"... a distance equivalent to swimming across the Channel and back again. Simon Holliday, 46, from Ashford in Kent, completed the 40.3-mile circuit of Lantau Island on Friday in 20 hours 57 minutes. Half an hour later, he was followed by Edie Hu of the United States, the first woman to make the swim. They did not wear wetsuits — marathon swim rules mean they are not allowed in waters above 20C — so the chill was one of their biggest challenges.... The three swimmers were followed by a support team in two boats and two kayaks. They were fed in the water every 45 minutes with snacks such as chocolate, jelly babies and bananas."
From "British man is first to swim round Hong Kong’s biggest island/Simon Holliday won the 40-mile race round Lantau — the equivalent of swimming the Channel and back — as competitors battled tides, hallucinations and cramp" (London Times).
20C = 68° Fahrenheit.
A quote from Hu (the woman): "I started getting a little loopy. I was getting sleepy and actually dozing off [in the water]. Then I started having some hallucinations — seeing Yoda [from Star Wars] on the mountain. After a shot of caffeine at 12.30am, I pulled it together and picked up my pace."
A quote from Holliday: " “There are those moments — split seconds — when you’re out there and you think of nothing, and it’s really wonderful. If I’m thinking nothing, it will be bliss."
What Holliday ate when the race was over: "cheesy beans on toast."

32 comments:
Remember homer and the apple core bars
Hu dat say dey gonna swim that island?
Sometimes I am jealous of people that float in water and could dose off.
How polluted are the waters around HongKong? Do they still have a million people living on sampans and junks crapping in the harbor?
Floating is no big deal, Achilles. Just keep your lungs full and you can float forever. (Another thing learned in the Navy)
John Henry
John henry said...
Floating is no big deal, Achilles. Just keep your lungs full and you can float forever. (Another thing learned in the Navy)
This might work in salt water. I still have to work to hold my face and nose up in the pool. I guess my brain isn't big enough. My chest slowly falls on it's own full of air. I have gained a little extra weight recently. Getting old. I might try again.
Sinking is real, John Henry. I've tried to teach adult African immigrants to swim and failed every time. African women float a little better, but not much.
A significant constraint on marathon runners is the limit of sweating and respiration to shed the core body heat generated from extended exercise. I wonder if the official upside cap on water temperature in marathon swimming is to keep the athletes from cooking internally.
I was a kayak supporter for a friend who swam a 25K from Vermont to Canada and back a couple years ago. She drank maple syrup every 30-minutes and took Tylenol and caffeine supplements. A few bananas as well for the potassium. Because it was fresh water, she drank directly from the lake
AI : "The first documented person to swim around the island of Manhattan was Robert W. Dowling.
On September 5, 1915, the 18-year-old Dowling completed the 28.5-mile circumnavigation in 13 hours and 45 minutes."
"The first woman to accomplish the feat was Ida Elionsky, who completed the swim in 11 hours and 35 minutes in 1916."
Money Manager: good point. I hate swimming a mile in water above 83°F. Racing pools are kept at 78°F.
Howard said...
Sinking is real, John Henry. I've tried to teach adult African immigrants to swim and failed every time. African women float a little better, but not much.
Swimming has always sucked for me but I figured it was normal.
This comment is actually illuminating with respect to Black people who have a tendency to have more quick twitch/denser muscle and probably have higher bone density too. We always gave them shit for failing swimming tests in the army but this makes sense.
It shouldn't have taken me 50 years to figure that out.
You can't really float vertically, you need to stay horizontal. Water Polo players stay vertical by doing the eggbeater kick. The Japanese have a treading water sport
The Japanese treading water sport is called Samurai Swimming or Nihon Eiho, a classical swimming art that evolved from the combative water skills, or suijutsu, of feudal warriors. Modern competitors showcase their core strength and control by performing routines that include surging the body out of the water while maintaining near-stillness and performing intricate movements, often with props like parasols or fans. It is a competitive and traditional martial art that is practiced in Japan today.
