August 10, 2019

Helter skelter in the cathedral.



"For such a place, steeped in mystery and marvel to buy in to sensory pleasure and distraction, is to poison the very medicine it offers the human soul," said The Right Reverend Dr Gavin Ashenden, former chaplain to the Queen, quoted in "Norwich Cathedral helter skelter 'is a mistake'" (BBC).

"The central aisle of Rochester Cathedral has also been converted into a crazy golf course..."



1. I already knew a "helter skelter" was some kind of British ride (which is why The Beatles sang, "When I get to the bottom I go back to the top of the slide/Where I stop and I turn and I go for a ride/Till I get to the bottom and I see you again!").

2. But I didn't know precisely what the ride was. I'd thought maybe something like Tilt-a-Whirl. But no, it's exactly the thing you see in the first video above, a slide wrapped around a tower.

3. The word "helter-skelter" dates back to 1593. The OED quotes T. Nashe Strange Newes: "Helter skelter, feare no colours, course him, trounce him." The definition is: "In disordered haste; confusedly, tumultuously, pell-mell." The word started meaning "A tower-like structure used in fun fairs and pleasure-grounds, with an external spiral passage for sliding down on a mat" in 1906, with "The World's Manufacturing Company, examples of whose ‘helter-skelter’ lighthouses are at Earl's Court, Blackpool, Southport, and other places."

4. We could go down the language rathole with "fun fairs"? "Pleasure-grounds"? The British have their own language, don't they?

5. Which brings up "crazy golf." That's British for miniature golf.

6. Or are you still wondering what was the "Strange Newes" in 1593? Wikipedia tells us that Thomas Nashe was "an Elizabethan playwright, poet, satirist and a significant pamphleteer." He was friends with Robert Greene who is famous for "Greene's Groats-Worth of Witte, bought with a million of Repentance," an attack on William Shakespeare. Greene had made fun of the writer Richard Harvey in "A Quip for an Upstart Courtier," and that inspired Harvey to make fun when Greene died. Nashe's "Strange News" is some sort of response. Here's the full text. Kind of complicated, so I'll just give you an easy example of Nashe's poetry:
"Unhappyie me," quoth she, "and wilt not stand?
Com, let me rubb and chafe it with my hand!"
7. When I went to Genius.com to get the lyrics for The Beatles' "Helter-Skelter" it looked like this:



Shirley Manson is a Scottish singer — whom you might know as the lead singer for Garbage. Manson is her name by birth, so there should be no association with the murderous Charles Manson. It's not like Marilyn Manson, which is a stage name and an intentional reference to the evil man. What strange advertising decision or algorithm put the ad for Shirley Manson on "Helter Skelter" lyrics page?

8. Here's what Wikipedia has at "Helter Skelter/Charles Manson interpretation": "Charles Manson told his followers that several White Album songs, particularly 'Helter Skelter,' were part of the Beatles' coded prophecy of an apocalyptic war in which racist and non-racist whites would be manoeuvred into virtually exterminating each other over the treatment of blacks. Upon the war's conclusion, after black militants had killed off the few whites that had survived, Manson and his 'Family' of followers would emerge from an underground city in which they would have escaped the conflict. As the only remaining whites, they would rule blacks, who, as the vision went, would be incapable of running the United States. Manson employed 'Helter Skelter' as the term for this sequence of events. In his interpretation, the lyrics of the Beatles' 'Helter Skelter' described the moment when he and the Family would emerge from their hiding place – a disused mine shaft in the desert outside Los Angeles." "Healter Skelter" was written (misspelled like that) in blood at the scene of the LaBianca murders. Manson wanted John Lennon to testify at his trial. John Lennon, years later, said: "All that Manson stuff was built around George's song about pigs ['Piggies'] and this one, Paul's song about an English fairground. It has nothing to do with anything, and least of all to do with me."

9. I've been avoiding all the stories about the 50th anniversary of the Manson murders which just could not avoid getting written this month. It took that helter skelter in the cathedral to get me here.

