September 24, 2018

"And so, 50 years after Dylan wrote it, 'The Times They Are a-Changin' ' vibrates with new meaning."

"Perhaps that's because the song itself doesn't look to the past — rather, it's an anthem of hope for a future where change is always possible," concludes NPR in "'The Times They Are A-Changin'' Still Speaks To Our Changing Times." Excerpt:
As the 1960s faded into the '70s, the urgency of the song faded, too. Bob Dylan moved on to other things, and the generation he first sang for grew up and...
I'll complete that sentence more bluntly: ... turned into the people who needed to get out of the way because their time was up.

The article goes on to describe the use of the old song, which anchors Bob Dylan in his political protest time, from which he changed. But Baby Boomer politicos have always harked back to it, and it serves them — I'm not including me — right to have that song sung in their face now that they are old and not ready to roll over for whatever advancement the young people think is due.

I don't include myself because I've never liked the forefronting of Protest Bob. "The Times They Are a-Changin'" is the song picked out from all the others by people who don't really know and love Bob. I don't like seeing him used this way, restricted to this narrow version.

And the words are too cruel and anti-inclusive to use generally (outside of the literal blocking of doorways in the desegregation era).
Come senators, congressmen
Please heed the call
Don’t stand in the doorway
Don’t block up the hall
For he that gets hurt
Will be he who has stalled
The battle outside ragin'
Will soon shake your windows and rattle your walls
For the times they are a-changin'
NPR calls particular attention to that verse, the third of five verses, because, I assume, calling out to authority figures and telling them what they need to do is more popular with protesters these days than speaking imploringly to "people" (verse 1), "writers and critics" (verse 2), "mothers and fathers" (verse 4), and the elite ("the first ones," verse 5).

And look at the threats of violence if you don't get up to the speed the singer is demanding: if you don't swim, you will "sink like a stone" (verse 1) and if you stall, you will get hurt (verse 3). Think what it means to revel in this song today: Accept my characterization that this is a fast-developing emergency, and if you don't do what I say, you're going to suffer terribly.

There are little spots where the song warns its singers not to be too smug and aggressive:
And don’t speak too soon
For the wheel’s still in spin
And there’s no tellin’ who that it’s namin’
For the loser now will be later to win
That's addressed to "writers and critics," so maybe that includes bloggers, even though Dylan's "writers and critics" are the ones who "prophesize with your pen" (and we're all typing now). He says "the wheel's still in spin," and you don't know who will win and lose over time. So be cautious, observant, and keep thinking clearly. Don't just jump onto the side you think is the winning side. It keeps changing.

36 comments:

tim in vermont said...

It was my anthem, election day, 1994.

mezzrow said...

Thunderdome on the Potomac has arrived, and Althouse is posting another Bob Dylan reference.

Time for another cup of coffee. It's Monday. Gonna be a long week.

Darrell said...

If the charges against Kavanaugh had any merit--and could be proven--the Democrats would have saved them to use as blackmail material like they did with Roberts. Better a puppet for the Left than a mortal enemy.

Quayle said...

"Bob Dylan moved on to other things"

Yeah, like:

"You're gonna have to serve somebody
Well, it may be the devil or it may be the Lord
But you're gonna have to serve somebody"

and

"
"Man’s ego is inflated, his laws are outdated, they don’t apply no more
You can’t rely no more to be standin’ around waitin'
In the home of the brave
Jefferson turnin’ over in his grave
Fools glorifying themselves, trying to manipulate Satan
And there’s a slow, slow train comin’ up around the bend"

Paco Wové said...

Boomers gotta boom, I guess.

traditionalguy said...

The 2016 Election was the Changing Time that started the wheel spinning which is Trump systematically flushing all crooked Swamp Creatures, foreign and domestic. Whether the swamp, in its death throes, confirms Kavanaugh or not is unimportant.

Anonymous said...

Don't forget "The Merry Minuet"
http://www.metrolyrics.com/merry-minuet-lyrics-kingston-trio.html

Ann Althouse said...

Ugh. Please don't talk about Kavanaugh here.

Ann Althouse said...

Unless you can directly tie it to the Dylan song.

Get out of my doorway if you can't shut up about Kavanaugh in every damned thread.

What a drag!!!

I'm going to do a Kavanaugh post soon, but you make me want to go on strike.

