December 22, 2021

"Manchin is especially vulnerable to accusations of imperial remove. Photos that circulated online show him chatting over the rail of his houseboat in Washington with angry constituents, who had arrived by kayak."

Writes Evan Osnos in "West Virginians Ask Joe Manchin: Which Side Are You On? The senator’s blockade against programs that have helped his constituents escape poverty makes some question 'who matters to Joe'" (The New Yorker).

Is it "imperial" to live in a houseboat — a houseboat accessible by angry kayakers?

Eh. Everyone has to write a lot of sentences about Joe Manchin right now. It's tedious but you can find some gems in there.

The Manchins are machers; Joe’s grandfather ran Farmington’s grocery store and served, over the years, as its fire chief, constable, justice of the peace, and mayor. His father had a similar stature in local politics, while also expanding the family business from groceries into furniture and carpets....

Machers... I had to look it up. It's a Yiddish word, I learned, reading "What Makes a Macher" (Forward):

Someone who gets things done? A nerve center? A mediator? An oiler of wheels? Here are some other attempts to define macher, taken from various print and online Yiddish-English lexicons: “Macher — a broker, an agent; a shrewd man; a swindler.” “Macher —an influential person; a fixer.” “Macher — a person who makes things happen; a big shot.” “Macher — a person with access to authorities, a man with contacts.” “Macher — a mover and shaker.” “Macher — a wheeler-dealer.”

Most of these definitions fall short of putting their finger on what makes a macher a macher. He is indeed someone who gets things done, but so is any competent CEO. He may be a nerve center, but a switchboard operator is, too. Mediators come in all varieties, of which a macher is only one. Oilers or greasers of wheels resort to bribery, which a macher does not necessarily do. Brokers, agents and swindlers may be machers, but machers needn’t be brokers, agents or swindlers. And while a successful macher is certainly influential, so is a successful author or intellectual. Machers make things happen? Theater directors and symphony conductors do, too. They’re big shots? Some are...

That leaves us with “fixer” and “wheeler-dealer.”... [T]he fixer is by definition engaged in activities that he would not want to be publicly known, he always operates behind the scenes. Machers, on the other hand, are often — although they don’t have to be — highly conspicuous.... “[W]heeler-dealer” suggests someone operating on many fronts and levels for his own benefit, whereas a macher may act on behalf of an organization or cause....
Both “wheeler-dealer” and macher may have negative undertones, but while most people would agree that the world could do nicely without wheeler-dealers, there is a social necessity for at least some kinds of machers. The Yiddish verb makhn means both “to make” and “to do,” and when one Jews asks another, “Vos makhstu?” he is simply asking “What’s up?” or “What’s doing?” 
A makher is someone who, often with no official position or title, makes it his job to get other people to do things, without being too finicky about the means he employs. Sometimes he’s a force for the better, sometimes for the worse. There’s really no exact word for it in English.

Now, I know what "macher" means. It's probably a word you could stick on any politician. By the way, what is Manchin's ethnicity and religion? He's Italian on his father's side — Manchin was originally Mancini — and Czechoslovak on his mother's side. Religion: Catholic. Of course, it's fine to use Yiddish words to talk about non-Jewish public figures. In fact, it borders on anti-Semitic to use Yiddish words only when describing characters who are Jewish.

One more gem from the Evan Osnos piece:

Bit by bit, Manchin, like [J.D.] Vance, is losing the credibility of his connection to the very place at the heart of his identity.... 

76 comments:

WWIII Joe Biden, Husk-Puppet + America's Putin said...

The left love to destroy anyone who gets in the way of their Soviet powered fever-dreams.

WWIII Joe Biden, Husk-Puppet + America's Putin said...

Joe Biden and his family are rich because of corrupt insider deals with international sources. That wealth is ultimately derived from the American Tax Payer.

Funny - nobody on the left asks Joe "Which side are you on?"

mccullough said...

Unlikely that Osnos understands West Virginians as well as Manchin.

