March 22, 2019

"The only thing easier than beating the Klan in court... was raising money off Klan-fighting from liberals up north

"... who still had fresh visions of the violent confrontations of the sixties in their heads. The S.P.L.C. got a huge publicity boost in July, 1983, when three Klansmen firebombed its headquarters. A melted clock from the burned-down building, stuck at 3:47 a.m., is featured in the main lobby of the Montgomery office today. In 1987, the center won a landmark seven-million-dollar damage judgment against the Klan; a decade later, in 1998, it scored a thirty-eight-million-dollar judgment against Klansmen who burned down a black church in South Carolina. With those victories, Dees claimed the right to boast into perpetuity that the S.P.L.C. had effectively 'shut down' the K.K.K. By the time I touched down in Montgomery [in 2001], the center had increased its staff and branched out considerably—adding an educational component called Teaching Tolerance and expanding its legal and intelligence operations to target a broad range of right-wing groups and injustices—but the basic formula perfected in the eighties remained the same. The annual hate-group list, which in 2018 included a thousand and twenty organizations, both small and large, remains a valuable resource for journalists and a masterstroke of Dees’s marketing talents; every year, when the center publishes it, mainstream outlets write about the 'rising tide of hate' discovered by the S.P.L.C.’s researchers, and reporters frequently refer to the list when they write about the groups. As critics have long pointed out, however, the hate-group designations also drive attention to the extremists. Many groups, including the religious-right Family Research Council and the Alliance Defending Freedom, raise considerable money by decrying the S.P.L.C.’s 'attacks.'"

From "The Reckoning of Morris Dees and the Southern Poverty Law Center" by Bob Moser in The New Yorker.

24 comments:

Amadeus 48 said...

SPLC is a criminal enterprise and they should have all their assets seized as part of a racketeering prosecution.

I was seated at a charity benefit for Chicago theater group next to an old lady who announced with a certain smug sanctimony that her largest annual charitable gifts went to SPLC. I wanted to scream, "Are you crazy?" at her, but good manners prevailed. But I did decide to be more selective as to which events I go to.

Kevin said...

The only thing easier than beating the Klan is beating yourself.

(Should be read with an FDR voice.)

David Begley said...

Cause to a racket. Eric Hofer.

And global warming is the biggest racket of all time.

rhhardin said...

Being on the hate group list is a mark of courage, at least if you're not retired.

It means staying on the right in spite of having been corrected on the matter.

TrespassersW said...

“Until justice rolls down like dollars.” That's golden.

And when you know that it was the employees making those jokes... (One wonders who was holding a gun to their heads, forcing them to keep working for an outfit that they knew was just a way of separating gullible donors from their money?)

Anonymous said...

"As critics have long pointed out, however, the hate-group designations also drive attention to the extremists. Many groups, including the religious-right Family Research Council and the Alliance Defending Freedom, raise considerable money by decrying the S.P.L.C.’s 'attacks'."

Ah, I see. That's the problem with government and journalists using the SPLC as their go-to "expert" source: The reaction of extremist haters to the SPLC's quote-unquote attacks. Not the non-quote-unquote attacks on the quote-unquote hateful opinions of half the citizens of the country, and the organizations these quote-unquote hateful extremist citizens form to advance their quote-unquote extremist views.

The Godfather said...

The article uses scare quotes to refer to the SPLC's "attacks" on the Family Research Council and the Alliance Defending Freedom. SPLC calls the Family Research Center a "hate group" and says the Alliance Defending Freedom "spreads demonizing lies". I think it would be accurate to call those statements attacks (no scare quotes) on those organizations, don't you?

Bob Boyd said...

The SPLC is a primo example of Eric Hoffer's dictum,
“Every great cause begins as a movement, becomes a business, and eventually degenerates into a racket.”

iowan2 said...

The focus of article wants to be about bad behavior by Dees. Ignoring the SPLC is nothing but an old time country scam that the media is its willing PR firm, working without pay.

Paul Zrimsek said...

That person who said "And you call yourself a journalist!" to Moser had a point. That's quite a story to be sitting on for 15 years.

CWJ said...

"The annual hate-group list, which in 2018 included a thousand and twenty organizations..."

That by itself is defining hate down to meaninglessness.

Jeff Brokaw said...

All those groups unfairly tarnished by the SPLC’s vicious and corrupt hate campaign ... what line do they get in to get their reputations back?

Anonymous said...

Teaching Tolerance is a re-education regime imposed on nearly all schoolchildren.

The latest Teaching Tolerance campaign promotes the scary lie that electing Trump led to a "tidal wave" (always a tidal wave) of so-called "hate crimes" presumed in the report to be committed by Trump supporters, though no perpetrators were caught. Curiously, these crimes occurred mostly in places like elementary school playgrounds.

Or, not so curious: the SPLC gathered this "data" from K-12 teachers who personally choose to subscribe to SPLC publications (using our money) and who "self-reported" such horrific incidents as the appearance of graffiti with the words "Heil Trump" or classroom incidents where some children reported nightmares after Trump's election.

