April 23, 2025

"Five years ago, meat hit a wall. Plant-based burgers were catching on, and the amount of meat the average American ate..."

"... per year started to wane. By 2022, it was down to 264 pounds — a drop of 10 pounds in two years. Editors at the recipe website Epicurious announced in 2021 that beef would be banished from all future content, citing its contribution to greenhouse-gas emissions. That same year, the chef Daniel Humm of Eleven Madison Park in New York City — considered one of the world’s top restaurants — retooled his $335 tasting menu to eliminate animal products. Restaurants of all sorts added vegetarian dishes for environment- and health-minded diners. Meat’s rebound surprised researchers.... The research showed that nearly 98 percent of households buy meat and 73 percent consider it a healthy choice, up 10 percent since 2020."

From "Meat Is Back, on Plates and in Politics/After years in which 'plant-based' was the mantra, meat once again dominates the national conversation about dinner" (NYT).

72 comments:

mccullough said...

Meat plummeted during The Interregnum.

JaimeRoberto said...

I guess the bugs weren't all that tasty.

Quaestor said...

Imperious chefs who get their jollies dictating what the commoners must eat and not eat are just begging for some Jacobin-style haircuts.

Up against the wall, meat martinet!

Michael Fitzgerald said...

This is just another proof-point that people hate libtard policies. Even libtards hate them which is why they so frequently get caught defying them.

Money Manger said...

I'll occasionally have a conversation with my spouse about dinner. I've never had one with the nation. Such a thing doesn't exist.

What silly pompous writing.

Lawnerd said...

I refuse to eat fake meat even though my former boss, who I like and respect, is an exec at impossible foods. I wish them success even though I will not be sampling their wares.

Dr Weevil said...

Seen on Twitter: a picture of various foodstuffs, labeled "Processed food is designed for human consumption. Organic food is just found on the ground somewhere."

Rabel said...

I am convinced that the cattle market is being manipulated.

tcrosse said...

Getting vegetable ingredients to mimic meat involves some heavy duty processing, but the bien pensants are against heavily processed foods. Go figure.

wild chicken said...

Chuck roast is awfully expensive now..I could cry.

William50 said...

I've always thought that real beef was plant based.

Quaestor said...

Imagine paying 335 bucks just to taste a few crumbs of some disgusting shit eaten only by echinoderms when times are desperate? Only a well-heeled Democrat, pockets bursting with stolen taxpayer dollars, wouldn't laugh in Chef Humm's punchable face.

Leland said...

Is the NYP now to take a lap explaining how veganism will be extinct by 2029, 1 year before the world reaches net zero emissions? It is interesting what the New York Times and its readers derive from unrelated survey questions.

5 years ago? That was Covid. They relied on surveys taken during Covid?

n.n said...

Plant-based diets are for ruminants and diet-supplemented vegans.

Ann Althouse said...

"By 2022, it was down to 264 pounds...."

That still sounds awfully high!

It's 0.72 pounds a day. Weird to view that as our waning appetite for meat.

loudogblog said...

Trying to make plant based foods look like meat is as dumb as trying to make meat look like vegtables.

There are plenty of great plant based dishes out there already.

But the people who were pushing plant based foods assumed that the buying public was so stupid that they wouldn't be able to tell the difference between plant based foods and meat dishes.

The real tell that the plant based market would crash and burn was the bargain bins at the supermarkets. In my local Vons, almost all the frozen foods in the 50% off section are plant based foods. (And it's been that way for a few years.)

Skeptical Voter said...

If the cattle herd is down (and it is) all of us will be eating less beef. OTOH if China stops buying US pork we will be enjoying more bacon and pork chops.

Narr said...

Meat good. Eat it up!

Ambrose said...

You can’t use the pandemic year 2020 as a baseline year for anything.

BUMBLE BEE said...

The beef at my market seems too lean. Fat is flavor and I think the cattle feeding practices-have changed due to the costs. Warm weather grilling is here.

