Someone must have been watching very carefully to witness that turn of unlikely events that could not have spanned even half a minute, which begs the question: Why did that witness fail to extinguish that nascent conflagration when it just matter of stomping it out?
I can only picture Maxwell Smart after telling this story saying "Would you believe...?"
I have seen osprey's carrying some decent sized fish. They screech with pride and climb, showing them off, saying, I guess, "Look what a great provider I would be for your hatchlings!" in osprey speak, but it almost seems like it would take a good sized musky, or a sturgeon to do this, and those fish don't hang out near the surface where an osprey or bald eagle, or whatever, could grab them. This fish would need some serious length. A 30 inch northern would not do it, I don't think, and I doubt that an osprey gets airborne with one of those.
"I have seen osprey's carrying some decent sized fish."
As have I. However, I point out that osprey's aren't born with the competence of breeding adults at catching and holding on to their prey. At this time of year, at least half of the osprey's we observe are juveniles–independent but sexually immature birds who nevertheless lack the fully honed skills of their parents. On average, an adult osprey misses more often than it succeeds. In the majority of tries either the fish completely escapes or is dropped after being caught. Sometimes–I would say rarely–the prey is lost due to harassment by a competitor, typically an eagle. More often the loss occurs while the osprey endeavors to get a firm grip with both feet on the struggling and very slippery prey. Ornithologists may disagree on the odds, but they're no better than one chance out of three that a fish will be caught and eaten by an adult, by a recently fledged juvenile, call it one chance in five if not worse.
The only thing unusual about this is the sparks and the brush fire.
Bob B: Karen Bass probably shudders whenever she hears of a fish being snatched away by an eagle or osprey. Wouldn't you if you had a fish name? (Assuming you don't. From statistical probability, I'm guessing the third B in 'Bob B' does not stand for Bass, Barb, Barracuda, Blowfish, or Blobfish.)
I was fishing on the Madison- wading. Second hook up of the day an osprey swooped down and stole my fish off the line. For a brief moment I wondered what would happen when the slack went out- mary poppins? No- hook fell out. The guide had to call her husband- never saw before. Later in the day we’re floating and some trash is in the river. Guide rows over and I fish it out- a Big Sky pilsner type beer in a Simms coozie. Fish paid me back I say. Good trade the natives would say…later the story regaled to and printed by Big Sky magazine- I was one half of ‘middle aged couple’ as reported by our guide…
If a fish falls into power lines in the forest with no one to hear or see it, does it make a sound (or a bullshit obviously fabricated but unquestioningly reported NYT story)? Was Christopher Steele the source?
"...The fish struck power lines, producing sparks that landed on dry grass and ignited the blaze, which took up less than an acre....."
Yes, there's a picture of a charred fish there. There's no comment saying anything about feathers though. Although there's a picture of the evidence, it's hard to fathom how a fish caused sparks. Wouldn't it have to be large enough to span between two lines, to cause a short? Not seeing how it happened - I think it's more likely that the osprey landed on a transformer, where the high-tension leads are actually pretty close together. Now that would have caused some sparks, maybe blown up the transformer, too. Lots of oil in transformers.
During snook season I fish along the bank of the intercoastal waterway using 8 to 10 inch live mullet as bait. I have learned to look for osprey before casting but they will spot the mullet if they get back into water less than 6 feet deep. It does create momentary excitement when he tries to fly with the fish. The osprey can pull a rod out of a rod holder very quickly if the bail trips.
The subject of power lines causing wildfires is big here in California. I'm very skeptical about the possibility of that happening, however 2 of the Electricity providers in the state have been found liable for that very thing. The Eaton fire is being blamed on a power wire structure. The Palisades fire was also blamed on power wires initially, but now they think it was fireworks that sparked the calamity. The Governor now wants all ratepayers to pay a little extra to buff up a Damages fund.
Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.
I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
Encourage Althouse by making a donation:
Make a 1-time donation or set up a monthly donation of any amount you choose:
40 comments:
I pretty much guarantee there was a Bald Eagle involved.
Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass thinks, why didn’t I think of that excuse?
Someone must have been watching very carefully to witness that turn of unlikely events that could not have spanned even half a minute, which begs the question: Why did that witness fail to extinguish that nascent conflagration when it just matter of stomping it out?
Poor osprey just tryna cook his fish and ends up starting a grill fire. I can relate.
“Officials say a flying osprey dropped its catch, which then struck power lines, causing sparks that ignited dry grass.”
And that osprey learned how to cook its dinner. Others will learn from its example— ospreys are smart birds.
Big Windmill is out to create bird hate. That way they can kill more birds. I knew it.
The gods got a little crazy, didn't they.
thats the story they are going with, a little Rube Goldberg
A whale tale handmade for publishing.
I betcha they blamed global warming not british columbia's forest management program,
The gulls must be jesting.
This reminds me of Frank's encounter with a corkscrew pasta. A hundred to one, doc. Publishes on Seinfeld's guide to planet Gaia.
That’s why we have cats.
yeah but no one keeps ospreys as pets,
Holy mackeral.
