March 28, 2022

Chris Rock — punched by Will Smith for a joke about Jada Pinkett Smith's hair — once made a documentary about black people and their hair.

Here's the trailer for "Good Hair": 

 

Here's Rock making the joke, Will chuckling, and Jada not amused, and then Will striding onto the stage and hitting/"hitting" Rock:

 

At 0:42, I felt sure what I'd seen was a fake "Hollywood" punch. Rock stood planted in position and even leaned his face forward, then — it seemed — threw his head back after the seeming contact. 

And Rock recovered so quickly, still smiling, and chattered out "Will Smith just smacked the shit out of me." But if it was scripted, would he have said "shit"? I haven't been watching the Oscars in recent years, but back in the days when I used to care enough to live-blog the hours-long show, I had the tag "fleeting expletives" to keep track of the litigation that arose after Cher's saying "fuck" at the 2002 Billboard awards activated the FCC. Who can even remember what the Supreme Court ultimately did about that threat to free speech? 

But when Will Smith got back to his seat and proceeded to yell "Keep my wife's name out ya fucking mouth! Keep my wife's name out ya fucking mouth!" it was hard to believe it was scripted. But, as I said, I don't know where we are with fleeting expletives these days, and maybe we are right where it would be scripted precisely because it would create the illusion that it was unscripted. 

Then Smith wins the best actor Oscar, and we get to listen to his speech, which give us another chance to assess the real-or-fakeness of the punch/"punch"/slap/"slap":

But if he's such a great actor — do we really still believe the stars who get the statuette are "great actors"? — he should be able to sell a scripted acceptance speech with faux-sincere lines about his being a "river of love" or some such nonsense and to cry seemingly real tears of apology.

What makes me think it was real is that it makes Smith look bad. He looked ugly yelling "Keep my wife's name out ya fucking mouth!" And he overshadowed his own winning of the Oscar. Why would anyone do that? The best explanation is that he lost his temper. But exactly why did he lose his temper? I think we'd need to know more about his relationship with his wife. Remember he was laughing at the joke, and she was looking grim. The camera wasn't on them continuously, but I imagine she said something to him or gave him a look that meant you'd better act now or you are not a man. 

Finally, it's sad that the Smiths aren't proud of Jada's hair. She boldly shaves it down to almost nothing and that's a way of expressing great confidence in one's own beauty. I'm seeing some articles talking about her alopecia, but if you go to that link, you'll see she has a thin line of baldness across the top, and it's something that would be hidden if she didn't shave her head. She's highlighting the beauty of her face and the elegant structure of her head. She's not like those women in Chris Rock's movie who spend so much time at the hairdressers, use harsh chemicals, and cause so much importation of human hair from India

Jada Pinkett Smith could have had any wig she wanted. To go to the Oscars with a shaved head is to make a strong statement that you think this is your best look. Chris Rock said she could play in a sequel to "G.I. Jane," which means she could play Demi Moore's iconic role. Demi Moore is famously beautiful. 

The best response to the joke would have been an imperious smile that meant: Yes, I know I am beautiful. Not: My husband will now punch you in the nose!

134 comments:

TRISTRAM said...

Another comment I saw related to locker roonm beefs in the NBA they were about bettings debts or womenm wiht the comment, 'What is the chance that Will isn't the fisrt Smith toe 'hit' Rock?'

Beasts of England said...

That’s what happens when you grow up in west Philadelphia…

wendybar said...

id say will smith hits like a woman but Im not a biologist, so - lance_manyon (diskus commenter)

tim in vermont said...

“The Moving laser pointer shines; and, having shone, Moves on.”

Mr Wibble said...

We don't know ow what goes on in her head, and whether or not the hair loss is a parti ularly sensitive subject. Personally, I'm not getting worked up over the whole incident. Rock apparently crossed a line, something which happens when you're a comic with material that insult members of your audience. Will Smith delivered a slap as a means of indicating that rock had crossed a line. End of controversy. I doubt that the two of them will even care about it a week from now.

mezzrow said...

It's getting a bit shaky in Tinseltown. I can't even be bothered to watch the punch.

The hegemony of America's soft culture faces its greatest threat. Like the rest of America, it faces a crisis of confidence and purpose.

Smith is still looking for his neuralyzer. He knows how badly he screwed up, like a 15-year old kid who got mad and shot somebody.

Wilbur said...

What nonsense. But these people are all dead to me anyway.

This story led our ABC affiliate local news show this AM. This informed me: A. The Oscar show was on ABC last night, B. What our affiliate thinks constitutes news, and C. There still apparently are people who care about this mess.

I have a higher regard for people who watch professional wrestling than the Oscars. Much higher.

R C Belaire said...