New Yorkers are provincial.

Tom T. said...

Osnos was born in London and educated in Greenwich, CT and Harvard. What are his qualifications to evaluate Manchin's connection to West Virginia?

J Melcher said...

The "fixer" who overtly helps the community but covertly helps himself .. . I'm reminded of the character in Gaiman's _American Gods_, the Hinzelmann:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hinzelmann

Mike (MJB Wolf) said...

“Losing credibility”? Not as I see it. There’s not a red county anywhere in WV and he is widely known as the only (as in single) Democrat able to win a statewide race in WV. I also reject the “things lost” argument about BBB. There is no benefit WV people enjoy that will go away by rejecting BBB. To the contrary there’s many provisions in BBB that would exacerbate the economic decline of coal country intentionally. Why can’t Democrats be happy they have his vote on judges etc and maintain control of the Senate. It could vanish tomorrow but they act like a Senator from WV is their God-given right.

John henry said...

I've always admired him for the sheer beauty of the EpiPen scam.


1) Wife it head of some national school organization. Lobbies DC (ie; him) to mandate EpiPens in every school.

2) He passes legislation mandating the $600 EpiPen, but not the $10 syringe, in every school in the US. Needs to be replaced annually so it keeps giving. By pure coincidence, the FDA refuses to approve competing European versions for use in the US.

3) His daughter, with few qualifications for the job, winds up as CEO of Mylan, which is the only manufacturer of the EpiPen. And Mylan doesn't even make it themselves. They farm it out to another big pharma company whose name you see every day.

It is so beautiful in its total corruption that one almost has to admire it. It is pure genius.

OTOH, he is standing firm against the BBB bill so there is that. I am happy to see him standing firm but I wonder if this is principle or if it is just because they have not come up to his price yet.

I'm betting that he eventually "caves".

John LGBTQBNY Henry

gilbar said...

serious question
can i bicycle up to the rail of Nancy Pelosi's house, and chat with her?

Also
these "angry constituents, who had arrived by kayak" ?
Had ANY of them EVER been to West Virginia?
https://newsdome.co.za/kayaktivists-protest-outside-joe-manchins-houseboat-over-budget-bill/


Activists in kayaks and other watercraft protested outside Sen. Joe Manchin’s (D-W.Va.) houseboat in Washington, D.C., on Monday, urging the moderate lawmaker to work with his colleagues to pass a massive budget reconciliation bill.

A small group of demonstrators with the groups Greenpeace USA, Young West Virginia, Race Matters WV, CASA, and the Center for Popular Democracy Action took to the waves outside the boat


Again... Had ANY of them EVER been to West Virginia?

Wince said...

Aren't houseboat the traditional redoubts of middle-aged bachelor private investigators?

Joe Smith said...

I knew 'macher' from my high school German. 'Machen.' To make, to go.

Yiddish is just corrupted German, and I can understand a fair amount if it's spoken slowly.

The shadier meaning is 'a guy who knows a guy.'

Marty said...

Ah, more shallow political fiction from the left-wing New Yorker. Thanks for sharing.

Lloyd W. Robertson said...

The last bit is great. If you don't vote woke, you don't really care about the poor, and you deserve to lose elections. What evidence is there that the woke actually care about the poor?

cf said...

Surely there is no state better than West Virginia to have garnered a talented, scrupulous Senator that gets good things going, or stops stupid things from getting done.

John henry said...

Why do people keep talking about Manchin's "houseboat"? A houseboat is a very specific type of boat. It is rectangular in shape rather than pointy on the front end. Not very stable for anything other than rivers and lakes.

Here is a picture of Algore's multi-million $ 100' long houseboat which is typical of the architecture.

https://www.all-about-houseboats.com/images/al-gore-enjoys-green-solar-powered-houseboats-21290185.jpg

Manchin's boat is more of a typical yacht. WaPo says it is worth $700,000.

He is not like the other KoolKidz that live in multi-million dollar mansions.