I'd love to know how many NYT comments appeared before Trump's name was evoked.
Sounds like we 'ave a Final Destination plot point!
I can only picture Maxwell Smart after telling this story saying "Would you believe...?"
I have seen osprey's carrying some decent sized fish. They screech with pride and climb, showing them off, saying, I guess, "Look what a great provider I would be for your hatchlings!" in osprey speak, but it almost seems like it would take a good sized musky, or a sturgeon to do this, and those fish don't hang out near the surface where an osprey or bald eagle, or whatever, could grab them. This fish would need some serious length. A 30 inch northern would not do it, I don't think, and I doubt that an osprey gets airborne with one of those.
Maybe a bald eagle that snagged a floating dead walleye or something.
...and that's what happened to my homework assignment.
Act Of God.
"I have seen osprey's carrying some decent sized fish."
As have I. However, I point out that osprey's aren't born with the competence of breeding adults at catching and holding on to their prey. At this time of year, at least half of the osprey's we observe are juveniles–independent but sexually immature birds who nevertheless lack the fully honed skills of their parents. On average, an adult osprey misses more often than it succeeds. In the majority of tries either the fish completely escapes or is dropped after being caught. Sometimes–I would say rarely–the prey is lost due to harassment by a competitor, typically an eagle. More often the loss occurs while the osprey endeavors to get a firm grip with both feet on the struggling and very slippery prey. Ornithologists may disagree on the odds, but they're no better than one chance out of three that a fish will be caught and eaten by an adult, by a recently fledged juvenile, call it one chance in five if not worse.
The only thing unusual about this is the sparks and the brush fire.
They screech with pride and climb, showing them off, saying, I guess, "Look what a great provider I would be for your hatchlings!" in osprey speak
Ha. I can attest they all do this.:
Bob B:
Karen Bass probably shudders whenever she hears of a fish being snatched away by an eagle or osprey. Wouldn't you if you had a fish name? (Assuming you don't. From statistical probability, I'm guessing the third B in 'Bob B' does not stand for Bass, Barb, Barracuda, Blowfish, or Blobfish.)
"A FIsh Falls From the Sky" would be a good title for a Hoagy Charmichael song.
That story sounds fishy to me.
I was fishing on the Madison- wading. Second hook up of the day an osprey swooped down and stole my fish off the line. For a brief moment I wondered what would happen when the slack went out- mary poppins? No- hook fell out. The guide had to call her husband- never saw before. Later in the day we’re floating and some trash is in the river. Guide rows over and I fish it out- a Big Sky pilsner type beer in a Simms coozie. Fish paid me back I say. Good trade the natives would say…later the story regaled to and printed by Big Sky magazine- I was one half of ‘middle aged couple’ as reported by our guide…
You have to think about the turtle on the fence post. It didn't get there by itself, so, the surmise about the bird.
More importantly, you have to think about who had it worse.
1. The turtle on the post slowly dying while waiting for help.
2. The fish on the high wire. Flash fried like Captain D's.
Never give up, Mr. Turtle. At least he a chance.
If a fish falls into power lines in the forest with no one to hear or see it, does it make a sound (or a bullshit obviously fabricated but unquestioningly reported NYT story)? Was Christopher Steele the source?
As we all know by now that "birds aren't real," I think we need to ask who would profit by having their robot cause this conflagration?
Your odds of encountering pescapyromania are small, but greater than zero.
I think it was an owl. Hootie and the Blowupfish.
“A Fish Falls From the Sky and Sparks a Brush Fire in British Columbia.”
I hate it when that happens
Must have been a steelhead.
That Meghan Mackerel will do anything to get attention.
Ave Maria.
I agree with Quaestor @ 2:43 above. A little too convenient for the responsible party.
Just in time for the King of the Hill reboot.
"...The fish struck power lines, producing sparks that landed on dry grass and ignited the blaze, which took up less than an acre....."
Yes, there's a picture of a charred fish there. There's no comment saying anything about feathers though. Although there's a picture of the evidence, it's hard to fathom how a fish caused sparks. Wouldn't it have to be large enough to span between two lines, to cause a short? Not seeing how it happened - I think it's more likely that the osprey landed on a transformer, where the high-tension leads are actually pretty close together. Now that would have caused some sparks, maybe blown up the transformer, too. Lots of oil in transformers.
During snook season I fish along the bank of the intercoastal waterway using 8 to 10 inch live mullet as bait. I have learned to look for osprey before casting but they will spot the mullet if they get back into water less than 6 feet deep. It does create momentary excitement when he tries to fly with the fish. The osprey can pull a rod out of a rod holder very quickly if the bail trips.
The subject of power lines causing wildfires is big here in California. I'm very skeptical about the possibility of that happening, however 2 of the Electricity providers in the state have been found liable for that very thing. The Eaton fire is being blamed on a power wire structure. The Palisades fire was also blamed on power wires initially, but now they think it was fireworks that sparked the calamity. The Governor now wants all ratepayers to pay a little extra to buff up a Damages fund.
Post a Comment
Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.