10. A cathedral has to do with a long-ago murder... or should I say attempted murder? Or will you say an execution is not a murder, whatever the circumstances?

11. Should there be fairground amusements inside a cathedral? Is it a sacrilege? One could argue that all the amazements and decorations of a traditional cathedral are themselves sacrilege and that if you don't think they are, you ought to accept the addition of other wonderful marvels to attract and grab hold of people. Or maybe that's precisely why you should object: Don't mix marvels! Keep the religious wonders separate from worldly tricks...

12. ... unless your aim is to knock religion down to earth.

36 comments:

Mr. Forward said...

Holy Roller Coaster!

Temujin said...

"For such a place, steeped in mystery and marvel to buy in to sensory pleasure and distraction, is to poison the very medicine it offers the human soul,"

I agree with the Right Reverend. It just seems to spit on the religion that the cathedral was built around, or the concept of spirituality at all. The only thing missing (and it may yet be there) are the concessions selling Scotch eggs. It looks amazing, but shows zero respect for the building or the reason for the building. Such is our society today.

Also, I don't know who Shirley Manson is, but her mug- large and staring at me- was used on the landing page at Linkedin.com for about a month or two. It was disturbing everyday. It's finally gone. She has a very good PR team behind her.

Ralph L said...

The English no longer go to C of E services, so many of them are being used for secular events or just tourist attractions.

I thought the Manson Family was supposed to lead the race war, so I'm happy to read they'll be out of danger.

gilbar said...

WHY can't those Brits learn to speak English?
Next thing you know; they won't even be using the Imperial system of measurements !

Leslie Graves said...

I'm reading Joyful, by Ingrid Fetell Lee.

She writes, "In the late Middle Ages, authorities within the Catholic Church were attempting to quell what they considered to be an excess of festivity in local churches. Early Christian services had been lively affairs. Dancing was often on the agenda, and even priests participated in the revelry."

She goes on to reference Barbara Ehrenreich's Dancing in the Streets as saying that "early medieval festivals took place inside churches, which didn't have pews, leaving plenty of space for dancing".

The church authorities, or so it says here, knew they couldn't stop people from playful celebrations, so what they decided to do was get it outside: "They designated certain days as feast days and allowed people to revel as much as they wanted to -- not in the church, but in the streets".

And then, the claim is made, this decision was the birth of Carnival: "the wildest of festivals, celebrated each year in hundreds of cities in the days leading up to Lent."

Fernandinande said...

What strange advertising decision or algorithm put the ad for Shirley Manson on "Helter Skelter" lyrics page?

Thanks for illustrating the bogosity of anecdotes.

The algorithm's one weird trick seems to be: "we show this ad because somebody paid us to show it" since the ad shows on a lot of pages.

tcrosse said...

That's the slippery slope we keep hearing about.

Fernandinande said...

@Leslie Graves, B. Tuchman claimed the church interiors were often painted in bright colors. (And stripes?)

Josephbleau said...

A blog of many colours. Yet will no one rid me of this turbulent priest!

Fernandinande said...

Holy roller coaster Batman!

Amadeus 48 said...

In Scotland, they call it “wee golf”.

iowan2 said...

Its only cultural appropriation when the self anointed elites tell me so. Carnival in the Cathedral? Accept or you're a thin skinned, superstitious nut. But if you put corn rows in your daughter's, of Scandinavian ancestry, hair, you shall be pilloried. And don't even think about wearing a sombrero on Halloween!

Leland said...

There are a lot of things entering businesses and churches that I never thought would be to attract new and young people. I don't have an issue with a church having such an item on the grounds, but inside the church "front and center" seems a bit much. Alas, I don't go to church regularly, so who am I to complain? Other than to say this won't attract me.

Anthony said...

Love Shirley. Used to be, Garbage recorded their albums in Madison -- which is where Butch Vig recorded a lot of Nirvana's first album (only to be mostly re-recorded in LA later on; only the Madison-recorded "Polly" track ended up on the album) -- but I recall one article that she didn't like it very much.