Sub-headline from the UK Guardian : "Oscars 2022: a historic night for women – overshadowed by male violence." Guys ruin everything!

Wilbur said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Dave Begley said...

I watched some of the show and it only reinforced my opinion that our culture is in deep trouble. Coppola, Pacino and DeNiro were on in order to honor 50 years of The Godfather. Nothing remotely close to The Godfather these days. Our newspapers have gone to shit. Other than country, popular music is horrible. When was the last time you watched something on TV?

The big issue now is trans and we are in a culture war because of CRT.

Who are the big Hollywood stars? Who has written a great original script? The last one was “Ford v Ferrari.”

Will Smith? Who cares? It was staged.

Our culture feels both exhausted and failing.

Mike Sylwester said...

Will Smith talked way too long in his acceptance speech.

wendybar said...

Will Smith SHOULD have been arrested on the spot for assault. Any regular person would have been, so what makes him so special??

Dan from Madison said...

how odd. Why didn't he punch him? I'm guessing staged since security didn't to anything.

Kevin said...

What if Will Smith were white?

wendybar said...

Penny Madashell 🤖
@rukiddingmelolz
So Kanye is banned from the Grammys for calling Trevor Noah names on social media, but Will Smith can physically assault someone on the Oscars stage & people are consoling him?

Someone explain this to me, I’m dumb lol
11:32 PM · Mar 27, 2022·

Lloyd W. Robertson said...

Did Rock come close to saying: Jada, I fancy you, it's probably that GI Jane look? This blog is getting confusing.

tim maguire said...

Absolutely nothing about that punch looked real. I can't comment about the expletives after, but I'll need to see a close-up from another angle to accept the punch was real.

mezzrow said...

"CODA is inarguably the greatest crime of the 21st century so far. If I had a gun with two bullets and walked into a room to find Vladimir Putin, Kim Jong-Un, and the studio exec who green lit CODA, I would shoot the studio executive twice. Though I was appalled by Will Smith’s shocking act of violence that marred the Oscars broadcast, my reaction would have been entirely different if Smith had lined up everyone involved with CODA and given them all one, big Three Stooges-style line slap." - Ethan Coen

https://imightbewrong.substack.com/p/guest-column-ive-farted-better-movies?s=r

Thank me later. Go read. It gets better.

Quaestor said...

Althouse writes, "But if it was scripted, would [Chris Rock] have said "shit"?

What?

Dave Begley said...

I have yet to see a still picture of Smith’s hand making contact on Rock’s face.

Only “West Side Story” and “Wild Mountain Thyme” are as good as my “Frankenstein, Part II.” That’s what motivates me.

Kevin said...

The talk about Will and Jada has been about her infidelity and how this has emasculated him.

Is this an attempt to shift the narrative and reclaim his stature as a man in the larger community?

MayBee said...

If you hit someone that easily, you've hit before.
I thought the same thing about Juwan Howard, U of M's basketball coach. It wouldn't be my instinct to reach out and hit someone who made me mad. Nor my husbands' or sons'. Sometime people show themselves to be hitters. Who else has he hit?

Heartless Aztec said...

Scripted or of the moment, neither makes the Oscars more appealing to my Boomer age cohort. Stick a fork it it. It's all wayyyyy overdone.

Heartless Aztec said...

Scripted or of the moment, neither makes the Oscars more appealing to my Boomer age cohort. Stick a fork it it. It's all wayyyyy overdone.

Jake said...

I guess I can understand why Miami has to shut down during spring break. Men always gotta show how big their ducks are to impress girls.

Masscon said...

The Will and Jada Smith roast is gonna be lit!

Leland said...

I guess he was acting in King Richard when he just took the punches, while becoming a better man.

Iman said...

That was a six out of 10 bitchslap on the bitchometer.

exhelodrvr1 said...

"The camera wasn't on them continuously, but I imagine she said something to him or gave him a look that meant you'd better act now or you are not a man. "

I doubt that - she's not a biologist.

Iman said...

Rickles! Where are you when we need you!?!?

Shoeless Joe said...

I really thought Will Smith was one of the good guys. But right now I wouldn't be at all surprised if it is someday revealed that he has a history of engaging in domestic abuse. A grown man who's that quick to violence over nothing would likely not think twice about slapping his family around. Love can make you do crazy things, but so can being a self entitled asshole.

Iman said...

And here I was wondering why Smith was out with Alopecia Pressley…

rastajenk said...

We watched only the opening comments from Amy Schumer, which was a decent start, and the first award to Best Supporting Actress. When there was a shot of the Smiths, I said, "She looks like an alien being."

