I'm struggling to reconcile these pages and the attitude therein with the offense you took at seeing a plastic crucifix lying on the trinket table at St. Vincent de Paul's. So, which is it? Respect religious symbols, or mock them? Wait, maybe we're just supposed to mock people who don't respect their own religious symbols? I'm confused.
I also note that the account of the miracle is much different at the link you provided in the comments than on your pages.
Joan: The notebooks are from 1993. I'm not completely consistent with myself from that long ago, but I'm not against making fun of religion! The photograph in question is finding amusement in the incongruities. I wasn't condemning the thrift shop so much as wondering about their lack of reverence. It is St. Vincent de Paul. In the case of the vomit miracle, I found it amusing! Don't you? As to the accuracy of the facts — I took my info from the walls of the Historical Museum. I have no idea what really happened in 1345, but I do regard it as a pretty strange thing to be considered an important miracle.
I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
Encourage Althouse by making a donation:
Make a 1-time donation or set up a monthly donation of any amount you choose:
4 comments:
Jack: Thanks.
Paul: Here's more info on what happened to it post-fire.
I'm struggling to reconcile these pages and the attitude therein with the offense you took at seeing a plastic crucifix lying on the trinket table at St. Vincent de Paul's. So, which is it? Respect religious symbols, or mock them? Wait, maybe we're just supposed to mock people who don't respect their own religious symbols? I'm confused.
I also note that the account of the miracle is much different at the link you provided in the comments than on your pages.
Joan: The notebooks are from 1993. I'm not completely consistent with myself from that long ago, but I'm not against making fun of religion! The photograph in question is finding amusement in the incongruities. I wasn't condemning the thrift shop so much as wondering about their lack of reverence. It is St. Vincent de Paul. In the case of the vomit miracle, I found it amusing! Don't you? As to the accuracy of the facts — I took my info from the walls of the Historical Museum. I have no idea what really happened in 1345, but I do regard it as a pretty strange thing to be considered an important miracle.
Pedro: We're up to page 16 out of 35. I'm not giving away the story!
Post a Comment