August 5, 2022

"The society for the Suppression of Unnecessary Noise was founded by a physician named Julia Barnett Rice in 1906."

Rice believed noise was unhealthy, and enlisted New York City’s gentry (including Mark Twain) to lobby for things like rules governing steamboat whistles, and silence pledges from children who played near hospitals. The group met in posh spaces like the St. Regis hotel, but Rice insisted that she was not solely interested in protecting New York’s upper class.... In 1909, the organization celebrated the passage of an ordinance that prohibited street vendors (many of them immigrants) from shouting, whistling, or ringing bells to promote their wares.....  Attempts to regulate the sounds of the city (car horns, ice-cream-truck jingles) continued throughout the 20th century, but... in the ’90s[, t]he city started going after boom boxes, car stereos, and nightclubs.... In 1991, the NYPD launched Operation Soundtrap, a campaign in which cops would trawl streets—often in majority-Black-and-brown communities—hunting for and confiscating cars with enhanced stereo systems.... When Rudy Giuliani became mayor in 1994, he used a cabaret-license law to force clubs out of gentrifying neighborhoods like the Lower East Side and Chelsea....New York was effectively codifying an elite sonic aesthetic: the systemic elevation of quiet over noise...."

37 comments:

Temujin said...

I'm not rich. I love quiet. There goes that theory.

Sebastian said...

"The sound of gentrification is silence"

Or, in the nicer parts of the country, lawnmowers.

Joe Smith said...

The sound of gentrification isn't silence, it's leaf blowers...

Narr said...

Memphis, which is now and usually has been the poorest big city per capita in the country, used to pride itself on being recognized as the quietest and cleanest, back in the era of Boss Crump.

Compared to other cities I've been in, it's still quiet--car horns are rarely used. (Then again turn signals can be scarce also.)

gilbar said...

damn gentrifiers! What with their home maintenance, and their paying taxes!
And their NOT raping and killing and murdering their neighbors!

Wilbur said...

I'm certainly not rich, but I prefer quiet surroundings and living among neighbors who are solicitous of each other in this regard.

And I think we all should greatly appreciate those automobile drivers generously sharing their music with the rest of us.

Balfegor said...

The quiet is one of the things I like most about Tokyo. It's not that there's no noise -- there's traffic and trains and amusement parks and playgrounds and noisy bars and Falun Gong oompah bands protesting the PRC -- but that there are busy public spaces where people are nevertheless quiet. When they have weekend pedestrian paradise in Ginza (the main thoroughfare is closed to vehicular traffic), you could walk through the crowd and talk at a normal volume, or even in a library voice, and still be heard. I'm sure I've mentioned this in the comments before, but when walking through Tokyo with a Chinese-American friend once, she was actually creeped out by how quiet these densely packed urban spaces were. Protesters stood quietly with signs and placards outside of company shareholder meetings. Fans all lined up for a Takarazuka theatre star after a performance were absolutely silent, waiting in orderly lines on either side of the pathway without obstructing pedestrian traffic.
Totally different from the city centres of New York or Shanghai, where people are constantly pushing and shoving and yelling at each other on the street.

If that's gentrification, let's have some more!

Carol said...

We need to downsize ASAP but where we live now is the quietest quiet I've ever had in my life.

So quiet I can hear every frequency in my tinnitus from being around so much noise in my life.

Maybe more noise would help cover it up.

Balfegor said...

I don't know if the author discusses it because I haven't read the article, but I hope she mentions Charles Babbage who hated musicians.

boatbuilder said...

I don't live in a rich neighborhood, and I am all in favor of noise reduction.

One of the reasons poor neighborhoods are poor is because people who have the money, gumption, luck or sense to get away from the asholes do so, and those who can't are stuck with the assholes. Who make the neighborhood crappy and drive down values by making lots of loud noise because they are assholes.

Has nothing to do with race--at least as the motivating force.

boatbuilder said...

Also the richer the neighborhood, the more money, time and influence the residents have to keep the assholes from making too much noise.

Clyde said...

Why does "Black" get capitalized in the phrase "Black-and-brown communities" but "brown" doesn't? Is this self-loathing on this Xochitl Gonzalez person's part? All I'm hearing is silence on the matter.

Earnest Prole said...

Despite your aspirations you can't be a True Deplorable if you like quiet.

Paddy O said...

"The sound of gentrification isn't silence, it's leaf blowers..."

Ha! Yes, this.

Tom T. said...

SNL: "Black Noise."

Original Mike said...