And why are there still categories by gender? Shouldn't we be past that? Maybe there should be Best Supporting Person in a Comedy, Best Supporting Person in a Drama, etc. That way a trans actor portraying a woman could win something without being accused of taking something that might have gone to a real woman. Wins all around! Exponential Wokeness!

Temujin said...

Jada Pinkett Smith is beautiful. She's beautiful with a bald head. She would look beautiful with the buffalo head worn by the shaman on January 6. Two things probably going on here. I'm guessing because I did not watch a minute of it. Just a clip of the slap. I have not even listened to Smith's acceptance speech, which I do not care about.

If you're a highly competitive person, which Wil Smith is, clearly (based on his growth as an actor), and you're sitting there all night at the biggest award show in your industry, waiting...waiting...for the end part of the show when they finally get around to your award, there's a certain level of hyper-nervousness going on inside of you. Add in that we don't know how Ms. Smith has been dealing with her alopecia. Maybe it's been a source of difficulty for her, and hence, for them.

Those two things going on and Chris Rock, who previously annoyed Ms. Smith (and we don't know, but there could be other history there) makes his comment. Wil Smith was in no mood to hear it. Maybe Jada cringed or maybe she fought off reacting- I don't know. But it's probably something that hit her/them deeply. Obviously. Wil reacted.

For what it's worth, I have a random sampling of women...or woman- my wife. She watched the clip of the slap with me and she said, "Good for him.", meaning good for Wil Smith. Which means that the next time some guy makes a crack about my wife's tennis serve, I've got to stand up and slap him just to keep up with the Smiths.

Temujin said...

Dave Begley at 6:09 stated it all perfectly.

James K said...

Whether staged or not, it was a publicity stunt. As is the entire Oscars show.

Lem the artificially intelligent said...

Will Smith talked way too long in his acceptance speech.

That’s what convinced me that it was real. He was mad at himself for not keeping it together. The way he kept it together at his wife’s show “the table”? The way Mike Tyson kept it together in the Barbara Walter’s interview with him and his wife.

If it was real, this is Hollywood after all, the pre-slap moment spoke to a confident Chris Rock that the last thing Chris Rock expected from Will Smith was a violent reaction. So Althouse’s point about Chris Rock seemingly leaning in is not that strong with me. Up to that point Will Smith had behaved like a paragon of virtue/bitch in way more distressing situations that his wife and son had put him through. Last night Will Smith seemed possessed.

tim in vermont said...

Didn't he have a show "Everybody Hates Chris"?

RNB said...

No big deal. Nothing new. Who doesn't remember that time John Wayne got up and punched out Bob Hope for making fun of The Duke's wife's decolletage?

Lem the artificially intelligent said...

This is a great post btw.

gspencer said...

Staged on a stage.

michaele said...

What if it was The Rock who made the mild tease as opposed to Chris Rock? I'll bet Will Smith would've stayed in his seat and kept smiling. Will Smith acted like a bully since he is bigger and stronger than Chris Rock.

Lem the artificially intelligent said...

Wait a minute. I just remembered something relevant to the side that says it was fake.

👉🏽 https://youtu.be/01AzChhAmYc

I now have it at 60-40 that it was real.

John henry said...

Did anyone win anything last night? Or did everyone just go home after this?

I haven't seen a thing about any actual awards so far today. I wouldn't even know the Oscar's happened if not for the assault. I am assuming staged, but don't care enough to look at the clip.

John LGBTQBNY Henry

Birches said...

Thank you Althouse. I had no idea this happened until now.

I think you're right, it was real. And it was Jada who made it happen.

Chris Rock is a freaking legend! I've always loved him (and known about the doc), but now? Champion status. He can freaking take a punch!

John henry said...

I think power of the dog was up for something. I watched about 20 minutes and it didn't look like it was going to get better so I bailed.

Big, stupid, controversy about being filmed in New Zealand. Looked like I would have expected a generic Montana cow town to have looked in 1925.

John LGBTQBNY Henry

Ann Althouse said...

"Did Rock come close to saying: Jada, I fancy you, it's probably that GI Jane look? This blog is getting confusing."

I know! Good point. GI Jane came up twice over the weekend. You're referring to the post about what Piers Morgan said to Sinead O'Connor. Strange!

Temujin said...

Ganders will be ganders.

Birches said...

"Everybody Hates Chris" is a great show by the way.

I hope Rock made some "Pootie Tang" jokes at his own expense.

Iman said...

A perfect moment for a tribute to “Chinatown” and the scene where Jack Nicholson keeps slapping Faye Dunaway’s face one side to the other, as she says of her daughter, “she’s my sister”, then “she’s my mother”, then, “she’s my aunt”, etc.

NYC JournoList said...

