Says a commenter at the WaPo article "The multiuse home space trend is coming for your dining room/A DIY dining library can create the perfect space for reading, crafting, work or dining with friends. Here’s how to get one."
The article is verbiage about putting bookshelves in the dining room. The author is Jolie Kerr. Was she a podcaster? I look it up. Wikipedia says:
Jolie Kerr (born 1976) is an American writer and podcast host. Her book, My Boyfriend Barfed in My Handbag... and Other Things You Can't Ask Martha, was a New York Times best-seller.... Writing for The New York Times, Dwight Garner called My Boyfriend Barfed 'the Lorrie Moore short story, or the Tina Fey memoir, of cleaning tutorials...[a] wise and funny new book.' At NPR Linda Holmes praised Kerr as 'at her most irresistible when she's handling the kinds of awkward questions that do traditionally go unanswered in your women's magazines and your perky home-maintenance shows.... Kerr now hosts a podcast... called Ask A Clean Person.
I can see why WaPo wants a writer like that, but this books-in-the-dining room thing is pretty ridiculous, and it is upsetting that WaPo canned the book review.
See "The Death of Book World/What the closing of the Washington Post’s books section means for readers" (The New Yorker).
The New Yorker article, from last month, is by Becca Rothfeld. It begins:
In April of 2023, when I was fresh out of a Ph.D. program in philosophy, I was hired as the nonfiction critic at the newly revived books section of the Washington Post. The shock to my system was immediate. In graduate school, where I studied aesthetics and German philosophy, I seldom came into contact with anyone who did anything else; even a brush with a classicist or the occasional stray Cartesian felt like something of a transgression. But the Post, it turned out, was much less siloed than the university. On my first day, I discovered that Books was seated next to Food....
Ha ha. I think we're talking about what long ago was called the "Women" section of the newspaper. Like cooking and cleaning and interior decoration, books are for women.
Unlike the specialized literary magazine and its informal cousin, the literary blog, the general-interest newspaper has a kind of noble rapacity, an encyclopedic ambition to wrap its arms around the whole of the world.... A newspaper is—or ought to be—the opposite of an algorithm, a bastion of enlightened generalism in an era of hyperspecialization and personalized marketing. It assumes that there is a range of subjects an educated reader ought to know about, whether she knows that she ought to know about them or not. Maybe she would prefer to scroll through the day-in-the-life Reels that Instagram offers up to her on the basis of the day-in-the-life Reels that she watched previously, and so much the worse for her. The maximalism and somewhat uncompromising presumption of a newspaper, with its warren of sections and columns and byways, is a quiet reproach to its audience’s most parochial instincts....

42 comments:
Estate sale books have long been a cheap way to inches and weight to a library or study. I figure the dining room book strategy grew out of the Barnes & Noble (and departed Borders, and independent store) practice of putting coffee shops in their stores. It's not unlike trying to read/work in a Starbucks either.
The all-time dumbest book design strategy is to place books backwards on shelves, so only the paper edges show.
Dear Abby: "How can I show my visitors that I'm illiterate without saying I can't read?"
https://stevenrsouthard.com/end-the-backwards-book-trend/
…apparently book people are no longer part of the desired psychographic…
We have 7 bookshelves in our dining room. Also a buffet, china cabinet, 2 desks, and a table with 6 chairs in the middle of it all. If you have the room, no reason to exclude the book shelves!
Dining room library makes a certain amount of sense. Similar to how the walls of the shared conference room at law firms used to be where they stored volumes and, when not in use, the conference table was added desk space for research.
My gay uncle , RIP, had a huge book library in his guest bath. It was glorious.
That’s is how you do it.
I try to remove books as fast as they come in to the house, and that's not always easy. I have a selection ready to go to the Used Book store at the end of Speedway. Also: Hooray for the Library.
I think the problem with having a lot of Estate Sale books in your dining room is that people might ask you what you think of something that you've bought and couldn't read. If you've not read it, why is it in your house?
