Wow, he looks old. I remember reading about him in Seventeen magazine when he was a one man band. He was written up as an up and coming new artist to watch.
Saw him at the Tacoma Dome around 1986 or 87. Did a bunch of new material with lyrics that were wholly unintelligible, though it might have been the acoustics. Seemed totally indifferent to the fact that he had an audience.
Dylan's vocals remain too buried for the majority of the show. The instruments and backing vocals are not well mixed, and one thing or another is always too loud. Also, the ultimate purpose of these tapes require them to be taken from pre-effects outputs. This means that the vocals sound dry and mid-range. Mid-range is usually an unpleasant frequency to the human ear, and this tape is no exception. As there are no other CD releases of this show, it is a milestone release. However, because of the raw sound, not everyone will care for it. It is an incredible piece of memorabilia of music history, but not necessarily an enjoyable listen at all times. Of course, there are many exceptions.
Here's the sales pitch from a review of the CDs made from and for that concert.
Oh, you can get the set lists of past concerts at the Bob Dylan site. So the set list for yesterday's Missoula concert was:
Leopard-Skin Pill-Box Hat Love Minus Zero, No Limit Things Have Changed Tangled Up In Blue Tweedle Dee & Tweedle Dum Visions Of Johanna Summer Days Spirit On The Water Honest With Me John Brown Highway 61 Revisited Simple Twist Of Fate Thunder On The Mountain Ballad Of A Thin Man Like A Rolling Stone All Along The Watchtower Blowin' In The Wind
Leopard-Skin Pill-Box Hat Love Minus Zero, No Limit Things Have Changed Tangled Up In Blue Tweedle Dee & Tweedle Dum Visions Of Johanna Summer Days Spirit On The Water Honest With Me John Brown Highway 61 Revisited Simple Twist Of Fate Thunder On The Mountain Ballad Of A Thin Man Like A Rolling Stone All Along The Watchtower Blowin' In The Wind
I saw him last year at a casino in Oklahoma. Terrible venue -- sound was not good, but I enjoyed it anyway. His band is terrific and I didn't expect to understand the words, anyway.
There's no accounting for taste. Colbert had Pete Seeger on his show, he passed sad and is now pitiful. Zimmerman is on the cusp from sad to pitiful. You got to know when to hang up the guitar.
There were quite a few younger people there, but the average age was perhaps 50. Of course, I'm much older than that. I mean, I'm younger than that now.
So how did he sound? So many of the singers we all listened to in the '60s (the ones still around, that is) sound terrible today. Paul McC and Bruce Springsteen come to mind, but they're hardly alone. A big part of the problem is that the keep singing the same stuff even though it doesn' fit their voice (what's left of it), and apart from the nostalgia value, the old stuff sounds ridiculous when sung by a superannuated geezer.
Even in music, the adage 'grow or die' applies. No standing still, no going back, no use pretending. Perhaps Dylan could set that to music -- I'd go to Missoula (even Madison) to hear it if he did.
It's neat that the set started with IIRC one of Althouse's favorite Dylan songs.
"So many of the singers we all listened to in the '60s (the ones still around, that is) sound terrible today."
With Dylan, how could you tell?
Heh. But seriously, the (let's say "homely") eccentricity of Dylan's voice is an advantage for that reason. What would it mean to say someone like Dylan has "lost his voice"? Dylan's voice has metamorphosed throughout his career.
A big part of the problem is that the[y] keep singing the same stuff even though it doesn' fit their voice (what's left of it), and apart from the nostalgia value, the old stuff sounds ridiculous when sung by a superannuated geezer.
One of the interesting things about listening to Dylan's live albums is that the old songs never stay the "same"-- the musical arrangements change, the tempo and tone and feeling and rendition of lyrics are reconceived. The old songs reprised become something new-- a different interpretation, in accordance with wherever/whenever Dylan might be in his life.
I imagine that must be a big part of the fun of seeing Dylan in concert-- listening to something intimately familiar, transformed. The simultaneous pleasures of recognition and surprise.