Rabel said...

Meat's back! Fur's back too!

I see a plan coming together.

doctrev said...

Well, what did they think would happen? If President Trump makes beef cheaper for the working man, especially if the Chinese are dumb enough to maintain tariffs on American food, no one is going to buy into soy and garbage unless they are NPCs like Rich or Freder.

doctrev said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Martin said...

The plant based burgers were one of the worst things ever made from a nutrition point of view.

rehajm said...

You can’t use the pandemic year 2020 as a baseline year for anything.

No you cannot. It has forever perverted and distorted annual data, never to be recovered…

Narr said...

A brief digression on Western vs Eastern cuisine, from Burgess's "Earthly Powers" (the gay Brit protagonist is visiting Malaya)

' . . . I mean, a Western banquet recapitulates the history of the earth from primal broth through sea beasts to land predators and flying creatures and ends with evidence of human culture in cheese and artful puddings. Mahalingam's dinner was all brutal surprises.'

Not sure about the predators, but anyway it's a brilliant passage.

Josephbleau said...

The smart kids are going long on natural leather bondage harnesses.

edutcher said...

Proof the Davos crowd has lost. Thank you once again, Donald Trump.

Cardiac Jack said...

Our ancestors did not claw their way to the top of the food chain so that we could eat tofu.

Lucien said...

How was average meat eating measured? Was it total weight of all meat sold divided by population? Was there a survey asking people to estimate their consumption? How were estimates of wastage factored in? How much of total meat sold is bone & gristle?

rhhardin said...

Morningstar soyburgers and Tyson oven roasted diced chicken breast are my diet.

Dude1394 said...

I bet this guy "chef Daniel Humm" doesn't eat vegetable meat.

Jupiter said...

"It's 0.72 pounds a day. Weird to view that as our waning appetite for meat."
Yeah, especially since that's per American, including little babies and women who eat like birds. It's almost like the New York Times just made that number up. Same as everything else they publish.

Randomizer said...

"Blamed for poor health, implicated in climate change and attacked for cruelty to animals, it played the villain while plant-based burgers, grain bowls and four-star vegan dishes took their star turn."

Somebody should explain to the NYT that we no longer believe the "experts" who were harping about those issues. Many of us would like to see their grant funding cut.

We all spent time living in crazy town, and didn't enjoy.

MikeD said...

Bumble Bee re: lean beef. The lesser the grade of beef, the leaner it is. Choice has more fat than Good and Prime has more fat than Choice. BTW the fat is in the marbling of the cut, not the exterior strip.

Bart Hall (Kansas, USA) said...

"Plant-based" meat replacements are some of the most highly-processed foods that exist.

Also, let's not forget that cattle are Solar-powered Grass Combines, and most of the world's grasslands are not suitable for planting row crops or grains.

mezzrow said...

"meat's meat, and man's got to eat." - Farmer Vincent

bagoh20 said...

Us carnivores would never force everyone to eat meat, but vegans would fillet and roast us if that's what it took to end us. I think it's envy.

Original Mike said...

"Five years ago, meat hit a wall. Plant-based burgers were catching on, and the amount of meat the average American ate..."
"... per year started to wane. By 2022, it was down to 264 pounds — a drop of 10 pounds in two years."


Yeah, that's 3.6%. Some wall.

bagoh20 said...

"Five years ago meat hit a wall."
I'm doing better now, almost completely healed.

Howard said...

Joe Rogan podcast approves this message. Jordan Peterson seconds.

boatbuilder said...

Yeah. People got hungry. Veggies make you feel "virtuous," but you're still hungry.
Also bacon will overcome "virtue" most of the time.

Howard said...

The carnivore diet is a good and relatively easy way to start an elimination diet. I have heard that a trotting phase may be required for a time.

Mr. D said...

A lot of people are eating Keto. Not the whole story, but certainly a trend that moves the averages back up.

Howard said...