John LGBTQBNY Henry

Menahem Globus said...

I used to think living in a houseboat in a live aboard marina like Doc Ford would be neat. Then I moved to Florida and got to see houseboat living up close. It would be like living at a KOA campground in a Winnebago. Fun for a short vacation but an utter nightmare for day to day life.

What's emanating from your penumbra said...

Is there a Yiddish word for not being surprised that when mentally ill people are put in positions of influence they influence others toward insanity?

Tina Trent said...

Somewhere, John D. MacDonald is proud of him. Go, Travis Manchin McGee!

Rollo said...

The kayakers almost certainly weren't his constituents, unless they were ex-Senator Rockefeller's grandkids.

Sebastian said...

If Joe had decided to vote for BBB, he would have been celebrated by the same people who now vilify him. Even prog disdain is situational.

Michael K said...

The hysteria over Manchin is amusing. Maybe they will force him to change parties. That would satisfy his constituents.

JRoberts said...

"Bit by bit, Manchin, like [J.D.] Vance, is losing the credibility of his connection to the very place at the heart of his identity...."

How much you want to bet Evan Osnos' familiarity with West Virginia wouldn't even fill a thimble.

Temujin said...

I only know a couple of things for sure. One- although West Virginia was for years a Democratic state, they voted for Trump over Biden in 2020 by 68.62% vs 29.69%. Basically a 70/30 split. That does not look like West Virginia is a Democratic state any longer. Nor does it look like they much cared for or bought what Joe Biden was selling then. I suspect they don't care much about it now either, but I don't know for sure.

On the other hand, I'll be Joe Manchin does. And I'll also bet that he 'gets' his state in a much more ground level way than say...Evan Osnos, born in London, raised in Greenwich, CT, went to college at Harvard, and has been with The New Yorker for years. I suspect Evan, though he may be a great guy, knows nothing about what makes a West Virginian tick.

Nor does the rest of our screaming media.

JRoberts said...

After reading Ann's various descriptions of "Macher", I find myself thinking of Josh Brolin's character in the movie "Hail Caesar!" Especially the scene where Brolin slaps Clooney and tells him to "snap out of it!"

It's a tough job, but somebody has to do it. At this moment in time, I'm glad Manchin did what he did. I reserve the right to change my opinion in a few months.

Osnos (and probably "The Squad") thinks real life should be lived out like a college dorm room bull session.

stutefish said...

"Manchin is especially vulnerable to accusations of imperial remove."

Is he, though? I mean, sure, you can point your finger at that photo and cry out dramatically, "see?! Imperial remove!" But does it actually matter? Is he actually vulnerable? Or is this just wishful thinking?

Tofu King said...

Was machts du? "What's up" in German. Seems in Yiddish they just changed the spelling or the author went with what they heard phonetically.

phantommut said...

Another piece including no evidence supporting its conclusions other than anecdotes and "just so" stories from sources who are the author's kindred spirits. You'd think writer might have tracked down a poll.

Mike Sylwester said...

The word remove is a verb, not a noun.

The expression imperial remove is bad writing.

NorthOfTheOneOhOne said...

"West Virginians Ask Joe Manchin: Which Side Are You On? The senator’s blockade against programs that have helped his constituents escape poverty makes some question 'who matters to Joe'"

Really? If that's so, why has he been in office since 2010? Why did he serve a term as Governor of West Virginia? The people of West Virginia keep electing him for some reason. Contrary to what Evan Osnos seems to be implying, he didn't seize power and appoint himself Senator. The only alternative would be election fraud and I'm sure Mr. Osnos doesn't want to bring that up! It's too bad Ruy Teixeira didn't put something in his recent Substack post about this falsely assumed ability the Left has for reading the minds of people they normally wouldn't deign to talk to.

Bit by bit, Manchin, like [J.D.] Vance, is losing the credibility of his connection to the very place at the heart of his identity....

And bit by bit, Evan Osnos and The New Yorker slip more and more into Fantasyland.

