January 20, 2025

"Calling themselves 'TikTok refugees,' [American] users paid the 'cat tax' to join RedNote by posting cat photos and videos."

"They answered so many questions from their new Chinese friends: Is it true that in rural America every family has a large farm, a huge house, at least three children and several big dogs? That Americans have to work two jobs to support themselves? That Americans are terrible at geography and many believe that Africa is a country? That most Americans have two days off every week? Americans also posed questions to their new friends. 'I heard that every Chinese has a giant panda,'” an American RedNote user wrote. 'Can you tell me how can I get it?' An answer came from someone in the eastern province of Jiangsu: 'Believe me, it’s true,' the person deadpanned, posting a photo of a panda doing the laundry. I spent hours scrolling those so-called cat tax photos and chuckled at the cute and earnest responses. This is what the internet is supposed to do: connect people...."

From "TikTok, RedNote and the Crushed Promise of the Chinese Internet/China’s internet companies and their hard-working, resourceful professionals make world-class products, in spite of censorship and malign neglect by Beijing" (NYT).

"But the U.S. effort to ban TikTok highlights how hard it is for Chinese internet companies to expand overseas.... It’s well known that China’s leader, Xi Jinping, is no fan of the digital sector, unless it is being used to advance his agenda of national rejuvenation.... 'The real economy is the foundation of a nation’s economy and the source of its wealth,' he said in 2018. 'Economic development must never deviate from the real economy toward excessive reliance on the virtual economy.'... Chinese internet companies and investors are increasingly caught between their authoritarian government at home and suspicion, even hostility, abroad...."

11 comments:

Leland said...

'I heard that every Chinese has a giant panda,'” an American RedNote user wrote. 'Can you tell me how can I get it?' An answer came from someone in the eastern province of Jiangsu: 'Believe me, it’s true,' the person deadpanned, posting a photo of a panda doing the laundry.

Remember, it was the Biden Administration that protected people from this disinformation. Now we will have a wild west Internet where people have to fend for themselves under the Trump Administration.

stlcdr said...

A giant panda in every pot!

Where’s my panda?!

Mike (MJB Wolf) said...

We haven't seen writing this giddy and lightweight, especially about the Internet, since long before Trump came down the escalator almost ten years ago. Is this really the NYT? No DEI-like scolding over stereotypes? No sharp Goldberg-esque anti-Trump buts or howevers?

Wait. Are TikTok and Rednote both NSA inventions after all?

rehajm said...

I enjoy the idea of TikTok refugees conversing with the Chinese. Like a grade 3 concussion it’s not like the Chinese leadership can do more damage to them and maybe they’ll learn something constructive by accident…

Fritz said...

I'll bet Panda tastes better than Griz.

tommyesq said...

The panda story is cute, as are the very naive questions about Americans. Too bad it is likely all catfishing by Chinese military or slave labor.

mikee said...

"Crushed promise" of the Chinese internet? The Chinese are running their internet exactly as the CCP desires, as a social media platform for societal propaganda, education, and most importantly control domestically, and as propaganda, societal degradation and most importantly surveillance abroad.

Joe Bar said...

Are you being sarcastic?

Aggie said...

Chairman Xi smiles......

Lazarus said...

"Redbook" would have conveyed the Maoist message better, but I guess that title was already taken.

Enigma said...

Nope, not taken, it actually is "Little Red Book" in Chinese. The Chinese name is Xiaohongshu, which Google Translate converts to 小红书. It then directly translates this to "Little Red Book." Rednote is a cover-up name / whitewashing of the real name.

https://www.npr.org/2025/01/15/nx-s1-5260742/tiktok-china-rednote-xiaohongshu-app