Green and fiber containing veggies don't make you hungry like rice pasta bread pizza sugar. I like a combination of lacto-ovo, vegan, carnivore, fruitarian, pescararian and fermentarian.

boatbuilder said...

You can’t use the pandemic year 2020 as a baseline year for anything.

No you cannot. It has forever perverted and distorted annual data, never to be recovered…


Not only the data. It destroyed the comfortable fiction that institutional "Science" is apolitical and concrete. "Climate Science" had it down and struggling to breathe. Covid put it down for good.

There is good science being done (I suppose). But I trust none of it.



Dave Begley said...

Another liberal failure.

tommyesq said...

Is it 0.72 pounds of actual, end product meat per person, or meat on the hoof (i.e. 0.72 pounds of pre-slaughter beef or chicken)? Huge difference. Where do eggs fit in this? Does NYT not remember that meat became largely unavailable for significant parts of 2020, and that people weren't eating tofu and elegant vegan, but instead mac n cheese because it was on the shelves? Are they simply kind of dumb?

Jim at said...

Why do they make plant-based burgers taste like ......... meat?

I kid, kinda.

I have many SDA friends I've known for nearly 50 years and I've eaten their vegetarian meals for nearly as long. Mixed dishes, stuffed mushrooms and things like that are delicious. And I always go back for more.

But they know better than to serve me veggie burgers, lentil loaf or facon.

And when they visit? I can make a lot of dishes that don't include meat or veggie meat.

Live and let live.

Jupiter said...

"Are they simply kind of dumb?"
Lying liars lie and lie,
Doo-dah! Doo-dah!
Lying liars lie and lie,
Oh, the doo-dah-day!

Jupiter said...

Gwine to lie all night,
Gwine to lie all day.
All the lies that's fit to print,
Oh, the doo-dah day!

Earnest Prole said...

If God didn’t want us to eat animals he wouldn’t have made them out of meat.

wildswan said...

Here's what they ate in the 19th century according to Mrs. Beeton. Dinner with a Guest.

MENUS FOR GUESTS’ SUPPERS.
(Summer.)
Lobsters.
Mayonnaise of Chicken.
Cold Lamb.
Salad, Cucumber.
Mint Sauce.
Raspberry Cream.
Fruit Tart.
Custard.
Fruit. Cake.
Claret. Sherry.

(Winter.)
Fish Rissoles.
Hashed Pheasant.
Cold Turkey.
Ham.
Salad.
Stewed Fruit.
Mince Pies.
Jelly.
Cheese Biscuits.
Claret. Sherry.

You notice there are several meat dishes though I believe they had menus at the table so you could plan which dishes to choose and which to leave.

And here's the vegetarian menus:
Summer
Green Pea Soup.
Savoury Macaroni.
Vegetable Pie.
Compote of Fruit.
Ratafia Pudding.

II.
Macaroni Soup.
Haricot Beans and Onion Sauce.
Green Peas.
Raspberry and Currant Tart.
Custard.
Celery Salad.

Winter.
I.
Lentil Soup.
Forcemeat Fritters.
Potato Pie. Fried Cabbage.
Apple Tart.
Tapiooa and Milk.

II.
Maize Meal Porridge.
Lentil Rissoles.
Carrot Pudding.
Macaroni and Tomatoes.
Plum Pudding.
Cheese Sandwiches.

I really notice how little cheese and fresh fruit there is in Mrs. Beeton's vegetarian menu since the vegetarians I knew had a lot of both.

https://archive.org/details/b21533489/page/281/mode/1up?view=theater

wendybar said...

My husband and I ate at Eleven Madison Park back when we still went into the city when it was safe before Progressives destroyed it.
It was excellent, and WE had meat with our prix-fix meal before the left denounced it.
Why is it the Progressives ruin everything??

Enigma said...

Plant based = ultra processed, and thereby in the no-no group.

Read the ingredients lists on this stuff.

Chris said...