"Why Do Rich People Love Quiet?"

Why do people think I want to listen to their "music"?

hawkeyedjb said...

On a trip thru New England this summer, I found several restaurants and bars that had either no piped-in music, or low enough volume that it didn't harm the ambience. Very pleasant - nothing like the low hum of conversation to make a dining room enjoyable. Then there were the "typical" American bars/restos, including a nice fish house where the angry, screechy music ruined the evening. I hate/loathe/detest music in public places. Harrumph.

And stay off my lawn.

tim maguire said...

The noise I make is fine. It’s the noise everybody else makes that’s a problem.

tim maguire said...

Original Mike said..."Why Do Rich People Love Quiet?"

Why do people think I want to listen to their "music"?


Why do the people with the best car speakers always have the worst taste in music?

Leland said...

I guess the author didn’t understand the lyrics to the song.

tommyesq said...

Capitalizing "Black" but not "brown" seems kinda racist...

WK said...

Acoustic racism.

Mikey NTH said...

Not rich here but a quiet neighborhood isn't bad.

Especially if you want to sleep.

Smilin' Jack said...

“From "Why Do Rich People Love Quiet?”

Maybe they became rich because they have more productive things to do than make noise.

Jupiter said...

Let me whitesplain it to you, Xochitl. It's not so much noise we object to, as the noise that you make. See, there, right there. You were about to do it again. Callate, puta.

Wilbur said...

I suppose my least favorite noise intrusion is at the gas pump, where it's now deemed appropriate to blare unspeakably loud advertising music at you while you're filling your car.

I hold my hand over the speaker to soften the volume as much as I can, and even went to the trouble of writing the company complaining about it; they couldn't bother to respond.

Rebel Gas, owned by Anabi Oil, I'm calling you out. Like you give a shit.

Old and slow said...

I refuse to patronise gas stations that play ad's at the pump.

Tank said...

Went to a minor league baseball game last week. Very enjoyable and exciting with a walk off single in the bottom of the ninth.

It would have been WAY more fun if they weren't constantly pumping noise into the stadium. Every frickin minute stuff blaring over the loudspeakers.

Robert Cook said...

"Why Do Rich People Love Quiet?"

They want to be able to hear their money growing.

stlcdr said...

Everything is class- or racist.

If ‘rich’ people like peace and quiet the corollary is that poor people like noise. Further, rich people have money and poor people dont; do poor people not want money?

Absurd discussions lead to absurd conclusions, and further absurdities.

MayBee said...

Balfegor said...
The quiet is one of the things I like most about Tokyo.


That's what I was going to say. Tokyo is so quiet! A block off the main road, and its so so peaceful. There are noises- the guys selling chestnuts or roasted yams as they walk their cart through the streets. The man who runs through the neighborhoods in the winter nights, clacking wood together to remind people to dampen their fires before they go to sleep for the night. The announcement at 5 pm to let children know to return home and do their school work. But even the sounds are peaceful somehow.

LA, on the other hand, is loud. Even the rich parts. There are so many helicopters. The sounds kind of bounce around the mountains. Koreatown (is that gentrification?) is so very loud, and it's right next to Hancock Park.

But maybe this author (like others we've talked about this week) really only knows New York and the NE.

baghdadbob said...

Harley Davidsons, and autos designed to be unnecessarily loud.

What motivates people to be drawn to own such obnoxious vehicles? Are there any owners of these noise-makers out there who can explain themselves?

Pete said...

Since the beginning of the pandemic I have taken to a lunchtime walk listing to a book with earbuds. The noisiest things by far are the big diesel trucks - nothing else comes close. Diesels have a lot of pollution controls nowadays but sound pollution is not one of them. I guess luxury is when you live in a neighborhood with few trucks.

KellyM said...

My section of SF is extremely quiet: the random car, city bus, and depending on wind direction, the surf. Oh, and random fireworks, in the middle of the night, for no reason. No one ever investigates. In the grand scheme of things that's a good thing.

NotWhoIUsedtoBe said...

The whole point of having money is being able to escape loud annoying people.

stlcdr said...

baghdadbob said...
Harley Davidsons, and autos designed to be unnecessarily loud.

What motivates people to be drawn to own such obnoxious vehicles? Are there any owners of these noise-makers out there who can explain themselves?

8/6/22, 10:26 AM


Why should one explain the things that they like?

baghdadbob said...

Because stlcdr, your rights stop at our ears. If I liked running my leaf-blower outside your house at 7am, that's ok with you because I'm just doing what "I like"?