If the hit was real then now way Chris Rock says “wow.”. The only question is whether Rock was in on it. I think he was, but that’s a guess. Remember, “Ali” Smith is a practiced pro at throwing fake punches.

rehajm said...

I was resisting a comment here but I watched the video and it appears the honorees, their hangers on and the entire audience could fit in the square footage of what used to be the stage. I could be wrong but don't wake me from the warm feeling its a sign civilization could be turning in the right direction...

Comedy has been under attack from the PC crowd for years. Rock and Jerry and the rest will lament some more...

Their typical Hollywood relationship issues aside Will and Jada were some I liked to watch in part because at times they possessed a bit of grace. That brand is sure out the window...

If there's any left, and I'm sure there are, the racist old Hollywood types must be I told ya so'ing in their heads this morning...

I'm rooting for a bit of follicle equity. Infinite empathy and support for every choice from women, infinite disdain and mocking for every choice for men. In today's world that's punching down. Fuck you all there...

RoseAnne said...

Will Smith won an award for a movie about the father of two of the greatest tennis players of all time. Not about the tennis players but their father. Now both were executive producers and presumably love their father, but I just find it interesting it all being about the man's reaction rather than about the woman herself.

tim in vermont said...

Men get over this stuff without calling cops or lawyers.

MadisonMan said...

This all falls under the Hollywood penumbra of "There's no such thing as bad publicity"

But I didn't see it, and I don't really want to read about the incredibly privileged of Hollywood having a little dust-up, scripted or not. I don't think Hollywood cares about me, either, though.

Lem the artificially intelligent said...

What does it say about race relations, something Hollywood has been keen on for awhile now, that the last thing Will Smith was worried about was his role model stature? That’s why I think he was crying because, even though he tried mightily, he couldn’t reconcile his violent action earlier with the Williams sisters father, he just won an Oscar for portraying.

Rusty said...

Althouse writes, "But if it was scripted, would [Chris Rock] have said "shit"?
Yes.
If it wasn't scripted would he have said, "shit"?
No.
He would have said, "Fuck you, motherfucker."

Birches said...

Alright, I just watched the acceptance speech. His wife was a complete afterthought in the speech which is weird, right? He mentions his mom and not coming because of issues, which is also weird.

I think he thought, "what would Richard Williams do?" after he realized Jada was upset. And then did it. The gossip has been for years that the two are estranged from each other. Perhaps it was his idea of a grand gesture. I have no idea. It all could be fake. Jada's loving reaction during the speech was definitely fake.

Václav Patrik Šulik said...

Good for Will Smith. I like a man who will stand up for his wife and family. To hell with the gender studies majors and their toxic masculinity bullshit.

Rollo said...

For a long time, the rumor has been that Will and/or Jada and/or the kids are gay. Just another rumor to be sure, but I wonder if that's a subtext.

wildswan said...

Maybe this happened because the joke was a little bit obscure? What part of GI Joe 2 applies to which woman sitting near Will Smith? Now they're saying that the whole sorry mess is all about Chris being insensitive and surprising people because Chris was chosen for being a sensitive, considerate guy which is his trademark. Actually, he was chosen for telling good jokes well and this joke wasn't very good and was not well done. Just hearing it as it was said - would you think that Chris Rock was comparing a military buzz cut to the lack-of-hair style of the second woman on the left? That left an opening for Mr. Smith to decide that Chris (Jada, I love you) Rock might be implying or people might think. SLAP. And the Academy Awards slip further down hill.

Mr. Forward said...

If I ever watch the Oscars, slap me!

Wince said...

Remember the Sinatra Group?

With Jan Hooks as Sinead and Chris Rock as Luther Campbell.

"Issue #3: What's with the bald chick, what's with her head?"

Go back to the beginning to see the the full Phil Hartman Sinatra.

Achilles said...

The look on Jada's face was not scripted. She was not laughing.

Will was laughing at the joke when it happened.

I missed the part where Will looked at his wife though. I would like to see that.

Lem the artificially intelligent said...

“He would have said, "Fuck you, motherfucker."”

Chris Rock did say something that I’m still trying to figure out… he murmur something to himself, shortly after the back and forth with Will Smith.

Btw. Am I correct in assuming years ago they would have cut to a commercial soon after the purported slap?

There’s so much material to analyse here about the current moráis.

But I have to go and make some money 😩

Lurker21 said...

The smaller, more intimate Oscars (i.e. the fact that nobody was actually there) made this possible.

In the old days, Will might have found it harder to get out of his seat and up on stage quick enough.

Will Smith won an award for a movie about the father of two of the greatest tennis players of all time. Not about the tennis players but their father.

