August 14, 2025

There are so many old songs that might soar into viral popularity with young people... if they'd only listen.

I'm reading "The Song Was a Hit 20 Years Ago. It Just Got a Video. Decades-old tracks by artists including Clap Your Hands Say Yeah, LL Cool J and Talking Heads are finding younger fans. Record labels hope new videos will feed their interest" (NYT).

But some of these videos sound like what AI would concoct. They're "overly literal" presentations of the lyrics: "In the video for Lynyrd Skynyrd’s 'Free Bird,' an older man remembers his carefree younger days before taking his motorcycle out for one last ride; the video for Bob Marley’s 'No Woman, No Cry' features a struggling Jamaican mother and her husband, who works in a faraway city...."

Here's an example, discussed in the article, of a more artful approach:


That came out 4 years ago and has gotten over 10 million views. We're told it's inspired new Peggy Lee fans to make their own videos out of Lee's recording — not only of "Fever,” but also  “Is That All There Is?” and “Big Spender.”

I wonder how that music sounds to young people, given what they've grown up listening to. Peggy Lee sounds good to me, and I grew up listening to 50s and 60s rock and roll. I'm 74, and Peggy Lee was my parents' music. But then I love going back to the 1920s, to what would have been my grandparents' music. The good is more heavily concentrated in the old. It's recorded music. Listen to whatever is best.

46 comments:

mccullough said...

Some music holds up well. Stevie Wonder and David Bowie’s albums from the 70s still sound fresh.

Popular music has some bangers from all eras.

Scott M said...

I think the best example of this is a Thor movie's use of Zepplin's Immigrant Song. An entire generation of kids suddenly wailing like banshees and a spike in Zepplin album sales :)

Last night we watched the second episode of the so-far-excellent new Alien Earth series. They dropped in Tool's iconic "Stinkfist" for the second episode's end credits and it left me grinning like an idiot. My 15yo and 17yo were both leaning in, trying to figure out who the band was :)

Lazarus said...

Is Old Music Killing New Music?
Old songs now represent 70 percent of the U.S. music market. Even worse: The new-music market is actually shrinking.
By Ted Gioia
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/01/old-music-killing-new-music/621339

Nancy said...

I couldn't bear to watch more than a minute. I'd rather just hear Peggy Lee sing.

Lazarus said...

I have my grandfather's music. His old records. Unfortunately, it's all marches and accordion music from the old country. I wish that after a hard day at the steel mill he had been able to develop a taste for the Delta blues or Highland folk, but it was not to be.

JAORE said...

Around 1990 our middle son came in the house all excited about the new song he'd just heard. It was Lou Reed with Walk on the Wild Side.
We laughed.
As another example "Fast Car" became a country music hit and re-started Tracy Chapman's career.

JAORE said...

FWIW the stick figure dancing to Peggy Lee's music does nothing for me. I'll take the real thing.

John henry said...

I love Peggy Lee. Is that all there is has to be her all time best of many great songs. Brings tears every time I hear it.

Is that all there is to life? Spend 78 years doing all sorts of cool stuff and wind up a commenter on a blog?

John Henry

Peachy said...

Most modern pop music is devoid of creativity. It's like the style section in a pathetic NY magazine.

Peachy said...

"The good is more heavily concentrated in the old. "
Yes.

narciso said...

music had soul then, the series has all sorts of wrong about it,

mezzrow said...

How hot is this? Hehehehe...
Why Don't You Do Right - Peggy Lee w/ Benny Goodman Orchestra (1943)

John henry said...

Back in the 80s or 90s David Lee Roth had a big hit with "Just a Gigolo"

One day we were riding around in the car and I had a Louis Prima CD going. Just a Gigolo was Louis and Keely's theme song.

Son wanted to know who was that covering David Lee Roth.

I still listen to Louis and Keely fairly regularly. Still watch old videos just to see her. Long ago I wanted to grow up and marry her.

I was listening to her just the other day, some tunes I have of her after she left Louis. She really doesn't hold up well on her own. She was Cher without Sonny.

For the younger folk, Sonny and Cher modeled their act, though not their music, on Louis and Keely.

