October 13, 2024

"I want to flag one case that’s really funny to me, Nuclear Regulatory Commission v. Texas. It’s sort of like the chickens coming home to roost..."

"... for the Supreme Court. A few years ago, the court made up the 'major questions doctrine,' the principle that when an agency makes a decision that involves a 'major question,' courts have a free-floating veto to block it. Well, the 5th Circuit used this doctrine to blow up the entire system of nuclear waste storage in this country, possibly forever.... The 5th Circuit sided with Texas in this case, declaring that the commission is actually powerless to grant licenses for the temporary storage of nuclear waste offsite from the plant... not because federal law says the commission can’t do that... [but because] temporary storage is a 'major question' because it involves nuclear material. And... Congress has to come in and authorize it even more clearly....Because the question 'has been hotly politically contested for over a half century.'"

Says Mark Joseph Stern, in "The Supreme Court Takes a Nuclear Waste Case Almost Too Wild to Believe" (Slate).

8 comments:

Leland said...

It seems Democracy doesn’t work because it is hard, but worse, our Supreme Court won’t allow the easy short cuts.

I think Matt Taibbi is right. Our elites are not and therefore not up to the task of leading us.

rehajm said...

Sounds to me like a call for ‘Cleanup on Capitol Hill’.

Dave Begley said...

Neal Katyal was in Omaha last week about was whining and bitching about how Chevron was overruled.

tim maguire said...

Anybody else notice how upset Democrats get when power is put in the hands of people who can be held accountable?

Mikey NTH said...

Tim for a show called "Return to Yucca Mountain".

Wince said...

I remember when the left would have called the siting of nuclear waste repository a “big fucking deal.”

Kate said...

If SCOTUS spends 20% of its docket on 5th Circuit cases decided by those nasty Trump appointees, then good. The court is supposed to clarify the law, especially when it's vague and the deep state has gone too far.

Kate said...

Yucca Mtn may be in the middle of nowhere, but the train lines for delivering the waste all go through the heart of Vegas. It was a haphazard plan forced on a state the coastal elites consider a desert wasteland. Congress may try it again and Reid is no longer around to stop them. Vegas has more clout now, though. Some other Western state will have to get the shaft.