Tofu King said...

I'm sure West Virginia has a vocal progressive segment of residents. Ask the coal miners what they think of BBB. They probably are not in kayaks on the Potomac.

Ron Winkleheimer said...

Bit by bit, Manchin, like [J.D.] Vance, is losing the credibility of his connection to the very place at the heart of his identity....

In the author's opinion, and his fellow lefties.

If Manchin thought the majority of his voters were for the legislation he would vote for it, unless he really does think it is highly inflationary and bad for the nation, in which case he is a statesman. I don't think he is a statesman, but I do think that he has a better handle on the "the credibility of his connection to the very place at the heart of his identity" than some journalist, who probably was to dumb to get into law school.

Lars Porsena said...

How many paid subscriptions for the "New Yorker" are there in all of WV?

Mike Sylwester said...

I have not read the linked article, but the excerpts indicate that the article is largely an ad hominem attack on Manchin.

Discussion of the substantive issues is more intelligent.

mikee said...

I see a Republican future for old Joe, since he has only a few more years to serve before retirement. I'm sure the press will treat Joe as favorably as they did Arlan Specter, should Joe switch parties. And hey, if you're being hung out to dry, you may as well do something to make it worth the punishment.

Dagwood said...

So are we to believe that his constituents rowed their kayaks all the way down the Potomac River from Harpers Ferry just to express their concerns? I guess that would be newsworthy, if true.

Rollo said...

This is similar to what Glenn Royal Dutch Shell Kessler tried to do to Tim Scott: find some ancestor who was a big fish in a small town and use it to dismiss a politician's achievements or portray him as part of the elite or as representative of an older, discredited elite.

Obviously, this is never done to politicians one agrees with, and it's done even if one comes from a more privileged background oneself. Evan Lionel Richard Osnos is more a part of the Establishment than Manchin's father or grandfather was.

Narr said...

I am surprised--almost shocked--that 'macher' was not known to you.

And yeah, Evan Osnos--transatlantic rich kid--is the guy to judge Manchin's and Vance's connection to the heartland.

Steven said...

The only person who is losing his credibility "bit by bit" in this piece is Osnos, who is quoting the views of two progressive activists, one of whom is characterized as having opposed Manchin for a long time, in order to try to sell people on the idea that someone who has a 60% job approval rating in West Virginia is losing his support because he did something supported by three-quarters of West Virginians ("Nearly 74 percent of voters also said Manchin should oppose the president’s Build Back Better plan.").

Rit said...

So, what looks like maybe a dozen people in kayaks and one small outboard boat now speak for all West Virginians? And should Manchin lose the credibility of his connection to the very place at the heart of his identity, then who do the tiresome fools who write stuff like this believe is going to replace him? This is West Virginia we're talking about.

Big Mike said...

Imperial Manchin? In West Virginia he’s well known for his common touch. We’re the kayakers really his constituents? It isn’t impossible, because West Virginia is home to some awesome white water. However my betting is that they are Democrat operatives who wouldn’t be caught dead living anywhere that isn’t a close in suburb of DC.

And Manchin knows that too.

Bruce Hayden said...

In their desperation to enact their extremely unpopular Build Back Bankrupt legislation, they forget that Manchin represents a very Red state. He doesn’t represent states like MA, CA, NY, CN, etc, where the legislation is popular, esp with the very rich, because of their capped SALT tax deductions. Very few of his constituents likely reach the cap on SALT tax deductions, but a lot of them work in industries that would be adversely affected by the legislation. What is their argument for selling out the bulk of his constituents? This sort of nonsense - right thinking people in the Bluest parts of the country (funded by those who are hardest hit by the SALT income tax cap) support the legislation, and don’t like him very much right now.

