May 5, 2020

"And just two men, locked in a hut for six months of dark and cold, would probably kill each other, he concluded."

"So it would have to be one person alone. As the leader of the expedition, he felt obliged to assign himself to the job.... Once the sun set, on April 12, he would be stuck. No plane could fly in again until the sun returned in October.... Byrd at first took comfort in his routine of weather observations and in constantly rearranging his supply closets.... His cabin was buried in the snow, to present a low profile to the wind; the only way out was through a hatch in the roof.... On the page, Byrd’s voice cries out like the merciless Antarctic wind. He sits in his sleeping bag playing solitaire. He bangs around in the dark, fetching food and fuel from his storage tunnels.... He registers the ice crawling up the inside walls of his cabin, and the drifts of snow that cover him whenever he manages to lift the hatch to peer out at the weather and tend his instruments. Weakened by the carbon-monoxide fumes from his stove, he throws up most of his food. He stares at sleeping pills and wonders if he should take them. 'The dark side of man’s mind seems to be a sort of antenna tuned to catch gloomy thoughts from all directions,' he wrote of a particularly bitter day early in June. 'I found it so with mine.'"

From "Self-Isolated at the End of the World/Alone in the long Antarctic night, Adm. Richard E. Byrd endured the ultimate in social distancing" (NYT).

31 comments:

rhhardin said...

Thurber has something belittling Byrd's accomplishments somewhere, though I can't locate it. About the shouty news coverage.

Mike (MJB Wolf) said...

Cmon why depress yourself with thoughts of isolation when you can be comforted by DEATH? Well not death per se, but the death statistics that will unlock is from our own isolation. And if this is true for America, chances are this statistic is good within your state (certain metro exceptions apply). Take a walk with me back to the early days of panic.

In those early days of March I heard an epidemiologist say the “only meaningful statistic” we have during the pandemic is DEATHS PER DAY because the other metrics (# of cases, # tested & # recovered) all are dependent on other variables, whereas D/D would not be revised as more testing occurs (with some exceptions for marginal deaths). That’s why I started my graph. Tracking deaths is the only way we know when we are past the peak, over the hump, those things we were watching for.

After hearing how this was “the important” metric I notice the DNC-Media started to ignore deaths per day. Never heard it on air again. We passed it mid-April, as Trump originally predicted the peak to arrive. D/D peaked at about 3200 and pretty steadily declined to about 1000/day presently. Yet this GOOD NEWS is 100% ignored by the media. We were all talking about flattening the curve, lowering that bump.

So why the news blackout for achieving that milestone? Why isn’t “THE SCIENCE” of our downward slope worth citing as proof we can safely reopen? Anybody else recall peak talk two months ago?

[updated and corrected from overnight thread]

Ann Althouse said...

"Thurber has something belittling Byrd's accomplishments somewhere, though I can't locate it. About the shouty news coverage."

Not really. You're thinking of Smurch.

"Both Lindbergh and Byrd, fortunately for national decorum and international amity, had been gentlemen; so had our other famous aviators. They wore their laurels gracefully, withstood the awful weather of publicity, married excellent women, usually of fine family, and quietly retired to private life and the enjoyment of their varying fortunes. No untoward incidents, on a worldwide scale, marred the perfection of their conduct on the perilous heights of fame. The exception to the rule was, however, bound to occur and it did, in July, 1937, when Jack (“Pal”) Smurch, erstwhile mechanic’s helper in a small garage in Westfield, Iowa, flew a second-hand, single-motored Bresthaven Dragon-Fly III monoplane all the way around the world, without stopping.... 'Mr. Lindbergh,' began a United States Senator, purple with rage, 'and Mr. Byrd—' Smurch, who was paring his nails with a jackknife, cut in again. 'Byrd!' he exclaimed. 'Aw fa God’s sake, dat big—' Somebody shut off his blasphemies with a sharp word...."

That sort of thing was hilarious 80 years ago.

I Have Misplaced My Pants said...

Mike, I haven’t paid much attention to the “some people want this to go on forever” points of view as too implausible but now I wonder.

No matter what the good news is there’s a “yabut” response. Some people, for probably widely varied reasons, want to put an extending the crisis filter on everything that comes down the pike.