Ten years before Ms.Kerr was born, my father and I finished an enormous book case and cabinet set, occupying an entire wall of our dining room. The actual living room was where we read the books, because that's where the comfy chairs were.
I miss the daily newspaper--it may have provided a superficial overview of what's going on in the world, but there was a wholeness to it--after reading it, I felt like I had a grasp of what's going on in the world. With today's internet-driven news, I may know certain things much more in-depth, but it's fragmented, atomized, and I have no feeling that I know what's going on in general anymore.
We tried subscribing to home delivery of The Times, but since we don't live in New York, we had to rely on whatever local printer has the Times contract and it's unreadable--literally unreadable. Not just the paper and print quality, but even the shape of the paper and font size of the type are all wrong.
Which is disappointing because I am coming up on retirement and lying in bed with a cup of coffee and a newspaper in the morning is one of the things I was looking forward to most. I don't see how that's going to happen now.
Bookshelves in the dining room are only acceptable if you live in a studio apartment where the dining room is also the living room, study, and whatever else that isn't bedroom or kitchen.
Pretty much every French movie that isn't about cops or lowlifes has a book case in it. If the apartment's not big enough, they put it in the dining room. The movies only rarely show anyone reading the books.
I remember going to the furniture store years ago and all the books were in some Scandinavian language and only for show. Maybe you can still buy cheap, only-for-show Swedish books from IKEA.
We have built-in bookcases in our dining room. So what?
I'm with Madison Man on this. "If you've not read it, why is it in your house?" I have bookcases all over the place and they are all full of books I've read and found reasons to keep around the place (usually on the theory that I might read it again some day and occasionally that actually happens). I am getting more particular about what I keep, mostly because I am running out of space. If your books are arranged by color, you are an interior decorator not a reader and you're not fooling anyone.
I put bookshelves wherever they will fit. I have them in the living room, dining room and bedrooms.
"I miss the daily newspaper--it may have provided a superficial overview of what's going on in the world, but there was a wholeness to it--after reading it, I felt like I had a grasp of what's going on in the world. With today's internet-driven news, I may know certain things much more in-depth, but it's fragmented, atomized, and I have no feeling that I know what's going on in general anymore."
Me, too. I tried subscribing to a news aggregator called GroundNews, but I still don't feel like I am getting a complete picture.
There’s nothing more parochial than the women’s section of a newspaper.
If it's only about decorating then just buy books by the pound from wherever, toss the dust covers, and print your own covers with the title of your choice. Viola! Your own custom fake library which you can salt with a few knick-knacks and few real books for authenticity. Off topic, but it bothers me to spend $35-$50 on book only find that's it's unreadable crap. At least when I walk out on a film or play I dont hava a reminder of a bad choice staring at me from the shelf.
What nonsense. Books belong on your iPad. Bookshelves are for your snow globes.
We have a lot of bookshelves, but not enough. I have large piles of books on surfaces designed and intended for other uses.
When you have limited home space, books can eventually become clutter. At one point, I had to institute a "one in, two out" policy, and stop browsing at garage or library sales. When I want to read something new, I'm more likely to download it to my Kindle. (Meanwhile -- like most people, I'm guessing -- my public--facing living room bookshelves are curated for classic novels and important-topic nonfiction, while the airplane reads and pop-psychology titles are piled up in the bedroom.)
Given that the WaPo book review section had long ago turned into a mid-wit leftwing echo chamber, losing it is no great loss.
The primary job of the MSM Book review section was to sell books by mainstream publishers. And punish any author that strayed from the party line. So Good riddance to bad rubish.
The only WaPo book critic i ever read was Jonathan Yardley, and he quit 12 years ago.
I dont see any reason for bookshelves in your dining room or the bathroom, but if it makes you happy go for it. We've decided we've reached our limit on books and DVDs/BRays. So if one gets bought, one goes out.
