May 19, 2019

"There is one form of power that has fascinated me ever since I was a girl, even though it has been widely colonized by men: the power of storytelling."

"Telling stories really is a kind of power, and not an insignificant one. Stories give shape to experience, sometimes by accommodating traditional literary forms, sometimes by turning them upside down, sometimes by reorganizing them. Stories draw readers into their web, and engage them by putting them to work, body and soul, so that they can transform the black thread of writing into people, ideas, feelings, actions, cities, worlds, humanity, life. Storytelling, in other words, gives us the power to bring order to the chaos of the real under our own sign, and in this it isn’t very far from political power.... I suppose that I chose to write out of a fear of handling more concrete and dangerous forms of power. And also perhaps out of a strong feeling of alienation from the techniques of domination, so that at times writing seemed to be the most congenial way for me to react to abuses of power...."

From "A Power of Our Own/Power is a story told by women. For centuries, men have colonized storytelling. That era is over" by the highly respected novelist Elena Ferrante (in the NYT).

I suppose that I chose to write out of a fear of handling more concrete and dangerous forms of power. 

235 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 235 of 235
Howard said...

It's alimentary, Watson

Churchy LaFemme: said...

First of all, McCaffery is not going to gift us with any more books.

Second, the first two Pern stories, "Weyr Search" & "Dragonrider" from 1967 were excellent. The first won the Hugo and the second won the Nebula, back when those meant something. Both are included in the first novel Dragonflight. After that, things went gradually downhill.

Second, early Norton books were certainly men's adventure, and in fact given the masculine (Andrew North) and ambiguous (Andre Norton) pennnames she chose, she was widely believed to be a man. Her early books also had exactly zero romance elements, and sometimes not even any female characters. (She got over it). I can highly recommend her YA duology The Zero Stone/Uncharted Stars from a teenage male perspective.

GatorNavy said...

She did not write a lot before her untimely death, but I submit Kage Baker for consideration. She was miles better than this bitter Elena.

wwww said...

Taken to playing dumb, have we?

The average adult woman can understand that sci fi/ fantasy is a genre of fiction and not a depiction of "real life." Just as the average adult man can watch GOT and do not expect to see dragons flying through the sky, the average adult woman can figure out sci fi/fantasy.

If, however, you wish to be concerned about women watching Buffy or men watching GOT, that's your deal and none of my business.

wwww said...

The male concern for women reading fiction has always struck me as really quite odd. Similar to Hawthorn criticizing the "scribbles" of 19th century female writers. Certain men got very concerned about women reading fiction in the late 18th early 19th century. Apparently they didn't have enough to worry them, more practical concerns, say like drought or small-pox. Nah, they were worried about Women Reading Fiction. The Root of All Evil.

I've never been able to read McCafferty, but my impression is her fiction tends to be in the YA section. I read both male and female authors. Doesn't matter to me. I don't judge by author but by quality of the writing, the story matter, characterization and plot.

Another good writer: Alex Bleedsoe. He's a lot of fun. Got a series about a guy who reminds me of the Bronn character, a sell-sword.

Lewis Wetzel said...

Opinions, vary, unknown. I like dragon-free fantasy, except for Tolkien. Tolkien's dragons are non-human, intelligent, and cruel. They only relate to humans on the level of myth. Dragons make GOT unserious fantasy, they are basically flying rotweillers or war planes with napalm bombs.

Churchy LaFemme: said...

Sure, de gustibus and all that. I will point out that Mccaffery's dragons are not, technically, fantasy. Pern is an alien planet that was colonized by humans (a spaceship-wreck iirc, not an intentional colony) and the dragons are part of the Pernese biosphere. The menace they help the humans fight are essentially spaceborn spores from another planet in the system.

Drago said...

wwww: "The male concern for women reading fiction has always struck me as really quite odd."

Its even more odd when you consider this assertion is completely made up and akin to other recent false narratives such as its republicans who are overly concerned with AOC, etc.

The concern male scifi fans seem to have is women who are not interested in the genre jumping in to demand the genre be entirely overhauled to suit insane feminist SJW demands while insulting male scifi fans along the lines we have all become accustomed to seeing.

But when reality doesnt help the narrative, just keep cranking out the BS.

effinayright said...

Drago said...

wwww: "The male concern for women reading fiction has always struck me as really quite odd."""
&&&&&&&&&&&&&

I'd just add that "The male concern for women reading fiction has always struck me as really quite odd" is utterly unsubstantiated.

Pulling bullshit out of your ass, wwww, is NOT an argument.

Back to Vox with you!

Narayanan said...

,,,the dragons are part of the Pernese biosphere.,,,

Not exactly: gengineered and developed by the stranded humans. Biotechnology without industrial infrastructure.

wwww said...

What? That guy up in the comments wasn't worried about women watching Buffy? It is weird; it's a TV show. The women are strangers to him. He's not complaining about his wife or girlfriend or daughter. Strange adult women are not his friends, they're not his family, they're not his children. They are strangers to him. He has no jurisdiction or cause to care. It's weird he cares that strangers he will never talk to watch a TV show about vampires. It's a radical idea, but minding one's own business about what other adult, unrelated, strangers want to watch on TV or read, is not a bad policy.

Was thinking about the similarity to 18th and 19th century men who were upset with women writers. Hawthorne couldn't abide those "scribbling women." He hated them because this "damn'd mob of scribbling women" stole his audience. Couldn't handle Louisa May Alcott. Weak.

Men and Women will both read whatever they choose. Frankly, it's nobody's business. And if women watching Buffy is one's biggest worry, be happy, because you ain't got any real problems.

Lewis Wetzel said...