The left literally wants to starve you to death. And you will feel good about yourself for dying the entire time.

stlcdr said...

Less than a 5 percent drop in consumption, based on their numbers, constitutes an up trend in plant-based (sic) burgers? During a tim3 where people we losing their jobs due to government ineptness?

Do they also believe the rise in temperature in the morning will lead us all to a boiling death by 5pm? (Hmm, ignore that, because they actually do).

Curious George said...

"Ann Althouse said...
"By 2022, it was down to 264 pounds...."

That still sounds awfully high!

It's 0.72 pounds a day. Weird to view that as our waning appetite for meat."

A little less than 12 oz a day doesn't seem that much.

Bob Boyd said...

A little less than 12 oz a day doesn't seem that much.

In the NYT, if Americans are doing something, it's bad and needs to change...no, it needs to be changed by the government.

tim maguire said...

Curious George said...A little less than 12 oz a day doesn't seem that much.

If I had a ham sandwich for lunch and a burger or steak for dinner, it would probably add up to about that and I wouldn't describe my day as being a big meat day But for a daily average, that seems like a lot to me. Far more than would cause a rational person to conclude vegetarianism is triumphant.

Kirk Parker said...

> Are they simply kind of dumb?

They are entirely dishonest.

jim said...

Is this the next perpetual indignation campaign on Fox etc?

War on meat joins war on christmas joins war on gas lights.

lgv said...

Illogical trends tend to regress over time. Going meatless for greenhouse gases is ridiculous when you look at it on a global basis. The entire world can't go meatless and survive.
Getting protein from non-meat sources is difficult, costly, and inefficient.

The plant based meat substitute is now viewed negatively due to the additives and the process itself. One trend kills off another.

The growth of EVs has also waned due to various realities. Shows with tiny homes seem to have disappeared as well.

Jamie said...

My husband is on a sales committee for the Houston Livestock Show and Rodeo (which, for those who aren't familiar with it, generated over $27 million for education in 2024, $14 million of that in scholarships for Texas kids). Donors can receive a certain amount of their donation back in gift cards to be used at one of a few butchers. As a result of our donation, our freezer is jam-packed with meat at present, steaks, chicken, marinated beef and chicken for fajitas, three kinds of sausages, and we only have until June 30 (I think that's the date) to use up last year's money, so I think our household consumption is going to skew the results for a while.

For our final meat order in a month and a half, we'll be concentrating on steaks. We needed the sausages in this shipment for a themed gathering we have coming up.

Mike (MJB Wolf) said...

No mention of the biggest bug-eating proponent Klaus Schwab giving up his scandal-ridden job at the WEF?

Koot Katmandu said...

"By 2022, it was down to 264 pounds...."
I am with you Ann that sounds way to high. I doubt most American's even eat half of that number. I wonder what they are counting as meat?

stlcdr said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
stlcdr said...

Is on-the-bone chicken included in that weight?

Anthony said...

I've bought the non-meat burgers, when they were like 50% off. Well, I got them once to see what they were like, and I quite enjoyed them. Nice to have some in the freezer in case you didn't plan dinner in advance; they thaw out quickly. I don't see them as 'fake meat' necessarily, just another potential thing to eat.

mikee said...

Protein is chosen based on available money to buy it. The type of meat is then chosen based on how often you can afford the ribeyes or pork ribs versus the bulk pack of chicken. The BBQ grill will do them each to a state of deliciousness with a little bit of effort.

Freeman Hunt said...

I like the non-meat burgers too. They're in the rotation. I am also skeptical that Americans eat an average of almost 3/4 a pound of meat every day.

Sotarr the Wizard said...

I remember when Burger King introduced the 'Impossible Whopper', and had a 2-for-1 deal, buy a real Whopper, get an Impossible Whopper as well. I ordered it, both burgers the same way.

The Impossible Whopper was decent, but didnt even come close to the **real** (i.e. actual meat) Whopper. ..

Post a Comment

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.