Ann Althouse said...

"... can't locate it..."

Well, don't try any navigation in the real world. That was incredibly easy to locate.

Mike (MJB Wolf) said...

Well, Misplaced, since the same people who wanted Trump impeached are the same people who want the lockdowns to continue for no apparent reason I’m starting to draw conclusions.

prairie wind said...

Mike, another useful metric would be a daily report of how many COVID-19 cases are hospitalized. The trouble with both of those measures is the question of how they determine if someone is sick from or dead of COVID-19. There seems to be an incentive to increase those numbers.

Butkus51 said...

I believe Michael Collins has him beat for the most isolated human ever.

rcocean said...

I'm sure that Thurber did belittle Byrd's accomplishments, because that's what members of the chattering classes do. Thurber himself did nothing except get drunk, get into little bitch fights with people at the New Yorker, and tell "humorous" stories.

Byrd operated a meteorological station at the South Pole. And suffered from Carbon Dioxide poisoning He had some amazing exploits in the 1920s and 1930s. But he's been almost completely forgotten, while Amiela Earhart has been become famous.

rcocean said...

I'm sure that Thurber did belittle Byrd's accomplishments, because that's what members of the chattering classes do. Thurber himself did nothing except get drunk, get into little bitch fights with people at the New Yorker, and tell "humorous" stories.

Byrd operated a meteorological station at the South Pole. And suffered from Carbon Dioxide poisoning He had some amazing exploits in the 1920s and 1930s. But he's been almost completely forgotten, while Amiela Earhart has been become famous.

rhhardin said...

No that's not it; there was an illustration map of Antartica in it. Dimly remembered as labelled "Byrdland" on the map.

A glance down the LOC Thurber index didn't suggest anything. Much page flipping would be required and those original editions don't flip very well.

rcocean said...

Such was the case when Admiral Richard Byrd returned from his Antarctic expedition, during which he conducted a number of geological studies. Ever ready to tweak a senator’s nose, the New Yorker’s James Thurber imagined an exchange between Byrd and a U.S. Senate subcommittee that was more interested in exploitable commodities than in scientific discoveries:

April 1930 issue.

Iman said...

I maintain a safe social distance from the morons at the NYT.

mikee said...

I read about Byrd's Antarctic stay and his rescue in Reader's Digest as a condensed book, back in the 1960s. I've been leery of carbon monoxide ever since.

Howard said...

https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/coronavirus-deaths-united-states-each-day-2020-n1177936

mikee said...

I read about Byrd's Antarctic stay and his rescue in Reader's Digest as a condensed book, back in the 1960s.

Mike (MJB Wolf) said...

What do you glean from NBC’s chart Howard?

Lurker21 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Lurker21 said...

Although Byrd was a Navy man, he never considered that two men, locked in a hut for six months of dark and cold, might fall in love. It was like that back then.

Admiral Byrd was the brother of Harry F. Byrd, who was senator from Virginia for 32 years before being succeeded by Harry F. Byrd Jr. There was much talk of the Democratic Party's "Byrd Machine" controlling the state politically.

Robert C. Byrd, senator from West Virginia for 51 years, was not related to the prestigious Virginia family, but changed his name when he was adopted by relatives of his after his mother died in the 1918 influenza epidemic. The name probably didn't hurt his political career.

LuAnn Zieman said...

Woodstock began in the middle of a pandemic--the Hong Kong flu--that killed 100,000 People in the U.S., mostly over age 65, and one million worldwide. It began in December 1968 and lasted into 1970. No school or business closures. No social distancing. Stock markets didn't crash. The medical community took primary responsibility for mitigation, as one would expect. It was widely assumed that diseases required medical responses, not political ones. I barely remember it, as do most others living at that time. I had just graduated from college and was in my first year of teaching.

TreeJoe said...

Howard's link to NBC's chart shows me alot of states have serious issues with counting, that the true number dead by Coronavirus may be inflated to a meaningful degree, and that overall the level of deaths (which proceeds infection rates by ~3-4 weeks) show downward trends across the board which means we have gone beyond flattening the curve to steeply declining the curve.

The original goal post was flatten the curve and then phase re-open. That's the goalpost. It's time to proceed.

Mr. O. Possum said...

