April 29, 2018

"Like many aspects of Japanese society, rental relatives are often explained with reference to the binary of honne and tatemae, or genuine individual feelings and societal expectations."

"Authenticity and consistency aren’t necessarily valued for their own sake, and the concealment of authentic honne behind conventional tatemae is often construed as an act of unselfishness and sociability, rather than of deception or hypocrisy. A case in point: the man who hired fake parents for his wedding because his real ones were dead eventually told his wife. It went fine. She said that she understood that his goal was not to deceive her but to avoid trouble at their wedding. She even thanked him for being so considerate.... In a sense, the idea of a rental partner, parent, or child is perhaps less strange than the idea that childcare and housework should be seen as the manifestations of an unpurchasable romantic love.... I’d started off assuming that the rental schema somehow undercut the idea of unconditional love. Now I found myself wondering whether it was even possible to get unconditional love without paying... A person can do things professionally—for a set time, in exchange for money and recognition—that she can’t do indefinitely for free... I had read about a host-club worker who studied romance novels in order to be able to anticipate and fulfill his clients’ every need, and consequently had no time left for a personal life. 'Women’s ideal romance entails hard work,' he said, 'and that is nearly impossible in the real world.' He said he could never have worked so hard for a real girlfriend."

From "Japan’s Rent-a-Family Industry/People who are short on relatives can hire a husband, a mother, a grandson. The resulting relationships can be more real than you’d expect" by Elif Batuman (The New Yorker).

13 comments:

Achilles said...

A demographic train wreck in progress.

China is going to make this look pretty in a decade or so.

The Cracker Emcee Refulgent said...

Hardly a new thing in Japanese society. Adoptions-of-convenience have a long and storied history even at the highest levels of society in Japan.

Ann Althouse said...

Note the parts of the post that are not limited to Japan: "In a sense, the idea of a rental partner, parent, or child is perhaps less strange than the idea that childcare and housework should be seen as the manifestations of an unpurchasable romantic love.... I’d started off assuming that the rental schema somehow undercut the idea of unconditional love. Now I found myself wondering whether it was even possible to get unconditional love without paying... "

YoungHegelian said...

Let me start out by saying I've never been to Japan, much less lived there for a long time & go to know the people.

But, I've read quite a bit of Japanese history & cultural history, and let's just say the Japanese are different. It is an island & they have a society with a ethnic homogeneity pretty much unknown anywhere else on the planet.

Japan isn't like Britain (another island), which existed in a continuous state of cultural traffic with the mainland since at least Roman times. For example, when Christianity came to Britain, it started a two way cultural traffic that never ceased since day one. When Buddhism came from China to Japan, it was as seeds that fell on native soil & sprouted as its own variant, quickly going its own way from its Chinese source.

Aspects such as described here aren't just strange to Americans. They're strange to Koreans (another unique people) & the Chinese, too, cultures are much closer in space & shared culture than we as Americans are.

Japan is a very strange place, a place whose history shows that even in cultures of incredible ethnic homogeneity, human beings work yet all the harder to discover reasons to justify their incredible cruelty to each other.

langford peel said...

They should import that idea to the United States so you horrible feminists can have a husband and a family. You just have to pay for it.

Because people like that Michelee Wolf have a better chance of getting killed by a terrorist than getting married.

wild chicken said...

Who says they aren't creative.

rhhardin said...

Wedding Date (2005)

rcocean said...

Whenever you read your daily 'Aren't those Japanese so weird' article in the New York/Washington Press, do you ever feel like you're being manipulated?

I mean the Nips are People of Color. And therefore, to criticize is "racist". But not with the Japanese. I wonder why.

Others just accept.

rcocean said...

And no Japan is NOT a demographic "Train Wreck"

They have 120 million in a country the size of California.

They have more than enough people. They have a temporary age imbalance which will right itself in 30 years.

Paco Wové said...

"'Women’s ideal romance entails hard work,' he said, 'and that is nearly impossible in the real world.' He said he could never have worked so hard for a real girlfriend.""

So it's not just those spoiled American bitches, then. Dang.

n.n said...

They have rent-a-relative. We have rent-a-womb for forward thinking women and unions with two fathers. Two mothers and other modern families pick-up their deposits at the bank.

walter said...

Need more bots

dbp said...

I thought of Althouse when I read the piece last week. It is a long article but I recommend reading the whole thing: It is funny,

"As an experiment, he asked younger women what they would think of a man who cried. All of them said that they would think he was sensitive and kind—provided that he was also good-looking."

And at times very moving, as when the actor plays a father for a girl who is becoming withdrawn.