What is interesting right now are the competing BBB ads on TV in PHX (similar ads for Tester on MT TV) aimed indirectly at Mark Kelly. Sitting for re-election to McCain’s old seat this year, the pro BBB ads try to bolster his support for the legislation. And, of course, the anti side want to tar him as a rabid leftist. Those mention the tax break for the richest taxpayers, as well as inflation. Interestingly, his name comes up as one of the Senators hiding behind Manchin’s refusal to vote for the legislation. He knows that voting for it would permanently turn him into an ex-Senator come November. But he isn’t the only one. Indeed, all three of our Dem Senators (Sinema and Kelly from AZ, Tester from MT) are apparently on that list (and of the 3, only Sinema is brave enough to oppose it openly - so much for the ads showing Kelly as a fighter pilot).

BarrySanders20 said...

Netflix will get right on it, and no doubt present an objective narrative: "The Making of a Macherer."

Richard Dolan said...

Perhaps there was a time when an article like this might have made a difference or would have mattered to someone. That time is long gone. So the NYer wants to tag Manchin as a high-living, boat-owning elitist -- think of him as the new John Kerry! -- because he won't vote like some lefty from Park Slope in service to the woke-i-dokes (that would be Schumer). And then this gem from the NYer: "West Virginians Ask Manchin: which side are you on?" Since Manchin is the last Dem to be elected statewide in WVa in a long time, and the circulation of the NYer in WVa is nil, the answer isn't hard to figure out.

"It's tedious," says AA, and that's quite the understatement. But it's also a pretty good indication of who in Dem-land needs bucking up -- all those readers of the NYer, you know who you are.

Bruce Hayden said...

From yesterday’s Manchin thread:

“Chuck Shumer has no power over Joe Manchin. He realizes he is only one phone call away from not being Senate Majority Leader. Being from West "by God" Virginia, he could care less about what any Yankee carpetbaggers or latte sippin' coastal elites think.”

No doubt there are Republican Senators who have vouched this with Manchin. I think that if he were less principled, he would have taken up their offer by now. The Senate Dems know this, and the smarter ones (like Schumer) know that if Manchin is pushed hard enough, he will likely jump. I don’t think that he is ready to do so - yet. And with that, their ability to pass legislation, and to confirm radical leftist cabinet members and judges, will come to a screeching stop. A lot of House Dems are leftist enough that they don’t care, so insist on making the situation worse.

James K said...

“Bit by bit, Manchin, like [J.D.] Vance, is losing the credibility of his connection to the very place at the heart of his identity.... ”

Wishful thinking must be like a narcotic or opioid. Feels great but doesn’t correspond to reality.

It’s not even obvious that those constituents are angry at Manchin, as opposed to Biden, though even if they are, so what. Not exactly a scientific sample.

Chris Lopes said...

As the only Democrat national office holder in a deep red state and with the Senate at 50/50, Manchin isn't vulnerable to much except people who can't do the math. If you are trying to hand the Senate back to the Republicans before the midterms, attacking Manchin makes perfect sense. Otherwise, you are engaging in the kind of infantile rage Trump has been accused of.

wildswan said...

A roar of approval goes up in the heartland but if the media doesn't report it does it make a sound?
What does make a sound?

Say it loud, say it proud: DC HATES JOE MANCHIN !!!

Big Apple Bites Man.
New York Turns on Joe Mancini- Must Mask at Parties
"Yeah, Joe's gonna have to wear a mask like a servant at any party he gets invited to which will be none."

Los Angeles staging "Welcome Joe Manchin" party at the Nakatomi Plaza.

Narayanan said...

Manchin is especially vulnerable to accusations of imperial remove.
---------
if only Manchin should have offered the kayakers cake on a six foot paddel from his boat

Narayanan said...

arbeiter macher frieer

Narayanan said...

to gain popularity change his name back to Mancini and do a musical Rambo?

hombre said...

“... angry constituents, who had arrived by kayak.” By kayak from West Virginia? Bwahahahaha!

Are New Yorker journalists and/or their readers bubbleheaded enough to buy this?

MadTownGuy said...

'Macher' - like Frankie the Fixer in the Lilyhammer series?

hawkeyedjb said...

