August 13, 2024

"For more than a month now, people across social media have been bragging about the scuffed, worn-out shoes..."

"... they’ve been wearing since middle school and how they use their makeup all the way till the very last drop. They’re proud that they’re using decades’ old pans, inherited from their parents. Or how they don’t buy food storage containers; they just use old mason jars. This all sounds like Depression-era behavior, but it’s not. It’s a trend that has been exploding throughout the summer, under the hashtag 'underconsumption core.'.... As I’ve written in the past, companies tend to be very sensitive to changes in consumer behavior because their financial success depends on responding to trends. The 'underconsumption core' trend has had a relatively long life, for an internet trend. It’s continued to bubble up for months now. Brands, take note...."

From "Why TikTok’s ‘Underconsumption Core’ trend won’t die/Brands, are you listening? Millennials and Gen Z are sick of poorly made products designed to fall apart. It’s time to change your business model" (Fast Company).

I noticed the "underconsumption" hashtag on TikTok today and saw it as a rejection of following trends, but, to Fast Company, it is itself a trend. Theoretically, "brands" can cater to it, with better quality items that won't be replaced and can be more expensive. That seems out of line with the heart of the "core," which is to love/accept second-hand, second-rate stuff that you already have.

I liked this TikTok from a young woman who bought a house and everything in it. The previous resident had died, and it was up to her to discover what was there that she could use and what to throw out or re-home. Her response to the scuffed up wood floors is quite charming.

Some of the videos show young people discovering things I figured out for myself long ago, on my own and inspired by various things, notably hippiedom and "The Tightwad Gazette."

31 comments:

pacwest said...

Value. What a new concept!

Temujin said...

Wait 'til they get to my age and go through their clothes to clean things out and think...damn...I've had that shirt at least 30 years. I can't throw it out now.

JaimeRoberto said...

Nothing wrong with being thrifty, saving money and discovering the difference between wants and needs.

Gusty Winds said...

I noticed the "underconsumption" hashtag on TikTok today and saw it as a rejection of following trends...

They're following a trend. They're broke and can't afford stuff because of the Biden/Harris inflation, sparked by COVID and its massive transfer of wealth to the already wealthy. Rent, interest rates, houses they can't buy, groceries and energy costs.

There is nothing wrong with thrifting and wanting quality in products. St. Vincent De Paul is great. But let's not pretend this is a rejection of a trend. It is a trend all its own driven by a horseshit economy Ivory Tower liberals would like everyone to believe is thriving.

The girl who bought a house with everything in it, and the charming scuffed up floors...bought what she could afford.

Michael K said...

Inflation has its silver lining.

Jamie said...

A response to fun-deremployment?

Kevin said...

I noticed the "underconsumption" hashtag on TikTok today and saw it as a rejection of following trends...

In a matter of hours, Kamala will be using it as an excuse not to sit for interviews -- she's underconsuming media attention.

Diamond said...

I really enjoyed that TikTok, thanks!

Bart Hall (Kansas, USA) said...

My parents came to adulthood during the 1930s Depression, and because Dad was away for WWII she waited in hopes he'd return. They married in their 30s, and I was their first. Nevertheless they had almost 60 years together.

One key result was that my parents were 10 to 15 years older than those of my age-mates. and it made an immense difference in how we were raised. Use it up, wear it out, make it do was just how we lived. Not so, most Boomer kids.

I could tell many wonderful stories of how those years unfolded and of how so much continues to this day, long after our parents' deaths. Perhaps most delightful is that my sons (in their 50s), and I (who can see 80 just over the hill), joke about how the eventual "Dead-Bart Sale" will be so simple, with almost nothing to discard, compared to their associates' utter dread of having to deal with deceased parents' insanely cluttered homes and three storage units.

rehajm said...

Tightwad Gazette was good bitd. The woman and her family weren’t lecturing about their frugality, mostly presenting for readers enjoyment. They turned me on to stop gardening- too much work for little nutrition.

Mason G said...

"Not so, most Boomer kids."

That's not the way I remember it. Maybe the families in my neighborhood were the exception, though.

Mikey NTH said...

I'm now trendy? I thought I was just frugal.

Mikey NTH said...

I have told nephews and nieces that I have shirts older than them.

Aggie said...