I think that all the positive female role models on television should be depicted as having a man's strength (or more), and no interest in marrying and raising a family, all while being gorgeous with a killer bod.
But I am speaking as a man. Why women would object to Barbie but embrace Buffy, I have no idea. Hysteria, I suppose.

Drago said...

Earlier BS from wwww: "The male concern for women reading fiction has always struck me as really quite odd."

Later self-contradicting wwww: "What? That guy up in the comments wasn't worried about women watching Buffy?"

I rest my case.

etbass said...

And To Kill A Mockingbird....

Narayanan said...

...if I realize I'm reading a novel written by a MAN that purports to be a first person narrative of a female protagonist, I find that positively vile...

I dare you to tell Agatha, Christie that is.

The Murder of Roger Ackroyd.

Rusty said...

Ursela le Guin
Really. Thus isn't difficult.

tim in vermont said...

Tolkien's dragons are non-human, intelligent, and cruel.

Just like the one in the Epic of Gilgamesh, which was found on stone tablets and is, I think, 5,000 years old. They made more sense when the world was a big mysterious place full of unknown things but Tolkien had a respect for the ancient texts and BTW, looted them quite thoroughly. I think that the Gilgamesh dragon’s treasure was the Cedars of Lebanon. I don’t have a problem with using dragons per se, but it sort of goes against the Western hero myth to have them on your side. Like giving your hero nukes.

tim in vermont said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
tim in vermont said...

The more I think about this piece, the more unremarkable it is, she uses “colonize” the way we would use it to describe a bacterial infection that colonized your lungs, except her infection is Marxism. It’s actually kind of banal. People have been using stories to preach forever. The purpose of Homer was to valorize Greek values and transmit them through the generations.

FIDO said...

I am sure Brett Kavanaugh found the female ability to tell stories quite life changing and exciting.

FIDO said...

Example of Wimmin Writing Wielded Wrongly, see Laurel K Hamilton.

She USED to be a moderately good fantasy writer. Sympathetic characters, fraught relationships. A bit of titilation

Except she wrote people in her life into her stories.

One divorce later and suddenly characters written out of the story. A personal interest in BDSM suddenly ruins the actual storytelling.

She breaks up with new guy and more character changes.

As a guy who has enjoyed his share of fantasy novels and erotica, when I say they are unreadable, they are JUST AWFUL.

Women writing as therapy session has made for some pretty tedious fare.

Jack Klompus said...

"Colonized" ranks with "black and brown bodies" and "whiteness" at the top of the cringeworthy pretentious shit list that stupid people use to sound like "intellectuals."

Referring to grown children as "our babies" merits mandatory summary execution in a perfect world.

chuck said...

> but I submit Kage Baker for consideration.

I miss her.

mrkwong said...

The Bronte sisters are sitting in a coffeehouse with Mary Shelley wondering what this hack is going on about.

Kirk Parker said...

I find that the above-mentioned overrated French philosopher is easier to take if you imagine his name is pronounced "fuck-o".

Kirk Parker said...

(Now that I think about it, it's kind of a "Duck of Death" move...)

Caligula said...

What's been colonized is book publishing. And book reviews. And most university English departments.

But it's not Hemingway-esque men who have colonized these places, it's high-theory feminists.

The consequence is that book reviews mostly evaluate works based on their politics, and publishers increasingly accept manuscripts based on their political content.

Whereas university English departments, having decided that authors and their works are of little interest or importance as compared with the brilliance of critics and literary theorists, create nothing that's even close to readable and have only contempt for those who do.

Michael K said...

www said...
The male concern for women reading fiction has always struck me as really quite odd.


Examples ? Where did this come from ?

tim in vermont said...

Examples ? Where did this come from ?

Well, it had to be made up, of course. I don’t know of any male concern for women reading or writing literature as long as we are not forced to read it ourselves. Men have internet porn, women have bodice rippers.

Doris Lessing was pretty good, Flannery O’Connor too. Virginia Woolf? Not so much “Mrs Dalloway, what are we going to do about flowers for the party????” Heavens! Or was that “The Hours”? It’s all a blur to me.

tim in vermont said...

Could you imagine Ernest Hemingway’s The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber being published today? Death in the Afternoon?

tim in vermont said...

roocean got a mention from the “Godfather”!

https://pjmedia.com/instapundit/330902/

Bruce Hayden said...

“If, however, you wish to be concerned about women watching Buffy or men watching GOT, that's your deal and none of my business.”

Buffy wasn’t just for chicks. (Spoiler Alert) Final Big Bang Theory episode had Raj traveling to the Nobel Prize presentation (physics prize shared between Sheldon and Amy) without a date. He ended up sitting next to Buffy on the plane and invited her to the ceremony. The other three guys were incredulous. And there she was at the awards ceremony, sitting with the BBT gang. They needed something, or someone big to finish the show, and apparently, in real life, she is a BBT fan, so it wasn’t apparently that hard to talk her into it.

rcocean said...

Thanks Nobody. And thanks to Glenn for using my quote.

Lewis Wetzel said...

You should insert neutral language for loaded language. "colonized" == "made use of."
So the leading quote to this post becomes:
"There is one form of power that has fascinated me ever since I was a girl, even though it has been widely made use of by men: the power of storytelling."
Isn't that better? It's more accurate and hasn't made use of words to push an ideological agenda. You can start a discussion or end it. "colonized" ends it.

RobinGoodfellow said...

Blogger madAsHell said...
Never heard of her.

Time magazine called Ferrante one of the 100 most influential people in 2016.


Time magazine is still a thing? Seriously??

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 235 of 235   Newer› Newest»