May 8, 2022

"The decline in mental health among teenagers was intensified by the Covid pandemic but predated it, spanning racial and ethnic groups..."

"... urban and rural areas and the socioeconomic divide.... 'Young people are more educated; less likely to get pregnant, use drugs; less likely to die of accident or injury,' said Candice Odgers, a psychologist at the University of California, Irvine. 'By many markers, kids are doing fantastic and thriving. But there are these really important trends in anxiety, depression and suicide that stop us in our tracks.'... The crisis is often attributed to the rise of social media, but solid data on the issue is limited, the findings are nuanced and often contradictory and some adolescents appear to be more vulnerable than others to the effects of screen time. Federal research shows that teenagers as a group are also getting less sleep and exercise and spending less in-person time with friends — all crucial for healthy development — at a period in life when it is typical to test boundaries and explore one’s identity. The combined result for some adolescents is a kind of cognitive implosion: anxiety, depression, compulsive behaviors, self-harm and even suicide. This surge has raised vexing questions. Are these issues inherent to adolescence that merely went unrecognized before — or are they being overdiagnosed now?"

From "'It’s Life or Death': The Mental Health Crisis Among U.S. Teens/Depression, self-harm and suicide are rising among American adolescents. For one 13-year-old, the despair was almost too much to take" (NYT)

35 comments:

Jefferson's Revenge said...

All of the above is true and COVID made it worse. It’s important to recognize that it existed preCOVID because it won’t just magically improve post COVID.

Unfortunately the “cure” will be worse than the disease. Schools and experts will create a new teen mental health industry/complex to suck more money into their pockets.

The actual solution is mentioned in the snippet- get the kids off the screen, get them outside for physical exercise, change school hours so they get a normal sleep patter, etc.

This is all common sense. Why can’t it be done? Why can’t parents do this?

Lem the artificially intelligent said...

It’s enough to make Jordan Peterson cry.

Bob Boyd said...

Have they looked at schools?

gilbar said...

The decline in mental health among teenagers was intensified by the Covid pandemic but predated it, spanning racial and ethnic groups

I've heard, that many teen's mental health;
is SO BAD, that they don't Even KNOW whether they are boys or girls!

Only one thing to do, with such mentally ill children.. Embrace their madness, and sterilize them
</sarc

veni vidi vici said...

Heavy duty cope from the media in its Quixotic efforts to absolve Dem politicians and gov't functionaries of blame for the adverse results of their pandemic decisionmaking.

What a lame attempt at mitigating the doomsday that's approaching this November. Wonder who'll be dumb enough to fall for this schtick.

Patrick Henry was right! said...

It's the electronic devices. Period. And crappy parents.

Mark said...

The inherent relativism and existential angst leading to nihilism of the progressivism that young people are drenched in - where nothing has any meaning, especially people's lives and why life is worth living - is going to have an effect.

Mark said...

And, yes, progressivism IS at fault. It is overwhelmingly in control of the culture, the schools, and hence has controlled children's lives.

This is the world that progressivism has created.

Howard said...

If anything, it's the deemphasizing of art, athletics and trade school classes (shop, home econ, etc). I can't imagine that the obesity and social media addiction is helping. As long as kids have non-academic outlets and are actively engaging in the real world, they are going to be fine.

holdfast said...

Are they really more educated? Or are they simply more credentialed?

Because by most standards, they don’t seem to know much AND they aren’t very good at working on tasks independently.

Old and slow said...

I'm in my mid 50's and I certainly do not remember any golden age of adolescent mental health back in the late 70's early 80's. I had a lot of fun at times, but I was plenty f'ed up and miserable too. So were most of my classmates...

Temujin said...

Well, first of all I truly think it's the electronics and social media paired up to destroy the kids. Or if not destroy them, let's say pull them over onto a path that delays their foray into reality. Life.

There are other things not mentioned directly, but possibly alluded to when suggesting 'impulsive behaviors'. These young people, who spend less in-person time, less outdoor activity time, and less time sleeping, also tend to gravitate when possible, to groups that will show them acceptance. And there are groups, activist groups, preying on the young, using this need for being welcomed and feeling accepted. So now we see groups of young women, for instance, large numbers of friends, all suddenly becoming 'trans'. In startlingly growing numbers. Or trying out alternative genders, or playing at being gay for a bit. Some of this has always been around as a part of curiosity in a young person growing up. But not to the extent and numbers we see today, and not with the fervor we see in it today.

I am not saying that being trans or gay is bad. Not saying that. It's not- if that's who you truly are. But to play at it, or take it on because the fad wants you, is dangerous. For both the individual, and for the society watching it.

We're having fewer kids, but we're fighting for abortion. We're having fewer kids, but we're changing our genders or just not having genders, or sex. All of these things in a normal percentage of society are fine. But when the percentage of these things blows up, and gets outsized from it's 'norm', that has a very real effect on the civilization as a whole. You won't see it today. But you will within your lifetimes. Throw in the other physical self-harms, suicides, depression, and it's not a pretty picture for American leadership going deeper into this century.

Something culturally has to change.

Karen said...