One drawback to switching from books to Kindle or PDFs is you are dependent on the companies keeping those books accessible. For Kindle books, you don't own them, you lease them from Amazon. For PDF's - they work fine now, but in the future the software may be changed - and then good luck making them viewable.
Some people have a weird obsession with the way that things like books, cd's, etc. are stored when not in use. Arranging by color makes more sense than most other arrangements when the books' primary purpose is ornamental. Plus, the books can only be read one at a time, so even if they were bought primarily to be read, there is no reason to shelve them in any particular fashion.
Note to self: start a business designing and printing dust jackets of fictional books.
Sell them to people who buy books by the yard for decoration
John Henry
Books are wonderful. The more the merrier in number and location. Until it is time to move.
For decorating, printed dust covers and foam blocks
Her book, My Boyfriend Barfed in My Handbag... and Other Things You Can't Ask Martha
She's a handbag person, so of course we all must hate her.
My daughter reads numerous books, and organizes them on the shelves by the color of their cover. It is a form of madness.
My own books, and I have many, are organized by how recently I bought them or re-read them, so I can't claim to be a good librarian either.
One of life's great truths is from Col. Jeff Cooper: "It is impossible to have too many books, too many guns, or too many bottles of fine wine."
I usually agree with Colonel Jeff Cooper, but his statement here really desperately needs Paddy O's addendum.
We’ve had dinobraries (DINing rOom + liBRARY) for ages. Good to see New Yorkers catching up to the Midwest.
“ My Boyfriend Barfed in My Handbag... ”
My boyfriend's barfed and there’s gonna be in trouble
(Hey-la-day-la my boyfriend barfed)
You see him heavin’ better cut out on the double
(Hey-la-day-la my boyfriend barfed)
So close your handbag in case he comes after you
(Hey-la-day-la my boyfriend barfed)
He's been horking so long with a lot to spew
(Hey-la-day-la my boyfriend barfed)
Now it’s done and he’ll be fine
(hey-la-day-la my boyfriend’s barfed)
But now my purse smell like brine
(Hey-la-day-la my boyfriend barfed)
But I’m gonna be sorry; it’s so wrong
(Hey-la-day-la my boyfriend barfed)
Cause he pukes a lot and it’s awful strong
(Hey-la-day-la my boyfriend barfed)
From the immortal Chuck Wagon & The Wheels, of "Disco Sucks" fame:
My Girl Passed Out In Her Food
Rocco, that is a thing of beauty. CC, JSM
Just watched the National Theatre production of The Importance of Being Earnest, with Doctor Who's Ncuti Gatwa. It's free on YouTube. Anyway, a key plot point is a baby abandoned in a handbag at Victoria Station. CC, JSM
Peachypeachy: "My gay uncle , RIP, had a huge book library in his guest bath. It was glorious."
To the extent I ever dream about a house, my dream house has an indoor-outdoor bathroom with soaking tub, so I can throw open French windows or something and enjoy the outside air while simmering, reading, having a whisky, and smoking a cigar. Never thought of the shelves, but they could come in handy! CC, JSM
Arranging books by color screams "I dont read".
Displaying the media you consume where people will linger over it definitely says something about your personality. It's almost like your own artwork. Unfortunately I don't have the space required in my living area these days, but in the past people would idly browse the shelves.
I have the Kindle app on several devices and my phone, and download a lot of books from Gutenberg.org. This way it is possible to have a library of classics without taking up any house space, and have plenty to read on my travels. Plus, I can enlarge the type at will, an important feature for an oldster.
My opinion: dining rooms are for dining and pleasant conversation, family news, etc. Books should be strewn about the living area for after dinner, so family and guests can flip through ones that may catch their fancy. Increases conversations. I would never just buy a box of books, that's insane. I buy stuff I'll re-read, and all Dewey Decimalized and entered into a spreadsheet, so I can loan with some idea of where they are.
I am a book person, needy book person. I can’t resist. A little gilt, a stiff back, I’m helpless. Take me.
I fully support the use of the "vomit" tag.
Post a Comment
Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.