I was at the Missoula concert Tuesday night and it was incredible. Have seen him perform a few other times and this was by far the best. His voice was strong and he looked like he was having a great time up there on stage. Everyone was there to have a great time and they did. Bob's fans are the best.
I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
Encourage Althouse by making a donation:
Make a 1-time donation or set up a monthly donation of any amount you choose:
46 comments:
Ok it wasn't the mountains and the hiking was it?
Wow, he looks old. I remember reading about him in Seventeen magazine when he was a one man band. He was written up as an up and coming new artist to watch.
Oh so now we know why. For shame.
Aw, cool! Love him.
Never been to a Dylan concert, don't know if I'll have a chance too... may be worth making a road trip to e.g. Missoula for it.
I'd love to know what songs he did.
Looks like you caught him in a good mood. When he's on form he's excellent and amazingly vital for a gentleman of his years
Saw him at the Tacoma Dome around 1986 or 87. Did a bunch of new material with lyrics that were wholly unintelligible, though it might have been the acoustics. Seemed totally indifferent to the fact that he had an audience.
Dylan's vocals remain too buried for the majority of the show. The instruments and backing vocals are not well mixed, and one thing or another is always too loud. Also, the ultimate purpose of these tapes require them to be taken from pre-effects outputs. This means that the vocals sound dry and mid-range. Mid-range is usually an unpleasant frequency to the human ear, and this tape is no exception. As there are no other CD releases of this show, it is a milestone release. However, because of the raw sound, not everyone will care for it. It is an incredible piece of memorabilia of music history, but not necessarily an enjoyable listen at all times. Of course, there are many exceptions.
Here's the sales pitch from a review of the CDs made from and for that concert.
So how was the show? I'm waiting for tickets to go on sale for the Dylan/Knopfler show in DC in November.
Oh, I thought you chose Missoula for Big Sky Brewery. I love their Moose Drool brown ale. ;-)
He's gonna be in Cincinnati in a couple weeks. You could've let the venerable Meade come home!
Althouse, did you catch the Pawn Stars episode with a guest appearance by Dylan? He's a good sport.
That's a great hat!
Dylan's coming to my little town on 8/21/12.
Hope he's still in a good mood.
We only have a Little Sky, seems to be about 1/3rd the size of Missoula's.
I blame the Democrats, naturally.
I don't get the concert genre at all.
It all seems like the other eleven tracks on the CD where the band is noodling around.
Oh, you can get the set lists of past concerts at the Bob Dylan site. So the set list for yesterday's Missoula concert was:
Leopard-Skin Pill-Box Hat
Love Minus Zero, No Limit
Things Have Changed
Tangled Up In Blue
Tweedle Dee & Tweedle Dum
Visions Of Johanna
Summer Days
Spirit On The Water
Honest With Me
John Brown
Highway 61 Revisited
Simple Twist Of Fate
Thunder On The Mountain
Ballad Of A Thin Man
Like A Rolling Stone
All Along The Watchtower
Blowin' In The Wind
yashu said...
I'd love to know what songs he did.
I wasn't there, but the set lists are on his site.
Leopard-Skin Pill-Box Hat
Love Minus Zero, No Limit
Things Have Changed
Tangled Up In Blue
Tweedle Dee & Tweedle Dum
Visions Of Johanna
Summer Days
Spirit On The Water
Honest With Me
John Brown
Highway 61 Revisited
Simple Twist Of Fate
Thunder On The Mountain
Ballad Of A Thin Man
Like A Rolling Stone
All Along The Watchtower
Blowin' In The Wind
Oops, you beat me to it! LOL
(Thanks anyway, LoafingOaf!)
I also started posting the setlist from Dylan's webpage and then thought "Hmm...better scroll down and see if anyone else did so already"
Looking forward to seeing him in Nov
And here I thought you had decided to go from one smugly liberal college town to another. :-)
Some months back, Dylan appeared at a small venue in Sattler, Texas, which is outside New Braunfels, which is outside San Antonio. I loved it.