Darrell said...

Unless you can directly tie it to the Dylan song.

The Times They Are a-'Changin'?"
At least that's what the Democrats think. I thought it was crystal clear.

Darrell said...

You did, too, I would suspect.
The air fist thrust.

Birkel said...

I liked the use of this song in the movie "The Watchmen".

Birkel said...

Lots of penises being foisted on an innocent audience in "Watchmen" because Dr. Manhattan wore to clothes.

Also, "Watchmen" did not use the article "the" so that proves my memory was hazy. It happens.

And the Dylan song was integral to the movie's setup.

David Begley said...

Yeah, the times are changing. People charged with sexual assault used to have due process, they could confront their accuser and vigorously cross exam the accuser.

Birkel said...

...wore no clothes..."

rehajm said...

Yah- forgive those if us who thought it was a Kavanaugh thread. Facts don't matter anymore and we only have big dark puffy word clouds wafted by the politically motivated to guide us. Dylan's a go to for that...

David Begley said...

I think the abdication of the Rule of Law in America is a BIG CHANGE.

Lloyd W. Robertson said...

Most societies, most of the time, think the way they do things is best. Anything foreign is ipso facto suspicious or just plain wrong. Small differences in dialect or pronunciation between neighbours are used to ban such things as inter-marriage.

We think we're so much better than that now. We're above all that bigotry, and we keep on learning how to not only avoid it, but overcome it. Pushing old people out of the way will probably help. But above all, instead of believing "we" are always right, we (the progressives) now believe "history" is always right. Alas, there is a "we" who claim to know history, and there is a "we" who claim to be changing history, and they can be ... wait for it ... bigots. It often seems this faith in progress is the stupidest form of self-congratulation that human beings have ever invented--and that is saying something.

The Crack Emcee said...

Dylan tried to run away from all of that. In the mid-60s, he retreated with his wife and three young children to Woodstock, New York. But even there, he couldn’t escape the legions of fans who descended on his home, begging for an audience with the legend himself. He says people would actually come to the house, wanting to “discuss things with me, politics and philosophy and organic farming and things.”

What did Dylan know about organic farming? “Nothing,” he says. “Not a thing.”


60 Minutes, 2004 - That was when I knew I had to check this Dylan-guy out.

mezzrow said...

you make me want to go on strike.

The voice of America in these times.

She was a level-headed dancer on the road to alcohol
And I was just a soldier on my way to montreal
Well she pressed her chest against me
About the time the juke box broke
Yeah, she gave me a peck on the back of the neck
And these are the words she spoke
Blow up your t.v. throw away your paper
Go to the country, build you a home
Plant a little garden, eat a lot of peaches
Try an find jesus on your own
Well, I sat there at the table and I acted real naive
For I knew that topless lady had something up her sleeve
Well, she danced around the bar room and she did the hoochy-coo
Yeah she sang her song all night long, tellin' me what to do
Blow up your t.v. throw away your paper
Go to the country, build you a home
Plant a little garden, eat a lot of peaches
Try an find jesus on your own
Well, I was young and hungry and about to leave that place
When just as I was leavin', well she looked me in the face
I said "you must know the answer."
"she said, "no but I'll give it a try."
And to this very day we've been livin' our way
And here is the reason why
We blew up our t.v. threw away our paper
Went to the country, built us a home
Had a lot of children, fed 'em on peaches
They all found jesus on their own

Birkel said...

Dylan on "Watchmen" intro:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=nZj43rtoEp4

They use the song to reveal the alt-history necessary for the super hero plot line.

Mike Sylwester said...

... vibrates with new meaning

I thought that was a reference to the MeToo accusations -- such as the accusations against Kavanaugh.

MadisonMan said...

I thought of a different song from the mid-80s today.

Pat Benatar's classic. (Love is a Battlefield might work too).

Welcome to the new Puritanism.

Ann Althouse said...

"Yeah, the times are changing. People charged with sexual assault used to have due process, they could confront their accuser and vigorously cross exam the accuser."

The song, heard today, does sound like a celebration of the death of due process.

Bay Area Guy said...

No Kavanaugh on this thread, dammit! Only Bob Zimmerman.

