whole thing. Militias (honored in the Constitution) are the evil among us.

All this is now dropped because in fact, these are not conservatives, right wing, or any form of Trump supporter, so silence is now the game of leftist, wiping egg from their face(Can the governor be removed through the 25th amendment? Her performance was worrying.)

Yancey Ward said...

When Chuck announced that he was no longer a poll watcher for the Republicans, Democrats had a meeting and decided it was now too risky to continue cheating.

The Gipper Lives said...

The plotters tweeted to their co-conspirators that the chief executive was in the residence all alone with no weapons or security detail.

Oh, wait--that was Mayor Bowser tweeting to her lynch mob to attack the White House.

Tyrone Slothrop said...

Kidnapping ringleader hates Trump, too.

daskol said...

This reeks of COINTELPRO.

Pikers. Sure, elements probably knew about Kennedy's assassination and possibly supported it actively, at least in using their informant Oswald as the patsy. But I'm starting to think they're pikers compared to what we've got today, if not in cleverness and skill than in sheer power, given the brazenness of things today.

Bushman of the Kohlrabi said...

Sucks for them that they aren't Democrats. If they were, the FBI would still be trying to decide 4 years from now whether to file charges.

mockturtle said...

Daskol observes: But I'm starting to think they're pikers compared to what we've got today, if not in cleverness and skill than in sheer power, given the brazenness of things today.

Yes!!! That they are brazen about things they used to hide is disturbing. It merely shows that they are utterly confident of their impunity.

Bilwick said...

I'm sure Kamala Harris will bail them out like she is reported to have done for those Antifa or BLM people.

The Gipper Lives said...

If these were real terrorists wouldn’t Bob Mueller help them flee the country?

Six arrested–5 from Michigan, 1 from…Delaware? Hmmm…

Unknown said...

preventing crime!

If only they could prevent left wing riots

Jason said...


Robert Cook: "If people attack police stations and there are no dragnets or mass arrests, one can fairly assume the attackers were agents provocateurs, and not real protesters."

IF SHE WEIGHS THE SAME AS A DUCK, SHE'S MADE OF WOOD!

#CookLogic

Mark said...

"Lefty Mark is too dumb to realize if the shit ever hits the fan, we're not targeting government officials. It'll be antifa shitheads like you."

And Ann wonders why Google pulls their ads.

Perhaps they don't like implied threats of violence. You might be cool with hosting that, but they might see it for what it is.

TheOne Who Is Not Obeyed said...

"If people attack police stations and there are no dragnets or mass arrests, one can fairly assume the attackers were agents provocateurs, and not real protesters."

"Fairly"? What the heck would a dishonest lefty know about fairness? One could absolutely NOT "fairly" assume such nonsense. One could "fairly" repeat Dem talking points without actual evidence, however.

TheOne Who Is Not Obeyed said...

"Perhaps they don't like implied threats of violence. "

Can't be, they have no problem with leftist ACTUAL threats of violence, based on the anti-American Democrat groups wherein I lurk.

Like Lefty Mark, LLR-Chuckie, and all the others on the Left, Google is evil.

JAORE said...

Let's see, thirty days hath September....

It's October 9, so there should be about 22 more October surprises.

Some might even be less laugh worthy than this one.

Drago said...

Dumb Lefty Mark: "Perhaps they don't like implied threats of violence."

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

Google and youtube and twitter LOVE not just implied threats of violence, they love the actual violence and generally support it.

They allowed ISIS to post with impunity, including actual beheadings (gee Dumb Lefty Mark, do actual beheadings count as "violent"?), threats by the Iranian leaders that they will destroy Israel, calls to attack jews and westerners globally, whatever antifa/BLM wants to do including doxxing individuals who don't want to play Stupid Antifa Games, etc.

It goes on and on.

Sorry Dumb Lefty Mark. Everyone sees what is going on and now, as is always inevitable, when the lefties/marxists are on the march to destroy others, the backlash against that begins.

It's only happened everywhere throughout history.

What's happening at Althouse is that many here understand history and where this is all heading and they are pointing out how this will go if you Dumb Lefties insist upon taking your Resistance/Revolution/Destruction of the Republic all the way.

But you're right about one thing, google, youtube, twitter et al REALLY REALLY don't like it when people start pointing out what they are up to......which is precisely what is happening at Althouse.

Kirk Parker said...

Lefty Mark continues at long-standing lefty tradition of claiming that their initiation of violence is fine, it's the return violence in self-defense that is a problem.