I have always been frugal and prone to make things stretch. I have shoes, clothes that are well over 25 years old, tools that are older than I am. My last truck lasted 27 years. I am pleased to see this trend in the younger generations. My daughter, who is early into family life, is also learning the joys of the value (durability, sturdiness) of older furniture, having now owned modern Etsy-type stuff and seeing it scuff and deteriorate in months. Good for her ! Good the for them ! Long may it continue. And I need hardly add: This is what true environmentalism really looks like - reduction of consumption.

Jeff Weimer said...

I'm "underconsuming" because I'm (re)paying off (via 0% accounts) my *over*consumption the last 20 years.

GRW3 said...

Mason jars are food storage devices. If they are used in a pressure cooker to can, the inner part of the lid has to be replaced before the next canning.

Dr.Bunkypotatohead said...

It's good they're preparing now for the upcoming economic depression. Perhaps #starving will be trending soon.

Fred Drinkwater said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Fred Drinkwater said...

My parents were depressions kids. My wife's parent's generation survived Mao.

21st century U.S. frugal? It is to laugh.

And anything labeled "core" can safely be ignored.. Pure marketing.

Skeptical Voter said...

Underconsumption may be a fad--but I think it's going to become a movement. Tuesday morning's WSJ had a front page story about people not being able to afford necessities--like paying the water bill or the electric power bill. It's one thing to reuse Mason jars, or cut back or eliminate trips to restaurants or fast food places. It's another when you have to worry about not being able to pay the electric power bill. Bidenflation is real.

I Use Computers to Write Words said...

The woman with the house was so charming. I love a positive attitude.

Tina Trent said...

The only things I buy new are jogging sneakers, underwear, socks, and wifebeaters. My husband and I go through the wifebeaters pretty quick. Then they become cleaning rags. So they end their life with the wife beating them.

Mary Beth said...

Use it up, wear it out,
Make it do, or do without.

donald said...

I have a shirt I bought in Perth Australia in 1982. I seriously doubt I could get it over my big fat head by now.

Wilbur said...

Ask someone in the restaurant business about the economy and people tightening their belts.

Don't believe the so-called polls. The Democrat Party is whistling in the dark about the economy.

Old and slow said...

Words to live by.

Interested Bystander said...

When we first moved to our neighborhood in 1991 we had an old lady neighbor who was in her 90s at the time. I was always amused at the little treats she'd share with us, always wrapped in re-used aluminum foil or inside a re-purposed plastic butter tub.

When the winds blew down small twigs and branches from our sycamore tree you'd see her out the next morning collecting them into small bundles and tying them up with string that she'd saved and rolled up into a big ball. She used them for kindling.

Her yard was a beautiful place with azealeas and perennial flowers that bloomed wildly every spring. She once told me that everything on her lushly landscaped lot was stuff she'd collected as cuttings from neighbors and friends. I still have some plants growing around my place all these years later that I grew from cuttings she shared with me. Even her house was purchased and moved here because it had been condemned for the building of I-5. Her ways were strange to me, coming from the boomer generation where everything was throwaway. My parents had been Depression kids but this old gal was about 20 years older than them. What my parents eventually outgrew and left behind stayed with Dr. Ingrie for a lifetime.

Interested Bystander said...

If they want to continue to travel overseas and take two vacations a year like they did when they were just out of college those just now entering middle age will have to cut expenses somewhere. Take a bag lunch to work, eat meals at home, stop wasting money on ready made packaged food and only buy fresh ingredients, learn to repair clothing instead of throwing it out, find a shoe repair guy if you can and have those boots resoled. Buy the young kid's shoes a size too big so they can grow into them, same with jeans. Let them roll the cuffs up until they fit them. My daughter and her husband are fortunate to make great incomes. If they had to do as I described above it would be like learning a new language. So many things we did as boomer kids growing up that we forgot to teach our own kids. Maybe it would be better for the economy and the environment if they did it anyway. The culture of waste is still alive and well in Western societies.

Anthony said...

It's not just younger peeps fed up with low-quality junk. We had the same Sunbeam hand mixer for probably 20 years, got a new KitchenAid one, and one of the beaters was broken after two uses.

Rocco said...

Mikey NTH said...
I have told nephews and nieces that I have shirts older than them.

Earth tone paisley dress shirts with the gigantic lapels?

An uncle gave me his last pair of steel toed work boots that he wore a couple of years before retiring. He retired in 1982. I still use the boots.

Tim said...

It seems like the girl had some reverence for the deceased and the life they lived in that house.