Said Alain-Charles Perrot, director of the Maison et Jardins de Claude Monet, quoted in
"For the love of Monet: record crowds threaten impressionist’s centenary/In Giverny, up to a million visitors are expected this year but can the village balance the artist’s legacy with the pressures from mass tourism?" (London Times).
Giverny, now with its bus parks and columns of art pilgrims flowing over Monet’s green Japanese bridge, became the epicentre of the modern mania for impressionism soon after la Maison Monet was opened to the public in 1980. A recent social media-era surge was compounded when Emily strolled... over the water lily bridge... the Netflix series Emily in Paris.
Critics are often rude about the “Monetisation” of the art world, referring to its merchandise, immersive shows and the way the impressionists as a brand have eclipsed that of other art movements. “Claude Monet has become the sacred and milk cow of the art world,” Marianne magazine noted.
38 comments:
Monet, meh.
A week in Madrid is vastly better value, in artistic breadth and diversion.
I think I did a Monet yes in my art album.
Manet, Monet. Ape-ree-cot, Apricot. A moron wouldn't know the difference.
serious questions:
now that europe is a wholly muslim area.. will Monet continue?
now that europe is a wholly muslim area.. What is NATO for?
now that europe is a wholly muslim area.. WHY is in NATO for US?
now that europe is a wholly muslim area.. how long before a shooting war starts between muslim europe, and those that STILL think things like Monets are "good"?
WHEN that shooting war starts..
between the forces of Islam and the infidels..
which side will america be on?
I sometimes watch Emily in Paris. It's a dumb show, but it features pretty girls with a picture postcard background. Its relaxing to watch. It's a fantasy show, like GOT for tweener girls. It gilds the lily
seriously..
How LONG?
how long before these paintings, that infidels that support graven images are all burnt by the rightous hordes of Islam?
"I didn't want it to become Disneyland."
Is M. Perrot absolutely sure those crowds aren't expecting the house and gardens of Édouard Manet? Is it possible they've confused him with M. Poirot?
I'm looking at my print of The Battle of the Kearsarge and the Alabama at this moment. I think I prefer the a dude to the o dude. He didn't hang around underage girls so much.
When the tourist trade was damaging the ancient wall paintings in Southern France, the French built new, fake cave painting sites, so maybe a phony Monetworld isn't a bad idea.
But don't make it Disneyland. Save yourself the trouble of having to shoo away Lindsey Graham.
Comme ci, comme ça... but at least there a few Frenchmen left in France to attend that centennial.
restrict it using a lottery system.
All the things worth seeing are ruined by too many tourists.
During Covid in Colorado - all the state parks in the mountains were over-run with people. I am not usually impressed with government solutions, but they now use a system where you must book a spot. I like it. Because I can book a spot, get in without waiting in a long line of cars... and enjoy a day in my backyard... not over-run with tourists.
I posted this before. I love art history and this guy does a great job.
I thought the problem was he was man, a white man, and we were showing too much of his art, and shutting out POC's and women who aren't as good.
Oh well. Given the toxic wasteland of today's art "world" aka Industry - I don't give a rip that critics are muttering over their latte's about Monet's "Commericalization". And Tourists. OMG, muffy, tourists!
Yes, the mass tourism is getting even massier. The Chinese and Indians all 2.5 billion of them are wanting to see the sights. For example, the bulls cant run anymore in spain, too many tourists, they now have to trot in stop/go traffic.
" ... the way the impressionists as a brand have eclipsed that of other art movements."
Maybe the "other art movements" need a marketing plan. In reality, these things come and go.
Monet, Cézanne, Renoir - I liked them when I saw them in Paris. But i liked the representational stuff better, like Jacques-Louis David
We need open borders, and cheap labor. Let in 100 million immigrants. Cue Neil Diamond's Comin' to america - fuck yeah. Gosh, wonder why its so crowded and there's so much traffic.
"Count de Money" - Mel Brooks
I would totally stand in line for Mr. Monet's Wild Ride and a Monet themed roller coaster.
"It's an Impressionistic World After All, It's an Impressionistic World After All, An Impressionistic World" [continued ad nauseum]
Don't go on the Monethorn though.
It always breaks down.
I just don't appreciate old paintings the way I should. But I'm glad others do.
I few years ago I took an art history course from a reputable institution in New York. A woman in my class was there to learn more about the impressionists she said, so that she could be better informed on how to market a Monet inspired eyeshadow palette of soft, bendable shades with pearl and lamé finishes.
