January 9, 2023

"At a personal level, every morning, I get up at such a time that I can spend an hour in prayer, followed by an hour of reading before I let myself look at my phone."

"At a more family level, we practice Sabbath together. The whole 24-hour period, we put all of our phones away. We gather around the table with close friends. We celebrate a huge meal. We practice gratitude, rest; we sleep, we play. And that is a major part of our rule of life that we kind of anchor our weekly rhythm as a family around...."

Writes Tish Harrison Warren, in "This Year, Try Organizing Your Life Like a Monk" (NYT). 

"Do you think nonreligious people or people who are not Christians should have a rule of life? Well, I would say that all people have a rule of life. You likely have a morning routine, you have a way that you spend your free time, you probably have a job. Hopefully you have a budget. For a lot of people, the problem in their life is not that they don’t have a rule of life, it’s that they do. The problem is not that it’s not working. It’s that it is working, but it’s poorly designed. It’s giving them outcomes — emotional outcomes, relational outcomes, vocational outcomes — different than the ones they actually desire.... [C]larify in your mind and heart a vision of the kind of person you want to be and the kind of life you want to live — what you most deeply value — and then work backward and very slowly. Don’t try to go hard core...."

The author is influenced by the Rule of St. Benedict, and here's the Wikipedia article:

[I]n about the year 500, Benedict became so upset by the immorality of society in Rome that he gave up his studies there, at age fourteen, and chose the life of an ascetic monk in the pursuit of personal holiness, living as a hermit in a cave.... [H]e eventually founded the monastery...where he wrote his Rule near the end of his life....

The "Rule" seems like many rules. Chapter 7 alone has 12 rules — 12 steps in a ladder to Heaven — just on the topic of humility:

(1) Fear God; (2) Subordinate one's will to the will of God; (3) Be obedient to one's superior; (4) Be patient amid hardships; (5) Confess one's sins; (6) Accept the meanest of tasks, and hold oneself as a "worthless workman"; (7) Consider oneself "inferior to all"; (8) Follow examples set by superiors; (9) Do not speak until spoken to; (10) Do not readily laugh; (11) Speak simply and modestly; and (12) Express one's inward humility through bodily posture.

It's interesting to see Step 10,  "Do not readily laugh" right after blogging about the intern at the "best restaurant in the world," who, assembling "fruit-leather beetles," was "forbidden to laugh." Forbidden! St. Benedict's humility rule was only do not readily laugh. The rule against laughing too easily was for the purpose of humility. The rule against all laughter, at the pretentious restaurant, was for the opposite purpose: hauteur. 

So, yeah, I don't think things are as bad today as they were in the year 500, but the NYT author seems to think we're in a similar predicament. Whether we are or not, it is a good idea to look at what you are doing — what rule you are following — and figure out what end you are pursuing. If that's not the end you want, maybe you could think in terms of writing a new "rule" for yourself or, like the author, for your whole family.

32 comments:

Derve Swanson said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
RideSpaceMountain said...

My favorite Benedictine precept is Laborare Est Orare - "To work is to pray".

If you know anything about the history of European Christianity, you might come to the conclusion that had the Catholic church adhered and reinforced this principle, the reformation might have never happened.

Far too many aristocratic nobles made it into the church hierarchy in the preceding centuries. Nobles with their attendant sense of luxury and idleness. You know what that gets you? Marks on your cathedral door in Wittenberg.

Narayanan said...

Far too many aristocratic nobles made it into the church hierarchy in the preceding centuries.
=======
now they make hierarchy in the Church of WorldEconomicForum etc

Jaffanese American said...

Captivated readers may want to delight themselves with Humility Rules, by a monk, the funniest book on a theological subject I know of. https://www.amazon.com/Humility-Rules-Benedicts-Twelve-Step-Self-Esteem/dp/162164149X/ref=sr_1_1?crid=2UH4X0WJ0FC53&keywords=humility+rules+saint+benedict%27s+12-step+guide+to+genuine+self-esteem&qid=1673285815&sprefix=humility%2Caps%2C79&sr=8-1

Jaffanese American said...

My favorite book on humility, by a witty monk. Just look at the cover. https://www.amazon.com/Humility-Rules-Benedicts-Twelve-Step-Self-Esteem/dp/162164149X/ref=sr_1_1?crid=2UH4X0WJ0FC53&keywords=humility+rules+saint+benedict%27s+12-step+guide+to+genuine+self-esteem&qid=1673285815&sprefix=humility%2Caps%2C79&sr=8-1

Enigma said...

The Woke Generation would benefit from any proven set of rules for life (a la Jordan Peterson's 12 Rules), be they derived from traditional religions or be they New Age Gaia Mother Earth Greta Thunbergian rules. The key for sanity/success is to reference tested rules that have outlasted any single person's lifespan. This results in a sense of continuity, sameness and common ground between grandparents and grandchildren, and useful predictability...but the NYT readers and Woke created their own juvenile, puerile, unworkable, incoherent, dogmatic rules because of being raised on impulsive social media, single overworked parents, and the osmosis of Marvel Comics movie morality.

I wonder what Saint Harvey Weinstein's rules for life include?
I wonder what Sex and the City's rules for life include?
I wonder whether the Church of Spiderman, Batman, Hulk, Iron Man, Dead Pool, or Wolverine is the One True Church?

Quaestor said...

...and hold oneself as a "worthless workman"...

Adhere to this too closely and everyone will agree with you.

rehajm said...

Good idea. I vow to adopt the routines of the St Sixtus Trappists and spend much time with high quality beer.

Achilles said...

