October 20, 2025

"We work in the dark — we do what we can — we give what we have. Our doubt is our passion, and our passion is our task. The rest is the madness of art."

Wrote Henry James, quoted by retired book editor Gerald Howard, in "The Dogged, Irrational Persistence of Literary Fiction" (NYT).

Howard writes: "Substack essays and chin-pulling opinion articles galore agree that literature is not only in the doldrums, but even in danger of extinction from, take your pick, a declining attention span, a disappearing audience of people educated enough to understand and appreciate it, or a near-future technological onslaught (see: novels written by A.I. entities). The sense of a possible ending is palpable. But what the discourse leaves out are things like historical perspective and the blind faith and, from the purely practical and economic points of view, sheer illogic of the literary enterprise...."

19 comments:

Peachy+2 said...

the covid jab. did this...

Wilbur said...

The market, inexorably, will decide.

Wince said...

"I read only good books."
- Pastor Rod Flash

Mike (MJB Wolf) said...

Well almost totally excluding white men, who admittedly made up the majority of literary fiction writers when I was a youngster, from your little club severely impeded the very "diversity" of voices that Publishing Inc. put into print. Diversity of thought makes up the largest single difference between people, being influenced by both the external and internal forces we experience.

Mike (MJB Wolf) said...

This an era where you can't get a screenplay into production without a trans, gay or girl-power fierce chick in the lead, and even Disney has been mocked endlessly by the "make it gay" mocking that South Park gave it.

And G Howard is pondering why literary fiction, a genre built on references to great works that came before, is suffering in this current environment.

Obviously the teaching profession does not find reading or classic works as valuable as they did back in my day or they would be working to reverse the dumbing of American students that is documented so well.

Achilles said...

The only end will be for the mediocre players writers.

Exceptional writers will be able to put out near infinite amounts of content.

Literature is going to be better than ever.

Wilbur said...

If only we could bring back the WPA and Federal Project Number One. Then the Federal Gummint could choose the writers and authors to subsidize. Kinda like the NEA, but more blatant and rampant.

Mister, we could use a man like FDR again ... right Leftists?

rhhardin said...

The theory of literature is worth reading even if literature isn't. "The Space of Literature" by Maurice Blanchot, trans Ann Smock I think, is good.

Hassayamper said...

I'm sorry, that quote from James is meaningless gibberish. I'm sick of pretentious mental masturbation by literary types. The Emperor is naked.

Yancey Ward said...

Literally anyone who can write in a language can publish a novel these days. Getting paid for doing so, however, is a different topic.

Tom T. said...

I tried to read Henry James. It's impossible.

Lazarus said...

He mentions the armfuls of books sold at his local library book sale, but doesn't tell us how many of those books were "literary fiction." Reading isn't going away. Is "literary fiction"? I don't know, but the fact that Faulkner or Melville had problems getting published or finding readers when novel reading was still a widespread pasttime doesn't give today's writers much comfort.

The James quote may have made more sense in its original context -- a story about an aging novelist who was doubting the worth of his work. I had to groan though, when the bug nut in a CSI episode quoted it from memory.

Leora said...

I tend to think it's not literature unless people have been reading it for 50 years or more. It's just fiction until then and most of it is forgettable.

Eva Marie said...

We work in the dark . . . “ Precursor to What We Do In The Shadows. Blog is taking on a Halloween-y vibe.

Josephbleau said...

“Our doubt is our passion, and our passion is our task. The rest is the madness of art."

No, our doubt is our ignorance, and our ignorance is our misfortune.

RCOCEAN II said...

Genre fiction is doing quite well. Mystery/crime, romance, horror, fantasy. SF has declined but hanging on.

But serious literature? Well, for that you need serious readers. And publishers. Are they running out of Chicks, Gays, and Jewish readers?

mccullough said...

Most literary fiction, like most writing, is mid at best.

Henry James was the OG Incel

Jaq said...

I think the rise of romantasy as a genre explains it all. Men are allowed to be men and act as men, as long as we all agree that it's a bit naughty when they do and that there is no connection to the real world.

Hassayamper said...

I think the rise of romantasy as a genre explains it all. Men are allowed to be men and act as men, as long as we all agree that it's a bit naughty when they do and that there is no connection to the real world.

Is that the genre where overlooked women of a certain age go on an Eat Pray Love trip, and find inner peace and transform themselves, becoming so irresistibly attractive that they are overpowered and raped by a wealthy Wall Street tycoon, or was it a Scottish laird in a kilt who lives in a castle? -- but fall in love with their rapist, and tame him through Girl Power, and change him into Phil Donohue with bulging muscles and a yacht, and live happily ever after?

Post a Comment

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.