"Sustained by bananas and painkillers" would be a great masthead motto.
Or, if you want to avoid the drug reference, "chocolate, jelly babies and bananas." CC, JSM
Achilles said...
“Black people who have a tendency to have more quick twitch/denser muscle and probably have higher bone density too.”
NASA quietly confirmed the greater bone density of blacks decades ago as they had fewer bone loss issues from long term space flight.
Osteoporosis statistics for the US in 2025: https://www.theglobalstatistics.com/united-states-osteoporosis-statistics/
By sex:
Men: 4.2% (1 in 25)
Women: 18.8% (1 in 5)
By “race”:
- NH Asians: 18.4%
- Hispanics: 14.7%
- NH Whites: 12.9%
- NH Blacks: 6.8%
Asians are not split out between east and south. Hispanics can be of any race. And blacks, unless they are recent immigrants from Africa, are also almost all part white.
"marathon swim rules mean they are not allowed in waters above 20C "??? What.. above??? So they wanted to freeze them?
I assume these weren’t opioid painkillers?
Beasts: "I assume these weren’t opioid painkillers?"
The Brits tend to use the word to refer to over-the-counter pain relief, to avoid the specificity of aspirin vs ibuprofen vs acetaminophen etc. "Oh, luv, if you're going to Boots, could you get some more painkillers? We're almost out." CC, JSM
I'm impressed with the feat, and understand the desire to do something hard just because it's hard, but I wish people so inclined would do something actually constructive. It's so much work and logistics. It seems like a waste of human effort just to use it to swim in circle. I'd suggest something like dig 100 wells in African villages in 1 month, or wash my truck every week for a year. That would really impress me.
"Painkillers"? Really? Stop the violent rhetoric.
"Sustained by bananas"
Foo. I thought they built themselves banana rafts (in this interpretation, "sustained" means "floated on"). But no, they ate the bananas.
I like my story better.
I'm something of a polar bear. I love cold water swimming and sports like whitewater kayaking. I thought I was pretty tough until I discovered the coldest water I could tolerate was 52 degrees F.
Compare that to the Labrador Current in mid-April.
We had the "Rock Squad" in the Army. The guys who couldn't swim. They were mostly all black dudes. We were told this is because their body composition is denser.
Marathon running, marathon swimming, marathon bike racing, marathon dancing ... note that the activity is based upon pure repetition of actions that are individually meaningless and devoid of emotional reward. The activities rely upon abilities to combat ennui and lactic acid accumulation, these abilities are not worthless. But they aren't really worth much either.
"Sustained by bananas and painkillers"
Breakfast of Champions.
In general, women float; men don't. It has to do with distribution of body fat. A huge flaw in The Poseidon Adventure.
I intend to rely on bananas and painkillers to get me through Thanksgiving.
"A huge flaw in The Poseidon Adventure."
They would all have survived if only they had used Shelley Winters as a life raft?
Some people have natural negative buoyancy. Donald Sinden famously almost drowned during filming of The Cruel Sea.
I prefer the little apple banana. grown in tropical regions and most tasty.
"Racing pools are kept at 78°F."
I'm not a competitive swimmer but 78° seems outright hot for a fast mile. 72° is better for me in a saltwater pool. 40 miles? Holy shit! My son wanted me to do a 10 mile with him in Hawaii which was a maybe, probably not at my age, but when it was pointed out that you're not at the top of the food chain out there it became a no way no how.
When we made port calls to honk Kong back in the 70’s the water was not considered safe for swimming. We had a BT (boiler technician) who was restricted to the ship for a prior discipline issue who decided to jump overboard and swim the 1/2 mile to shore. He was fished out of the water about a hundred yards from the ship into the captain’s gig. He was given (probably as punishment) every possible vaccine available and handcuffed to his rack.
Post a Comment
Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.