If you want to get something done, put it first thing during the day.

As the day continues on you lose motivation and energy.

Schedule difficult tasks that take a lot of discipline in the morning. Easier tasks that require less discipline in the evening.

rcocean said...

we practice Sabbath together.

Odd phrase. But i guess practice makes perfect.

Rabel said...

The Rule of Althouse:

1. Comments may need to pass through moderation.
2. Comments should respond to material raised in the post.
3. I encourage brevity and substance and discourage personal attacks and repetition.
4. You must use a name or pseudonym.
5. The non-name "unknown" is not accepted.
6. Thou shalt not use the n-word.

It's more like The Guideline of Althouse - except for number 6. And as of today, number 5.

Mountain Maven said...

A worthy practice. I fit in my prayer and bible reading around my more prosaic pursuits. Not optimal.

Lem the artificially intelligent said...

For years I kept hearing fellow alcoholics say how morning prayer helped them have a better day, but still it took me awhile to pick up the practice and even then, sometimes I forget the single Spanish sentence “Padre, en Tus Manos encomiendo Mi EspĂ­ritu”.

Lurker21 said...

Do you think nonreligious people or people who are not Christians should have a rule of life?

Maybe, maybe not. But I think I'm allergic to actual monks. Living what you think is a monkish lifestyle and living in an actual monastery can be very different.

mikee said...

And only 700 years later, Saint Francis of Assisi had to abjure worldly possessions and found a new mendicant order because other monks had become too attached to their wealth and lands and power.

Some things never change.

J. Farmer said...

My mentor used to say, "Always practice two things: (1) differentiating thoughts from feelings, (2) differentiating your thoughts and feelings from others' thoughts and feelings. The first will give you self-knowledge, the second will give you self-control." a

Jupiter said...

Allow me to be the first to call Bullshit on this claptrap.

tim in vermont said...

J. Farmer! Nice to see your avatar again!

tim in vermont said...

J. Farmer! Nice to see your avatar again!

Blastfax Kudos said...

"the reformation might have never happened."

It would've happened anyway.

traditionalguy said...

Interesting that the most disciplined teenagers are the star football players and the first thing they say when interviewed is thanks to their Lord Jesus. Humility helps winners win. KICK OFF TIME AT SOFI….NOW.

Nancy said...

Lem, your comment startled me. I often focus on the line "B'yado akhid ruachi" from the Hebrew poem/song/prayer "Adon Olam": "In his hand, I deposit my spirit."

Assistant Village Idiot said...

Sabbathkeeping is a good habit. Do what you can to start.

J. Farmer said...

If that's not the end you want, maybe you could think in terms of writing a new "rule" for yourself or, like the author, for your whole family.

Rule #13: Don't always treat life like a problem to be solved.

Mech Connie said...

Morning prayer is really therapeutic

Mea Sententia said...

I take a Sabbath rest from news and opinion on Sundays. It helps clear my mind.

walter said...

rehajm said...
Good idea. I vow to adopt the routines of the St Sixtus Trappists and spend much time with high quality beer.
--
It's a calling.

Narr said...

Benedict, Francis (the saints) and other early reformers weren't able to shake the institution the way Luther among others was able to do (not that that was their goal), partly or mostly because the later reformers/Protestants mastered the new tech and its potentials better than the hierarchs of the church.

Luther and his people had their own rules, too, if not monastic ones.

Although I'm anything but a morning person myself, I'm with Achilles on when to tackle the important or onerous tasks--in the a.m. if not the early a.m. Fortunately for me I have few of those nowadays.

Which is a good time to say good night, y'all.

iowan2 said...

As noted elsewhere, following a set of "truths" that have survived generations will increase you serenity and productivity.

Pick your own, but its hard to beat the 10 commandments, and the 7 deadly sins, as a path and the guardrails.

In general>>> When in doubt, be of service to others, >>love your neighbor as yourself, >>all things in moderation.
Incorporate that into your daily living and problems will slowly dissolve. Because most of our internal angst is self afflicted.

Kai Akker said...

---Far too many aristocratic nobles made it into the church hierarchy in the preceding centuries. Nobles with their attendant sense of luxury and idleness. You know what that gets you? Marks on your cathedral door in Wittenberg. [RideSpaceMountain]

Exactly right. I used to think how righteous a piece of history it was that Christianity, starting from its lowly Nazareth beginnings, had conquered the Roman Empire with all its pomp, power, and might.

But Constantine's conversion actually opened the doors for massive corruption from the luxurious Roman upper classes into bishoprics and other power centers in the Church. According to a history I finished recently (Early Christianity, by Charles Freeman), by the end of the 300s the Church was heavily coopted and corrupted. Lifetime appointments as bishop beat 3-year terms of various political and military offices.

It still took 1,100 years for Martin Luther to reach the breaking point, though.

Narr said...

Albigensians and Hussites predated Luther and Calvin by decades and centuries, and something that is not known to most moderns is that Protestantism and even Unitarianism had made huge gains in areas we now think of as ur-Catholic--Austria, Czechia, Hungary, Rumania, parts of western Ukraine, etc. Conversion to Islam--which was rarely REQUIRED by conquering Muslims (they liked the extra tax on non-Muslims)--was not unknown, either, but nobody wants to think about that.

The best testament to the necessity of the Reformation is the reaction it sparked from the RC--not only oppression, but the backhanded acknowledgement that they really needed to step up their game intellectually.

DINKY DAU 45 said...

Way too much "Hate your next-door neighbor but don't forget to say grace" Sgt.Barry Sadler on the EVE OF DESTRUCTION. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qfZVu0alU0I