November 16, 2019

"In no other show this year will you see an elderly character wearing a wig of pubic hair at her crotch while playing air guitar or a younger one spider-walking topless while growling demonically."

From the NYT article, "Make Way for the Carnal Clowns of Stand-Up/Three rising comics share an aesthetic that marries crass physical humor with disarmingly sexual themes. They’re unsettling and hilarious."

Good use of the verb "marries."

The first 2 "clowns" discussed in the article are female, so I was cynically thinking gender was a big part of why the NYT was giving such an enthusiastic write-up. But the third "clown" — discussed very briefly — is male.

Cynical Me rears her ugly head to say they only threw him in so it would look as though the new trend was crass physical humor with harshly sexual themes and not specifically women getting into the old male terrain of physical humor and sexual themes.

Cynical Me points out that that there are only 3 sentences about the male, and the third one is, "He is a familiar type: The comic with infinite confidence and no skill." Old, not new. Does he really belong in this article?

The article ends:
As artists searching for originality often are, they borrow from a variety of sources.... And perhaps what makes them seem so thrillingly unpredictable is that they don’t seem to be reacting against a tradition as struggling to forge their own.
But the guy — whose comic persona is a bad standup comedian — doesn't sound "thrillingly unpredictable." That is "reacting against a tradition." And we were just told "He is a familiar type."

19 comments:

Wilbur said...

AA, don't label yourself "Cynical Me". You're just a Cruel Neutralist. It's why many of us read you.

Anne in Rockwall, TX said...

"In no other show this year will you see an elderly character wearing a wig of pubic hair at her crotch while playing air guitar or a younger one spider-walking topless while growling demonically."

And I wouldn't want to, but thank you very much for offering.

Mr. Forward said...

“In no other show this year...”
The year isn’t over and neither are the debates.

tim in vermont said...

I wish I had the skill to wear a wig of pubic hair on my crotch while playing air guitar. It sounds like it would take way more practice and preparation than I am willing to put in, though.

Nancy said...

Thank heavens Ann reads the NYT so we don't have to.

samanthasmom said...

Where is the audience for this stuff coming from?

bleh said...

Your first cynical thought was the right one. It’s incredible how liberals will force themselves to try to enjoy certain things in order to make themselves feel better about themselves. Same as the tokenism you see in so many of their friend groups, ticking boxes, etc.

Jeff Brokaw said...

New NYT tagline: All the “news” that nobody gives a shit about.

tim in vermont said...

A liberal woman friend of mine admitted a while ago this: “I watched The Handmaid’s Tale” for a while becuase it was supposed to be smart, but you know what? It was stupid and boring."

Temujin said...

"A clown show about consent."

Today's idea of comedy seems to have missed the idea of what comedy is supposed to do.

chuck said...

Leaving pee and poop jokes behind, comics go where no one has gone before.

gilbar said...

how many feminists does it take to screw in a light bulb?
That's NOT funny!

Anonymous said...

"Unsettling" and "hilarious".

Translation:

Unsettling: Validates the existing views of the intended audience.

Hilarious: Not funny.

"In no other show this year will you see an elderly character wearing a wig of pubic hair at her crotch while playing air guitar or a younger one spider-walking topless while growling demonically."

So, "artists" with no talent or craft, but lots of narcissism and assorted other mental health issues, and opinions on stuff conforming completely to those of the intended audience.

Amadeus 48 said...

What's so funny?

Amadeus 48 said...

So, do they call it "The Aristocrats"?

Fernandinande said...

Sounds like a stale pale female imitation of a frat party.

SDaly said...

The article missed the rare opportunity to use the word “merkin” as part of a story. Unforgivable!

Iman said...

It takes a lot to cry, it takes Obama on a train to laugh...

Tom T. said...

I assumed this was somehow going to be about library story hour.