It's like Jussie Smollet teaching your kids. And yes, we do pay for this stuff. Ever since the FBI kicked the SPLC off its hate crime advisor list and cut off the money advisor groups get to "train" prosecutors and judges and police, they have harvested much of their money through K-12 schools buying Teaching Tolerance.

Mao would be so proud. Always get'em through the little ones.

robother said...

Biglaw? Pshaw, the really big bucks are in Poverty Law.

David53 said...

“If you’re outraged about the path President Trump is taking, I urge you to join us in the fight against the mainstreaming of hate,” a direct-mail appeal signed by Dees last year read. “Please join our fight today with a gift of $25, $35, or $100 to help us. Working together, we can push back against these bigots.”

We were part of the con, and we knew it.


These bigots? Obviously he was talking about anyone who voted for Trump, but like many things it's primarily about the money. The SPLC is worth about half a billion now, they take in way more cash than they spend.

Wince said...

Jerry Garcia’s Iconic ‘Wolf’ Guitar Goes to Auction to Benefit SPLC

Grateful Dead singer’s go-to instrument for nearly two decades will see proceeds go to Southern Poverty Law Center

Jerry Garcia‘s iconic “Wolf” guitar, the Grateful Dead singer’s go-to instrument for nearly two decades, will head to Guernsey’s auction block in late May, with all proceeds from the sale benefitting the Southern Poverty Law Center.

Garcia first brandished the instrument at a private 1973 New York City concert he played for the Hells Angels. From that point on, the guitar – crafted by luthier Doug Irwin before Garcia affixed a sticker of a cartoon wolf below the instrument’s bridge – was utilized in countless Dead performances before retiring it following a February 1993 gig at the Oakland Coliseum.

Irwin reclaimed the “Wolf” guitar years after Garcia’s 1995 death and sold it at a Guernsey’s auction in 2002 to its current owner for over $700,000, then a world record for a guitar. That anonymous owner will now sell the guitar at a May event held at Williamsburg’s Brooklyn Bowl.

“I’ve been a fan of the Dead since I was a kid, and playing this iconic guitar over the past 15 years has been a privilege,” the guitar’s owner said in a statement. “But the time is right for Wolf to do some good. My wife and I have long supported the efforts of the Southern Poverty Law Center, and if ever we needed the SPLC, we sure do need them now.”

The Last Dragon Slayer said...

Interview with the last dragon slayer
Excerpt…
Reporter Kim Weaver: What is the hardest thing about being a dragon slayer?
The Last Dragon Slayer: Resting on my laurels.
RKW: How so?
TLDS: After my first dragon slaying, I could easily have lived the life of a king. Or at least a minor noble. I could bask in my glory. I could have commanded tribute and accepted the gifts of many grateful people.
RKW: That does not sound that bad. Wouldn’t you have earned it? You did slay a dragon, after all.
TLDS: To do so would have diminished my achievement and rotted my soul. My achievement would be null. Maybe not at first, but history would not be kind.
RKW: Rotted your soul? Isn’t that a bit harsh?
TLDS: Not at all. I would become almost as bad as the dragon I slayed. I would generate destruction and calamity as I fed my ego. I would become a dragon who must be slayed, myself. What a sad legacy that would have been.

Static Ping said...

"The annual hate-group list, which in 2018 included a thousand and twenty organizations, both small and large, remains a valuable resource for journalists...

It's not every day that you have a journalist admit that journalists are lazy.

mockturtle said...

It's high time the SPLC was called out for what it is--a lucrative enterprise feeding off ill-informed white liberals while causing innocent persons and groups to lose funding and social media status.

narayanan said...

Prescient woman writing during LBJ era of GREAT SOCIETY

Poverty is where the money is Hardcover – 1968 by Shirley Scheibla (Author)

robother said... Biglaw? Pshaw, the really big bucks are in Poverty Law.

Anonymous said...

Amadeus 48 said...
SPLC is a criminal enterprise and they should have all their assets seized as part of a racketeering prosecution.


while I appreciate the sentiment, as a conservative, I dislike the mechanism. I don't want the government punishing groups like the SPLC. I'm happy for private citizen suits to bankrupt them.

hombre said...

The SPLC is pure evil and it’s supporters are enablers. Presumably, the only reason they haven’t lost more multi-million dollar defamation suits is that their condemnation is a fund-raising boon and a badge of honor for many decent, honorable organizations like Alliance Defending freedom - the recipient of my largest charitable donation and a consistent winner in the Supreme Court against the kind of fascists who fawn over the SPLC.

Big Mike said...

Amadeus (5:23) reminds us that you cannot do northern liberalism withou stupid and smug.

And hate. 21st century liberalism is nothing without hatred.

ken in tx said...

"Ender's Game", in sequels to that novel, Ender became a historical villain, even though he saved human civilization. He was a villain for wiping out the ant based attackers. It was genocide.