December 18, 2019

"Twenty-some years ago, I got a Guggenheim grant to write a memoir. I ended up using most of the money to buy a garden tractor."

"I failed for a number of reasons. I don’t feel interesting. I don’t trust my memories (or anyone’s memories) as reliable records of anything—and I have a fear of lying. Nor do I have much documentary material. I’ve never kept a diary or a journal, because I get spooked by addressing no one. When I write, it’s to connect. I am beset, too, by obsessively remembered thudding guilts and scalding shames. Small potatoes, as traumas go, but intensified by my aversion to facing them. Susan Sontag observed that when you have a disease people identify you with it. Fine by me! I could never sustain an expedient 'I' for more than a paragraph. (Do you imagine that writers speak 'as themselves'? No such selves exist.) Playing the Dying Man (Enter left. Exit trapdoor) gives me a persona. It’s a handy mask."

From "The Art of Dying/I always said that when my time came I’d want to go fast. But where’s the fun in that?" by Peter Schjeldahl. Schjeldahl is 77 and dying of lung cancer. This is quite a long essay — about death — but there's a highly enjoyable breeziness about it.

I chose that passage in part because it had a tractor and, then, potatoes. And because I identified with the feeling of being "beset... by obsessively remembered thudding guilts and scalding shames" and that reminded me of what I was reading about Adam Driver earlier today, that he had "a tendency to try to make things better or drive myself and the other people around me crazy with the things I wanted to change or I wish I could change." I'd said, "I do think there's a great range in how minutely people examine and reexamine their failings and imagined failings."

14 comments:

Brent said...

Read this yesterday after a friend texted the link to me. Not a comfortable piece for the most part. But among the most beautifully written things ever. What a writer!

BarrySanders20 said...

So call this his memoir. It just took him 20+ years to get around to it. Meanwhile, he's had 20+ years of freshly mowed grass and plenty of time to think about what to write. Very practical decision for the Guggenheim dollars.The tractor, therefore, could be seen as both an obstacle getting in the way of what he wanted to accomplish (a la Grapes of Wrath) or the catalyst that allowed him to accomplish the task.

Ot maybe he's just a lazy bastard and should give the tractor back.

AllenS said...

Tractors have drive shafts, lawn mowers are belt driven. There is a difference.

Two-eyed Jack said...

I nearly died once, but didn't. I suppose I simply have no talent for it. My uncle just died last week, but he took a long time getting around to it. I suppose he had other things he got up to, but what they were, I don't know. I suppose, like me, he just wasn't particularly inclined that way. So leave it to those looking for a good closing for their memoirs and the enthusiasts.

Sebastian said...

"I identified with the feeling of being "beset... by obsessively remembered thudding guilts and scalding shames" . . . "I do think there's a great range in how minutely people examine and reexamine their failings and imagined failings."

Interesting. I got that vibe long ago in your tale about the mean principal who did not respect your autonomy as expressed by a mini skirt worn to school. Your defense mechanism kicked in strongly as you told it, but we Freudians detected the suppression of scalding shame and imagined failing in your retrospective treatment of him and the norms he represented.

Rob said...

If he didn't want to write a memoir, why did he apply for a grant to write a memoir? Did he give back the money? (Silly question, I know. Of course he didn't.)

Quaestor said...

This is quite a long essay — about death — but there's a highly enjoyable breeziness about it.

Breeziness and cancer in the same paragraph. The Althouse cruel neutrality trope has taken a turn toward the macabre.

It fits with the Mel Brooks theory of humor, at least.

Narr said...

Range there may be, but is it 'great'? Cheap joke, but still. And do you mean 'great range' in a single person, or among and between people, or both?

I do think thudding guilts and scalding shames is a lovely phrase for things we all feel--at least I know I do!

I never got paid to write (per se), I just had to.

Narr
I was a teenage belt-driven lawnmower

rcocean said...

As Susan Sontag once said: "Liberals often vote Democratic" - words to live by.

rcocean said...

As Leo Tolstoy once said; "Don't let the dog in when it has mud on its feet".

Yancey Ward said...

Wow, what an essay!

Anonymous said...

It must be difficult to reconcile a squandered life.

rcocean said...

Nice essay. Too bad he's a Sontag fan. As for dying at 77, its not unexpected. Y'know what I'm saying.

rcocean said...

Better to just drop dead of a heart attack. Drawn out death is the worst.