Oddly enough, I started to try to read this book just a few weeks ago.

Why did he do this? I asked myself.

The answer? "Aside from the meteorological and auroral work, I had no important purpose. There was nothing of that sort. Nothing whatever, except one man's desire to know that kind of experience in the full...." A page later he writes "I was conscious of a certain aimlessness."

Very strange.

Not much happens in the book, except extended descriptions of his miseries.

He likely did make quite a bit of money from his book. Incidentally, Sir Ernest Shackleton made much money from his ill-fated polar expedition. Before that trip began, he required all his crew to sign contracts in which they agreed not to exploit their journey for profit.
He reserved that for himself.

My guess is that Byrd did his solitary confinement stunt for publicity and profit and definitely not for scientific reasons.

Bill Peschel said...

Following up on the Thurber story, I find Jeff Greenfield wrote about it in the context of Trump possibly winning the nomination.

He might have been the first talking head to suggest assassinating Trump if he won.

Bill Peschel said...

I should add -- I'm researching Thurber ahead of publishing a collection of his Sherlock parodies -- that he was a lot like the other writers of his time. They wanted to get out of their podunk town because their humor and insights didn't jibe with the locals.

Of course, once he got out, he made his living revising and retelling stories about the people he left behind.

At least these people seem genuinely real. They saw one side of life, and moved to experience the other side, which in their minds was more intellectual, more cultured, more lively, more forbidden (you can be a whoring drunk and still work and be invited to parties).

It was their children, brought up in this environment, who exhibit a narrow-minded belief that they were much smarter than people not like them. In that way, they exhibit the same narrow-minded, racist, parochial tendencies as the people Sinclair Lewis parodied in "Main Street."

(Also, Thurber engaged in writing fake news as a journalist. Working for the Chicago Tribune's newspaper in Paris, they would receive a single-sentence recap of something President Coolidge said in a speech, and spin out an entire article from it. When no telegram came in, he simply made it up.)

n.n said...

Who will remain to cannibalize the remains? #WickedChoice

Perhaps mutually planned is the lesser evil.

Big Mike said...

Anyone besides me remember defrosting your refrigerator back in the days before all of them became frost free? That’s what nearly killed him when the rime blocked his ventilation system.

narciso said...

oh well then


https://amgreatness.com/2020/05/04/the-failed-experiment-of-social-distancing/

rhhardin said...

More Ice Added to U.S. as Thousands Cheer

To a great many people, including myself, the newspaper accounts of Admiral Byrd's latest discoveries in the Antarctic a week or so ago made little, if any, sense. I confined my own study of the involved expeditions to the Herald Tribune article. I reread this article many times and pored over the map that went with it, but for two or three days, I couldn't make out what had actually been done and how it had been accomplished. All that I knew for sure was the Byrd had reported to President Roosevelt (who doesn't have enough to worry him the way it is) that the recent discoveries had added approximately two hundred thousand square miles of ice to American possessions at the South Pole...

..The dotted area marked A represents the ice that Byrd had discovered previously. It will be noticed at once that the newly discovered ice completely surrounds the previously discovered ice, and a moment's thought will lead one to wonder how this could be. I couldn't figure it out myself for a long time, but finally I decided that that's what comes from exploring in airplanes. You can fly right over something without discovering it, discover something further on, and then come back and discover what, if you had been on dog sledges, you would have been bound to discover first...

[On Byrd's description of something that may possibly exist or may not] I have been over that sentence a dozen times, and I have come to the conclusion that Admiral Byrd was lost. I think he was lost, and I think he was too proud to say so...

People Have More Fun than Anybody p.104ff

Narayanan said...

why not build a second hut?

Marcus Bressler said...

The TV series "My World and Welcome To It", based on Thurber and using the title of his book, was not very funny at all. The "cartoons" were childish. William Windom sucked in it. While it won an Emmy (no real reason), it was cancelled after one season.

THEOLDMAN

A classic example of NY/Hollywood thinking of what the rubes wanted to watch. We just watched it because we were waiting for Laugh-In.

rhhardin said...

Thurber, like ee cummings, was against oppression by the officials of the culture. He's mostly misunderstood as misanthropic and misogynist, there being a lot of culture officials in both places.