That is strange, especially in today's world. It wouldn't be so strange if Hollywood had made a point in the past of making movies about the mothers of famous men and women. Yes, Venus and Serena wanted the picture to be made, but it is a little telling that so few other celebrities have produced pictures about their parents. Or maybe they have, but just use other names for the characters, not thinking themselves important enough to have biopics about family members.

Anyway, staged or not, the incident makes for a great distraction from Biden's gaffes and Hunter's scandals.

Lem the artificially intelligent said...

“I think he thought, "what would Richard Williams do?" after he realized Jada was upset.”

I haven’t seen the movie… that’s why I had an alternate interpretation of the crying.

Jim said...

I’m assuming this was a real heartfelt reaction.

I’m no biologist, but Will Smith is a man.

madAsHell said...

I played HS football on a sand lot. No grass, just fine gravel, and sand.

Take a handful of that, and dump it on the black guys hair. They would work for days to get that fine gravel out of their hair.

I think this was the genesis of "Lather, rinse, repeat."

Dave Begley said...

I read that something like two-thirds of movies' box office (excluding streaming) comes from foreign countries, mostly China. That's why we have so many worthless comic book movies today. I don't think the Chinese would get "The Godfather" or "Shawshank Redemption" or "West Side Story" et alia.

madAsHell said...

This is why "Black Lives Matter" is so hard to reconcile in light of what I see in the street.....and stage.

I'm wondering how this fits in with the Critical Race Theory narrative. Which man is the racist??

BarrySanders20 said...

More Context

zipity said...


Ah the Oscars. The annual ritual where Hollywood royalty give each other awards for movies nobody liked and nearly no one saw....

JK Brown said...

I see it as an example of Thomas Sowell's 'Black Rednecks" and the "White Liberals" looked on. That's not to insult, but Sowell's premise is that what is now called black culture is the southern blacks having adopted the redneck culture of the whites, which is traceable all the way back to where those white's ancestors emigrated from in Britain. Quick to anger over personal insults, and often self-destroying violence out of insults to honor.

"Whether black redneck values and lifestyle are a lineal descendant of white redneck values and lifestyle, as suggested here, or a social phenomenon arising independently within the black community and only coincidentally similar, it is still a way of life that has been tested before and found wanting, as shown by its erosion over the generations among whites who experienced its counterproductive consequences. By making black redneck behavior a sacrosanct part of black cultural identity, white liberals and others who excuse, celebrate, or otherwise perpetuate that lifestyle not only preserve it among that fraction of the black population which has not yet escaped from it, but have contributed to its spread up the social scale to middle class black young people who feel a need to be true to their racial identity, lest they be thought to be “acting white.” It is the spread of a social poison, however much either black or white intellectuals try to pretty it up or try to find some deeper meaning in it."

–Sowell, Thomas. Black Rednecks & White Liberals (p. 64).

Amadeus 48 said...

Denzel Washington reportedly said to him that at your highest moment is when the devil comes for you.



zipity said...


Ah, the Oscars. The annual ritual where Hollywood royalty give each other awards for movies nobody likes and no one sees....

GRW3 said...

Why did he slap instead of punch. He trained hard to learn true boxing skills to play Muhammed Ali. He can punch with real effect. While it might not phase a professional boxer, he could probably really hurt someone like Chris Rock. He's probably been warned about using boxing skills.

0_0 said...

Smith is also trying to compensate for a certain view of his marriage.

Amexpat said...

I watched the clip and it wasn't a punch, it was a slap. Big difference. A punch can do serious harm. A slap is to make a point without intending physical harm.

It wasn't staged, you could hear the slap clearly. If it were staged Rock would have had a snappier comeback and even though he kept his outward composure and tried to joke about it, you can see he was a bit shaken. He muffed the first line of the presentation afterwards

Lurker21 said...

Will laughed at the joke. Jada glared. Presumably he could see that she was angry and felt he had to do something about it. He did seem furious afterwards, but he knows how to throw a fake punch (or in this case, give a fake slap). Then again, he knows how to fake being angry (and how to fake being amused). It's quite a conundrum, but my guess is that Jada was actually angry and the event wasn't preplanned or faked. Maybe Will doesn't have much experience slapping (outside of the movies maybe) and just isn't that good at it so it looks faker than it is.

Another conundrum: If Chris Rock had made a GI Jane joke 10 or 20 years ago, would Ashton Kutcher or Bruce Willis have slugged or slapped him?

Andrew said...

Chris Rock handled the situation well. But I wish he had snapped, and forgotten about the Oscars, and turned it into a comedy club gig. He should have used all his skills, combined Don Rickles and Richard Pryor, and slaughtered both Will and his bald wife, and their "open marriage." And then mocked every TV show and movie Will has ever been in. Starting with his gay services to Uncle Phil to pay the rent in Bel-Air.

