February 14, 2022

"To be sardonic is to be disdainfully or cynically humorous, or scornfully mocking."

Wikipedia explains at "Sardonicism," to which I was redirected when I clicked on the words "sardonic grin" in the caption "Sardo-Punic mask showing a Sardonic grin" under this riveting image:

I found that at the Wikipedia article "Punic people," which I was reading because the letter combination "punic" had arisen in the course of talking about a particular word puzzle.

But what is the "Sardonic grin"?

Both the concept and the etymology of the word ["sardonic"]... appear to stem from the Mediterranean island of Sardinia. The 10th-century Byzantine Greek encyclopedia Suda traces the word's earliest roots to the notion of grinning (Ancient Greek: σαίρω, romanized: sairō) in the face of danger, or curling one's lips back at evil.

One explanation for the later alteration to its more familiar form and connection to laughter (supported by the Oxford English Dictionary) appears to stem from an ancient belief that ingesting the sardonion (σαρδόνιον) plant from Sardinia (Σαρδώ) would result in convulsions resembling laughter and, ultimately, death. In Theory and History of Folklore, Vladimir Propp discusses alleged examples of ritual laughter accompanying death and killing, all involving groups. These he characterized as sardonic laughter:

Among the very ancient people of Sardinia, who were called Sardi or Sardoni, it was customary to kill old people. While killing their old people, the Sardi laughed loudly. This is the origin of notorious sardonic laughter (Eugen Fehrle, 1930). In light of our findings things begin to look different. Laughter accompanies the passage from death to life; it creates life and accompanies birth. Consequently, laughter accompanying killing transforms death into a new birth, nullifies murder as such, and is an act of piety that transforms death into a new life....

Risus sardonicus is an apparent smile on the face of those who are convulsing because of tetanus, or strychnine poisoning. From the Oxford English Dictionary, "A fixed, grin-like expression resulting from spasm of facial muscles, esp. in tetanus." Also:

[Convulsion of the] facial muscles may cause a characteristic expression called Risus sardonicus (from the Latin for scornful laughter) or Risus caninus (from the Latin for doglike laughter or grinning). This facial expression has also been observed among patients with tetanus. Risus sardonicus causes a patient's eyebrows to rise, eyes to bulge, and mouth to retract dramatically, resulting in what has been described as an evil-looking grin.

In 2009 scientists at the University of Eastern Piedmont in Italy claimed to have identified hemlock water dropwort as the plant responsible for producing the sardonic grin. This plant is the candidate for the "sardonic herb", which was a neurotoxic plant used for the ritual killing of elderly people in pre-Roman Sardinia. When these people were unable to support themselves, they were intoxicated with this herb and then dropped from a high rock or beaten to death.

If I read that correctly: The old people were given a substance that made them look like they were laughing while they were being murdered, and the murderers were also laughing, and not because they found it funny, but because they believed their laughing would transport their victim to a new life.

And that's what "sardonic" means.

20 comments:

ga6 said...

They made a movie about this:
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0055200/

M Jordan said...

One way to get a jump on Wordle is to understand the words aren’t randomly selected. The editors, now NYT people, are looking for certain types of words, certain flavors, certain unusual letter combinations, etc. If you’re down to your 6th guess and have to choose between “tunic” and “tonic” go with “tunic.” It’s a little bit cooler, woker, trickier.

Kay said...

Brilliant! Great post.

traditionalguy said...

Wow! looks just like the Bill Gates smirk. I am not kidding. Gates, when he is not enjoying orgy island vacays, engineers eugenic pandemics as the ultimate funny things using his Bio-weapons that he paid the ChiComs to create and distribute.

All those old folks alone and intubated in enduced comas until their death. That’s his ROFL time.

Temujin said...

"...it was customary to kill old people."

This was a great post. Interesting. And non-political. So forgive me but...

It's weird that when I read about people laughing at the killing of old people, my mind went to Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer and former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo, both of whom had many on-camera laughing and smiling moments while their policies were knocking off seniors in their states at the beginning of the Wuhan outbreak.

I remember Whitmer in particular because my family lived it in real time. Some things will stick with you.

Ann Althouse said...

"This was a great post. Interesting. And non-political. So forgive me but..."

Here at Meadhouse, this post got us talking about how Biden is always smiling inappropriately... and so is Kamala Harris. Laughing when nothing is funny does make you look evil. I feel sorry for someone with tetanus suffering horribly and forced, also, to look evil, but nothing is forcing Biden and Harris to wear the sardonic grin.

Quaestor said...

"They made a movie about this..."

They made at least three. The first is a widely acknowledged classic, The Man Who Laughs (1928). William Castle's 1961 grindhouse shocker was a pale and exploitative derivative of the same material.

The most recent is probably Tim Burton's Batman (1989), the movie most responsible for the plague of revoltingly asinine MCU live-action cartoons that drove me wretching from the cinemas long before the other plague. The plot involves the Joker's conspiracy to poison Gotham City with a chemical that makes its victims literally die laughing, which is more akin to this supposed Sardinian death ritual than anything discussed so far.

traditionalguy said...

Experts on seeing a liar point to watching out for the moment of glee the deceiver’s face gets from successful lies. It shows for a half second before the deceivers face goes back into character. They call this facial tell “ the duper’s delight.” Once you learn to look for it, it always works.

That could explain Slow Joe. But in rich man Bill Gates case, he can just let it all hang out as his sardonic grin.

Quaestor said...

The art nouveau lobby card for The Man Who Laughs is one of the best to come out of Silent Era Hollywood; it's also the graphic inspiration of Batman's nemesis.

rcocean said...

Things were tough in the old days. No social security or medicare. Just relatives with sticks beating the old geezers to death.

Honor they mother and father. Probably easier in the land of milk and honey. Didn't the Japanese lead the old people to a mountain top and let them starve to death? That could be less emotionally draining.

rcocean said...

Old movie villians - especially the Nazis and the Nips - always had sardonic smiles. That is until some Yankee Doodle Dandy wiped that smile off their face.

rcocean said...

What is the difference between a smirk and a sardonic smile? A college education?

Richard Dillman said...

Excellent post, truly Informative. I will think of this whenever I try to be sardonic. Now I will google sarcastic.

Danno said...

So I now have some idea of what meaning is of the title of an album I bought in college back in the 70s, the Twelve Dreams of Dr. Sardonicus.

Yancey Ward said...

Two beat me to it- smirk is what I was thinking.

rcocean said...

O villain, villain, smiling, damnèd villain!
That one may smile, and smile, and be a villain.

Howard said...

I prefer Sardonic Gins

Narr said...

Yes, Spirit's great album came to mind. And the Covington Kid.

The old and burdensome get short shrift in a lot of places, no surprise there. But I didn't know the details of the etymology. Holocaust literature is full of laughing murderers, and people like that infest the planet at all times.



hombre said...

It's a wonderful image. It may even be a sardonic grin. But it's important to remember that many Wikipedia contributors live their lefty minds.

Vittorio Jano IV said...

"He whips her lightly, sardonically with belt."
--The Doors - Angels and Sailors (American Prayer)