I think I actually managed to burn additional grooves into the "Version 2.0" CD when it first came out I played it so much. . . . . .

traditionalguy said...

Think of it as a huge Choir production showing off happy music. The Norridge folks must be bored with Anglican services. What they need is better lighting ...some one needs to replace those stained glass windows with see through ones to complete the Reformation that was stopped half way by Elizabeth I.

Helter skelter was a sacrifice of a baby inside the woman bearing it ...a twofer. All done to cast a spell that failed to work outside of a few Hollywood insiders.

MacMacConnell said...

In an interview the priest said the mini golf was to get kids off the street during the summer.

Rory said...

Sir Humphrey: The Church is trying to be more relevant.
Prime Minister: To God?
SH: No, of course not. I meant relevant in sociological terms.
PM: So the ideal candidate in the Church's view is a cross between a socialite and a socialist?
SH: Precisely.

--Yes, Prime Minister

rehajm said...

We used to have goofy golf. The alliteration what’s sells it.

Sebastian said...

"One could argue that all the amazements and decorations of a traditional cathedral are themselves sacrilege"

But then one would be a Protestant.

wildswan said...

You don't have to be a believer in Jesus Christ to be a bishop in the Anglican Church at present. And it shows. The Anglican church has non-believers right at the top, in the ministry for the prestige - and, still worse, some are in it for a chance to destroy a Christian church while receiving a high salary from said church. (see picture) This is the logical outcome of modernism or the belief by some Church leaders that Christian churches have nothing to say which comes from an independent revelation from God but only a duty to teach the ethics approved in their own time by the approved elite.

Otto said...

Sorry Ann but it ain't going away much to your dismay - 2.4 Billion. Watch out for the Asian explosion, especially in China in the next half century.

Steven said...

You know, if the Anglicans are done pretending to be a church, I'm sure the Pope would be willing to take the cathedrals back.

Roughcoat said...

My God ... this post is filled with words!

Marc in Eugene said...

"You know, if the Anglicans are done pretending to be a church, I'm sure the Pope would be willing to take the cathedrals back."

Perhaps not the Roman Pontiff currently reigning nor most of the English and Scottish Catholic bishops: but a few of the bishops and the English and Scottish Catholic people generally would gladly receive back the ancient cathedrals.

Yancey Ward said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
JaimeRoberto said...

"Charles Manson told his followers that several White Album songs, particularly 'Helter Skelter,' were part of the Beatles' coded prophecy of an apocalyptic war in which racist and non-racist whites would be manoeuvred into virtually exterminating each other over the treatment of blacks.

So the Beatles were using dog whistles?

Yancey Ward said...

Shirley Manson is awesome, though. I am a long time fan.

Yancey Ward said...

There shouldn't be such a thing in a cathedral, and I write this as someone who is as irreligious as it is possible to be without being obnoxious about it. It is an insult to the people that built the structure.

YoungHegelian said...

"And she's buying a fairway to heaven."

LordSomber said...

The Church of England seems determined -- hell-bent, if you will -- to trivialise itself out of existence.

Bilwick said...

No biggy. In my church we had "Ride the Priest."

tim maguire said...

I never knew what helter skelter meant. A fair ride? How disappointing.

Darrell said...

Shirley Manson and the urinal surprise.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JuNZeWOeLUM

Shirley Manson and the urinal surprise.

readering said...

There must be something still to the C of E if it required BoJo to visit the Palace alone.

Maillard Reactionary said...

My first thought was that The Principalities of The Air are always busy.

Is the Church the Mystical Body of Christ, or just another corrupt human institution?

We'll have more on that story and the latest sports news on our 11 PM broadcast.

I'm a religious nonbeliever, but for some reason this story made me feel a bit sad, for a moment. Not surprised, though.

I am in mind of Robert Frost's poem, "The Ovenbird", which asks the question: What to make of a diminished thing?

Jungle Clips said...

Love to read this blog
DIY