How do they not see that this is a direct result of screen time? “Federal research shows that teenagers as a group are also getting less sleep and exercise and spending less in-person time with friends — all crucial for healthy development — at a period in life when it is typical to test boundaries and explore one’s identity.”

Karen said...

This is not a separate problem, but a direct result of screen time—> “Federal research shows that teenagers as a group are also getting less sleep and exercise and spending less in-person time with friends — all crucial for healthy development — at a period in life when it is typical to test boundaries and explore one’s identity.”

Richard said...

At a restaurant recently, saw a young couple seated across from one another, elbows firmly planted, devices in front of face. Didn't see them speak. Not the only time.

Ambrose said...

Like the "spinning racial and ethnic groups." Everything has to be about race and ethnicity, even when it is not.

Gahrie said...

Teenagers today are bombarded with constant messages that the USA sucks, everyone is oppressed, and the world is going to end tomorrow.

Joe Smith said...

Kids also used to spend most of their time outside playing when not in school...even kids from the big city.

The only video game was Pong and there were 6 or 7 TV channels to watch, depending upon your antenna.

Despite us being immeasurably richer, things aren't necessarily better...

Michael said...

I agree that Progressive nihilism is largely the culprit, with social media (and the schools) the vehicle. Children raised by their parents and the broader culture to believe in duty, honor, Country, faith and family do not wind up depressive and suicidal. Kids will be healthier who reach an appropriate age before making their own decisions regarding sexuality (and the Oxford comma.)

Michael K said...

Blogger Howard said...

If anything, it's the deemphasizing of art, athletics and trade school classes (shop, home econ, etc). I can't imagine that the obesity and social media addiction is helping.


Howard, what has come over you ? Here I am agreeing again. Last week I agreed with Cook.

There is an interesting study of myopia in Chinese teens. In Singapore and Shanghai the incidence is high. In Australia, the incidence in Chinese teens is half that. The theory is that Chinese kids in Australia are outdoors more and spend less time studying.

I haven't seen a study of US teens and myopia but I'll bet it is way up.

What's emanating from your penumbra said...

"anxiety, depression, compulsive behaviors, self-harm and even suicide"

One plausible theory is that this is a natural result of re-ordering the cultural hierarchy of values by raising empathy at the expense of resiliency.

But what is the mechanism?

Would it surprise you if an increasingly feminized world expressed a higher degree of neuroticism?

Sebastian said...

"a kind of cognitive implosion"

Knowingly aggravated by prog politicians and experts during Covid. How will they be held accountable? When will the lawsuits start?

Eleanor said...

Kids need to work. They need age appropriate chores at home, responsibilities at school, and an after school or summer job when they're old enough. They need to become partners in the running of their families. No one gets a free ride in life. If we want them to build self-worth, we need to help them establish their worth. We've made childhood and adolescence an extended time of being freeloaders, and then we clutch our pearls when they become depressed and have no coping skills.

Jupiter said...

Let's not forget the huge increases in autism and other iatrogenic diseases that have accompanied the massive growth of the CDC's vaccination schedule.

Michael said...

A reminder, it's not COVID which caused this spike in anxiety, depression and self-harm among girls. This is caused by the government lockdowns. We need to hold these fockers accountable.

realestateacct said...

There are a lot of rewards for being unstable now that didn't exist when I was growing up. Testing anxiety was treated by adults telling you to get over it instead of giving you more time on the test. Jordan Petersen seems to be the last adult telling people to pull yourself together and face your life.

Kate said...

I'm surprised that no one ever correlates the impact of 9/11 with late Millennial and Gen Z depression.

Karlito2000 said...

Another factor at work is the medicalizing of this generation. We know a wide swarth of young people in this cohort who have all been cycled through a cornucopia of mood altering pharmaceuticals. Some have found the right mix of meds, most have not. As a group they are way overmedicated.

MadTownGuy said...

From the article:

"The decline in mental health among teenagers was intensified by the lockdowns but predated it, spanning racial and ethnic groups..."

FIFY

Dagwood said...

I wonder why Odgers believes that teens today are more educated. Diplomas? SAT scores?

Mark said...

"This is caused by the government lockdowns."

Given the wide disparity between areas that opened back up quickly vs places that returned to in person school a year later, one would think that your point could be easily demonstrated ... yet it has not been.

Your claim requires backup, why don't you provide some data?

realestateacct said...

Kate has a good point.

tshanks78 said...

Safetyism leads to suicide. A generation of kids taught to be afraid of everything from birth. Be careful. Don’t get hurt. Be careful. Don’t get hurt. Danger lurks behind every corner. And don’t forget you’re destroying the earth.

Bender said...

"This is caused by the government lockdowns."

Your claim requires backup, why don't you provide some data?

The lockdowns led to a loss of social interaction. Such isolation leads to depression, which leads to despair.

Do you really need someone to draw a diagram for you?

Mark said...

Bender, given the disparity between those who closed schools only a few months and those who closed for a year or more, if lockdowns were the problem then you should have pretty clear data showing that.

But you don't. You just go to put downs, which shows that you know you lack evidence and are trying to avoid admitting that.