And here is Just a Gigolo https://youtu.be/QSGVD2DgWy8?feature=shared

(Can I get a witness, Sam?)

John Henry

John henry said...

Didn't PDJT say that he was going to rename Kennedy Center to Trump Center?

John Henry

Sean Gleeson said...

I love Peggy Lee's voice, but I never can forgive her for butchering the lyrics of "Fever" (the original was by Little Willie John in 1953). The "Pocahontas" verse is so wrong that I grate my teeth every time I hear it. No, dammit, she did not marry Captain Smith!

MadTownGuy said...

Not Peggy Lee, but a reimagining of "Fever:"
https://youtu.be/VoIZQh1IjI8?si=bh8TgGpv51iIAbGC

narciso said...

its like the song that punctuates 'endgame' which came out after steve rogers went into the ice,

Scott M said...

Most modern pop music is devoid of creativity. It's like the style section in a pathetic NY magazine.

True, but there is a lot of modern music that isn't pop or rap or country that is very innovative and original. The problem is that we might not get another icon. The music industry is nothing if not horribly diffused now.

tcrosse said...

I await the return of the music of my youth: early Elvis, Little Richard, Jerry Lee Lewis, Chuck Berry.

John henry said...

Thanks, Mezzrow. Just what I needed to wast some time while I need to be working!

And after Peggy, I got a 10 minute clip from the movie Sun Valley Seranade Glenn Mill with Tex Beinecke and the Modernaires, Dorothy Dandridge and the Nicholas Brothers.

Now back to work.

John Henry

n.n said...

Jennifer Rush - The Power Of Love

Céline Dion - The Power Of Love

Google got a googol hits through it's crossreferencing algorithm... over time and space.

wild chicken said...

Every day I listen to Like a Rolling Stone...what a groundbreaking record that was. What must the Beatles have thought when they first heard it, and going on for 6 minutes?

It's like a prototype rap song, barely sung, with such a great internal rhyme and phrasing that just barely hangs on by the seat of its pants. And Dylan's voice is just so OUT there, like a boss. Not buried like so many other vocal tracks were back then.

50 years ago... Time to listen to it again.

mryan said...

Some artists are timeless. Peggy Lee is one of those artists.

tonyg said...

My 35 year old daughter has these three albums displayed over her vinyl collection:
Nyro - Christmas and the Beads of Sweat (released 1970)
Mitchell - Circle Game (1970)
Emmylou - Pieces of the Sky (1976)
As others have written, some music just hold up.
PS. She can’t believe that none of her friends know who Dusty Springfield is.

Roger von Oech said...

Speaking of the past and present:
Let’s say Happy 80th birthday (b. 14 Aug, 1945) to one of my favorite directors, the German: #WimWenders. I recently re-watched Wings of Desire, Alice in the Streets, Kings of the Road, and The American Friend.

Narr said...

That was nice. I didn't recall that the lyrics included the word 'forsooth.'

And I'll give the lyricist a break on the Pocahontas verse.

Enigma said...

Tony Bennett came back generation after generation. He had so much raw talent that anyone who heard him the first time appreciated his talent. This lasted even when he was very elderly and creaky of voice.

I went through a Sinatra -- Bennett -- Peggy Lee and similar pop vocals phase long, long after their primes and after many of the old time performers were dead. Before AutoTune and when the record companies had to front $$$$$$$ to get new music out the door and on radio, the performers had to be great. Not just good, great. It still shows in their output.

The mainstream technical quality filter started to break down with independent studios by the 1970s (e.g., punk rock) and then evaporated by the year 2000 with DIY home productions and self-released streaming content. Some of the newer stuff is great and equal to anything that came before, but you must dig to find it and filter it yourself.

Narr said...

I was a bit surprised and pleased a while back to find that my son (mid-30s at the time) and his buds were fans of early Jethro Tull.

Wilbur said...

@John Henry
Prima was great, but not for everybody's taste. The Vegas recordings with Sam Butera were classics.

ga6 said...

Norma Deloris Egstrom Jamestown, North Dakota

rhhardin said...