"Vulnerable" To what? If Manchin switched parties and ran as a Republican, he'd probably win 80% of the vote in his state.

Ted said...

If you read Yiddish literature -- which mostly takes place in small communities -- a macher is a local big shot, the type of guy others listen to and who gets things done. It denotes high social status, whether or not the person is wealthy or has a fancy job. (For example, it's the type of person Tevye the Milkman imagines he would be "if [he] were a rich man" -- the main point isn't the money, but how others would view him as someone important.) You can imagine this word being used factually ("I know a macher who can get us what we need"), proudly ("My buddy, what a macher!") or sarcastically ("That idiot, he thinks he's such a macher!").

madAsHell said...

Bit by bit, Manchin, like [J.D.] Vance, is losing the credibility of his connection to the very place at the heart of his identity....

This is schizophrenia. They always want to add facts, comments, that are not in evidence. I can't imagine how someone would think that is a meaningful statement.

This is the "mostly peaceful protestors" as the camera pans out over broken windows, and fire-bombed buildings. "Who are you going to believe? Me, or your lying eyes!!"

gadfly said...

In May 2016, Trump told a throng of West Virginia coal miners, “Get ready because you’re going to be working your asses off.”

And yet, more coal-fired electric generation plants were shut during the (2017-2020) term of the Trump administration – estimated at 46,600 Megawatts – than during Obama’s second term (2013-2016) – around 43,100 MW. In 2012, Obama set up his EPA to reduce 1,400 coal-fired electric generating units at more than 600 power plants generating 317.6 gigawatts down to 266 coal-fired power plants in 32 states, generating only 228.9 gigawatts annually since then.

Government subsidies for "renewable" wind, sun and water generators and an Obama threat to impose a CO2 tax on new coal plants built has virtually brought West Virginia and Wyoming coal mining firms into Chapter 11 depite the fact that renewables cost 280% more per MW than coal and the cheapest unsubsidized fuel in all the world comes from the Powder River surface mines in Wyoming. And lest we forget, no electricity is ever generated when renewables await the wind blowing and sunshine - an unacceptable condition in America (ask a Texan) which means keeping coal and natural gas generators operating in a wait state at idle. West Virginia is also concerned about negative legislation which can impede the benefits of gas and oil taken from Marcellus shale under the state.

In summary, Sen. Joe Manchin, coal companies and coal miners are being put out of business and the American consumer is paying higher and higher electric prices resulting from stupid government interference into private enterprise. So if the choice is coal or child care, informed Hillbillies will pick coal.

Big Mike said...

The New Yorker needs to look at this chart to see why it is so dubious that the kayakers are genuine West Virginians. There are eight political offices that are elected statewide in West Virginia: Governor, Secretary of State, Attorney General, Auditor, Treasurer, Commissioner of Agriculture, and the two US senators. Joe Manchin is the only one of those eight who is not a Republican. The West Virginia State Senate is Republican by better than a 2:1 margin, and the House of Delegates is even redder, Republican by better than a 3:1 margin. Manchin won with 61% of the vote in 2012, but won by only 3% and with less than 50% of the vote total in 2018 -- a blue wave year.

Manchin gets which way the wind is blowing; The New Yorker not so much.

Ozymandias said...

The most common idiomatic meaning of macher is "big shot." That meaning is consistent with the author's aim of portraying Manchin as a member of the elite who ignores his constituents' interests.

cubanbob said...

Osnos' view is limited to the George Washington bridge and battery park. In other words not beyond Manhattan. I'm sure Manchin would poll well in Staten Island with respects to the insane spending bill. Osnos like most New York liberals are rather parochial while thinking themselves smart, sharp, savvy people not like the rubes not realizing they are the rubes.

Leora said...

Based on my mother's explanation of the word, a Macher is someone like Donald Trump.

Molly said...