One of the treasures of growing up in SoCal in the 20th century was having the Norton Simon ad play regularly on tv. This ad gave countless amount of people their first exposure to artist names and even if you didn't go, it gave a burst of good art history in a minute's time. It still is a great museum to go to, went there a lot when I was living in Pasadena.
One of my best experiences going there was while in seminary. Had a course on theology and art, and the professor had a dual PhD in theology and art history from a European university. His insights from both directions was so illuminating.
I finally got to see an actual painting by Monet in Denver last year. He used an interesting painting style - the pond water painted one way, a different style of paint application on the water lilies - to achieve an amazingly 3D effect. So his impressionism included a very consciously chosen method to convey to viewers of his work more than just color, more than just blurry flat shapes. He gave the painting life.
Like the O’Jays sang - MonetMonetMonetMon-et! Mo-net! Some people- got-ta have it!
All the wrong people like his pretty pictures. How gauche.
Quaestor, I'm looking at the huge model of Kearsarge that I built with my father, about 1965. I doubt that i could now reproduce the wash technique we used to get the right dark greenish sheen on the copper hull sheathing. Amazing that it, and its glass case, have survived so long in a household with five kids.
Celebrating Money’s death is morbid
Overheard at a gallery exhibition in Seattle, where on the wall was a picture of an overly-tattooed woman with her bush out of her shorts, little girl cowboy boots on while holding a picture of herself over her own face: 'Can you believe that they want to take art away from us? I mean No Funding. This is how we come together.'
She was a good photographer, but I thought her project was puerile, preachy and mostly predictable. A doom loop of narcissistic Self-aggrandizement alongside the bromides of ideological rigidity and choir-preaching emotionalism.
Sometimes you see real talent, creativity and determination, but most of the industry is co-opted by Selves in the existential/nihilist/post-post modern void...seeking meaning in all the wrong places, with all the old knives.
My experience of Madrid: It has the staid conformity of a governing city (like D.C...people like to unwind in weird ways as a result of being uptight), but it's also only been there for about four-hundred years. I stayed about two blocks away from the Prado for two months ('Prado' is a old-timey word for 'meadow' in Spanish). I was surprised at how insular, local and Spanish the national museum was. Some cave painting. Roman statuary and tiles from not that far away. Romanesque church painting. El Canto Del Mio Cid under glass (the epic poem and modern origin story of the Reconquest). Lots of El Greco, Velazquez, Murillo, Picasso etc. This was their place (and they're kind of insular, homely and close-knit)
Realizations I had over time: Visually, the Spanish are really good. The backsplash tiles in my shitty, shared apartment had better design and color than most tilework here (they put their energy into painting/visual arts). We walked by a nondescript door every day, and the knocker was a brass lion that was impressive to behold
Much of that machismo, emphasis on visual arts, all the domes and much architecture, and even their deep Catholic habits...much of this flowed from Islam and was a reaction to that history. Yes, I knew, but one day it hit me. Oh.
The culture was older demographically, but walking around the Gran Retiro with regularity, I realized (again I 'knew' but it really hit me one night) that the Spanish were still living in their Golden Age. Strolling meekly forwards with hands clasped behind their backs; an air of nostalgia, diminished, wounded pride and ennui. A culture can peak and...just kind of...plotz along
rhhardin@9:41 What a lovely photo
peachy@10:26 Video at link says it’s private.
Spain could build a Goya World and scare the bejeezus out of all those Viking River Cruises wankers....CC, JSM
I did go to Giverny on a Martin Randall tour (small groups, led by professors, assisted by British guides who have spent a lot of time in the area and speak the language; I highly recommend). Our organizers were smart enough to get there early. Even so, we were subjected to the Viking invasion, which totally harshed the mellow. And this was about eight years ago. Lord knows what it's like now. CC, JSM
"Spain could build a Goya World"
A lot of Goya (and there is a @#£% ton of it) is scattered around the country.
All the prints (and plates) are in the basement of The Academia de Arte Real de San Fernando on calle Alcala. AKA Carlos III's art collection, expanded somewhat.
In a very small area, perfectly walkable, you have the Prado, the Academia Real (San Fernando), the Thyssen, and what shouldnt be missed, the Naval museum.
Not that much further (get a taxi) are the Reina Sofia and the Monasterio de descalzas reales. And much, much more.
There are the"Fiestas Goyescas" in Zaragoza, which would pass for a theme park approach. In May I think, we were just there once.
Mosby--
You think the Vikings are bad, wait for the Saracen tours.
Post a Comment
Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.