September 30, 2019

“The sixth-grade girl at a private Virginia school who accused three classmates last week of forcibly cutting her hair now says the allegations were false...”

“... , according to statements from the girl’s family and the principal at Immanuel Christian School in Springfield. School officials met with the girl and her family Monday morning before releasing the statement. The 12-year-old, who is African American, said three white boy students held her down in a school playground a week ago during recess, covered her mouth, called her insulting names and used scissors to cut her hair. The grandparents of the girl, who are her legal guardians, released an apology Monday....”

WaPo reports the least surprising news of the week, and this is why I said from the start that this story should never have been reported, certainly not with the little girl’s name.

ADDED: Here’s what I wrote in the comments 2 days ago:
I’m blogging this story because I believe there are many adults in the picture here, including the people at the NYT, who are not doing enough to protect this child. Whether the story arose 100% from a real life incident or whether it’s all made up or somewhere in between, the girl’s needs are the overwhelming top priority and every adult with anything to do with this should do all they can to help and protect her.

I don’t know that the boys have been named and accused. It sounds like they go to the school and would be easily identifiable. If particular boys are accused, then treating them fairly is also paramount. If the boys are not named, then it’s very hard to believe the story.

As I read it, the story emerged after interaction with the grandmother. The child might have been pressured and asked leading questions and had no idea of what a big deal it would become. That’s why her name and picture should never have come out before an investigation. Even after an investigation, I wouldn’t burden her life with this story, whether it’s true or false.

207 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 207 of 207
Tina Trent said...

Poor kid. Sounds like grandma and grandpa were the ones pushing the narrative and shoving her in front of the cameras.

In interviews on local news, she looked reluctant and terrified. Also not willing to finger anyone, also afraid of the adults raising her.

Someone call DFACS.

FullMoon said...

Now must to wonder if the adults fed her the story they wanted to hear and put the words in her mouth.

Her mother Cynthia, 53, said that her daughter was "in real pain but she wants justice." It was said that it had taken the girl two days to report the incident and had initially told her mother that the missing parts of her hair were the result of playing “beauty salon” with another friend.

“We continued to press her on it because it just didn’t sound like something she would do,” Cynthia Allen said. “Then she started breaking down crying, trembling, and shaking before telling us what happened.”
__________

the adults did not believe the truth she told - so she made up story that they would believe!

chile needs to be housed elsewhere

Steven said...

"Sixth-grader makes up story" isn't a big deal. But neither was "three sixth-graders bully another sixth-grader".

The big deal is that a bunch of news outlets published a hoax about something that wouldn't have been newsworthy even if it was true, and none of the editors responsible have been fired for their blatantly irresponsible actions.

chickelit said...

Then she started breaking down crying, trembling, and shaking before telling us what happened.

Isn't that exactly how the Salem girls behaved during and actual witch hunt?

Bunkypotatohead said...

Don't worry about the girl. She has a bright future as the next Anita Hill.

gravityhurts said...

I've seen numerous clips of the media decrying this racism in America, none retracting the falsehood. Are there any out there?

Ken B said...

Tlaib spread this, and other hoaxes, without retracting. https://freebeacon.com/politics/tlaib-has-promoted-four-viral-racial-hoaxes-in-2019/amp/

This is not carelessness, it is technique.

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 207 of 207   Newer› Newest»