Houseboats are a low cost way of living in DC. "These "liveaboard slips" are all available in Washington, D.C. with highlights like sundecks and full service galley kitchens. These listings vary in length from 41 feet long to 48 feet long and vary in price from $89,000 to $189,000." https://dc.curbed.com/2016/6/3/11844858/houseboat-washington-dc

If you were an elected Representative who planned to live permanently in DC, it would be kind of small and uncomfortable, and you would buy something on land. But if you maintained your permanent house in your home State (District), and thought of your DC residence as a temporary place to stay while you were doing your DC duty, then a houseboat might well be your best option.

Drago said...

It is impossible not to notice that whenever more disastrous news for Biden's Earpiece Administration comes out, particularly with ever declining poll numbers which are now below Jimmy Carters, and for good reason, then our little Poor Man's LLR ***** gadfly "swings into action" to launch hilariously adolescent and moronic and self-debunking "hit pieces" on Trump or Sarah Palin or (insert any other republican literally for any other reason here) in the desperate hope that he/she/xe can help prop up Team Dem.

Spoiler: .....well, you already know what the spoiler is, don't you?

That's okay gadfly. They still give participant medals, sometimes cookies and often pats on the head for good little for NPC-ers, like yourself.

Anonymous said...

I've got a lot of connections to WV. Friends who know Manchin outside the office as it were. Other than being a Dem, he's very well thought of in WV. The state of Robert Byrd. Bringing jobs to WV or protecting WV jobs is Job 1 through 10 for the Senator, as it should be.

Amateurs talk of coal. It's in decline, but will not stop, ever. Joe knows that it's a symbol of his faith with the voters. NG, oil and petro-feedstock is the future. For Byrd, his game was chair of appropriations. Manchin's is chairing Energy. same rules though. protect and add jobs.

WV was Dem when Dems were a blue collar union favoring operation. UMWA type unions.

Regardless of the talk, there are 10 other Dem Senators who are against or would hate a BBB vote. If Manchin were replaced by a sure BBB vote today, there would be another Dem who would be a quivering no vote.

The House progressives don't understand that Manchin(D) has gotten them 40 new Dem approved judges. Manchin (R) would not have given them that nor would he give them a Breyer replacement.

Anonymous said...

I've got a lot of connections to WV. Friends who know Manchin outside the office as it were. Other than being a Dem, he's very well thought of in WV. The state of Robert Byrd. Bringing jobs to WV or protecting WV jobs is Job 1 through 10 for the Senator, as it should be.

Amateurs talk of coal. It's in decline, but will not stop, ever. Joe knows that it's a symbol of his faith with the voters. NG, oil and petro-feedstock is the future. For Byrd, his game was chair of appropriations. Manchin's is chairing Energy. same rules though. protect and add jobs.

WV was Dem when Dems were a blue collar union favoring operation. UMWA type unions.

Regardless of the talk, there are 10 other Dem Senators who are against or would hate a BBB vote. If Manchin were replaced by a sure BBB vote today, there would be another Dem who would be a quivering no vote.

The House progressives don't understand that Manchin(D) has gotten them 40 new Dem approved judges. Manchin (R) would not have given them that nor would he give them a Breyer replacement.

Bunkypotatohead said...

Narayanan said...
"Manchin is especially vulnerable to accusations of imperial remove.
---------
if only Manchin should have offered the kayakers cake on a six foot paddel from his boat"


Or Jeni's ice cream from his Sub-Zero freezer.

rcocean said...

Manchin needs to back Schumer's bill.

Otherwise, he'll never grow in office.

Alumino said...

The “yacht” was purchased for $220,000 in 2014 from in a liquidation sale
(So likely a repossession or short sale)

Carl said...

Really good chance the kayakers are from out of state

Greg The Class Traitor said...

A makher is someone who, often with no official position or title, makes it his job to get other people to do things, without being too finicky about the means he employs. Sometimes he’s a force for the better, sometimes for the worse. There’s really no exact word for it in English.

Now, I know what "macher" means. It's probably a word you could stick on any politician.


