October 15, 2017

"The fundamental predatory nature of Hollywood is young, attractive people — largely females — putting themselves in front of men to be judged and appraised and chosen."

"It is a dark equation. From the moment the proverbial girl gets off the bus, the odds are stacked against her. In Hollywood, unlike at other Fortune 500 companies, the one-on-one meetings take place in hotel suites and bars. It’s an exploitative and oddly personal process."

Said Janice Min, the former editor of The Hollywood Reporter (who also describes a media event that took place last April at which Barack Obama gives a speech and, immediately afterwards, "amid rapturous applause," walks "right over to Harvey Weinstein and gives Harvey a hug").

Quoted in "Harvey Weinstein, Hollywood’s Oldest Horror Story," by Maureen Dowd (NYT).

5 more things about this Dowd column:

1. She follows the now-standard script of dragging Trump into the story, but she keeps that scene short. She merely sticks a "Like Trump" onto the front end of one sentence about Weinstein:
Like Trump, that other self-professed predator, there were complaints that in business deals he stiffed people on bills (advertising and public relations payments), and he had a reputation for lying, cheating, taking advantage, acting like a thug.
2. She doesn't otherwise talk about the political world, except to pass along Min's idea that Weinstein was "a master at protecting himself... by the veneer of power he cultivated, by giving to liberal causes and cultivating friends in the media and politics." Here, another name is stuck in: "just as Hugh Hefner was."

3. There's something a little sleazy about slipping in other names — Trump and Hefner — without specifying the points of comparison. The charges against Weinstein are so awful, that this "like X" style of writing flaunts unfairness.

4. And note the unopened door: Calling Weinstein "a master at protecting himself... by giving to liberal causes and cultivating friends in the media and politics" makes it sound as though he was a genius and ignores the lameness of the journalists in allowing this obvious and simple ruse to give him cover. Shine some light on the weakness of your own profession, Ms. Dowd. You've been writing very extensively about the movie business for years. Why didn't you go after Weinstein? Were you and your colleagues bought off by his generosity to causes that you like?

5. Dowd often does clever things with language, but some of her efforts are strained, and sometimes an idea just does not work and should be abandoned:
He relished the nickname “Harvey Scissorhands,” given to him by filmmakers who did not like his domination in the editing room. But the nickname could work just as well for his octopus ways with women, which resulted in lots of hush money being paid out.
You just can't merge "octopus ways" with Scissorhands when you're talking about a man approaching a woman's body. Scissorhands cut and even if the cut is skillful, the presence of blades near vulnerable flesh is dangerous (erotically so, in the movie):



The octopus has soft suctioning parts, nothing like scissors, as most memorably depicted in the 1814 Hokusai woodcut print "The Dream of the Fisherman's Wife":



These Scissorhands and octopus images are presented (by male artists) as powerfully erotic from the woman's point of view, but the eroticism is distinctly different and it doesn't helpfully connect up film editing with paying hush money. It's funny that Dowd was writing about editing when she let a stray octopus into that paragraph.

210 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 210 of 210
Jupiter said...

rhhardin said...

"The law's role obviously would be to jail the women."

Well, yeah. A woman who is using sex to cut into line ahead of better actresses is pretty clearly being antisocial, and there oughts be a law agin it. Evil whore. Of course, if she'd like to consult the judge in chambers, maybe something can be worked out.

EMyrt said...

Jose_K said...

FWIW: in Latin America , a woman would call a man an octopus if he is too insistent touching. Like he has 8 hands.
10/15/17, 1:00 PM

Jose, that's a panAmerican metaphor. I remember it from the 1960s.

Lydia said...

There must be some high-fiving going on in the Farrow household right now -- "Amazon Cancels Red Carpet for Woody Allen’s ‘Wonder Wheel’ Premiere"

Earnest Prole said...

I was late to this party, but looking back I see rhhardin has pitched himself as a proponent of manliness, liberty, and the free market. But no one who truly believes in the free market would accept market-distorting sexual bribes that are a common feature of third-world shithole capitalism. No one who truly cares about liberty would be indifferent to the dehumanizing private discrimination of Jim Crow. And no real man would accept his wife or daughter being touched against her will or forced to choose between her career and sexual extortion.

MayBee said...

Remember when Kate Winslet couldn't agree her ex-Nazi character having sex with a teenage boy was wrong because she had a relationship with an older man as a teen?

I remember that. We talked about it here.

William said...

Hollywood has been a little slow to condemn child rapists, rapists, and various other sexual abusers. In their favor, they have been out in front on Scientology. They condemn it. Tom Cruise has endured more snide remarks about being a scientologist than Harvey Weinstein--until recently--ever enduried about being a fat perv.......Ironically, Tom Cruise now stands as the conscience of Hollywood, the one leading man who never abused his leading ladies--other than the times when he married them.

Unknown said...

Today NYT follows up...

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/13/opinion/put-women-in-charge.html

> as long as we have a hierarchal society, the gender of those at the top matters. In any field where women consistently have to please men to realize their ambitions — or simply to survive — there will be exploitation. Right now, that’s almost every field, and that’s what has to change. No woman just starting out should ever be told she has to choose between working for a Harvey Weinstein and working for a Mike Pence. If there must be bosses, fewer of them should be men.

"quotas"

Peachy said...

"If a local government official(D) requires a blowjob to issue a building permit, we all understand it’s a bribe...".

fify

Earnest Prole said...

fify

fine by me

ndspinelli said...

ChipS returns. Made my year! Always smart and witty comments from ChipS.

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 210 of 210   Newer› Newest»

Post a Comment

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.