"We were born, it was thought, with most of the brain cells we would ever have and could not make more. But... studies using specialized dyes to identify newborn cells indicated that some parts of our brains create neurons deep into adulthood, a process known as neurogenesis... [F]or the new study... [researchers] divided the volunteers into groups, one of which began a supervised program of stretching and balance training three times a week, to serve as an active control. Another started walking together three times a week, briskly, for about 40 minutes. And the final group took up dancing, meeting three times a week to learn and practice line dances and group choreography..... The walkers and dancers were aerobically fitter, as expected. Even more important, their white matter seemed renewed. In the new scans, the nerve fibers in certain portions of their brains looked larger, and any tissue lesions had shrunk. These desirable alterations were most prevalent among the walkers, who also performed better on memory tests now. The dancers, in general, did not. Meanwhile, the members of the control group, who had not exercised aerobically, showed declining white matter health after the six months, with greater thinning and tattering of their axons and falling cognitive scores."
From the top-rated comment: "One aspect not addressed by this article: While walking, one is engaged in a kind if relaxed thinking. I walk a lot and constantly think about things - important and mundane things. I make plans, solve problems, talk to myself about issues - walking provides a kind of meditative state while you’re doing it."
22 comments:
Agree 100% with the top-rated comment. The next study should include walkers who aren't plugged in, and walkers who are listening to some podcast or music or somesuch. I wonder if that would cause a difference in outcome.
I agree with the top rated comment. I’ve always used walks to help me sort things out and solve problems.
A number of big time composers spent a lot of time walking in nature to work out their ideas - Brahms and Beethoven chief among them - and in a YouTube video talking about his creative process, Sting mentioned "taking a walk in the garden" several times.
"some parts of our brains create neurons deep into adulthood, a process known as neurogenesis" Gk neuron also means penis.
I walk for at least an hour a day. You end up going through a lot of audiobooks that way.
This is one good reason not to wear headphones while walking or running. There are many others...
“I agree with the top rated comment. I’ve always used walks to help me sort things out and solve problems”
I walk 40 minutes every day regardless of the weather. Sometimes I use it to mull personal matters, but far more often it’s a time for mental escape. A quality history podcast can make that 40 minutes pass like 5.
Most, but not all. Most understood this from likely prehistoric times. Walking integrates respiration, kinetics, and can integrate contemplation.
I mentioned this to my husband (we walk every morning) and he immediately said "So you're reading Althouse now." It's my only contact with stories from the NY Times.
I’m a a Walker. I average about 8,500 steps a day or 4.5 miles, give or take. I have a 12.4 A1C that came into my life four years ago to thank for it. 12.4 is off the charts diabetic and it came on after a year of sitting, writing, programming. So I started walking, dropped 4 stones*, and my health improved immensely. (A1C now around 6.)
Counting steps is the secret for me. Numbers motivate me. If it’s 11 at night and I’m under, say, 7,000 steps for the day, time for a moonlight stroll even on a January night.
*Come on, man. Do I have to do the math? It’s 60 pounds, gringo. Tee hee.
I wonder whether the author of this study is a big walker... I also wonder how they controlled for all the other behaviors of the study groups outside of the prescribed activities?
Not saying that walking is a bad thing - I'm sure that it is a goodthing. Just saying that I doubt that the study results are as definitive as the article makes them out to be.
I walk 30-40 minutes a day, and feel wretched afterwards. It never gets any better.
But I do it anyway or I feel cheated.
Interesting that at least a couple of commenters here mention listening to audiobooks while walking, and another suggests one should not have headphones when walking.
Clearly we don't know, but my suspicion is that listening to books while walking could very well shut off the particular musing-while-walking brain activity that helps the brain renew. There's nothing wrong with listening to books, but it is clearly a different activity than the special type of thinking one engages in while walking.
I usually have the Wright Show podcast playing when I walk, but I don't usually listen.
Multitasking!
It's 90 and humid out and I went for my usual bike commute. No problem, lots of breeze on a bicycle. You only notice sweating when you come back inside and it doesn't instantly evaporate.
I also broke out my solar powered air conditioner for the computer desk, side-yard solar panel powering a 12v fan that sucks cold air off the basement floor and shoots it at the desk upstairs, via 12" diameter flexible semi-rigid duct fabric tube. The secret is have the fan suck on the tube rather than blowing from the bottom. It's drawing 20 watts at the current setting and the solar panel has the battery voltage at 13.92 volts. So I could go to 30 watts if I wanted, in this bright sunshine.
Dog has transplanted herself by the fan.
Our swimming coach writes complex workout sets that look like algebraic and matrix equations. We were joking last night that she was helping us prevent dementia.
I probably swim six hours per week about half in the pool and half in a pond.
I walk about 12-hours per week. About 1/3 of that pulling around a 440-pound garden cart on side streets and the rest hill hiking on single track root rock and mud trails.
Darwinism prevents me from wearing headphones because situational awareness.
The wife and I both walk for exercise and for weight control, plus we follow a low carb diet. We've been doing this for about six years (3.6 miles walking route per day, paced at one hour elapsed time, five days per week.) She is 65 and rides a bike 15 to 20 miles the other two days, but I am approaching 78 and find I now need a couple of days off each week to avoid overdoing it. Walking works for us and I believe it keeps my mind somewhat sharper (the wife might disagree, though.) Our doctor says we are the only couple she sees who are our ages but require no medicine other than vitamin supplements. I don't know if our results are more gene related than diet and exercise, but either way it works for us. We'll keep at it until we can't do it anymore.
Above all, do not lose your desire to walk: every day I walk myself into a state of well being and walk away from every illness. I have walked myself into my best thoughts, and I know of no thought so burdensome that one cannot walk away from it. But by sitting still, & the more one sits still, the closer one comes to feeling ill. Thus if one just keeps on walking, everything will be all right.
Søren Kierkegaard
I used to use one of those gadgets to keep track of the number of steps, heart rate, etc... but having to concentrate on a gadget----the experience becomes all about numbers and not simply enjoying an experience.
Now, I just use my intuition to determine where I feel my heart rate is at, and what seems comfortable, yet invigorating to me, and how much time I think has elapsed.
It's hard to let your thoughts wander if you're too focused on what a device has to say.
Not even so much as a digital watch, on my daily jog/hikes.
---A very off-the-grid experience.
Ann & Meade,
Guess you are getting smarter and smarter every day. :>}
I would like to see an MRI study on old people who went back to grad school without walking compared to a control of walkers. An Uncle told me once that alcohol kills brain cells, but it only kills the weak ones, so your brain becomes pruned and lean.
I’ve started walking in minimalist shoes, with short bursts of running. I would predict, without evidence, that this enhances the benefits of walking.
Post a Comment