In the original script of Animal House, when the boys embarked on their famous road trip, they picked up a guitar-slinging young hitchhiker, Bob Zimmerman. After a few scenes, the guitar-slinging hitchhiker found an opportunity to escape and run like hell. I read this in Matty Simmons' autobiography about the making of Animal House, who said that was the only scene he regretted cutting.

But Yes, the times they are a-changing, and according to Steve Miller, time keeps on slipping into the future. The future where Leftwing smear artists pick and choose what standards to apply to a given confrontation though will not be a good future.

Molly said...

From John Wesley Harding:

With his lady by his side
He took a stand
And soon the situation there
Was all but straightened out
For he was always known
To lend a helping hand.

All across the telegraph
His name it did resound
But no charge held against him
Could they prove
And there was no man around
Who could track or chain him down
He was never known
To make a foolish move

Marcus said...

Yeah, no commenting on the Judge because now our hostess is having second thoughts on believing Ford because of the ludicrous allegations coming out -- she's embarrassed at buying into the con.

As to this post, I was in my Wonder Years during the late sixties (in 68, I was 13). I had no use for those hippie types then and less than zero now. Professional protesters, all of them.
No one wants to hear about their "boring stories of glory days".

tcrosse said...

And it's a hard, and it's a hard, it's a hard, and it's a hard
And it's a hard rain's a-gonna fall

D 2 said...

Come gather 'round commentators
Wherever you roam
And if you mention That ('82?) Party
Your hostess will groan
Just accept that your gender makes the Woke moan
Your cock ain't likely worth savin'
So you better start signalling,
Or you'll sink like a stone
For the times they are a-changin'.

Come anchors and pundits
Who pronounce Trump's doom with their pen
Or who silent all humour
Cause that's not funny again
But don't speak too soon
For the inquiry's still in spin
And there's no tellin' what crime it'll be namin'.
For the process ain't over until our side wins
For the times they are a-changin'.

gg6 said...

Yes, the times may be changing - whatever that means - but NPR still has it's head vibrating up its rear.

jimbino said...

Ann: Funny you should say "We're all typing now."

Otto said...

Poor Ann. Her zeal for basement dwelling is not showing any lasting values,so there is no choice but to go lower( never higher). But come to think of it what did she expect since she doesn't believe in values anyway.

Mark said...

Good one, D2.
Ann, that you like Dylan and apparently have a reputation for same, is a feature, not a bug.
Mezzrow, that is unfamiliar to me, but i avoid being in the loop, already done the things listed therein, but not a bad lyric. Not Dylan though, is it?

Critter said...

The world would be a better place if people attempted to understand Dylan's lyrics like you have, Ann. One of his themes has been to constantly seek the truth and to be as honest as you can be in what you see. But recognizing the human failing of subjectivity, we need to constantly stay on alert and not invested in any one perspective of reality. The only exception he made was for the ultimate truths that he found through his faith in Judaism and Christianity.

One of the reasons I love Dylan's songs and lyrics is how I see new meanings in them as I listen to them over time. He has a unique ability for a songwriter to create layers of thoughtful meaning in his words. Remarkable mind and ability.

rcocean said...

The reason the song had power -back then - was civil rights.

The "Old people" who were against Civil rights, were pushovers, because they didn't have any reason for segregation except old fashioned prejudice and "Things have always been done that way".

You had integration in 3/4 of the USA, and the sky didn't fall, so what was the point of having separate drinking fountains for blacks and whites in 1/4 of the country?

The old order in the 60s fell, because it had no reason to exist. They'd already accepted women and men being equal, so why shouldn't male colleges admit women? They'd agreed with all the liberal/left assumptions, and had nothing to fight back with.

Critter said...

Rcocean, you are correct but the public mostly never really listened to Dylan so much as they took his words literally to support their views.

Dylan’s words that the last will be first and first will be last is out of Matthew 20:10, which continues that many are called but few are chosen, a pointed personal message. Dylan is reported to keep an open Bible as well as a dictionary in his home near where he worked. He always has maintained that his messages were always personal and not political. Given the resistance to religious themes in popular music it appears that Dylan often made allusions to his faith (except during his 4 album period of Christian music.

Keep in mind this the same Dylan who soon after writing the lyrics of The Times They Are A’Changing also wrote I Dramed I Saw St. Augustine and other religious themed songs.i find that all of Dylan’s best songs are personal, just as all great writers write about what they know from their own experience in life.