I don't really follow Dylan, but I was wondering if he's still using the same band as what recorded the Modern Times album. I love that sound.
I saw him last year at a casino in Oklahoma. Terrible venue -- sound was not good, but I enjoyed it anyway. His band is terrific and I didn't expect to understand the words, anyway.
I thought Thurston Howell was dead.
I don't really follow Dylan...
Makes me think of "When you say Dylan, he thinks you're talking about Dylan Thomas, whoever he was. Man ain't got no culture."
It seems like he plays here every year now.
Isn't anyone getting tired of these greybeard boomer bands?
Love the Simon and Garfunkel quote Bob
There's no accounting for taste. Colbert had Pete Seeger on his show, he passed sad and is now pitiful. Zimmerman is on the cusp from sad to pitiful. You got to know when to hang up the guitar.
TosaGuy, LOL!!
There were quite a few younger people there, but the average age was perhaps 50. Of course, I'm much older than that. I mean, I'm younger than that now.
@TosaGuy: Are you suggesting that Bob Dylan is a 1% er?
Why to choose Missoula as a destination:
1) Double Front
Seeing Dylan in concert reminds me of my Senatorial Choices.
Looks like you scored great seats!
That's a fake Oscar on top of the keyboard.
Was that jacket fashionable in any decade?
So how did he sound? So many of the singers we all listened to in the '60s (the ones still around, that is) sound terrible today. Paul McC and Bruce Springsteen come to mind, but they're hardly alone. A big part of the problem is that the keep singing the same stuff even though it doesn' fit their voice (what's left of it), and apart from the nostalgia value, the old stuff sounds ridiculous when sung by a superannuated geezer.
Even in music, the adage 'grow or die' applies. No standing still, no going back, no use pretending. Perhaps Dylan could set that to music -- I'd go to Missoula (even Madison) to hear it if he did.
MArk Knopfler was a much better concert. And I could understand all the words.
BFD.
Bob effin' Dylan?)
So many of the singers we all listened to in the '60s (the ones still around, that is) sound terrible today.
With Dylan, how could you tell?
It's neat that the set started with IIRC one of Althouse's favorite Dylan songs.
"So many of the singers we all listened to in the '60s (the ones still around, that is) sound terrible today."
With Dylan, how could you tell?
Heh. But seriously, the (let's say "homely") eccentricity of Dylan's voice is an advantage for that reason. What would it mean to say someone like Dylan has "lost his voice"? Dylan's voice has metamorphosed throughout his career.
A big part of the problem is that the[y] keep singing the same stuff even though it doesn' fit their voice (what's left of it), and apart from the nostalgia value, the old stuff sounds ridiculous when sung by a superannuated geezer.
One of the interesting things about listening to Dylan's live albums is that the old songs never stay the "same"-- the musical arrangements change, the tempo and tone and feeling and rendition of lyrics are reconceived. The old songs reprised become something new-- a different interpretation, in accordance with wherever/whenever Dylan might be in his life.
I imagine that must be a big part of the fun of seeing Dylan in concert-- listening to something intimately familiar, transformed. The simultaneous pleasures of recognition and surprise.
"Bob Dylan at the Big Sky Brewery in Missoula."...And now you know why Althouse and Meade chose Missoula as a destination.
Should've waited--I understand he'll be opening for Cat Stevens at the Elks Club in Podunk next month.
@ wyo sis 1:12 am
The picture had him wearing hius harmonica. Wasn't it taken in Washington Square?
And he was smooth skinned and had that mop of curly hair.
Ah. That was back when Barbra Streisand shopped at thrift stores and wore cool vintage clothing. That really was vintage.
Same issue?
Wow. Professor, how close were you?
Bob is great. Wished I was there but I still haven't won the lottery.
Yet.
I was at the Missoula concert Tuesday night and it was incredible. Have seen him perform a few other times and this was by far the best. His voice was strong and he looked like he was having a great time up there on stage. Everyone was there to have a great time and they did. Bob's fans are the best.
Once upon a time you dressed so fine.
Threw the bums a dime in your prime, didn't you?
Post a Comment