Back when I had a working phase-steered 8-element active array for AM radio, for picking Imus out of the noise wherever he went, I could null away a local station, and then null away another semi-local station under that, and hear a distant station on the same frequency. The general rule, if you null away enough local AM stations, was that you got polka music underneath.

Sebastian said...

"But then I love going back to the 1920s . . .The good is more heavily concentrated in the old." But then I love going back to the 1820s and the 1720s. The good is more heavily concentrated in the very old.

Indigo Red said...

Oh, for a '60s pop radio station again. One never really knew what genre song was coning next. Rollings Stones followed by Paul Mauriat followed by The Turtles followed by The Singing Nun. You just never knew.

Colleen Brown said...

My favorite Peggy Lee performance - Why Don't You Do Right? with the Benny Goodman orchestra 1943. Check it out on YouTube. I'm a1960s person. I agree with wild chicken about Like a Rolling Stone.

john mosby said...

Scott M: "the so-far-excellent new Alien Earth series. They dropped in Tool's iconic "Stinkfist" for the second episode's end credits "

And for the first ep, they finished with RJD/Sabs' Mob Rules.

RR (Rocka Rolla)
JSM

Enigma said...

@Indigo Red: "Oh, for a '60s pop radio station again. One never really knew what genre song was coning next."

Two words to solve this problem for you:

Streaming playlists

Heartless Aztec said...

I play curated music for my students when they are doing worksheets. Music they would never hear otherwise. Big Band, Ray Charles, Bach, Beatles, Helen Forrest, Frank Sinatra, Supremes, etc. In one period as they were quietly working a young lady of appx 15 years old told me that song we had just listened to was the most beautiful song she had ever heard: "She's Leaving Home" by the Beatles. She had tears in her eyes. Music does indeed sooth the savage teenager.

The Vault Dweller said...

I think CCR put out some updated videos for their songs a few years back. I'm glad for that. CCR feels like real Americana that should last the test of time.

The Vault Dweller said...

The women in the new video are a bit too scantily clad for that Peggy Lee song. There is a fine line between sultry and slutty.

rehajm said...

Talking Heads new Psycho Killer video pushed to me the other day. It’s some stressed out woman in a pseudo Groundhog Day scenario. She’s stressed but not psycho and doesn’t kill anyone…

The Vault Dweller said...

"rehajm said...
Talking Heads new Psycho Killer video pushed to me the other day."

I think there is a video of Psycho Killer with cuts from the Jeffrey Dahmer Mini-Series, or show or whatever it was. It is much better.

Skeptical Voter said...

Fever was written by Otis Blackwell--and was originally written for and recorded by Litttle Willie John. Blackwell's songs helped get Rock n Roll--the music of the 50s and early 60s off the ground. "Fever---Don't Be Cruel--Return to Sender-Handy Man-Great Balls of Fire--Breathless". Wikipedia claims Blackwell wrote a thousand songs, which appeared on 200 million records. Now Blackwell was a black man from New York City. But a lot of Jewish kids were writing the stuff right there with Blackwell. Leiber and Stoller and Doc Pomus come to mind. The music was all good.

Christy said...

Allison Young, https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=e_0XSTQ61UI&t=83s&pp=2AFTkAIB0gcJCf8Ao7VqN5tD did a totally different cover of Fever. She does a lot of old songs and has a decent following. Also some Postmodern Jukebox performances.

RCOCEAN II said...

There's your music, there's your parents music, and there's everything else. As for Peggy Lee, I like her a lot. Someone already mentioned her singing "why don't you do right". I'd add:

Black Coffee
Siamese Cat Song
Blues in the Night (with Goodman)
Manana
Waitin for the Train to come in
I dont know enough about you (another light song)

Peggy Lee could really sing it all. She had great range but didn't have the warmth and power of Doris Day.

RCOCEAN II said...

Oh and "I dont want to play in your yard" - a perfect example of slowing a tune down and underselling it.

RCOCEAN II said...

i frankly don't care what music my daughter listens to. Its not like she's listening to me sing. I grew up in the 70s, that's "My Generations music" and I hated it.

Post a Comment

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.