Andrew said...

Chris Rock handled the situation well. But I wish he had snapped, and forgotten about the Oscars, and turned it into a comedy club gig. He should have used all his skills, combined Don Rickles and Richard Pryor, and slaughtered both Will and his bald wife, and their "open marriage." And then mocked every TV show and movie Will has ever been in. Starting with his gay services to Uncle Phil to pay the rent in Bel-Air.

Iman said...

I think Rock had a few jokes immediately spring to his comedian’s mind – given the words Smith chose – but decided against it, lol. “Keep my wife’s _____ out your F-in’ mouth.”

“Oh, I could… okay…”

—- Chris Rock

Lem the artificially intelligent said...

Another question is will Will Smith be cancelled?

Or does black on black on black get a pass?

Iman said...

In other words, Rock decided any additional mining of that comedy gold would be counterproductive, lol.

Breezy said...

Too bad Will didn’t just tell Jada to lighten up. He’s stolen all the post-award vibe from the Oscar winners. If I were one, I’d be upset with him, maybe even slap him.

Joe Smith said...

First, it was a slap (albeit a good one) not a punch.

I was on Rock's side because I thought she had it shaved as a 'look,' not that it was the result of a condition.

But it was still a bit over the top from Smith. He is a much bigger guy.

In Smith's defense, I once wanted to actually kill a man for something he said to my wife.

hawkeyedjb said...

"Keep my wife's name out ya fucking mouth!"
"Will Smith just smacked the shit out of me."

Charming display of our cultural high achievers. Oh well, since they had to give the award to a black guy, they might as well give it to someone who's going to make the evening memorable.

Michael K said...

As my mother-in-law, who was in the business, used to say, "These people are talent " It was not a complement.

Randomizer said...

I think the punch was phony. For a guy in his 50's who isn't used to violence to be roused to throw a punch in public, his adrenaline would be so amped up, it would take an hour or so to settle. Will Smith would be more likely to leave the event than to give an acceptance speech.

Ann, you mentioned that you haven't watched the Oscars in recent years. Nobody has. Would any of us be talking about the Oscars without this drama?

The stunt seems designed to play on stereotypes. Is it plausible that leftist Hollywood might think that this would appeal to the rest of America? NASCAR America likes conflict. Two hugely popular black men, both up from the street, can't leave their thug lives behind. Smith and Rock are both known for having working class roots. People in Hollywood could speculate that we'd view it that way. Or that we'd see it as Will Smith sticking up for his wife, so shares our values.

Will Smith seems like a pretty smart guy. He would know that assaulting Chris Rock on stage could ruin everything. If Smith was legitimately outraged, it's more likely that he'd walk up, give Rock a big shove, loom over him and yell his line at Chris to extract an apology.



Lem the artificially intelligent said...

Here’s another question…

Will Chris Rock be blackballed if he sues a star like Will Smith?

Rock’s last comedy special was not that good. He was doing movies. Career seemed on the ropes and now this happens.

My sympathies are squarely on Chris Rock’s corner.

Rory said...

Grand Openin'...Grand Closin'.

Lem the artificially intelligent said...

One more thing…

Is it racist to obsess over the incident?

I can see that take taking shape right now.

Lem the artificially intelligent said...

Reddit sample …

👉🏽 https://www.reddit.com/r/funny/comments/tqbr0b/we_dont_talk_about_jayda_no_no_noooo/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf

WWIII Joe Biden, Husk-Puppet + America's Putin said...

ultra wealthy bubble dwellers - the psychosis.

WWIII Joe Biden, Husk-Puppet + America's Putin said...

I'm so glad I gave up watching these over-paid assholes hand out golden statures for being overpaid assholes.

WWIII Joe Biden, Husk-Puppet + America's Putin said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Lem the artificially intelligent said...

r/dadjoke doing really well…

What’s on Chris Rock’s Face?

Fresh Prints!

����‍♂️

NorthOfTheOneOhOne said...

If this was a work it was the most desperate bid for attention from Hollywood ever.

Hopefully, it will mean no more comedians hosting the Oscars and the show's run time will drop from 3 hours to about 45 minutes.

JZ said...

Was the slap planned? Did Lee Harvey Oswald act alone? We may never know!

Rusty said...

Two actors. On a stage. Dots. Connect them.

WWIII Joe Biden, Husk-Puppet + America's Putin said...

The Oscar show should force all the attendees and nominees sign a waiver that they won't lose their temper if the host leading the clown show makes a joke about them.

People want to see the host mock these holier than thou "actors"

Rabel said...

"Too bad Will didn’t just tell Jada to lighten up."