Nope. Because politicians have "official positions and titles"

The senator’s blockade against programs that have helped his constituents escape poverty
Bullshit. None of the "climate change" bullshit has helped any of Manchin's constituents escape poverty. The expansion of teh SALT credit doesn't do it, either.

To the extent that there are any actually worthwhile programs in BBB, it's the "Progressives" who are holding those programs hostage in exchange for trillions of dollars of payoffs for rich lefties

Greg The Class Traitor said...

Bruce Hayden said...
I think that if he were less principled, he would have taken up their offer by now. The Senate Dems know this, and the smarter ones (like Schumer) know that if Manchin is pushed hard enough, he will likely jump. I don’t think that he is ready to do so - yet. And with that, their ability to pass legislation, and to confirm radical leftist cabinet members and judges, will come to a screeching stop. A lot of House Dems are leftist enough that they don’t care, so insist on making the situation worse.

Given that Schumer keeps on claiming he's going to force procedural votes on BBB and other (DOA) Dem wish list items, either Schumer is flat out lying, or he's not longer one of "the smarter ones".

I mean, I'd love to see Tester, Kelly, and Sienema all forced to vote on BBB during an election year, in a vote where we know it's going to lose. But I don't see how any intelligent Democrat could want that

Richard Dillman said...

Osnos is dead wrong on West Virginians. I lived there for about a year, and I found it to be a conservative, hard-scrabble, working class
society. West Virginians value hard work. When I lived there in 1960, it was a difficult place to earn a good living. Sixty years later, the economy has substantially improved, but it is still a difficult place to earn a good living.

Oh by the way, as a former kayaker, most kayakers I knew were fairly affluent, upper middle class people. This is not a binary, elite
versus proletarian conflict. Considering the price of real estate in D. C., living on his houseboat might be a frugal choice, especially if he sees his senate job as temporary.

WV John said...

WV state motto
Montani semper liberi, Mountaineers are always free.
Looks to me like Manchin is living up to the motto.

traditionalguy said...

Senator Manchin understands his State wants leadership that they can trust will lead them to victory in this hard world. That is 1000% not Biden/Obama politicians who sell them out every chance they get. He can just abstain and win support. But don’t join the Destroy America Party’s coup de grace.

Big Mike said...

Osnos like most New York liberals are rather parochial while thinking themselves smart, sharp, savvy people not like the rubes not realizing they are the rubes.

Ruy Teixeira should have listed the liberals’ unshakeable belief that they’re the only smart people in the room as a sixth Deadly Sin. Yes, I get that the GOP has often earned the title “The Stupid Party,” but the Democrats’ inability to make the mental connection between runaway government spending and runaway inflation is simply incredible. And not at all intelligent.

tim in vermont said...

“Bit by bit, Manchin, like [J.D.] Vance, is losing the credibility of his connection to the very place at the heart of his identity.... ”

Nothing builds 'credibility' with the poor and downtrodden like huge tax cuts for rich Democrats, and Manchin is just flushing this all down the toilet.

The Senator from neighboring Maryland says that without the tax cuts for wealthy Democrats, err, I mean without removing the cap on SALT deductions, -- an urgent priority -- he's a no on Build Back Broke. But he is in touch with those in need, those in need of a huge tax cut. This gives him credibility in those cabins in Butcher Holler Loretta Lynn sang about, unlike Manchin.

Lurker21 said...

I don't think I've ever been to West Virginia, but supposedly there is that little bit in the extreme east on the Potomac, the three counties that wanted to stay in Virginia. They were put in West Virginia to safeguard the rail line for the union. Charles Town has long resented Charleston, and I believe Rockefeller lived there after putting in his required time in Appalachia. I'd imagine a lot of people there work in DC or its suburbs and some actually have kayaks. But seriously, I do doubt those protestors were Manchin's constituents.

Subrat Kumar said...

I had seen many people are talking about the furniture shifting so I recommended if you live in Bangalore then chose cloud packers and movers in Bangalore to shift your furniture.