Who is Althouse? * View only LAW posts * Contribute * Shop AMAZON*
How is it that the victim has more to lose from reporting a rape than the rapist?
Rape should be a capital crime.
But was it rape-rape?
By far, the most poorly rated comment at that newspaper:"It's her baby too .... Give it to someone who would love to have a baby .. It's not the baby's fault the way it was conceived ."
Leslyn-The problem with making rape a capital crime is that it encourages rapists to kill their victims. They have nothing to lose, and killing the witness makes it less likely that they will be caught.
@John Lynch. Well, there's that.But people who murder others, including in rape, don't seem to think about that consequence much.
It sounds like a forgotten birthday to me.
I'm encouraged by brave women who overcome the barbarity of their religion and government.
"The problem with making rape a capital crime is that it encourages rapists to kill their victims. They have nothing to lose, and killing the witness makes it less likely that they will be caught."It also skews the legal process and prejudices it to punish the women instead of the men.That is why, for a *capital* crime, rape in Islamic countries (or some of them, to be sure) requires something like three witnesses. And it should, don't you think? Someone shouldn't be killed without absolute proof. So they aren't going to kill a man with less than three witnesses. So instead, seeing how she just confessed to being a slut, the woman is punished.My uncle, who was a county deputy sheriff said the same was true of any law that seemed too harsh. If nothing else the cops would ignore it if they could.And so we've got this lady who *probably* had no other real options. And if she is convicted of murder at least her children won't carry the stigmatism of having a mother who was a whore.
Judith would approve.leslyn said...Rape should be a capital crime.It was, dear, until all the Lefties got their way.
Ok.. I guess this means that old guy from Missouri is a neanderthal.. and Althouse is dancing on the ceiling.
The dead guy who made the mistake of forcing her to continue an affair by blackmail (however "voluntary" the first encounter) learned an important lesson.If he's shaming her into continuing because she's trying to protect her public honor and her children's reputation from what he's threatening to reveal to the world... getting her pregnant is a terminally bad idea.
Synova-This reminds me of an old law review article I read in Con Law. The author was making a comparison between torture and plea bargaining.Because medieval law required two witnesses to convict a criminal OR a confession, and because there were never two witnesses, torture became a common way to extract a confession and resolve the case.Our criminal justice system has so many safeguards that it's unworkable so plea bargaining has become the real system, not the jury trial.Make a system unworkable and people work around it.
"That is the head of one who toyed with my honour."Well you go, Girl!Compare that to these clueless sluts and the problem of cultism becomes clear.Soul in a hole, indeed,...
" leslyn said...Rape should be a capital crime."This one was.
That which happens in Yalvac, should stay in Yalvac.
It was literally a capital crime. Via Wikipedia, "The term capital originates from the Latin capitalis, literally "regarding the head" (referring to execution by beheading)."
Good for her, sad for her children, fitting end for the rapist.
" leslyn said...Rape should be a capital crime."leslyn, how would you like to see these rapists executed?
Your mother beheaded your father, and has wanted you dead since you were conceived. That's a bad start to a life.
Rape should be a capital crimeIndeed it was at one time. Caryl_Chessman
leslyn,Rape should be a capital crime.This is short sighted. All this would do is increase the number of dead women. After all, if you're going to get the death penalty for rape, why leave a living victim?
She'd not offered her honorHe dishonored her offerAnd all night longIt was off with his topper
Somewhere between 1 and 3 humans will die because of this. Sex is expensive business if you don't do it right. It's hard to believe it can also be loving, life affirming or casual. Context is everything.
"Somewhere between 1 and 3 humans will die because of this."Truth. And sad.But if the woman is right, at least there will be two children able to grow up without being mercilessly tormented on account of their mother was a slut.That's not nothing.
Well, as we used to say back home in Alabama:That'll learn him.which was often followed by:Some folks just need killin'.
"leslyn, how would you like to see these rapists executed?"Same as any.
Too many situations like this to make it a capital offense
leslyn, how would you like to see these rapists executed?What's interesting is there really seems to be a crackdown on women "rapists". That is to say, women having sex with underage boys.And I guess that's good, for equal justice under the law. And yet I feel way more sympathy for a woman having sex with an underage guy than a man having sex with an underage girl.I'm like, "throw the book at him!"And "let her go!"Totally unfair. There's a huge number of women having sex with underage boys, apparently. What is up with that?Those are not good mug shots, by the way.Although Megan Crafton is hot. And "the victim" was 17. I would totally let her go. Amber Jenkins, also smoking hot. She got probation.Carrie McCandless, way hot. She got 45 days in jail.If I was a prosecutor, I would want an all-female jury in these cases. I'd want an all female jury, a female prosecutor, and a female judge.
Allie,Good for her, sad for her children, fitting end for the rapist.If a woman harassed and raped a man, then the man killed and decapitated the woman, would you say "Good for him"?
"There's a hugenumber of women having sex with underage boys, apparently. What is up with that?"Because they don't want to deal with equals. It would be pretty easy for an experienced older woman to control and pyschologically manipulate a horny 17 year old boy. It's harder to control a man, even a horny one. Any man worth their salt, that is.Meh. I imagine myself sitting on the edge of the bed, listening to some pimply high schooler talk about trying out for the football team and how boring Mrs. Jones the English teacher is and wondering if Taco Bell is hiring...doesn't fill me with erotic longings.
Allie - you are pro capital punishment?
Turkey needs more gun control.
If I were this woman's lawyer, I'd want a jury of praying mantises.
It strikes me as odd that more Muslim women don't kill their rapists, since they will be jailed or honor-killed for being raped. Really, SHE has nothing to lose.
ChipOn the rare occasions when I get you it's worth it. I wish it happened more often.
Hey guys, check out Gerad Hibbs' link at 10:08, and you will feel safe in your superior position in our Patriarchy. Imagine if he had no camera.
New bumper sticker: Don't Mess With Turkish Women.
Did anyone else find the woman's alleged statement that she'd be willing to die so long as she got an abortion, er, damned strange? She could accomplish both things at a stroke, as it were, all by herself. I realize that Islam isn't keen on suicide (except in special cases, as when you can take a bunch of your enemies with you), but then it's not especially keen on abortion either.
Hibbs' link has been smited. "This video has been removed as a violation of YouTube's policy prohibiting content designed to harass, bully or threaten."What was in the video?
Alan,The landlord (hotly dressed female) comes into the apartment telling the renter to leave. He refuses, and she starts acting hysterical yelling that he's trying to rape her and won't let her leave, while he clearly never touches her and the door is open. If he didn't have it on video, it would be his word against hers and her two companions. This is what we call an "illegitimate rape".
Rape should be a capital crime.If you really want rape to be a capital crime, you'll vote Romney.See, in 2008's Kennedy v. Louisiana, Justices Kennedy, Stevens, Souter, Ginsburg, and Breyer said it was unconstitutional for rape to be a capital crime.For rape to be restored to its historical status as a capital crime, we're going to need more justices like Alito, Roberts, Scalia, and Thomas. And Obama isn't going to appoint them.
Firearms even up the physical balance of power between men and women. NOW should be a big ally of the NRA. Given the decades that NOW has has to figure this out I am mystified that it is not.Yours,Tom
Michelle... how would the existence of a bastard sibling impact her other two children in that culture?I couldn't say, but it's a thought.
Post a Comment