If Chris Rock had told Jada Smith to "lighten up" at that particular moment this could have turned into a Golden Corral video.

effinayright said...

I'll always love Chris Rock, if only for this:

"How to Not Get Your Ass Kicked by the Police"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uj0mtxXEGE8

n.n said...

Pomp and piety.

Scotty, beam me up... said...

On first glance, the camera shows Smith was laughing at the GI Jane 2 joke. If you look at Jada at the same time, she is not only not laughing, she looks dismayed at the very least and possibly restrained anger. Moments later, Smith is going onstage, smacks Rock (you can then hear something on Rock’s microphone that sounds like contact and not fake), and Smith walks back to his seat looking angry. At that point, it looks like it was staged. But in my mind, it wasn’t staged after Smith is yelling very angry words with several F-bombs. What he said was picked up clearly on microphones that were a long distance away from Smith, which means he was screaming at Rock. If this was staged, Smith wouldn’t have used those F-bombs and his voice volume would have been lower with Rock still able to hear him but the microphones would not have been able to clearly pick up what was said - and Smith would have been smiling and laughing when he said those words.

Chris Lopes said...

"Two actors. On a stage. Dots. Connect them."

Neither actor (particularly Smith) have any reason to pull such a stunt. I'm willing to bet that a not small percentage of the movie going public has a different view of Smith today than they did 24 hours ago. Since the slap (there's a still of the incident on Instapundit that clearly shows an open hand) came after an insult to Smith's wife, Rock can't credibly claim to be the innocent victim either. So this doesn't help anyone's career.

Leland said...

I'm not buying the "it was staged". Nothing about this makes Will Smith look good, even if it is a good act. Even if you believe he was honorable in standing up this his wife; well then he looks like an idiot that stood up for his cheating wife, which was made clear earlier. I do think he was hyped up on the thought of winning the award for Best Actor. He probably didn't like his "perfect night" be made imperfect, and Rock's joke was just the breaking point.

wendybar said...

Imagine the horror if Sarah Huckabee's husband slapped every comedian who made fun of HIS wife?? THIS is why we are in the place we are....Progressive hate and violence.
https://conservativepost.com/breaking-news-about-sarah-huckabee-sanders-this-is-horrible/

rhhardin said...

Make fun of Mohammad's hair.

Leland said...

At least we know when they said they would have a "gay night", they didn't mean joyous, light-hearted, and carefree.

Lucien said...

If Chris Rock has the good sense not to claim PTSD, file suit, etc., then it may be years before he has to buy a drink; while Smith self-imolates. Taking a shot to the kisser and only standing there saying “Wow” is so masculine that the Woke must think it’s toxic.

Narr said...

Much ado about nothing.

I'm glad I saw the Rock movie trailer--funny.

Apparently a comic can't make a bad joke about somebody's hair (or lack of it) without courting violence. Among certain people.

I watched the slap and honestly I don't think either Mr or Mrs Smith even got the joke--she was pissed off because she's vain, and he had to Be A Man.

An amusing window into lives of the too rich and famous.

WWIII Joe Biden, Husk-Puppet + America's Putin said...

Lesson - the Host must be very careful and overly fawning of the delicate over-paid bubble dwellers in attendance.

WWIII Joe Biden, Husk-Puppet + America's Putin said...

Lesson: ONLY Make fun of conservatives.

Anthony said...

Wait, is that "violence" against a "woman"? Or is just saying mean things "violence"? Is JPS a "woman"? Has anyone checked?

This is all so confusing. . . . .

Lucien said...

Slightly OT, but what was the deal with Regina Hall calling up four (mostly white) men to say they needed to take COVID19 tests in the back room with her & that she’d just have to swab the backs of their throats . . . With her tongue?
What Einstein green-lit that?
Imagine a co-host Louis C.K. doing that with (mostly black) women. Who could possibly complain?

Iman said...

“If Chris Rock had told Jada Smith to "lighten up" at that particular moment this could have turned into a Golden Corral video.”

Agreed… coulda used it to kick-off/highlight the new Golden Corral’s Endless Fountain of Ham.

WWIII Joe Biden, Husk-Puppet + America's Putin said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
MB said...

I didn't see it, but when I read about it, I thought the GI Jane remark was simply there to provide an allusion to the Piers Morgan / Sinead O'Connor Twitter spat. Pinkett Smith was just a means to that end.

WWIII Joe Biden, Husk-Puppet + America's Putin said...

*updated*
I used have neighbor's who lived around the corner who were black. I adored them - they were lovely people and we were friends. Sadly, they moved to Arizona several years ago.
Before they moved away, I was at their home one time, and the Mrs., who had natural hair and she had grown it out a bit - was a bit sensitive and nervous about her hair for some reason, and made it known to me.
The topic of hair caught me off guard. She was truly suffering from some major insecurity about it.

She told me she felt uncomfortable wearing her hair in its natural state. she assumed people would judge her for her natural appearance. I didn't understand why? I mean - I thought she looked great. I told her that she looked great and that she shouldn't let anyone make her feel bad. Nor should she make herself feel bad!
I think I even said something stupid like - 'let your freak flag fly, girl.' (geeez) ( again - I was caught off guard with the topic)

At this stage in life,I care less about hair that ever, personally. Tho I would say that most women have hair-envy. Most women think their hair is insufficiently styled or insufficiently thick and lacking in beauty.


That Chris Rock video - I now understand. Black women feel intense pressure to have what our culture has decided is acceptable hair. Straight.

Thank you Cris Rock. and thank you -Ann.

& (to which*) I say - black women everywhere - let your freak flag fly! go for the fro!

NorthOfTheOneOhOne said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Richard Dolan said...

Other comedians have been far more cutting in their mockery of Hollywood celebs and their 'beautiful people' culture -- Ricky Gervais being a stand-out but there are many others. But this seems another step on the death-march of comedy -- one more thing (the Af-Am hair shtick!) that's now officially off limits, at least at High Hollywood events. And its target this time is a guy who has made his name making jokes about the black community. Will Smith ended by saying he hopes the Academy will invite him back. I think the one in danger of not being invited back is Chris Rock.

rehajm said...

Denzel Washington reportedly said to him that at your highest moment is when the devil comes for you

Contractual obligation they call it...

gahrie said...

I now understand. Black women feel intense pressure to have what our culture has decided is acceptable hair. Straight.

We live in a world in which White people spend billions of dollars every year to darken their skin and curl their hair. We also live in a world in which dark skinned people around the world spend billions of dollars every year to whiten their skin and straighten their hair.

Stoutcat said...

rastajenk said...
"Maybe there should be Best Supporting Person in a Comedy, Best Supporting Person in a Drama, etc. That way a trans actor portraying a woman could win something without being accused of taking something that might have gone to a real woman...

That's so 1980s. The Year of Living Dangerously won Linda Hunt her best actress Oscar for playing a man way back in 1982.

Stoutcat said...

rastajenk said...
"Maybe there should be Best Supporting Person in a Comedy, Best Supporting Person in a Drama, etc. That way a trans actor portraying a woman could win something without being accused of taking something that might have gone to a real woman."

That's so '80s. Linda Hunt won a best actress award in 1982 for playing a man in The Year of Living Dangerously.

Bunkypotatohead said...

You can take Fresh Prince out of the ghetto...

Mea Sententia said...

I didn't stay up late enough to see when the woman got her husband to assault a man on stage, but I was watching earlier when another woman got some men on stage, made sexual comments about them, and fondled their bodies. What a family friendly show!

mikee said...

Absent this moment of misbehavior, would any commentary on the Oscars show be seen today?
No. Without this misbehavior, nobody would discuss the Oscars show today.

The Oscars as a promotion of the movie industry to the public is as dead as a Norwegian Blue Parrot in a Monty Python skit. Now it is just a clickbait generator, and a poor one at that.

Mary Martha said...

The Chris Rock documentary "Good Hair" is really good.

It made me appreciate my black friends hair concerns. As a white woman with curly hair I never really understood the cultural pressure on black women about their hair. It's a serious thing (and a giant waste of money holding women down).

The 'slap' seemed staged, but honestly everything at an event like that seems staged.

Shoeless Joe said...

Would love to see them hire Joe Rogan as host / security for next year's Oscars. It would probably triple their TV ratings, and should any of the celebrities get out of hand Rogan could squash them like bugs.

Win Win in my book.

Ty said...


The original...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kv73yzYuE_M

LA_Bob said...

Lem said, "This is a great post btw."

I agree. I wondered if Althouse would blog about this. I was shocked to see the footage when it showed up on Twitter last night.

Staged of not, this is more of the vulgarization of "popular" culture. The Academy Awards of decades past had an air of elegance. Not anymore and not for quite some time. I wouldn't ever bother watching.

And I certainly won't go out of my way to watch a Will Smith movie. What an ass. Stupid mofo.

The slap is so distinct the production crew almost had to have been in on the joke were it staged. But Rock's composure throughout the incident makes me wonder. I might live long enough to find out. Might not.

We haven't seen the interaction between Smith and his wife before his march to the stage, but I'd bet the footage exists. The camera was probably still recording them as Chris spoke. I'd also bet that footage becomes a bigger secret than what was on Hillary Clinton's server.