February 14, 2024

"[Jon] Stewart intends to host 'The Daily Show' through Election Day. In order to succeed, whoever comes after him will need to avoid the excesses of the format..."

"... that he popularized: so-called clapter comedy, a phrase that has been credited to [Seth] Meyers which describes the kind of jokes that, instead of making audiences laugh, elicit applause by pandering to their preëxisting beliefs. Stewart resorted to such lines at least occasionally during his tenure; in the Trump era, the tactic exploded. The use of clapter as a crutch, and a general ethos against 'punching down' among moral-minded standups, has rendered much of today’s political comedy predictable...."

Writes Inkoo Kang, in "Jon Stewart Knows 'The Daily Show' Can’t Save Democracy/The comedian transformed the late-night landscape before his departure almost a decade ago—and returns to reckon with a nation that’s been transformed, too" (The New Yorker).

62 comments:

CJinPA said...

Surprising take from The New Yorker. And from Seth Meyers, a guy who relied heavily on clapter at SNL.

R C Belaire said...

Eff John Stewart. There. I said it.

Ampersand said...

There's big demand for well packaged political propaganda. Stewart can meet that demand. The left has lots of platforms, but things like The View are clumsy and repetitive. If only Jon Stewart were the only person who had to endure the consequences of his propaganda.

RideSpaceMountain said...

If you can't smell the globalist desperation in bringing Mr. Stewart-Leibowitz back, you're nose-blind.

They always do this when they're caught, just like Anita Sarkeesian hosting the show after gamergate started going mainstream.

It's damage control directed at proles.

Aggie said...

Putting it right out there: The only reason Stewart is here, is because it's an election year.

The unspoken part: The only reason Stewart is here, is because Trump is running and Democracy is in Danger, and Stewart hates Trump, like every good Democrat.

The secret unspoken part: Remember, comrades: Democracy is only for Democrats. If you're not a Democrat, then you qualify for treatments prescribed for the infidel, a 'lower' person, an apostate: Taqiyya, shunning, unpunished violence, selective persecution, and so forth. With the infidel, the ends justify the means.

D.D. Driver said...

A. You can't punch down.
B. I am always the victim.

Neat trick.

Kate said...

The diaresis makes me stabby.

rehajm said...

The fact they are openly discussing the ‘beneficial’ propaganda aspect of the show is all you need to know.

‘You missed a lot’ my ass..

Sebastian said...

"The use of clapter as a crutch, and a general ethos against 'punching down' among moral-minded standups, has rendered much of today’s political comedy predictable...."

All prog humor is clapter. Political comedy was predictable yesterday too, having devolved into prog propaganda.

The ethos against punching down must be the reason "political comedy" doesn't make fun of that nice old man with failing memory, grandpa Joe.

RideSpaceMountain said...

"A. You can't punch down.
B. I am always the victim.

Neat trick."

The funny clown cries out in pain as he makes fun of you.

PM said...

Help me, Obi-Jon Kenobi. You're my only hope.

rehajm said...

The diaresis makes me stabby

Haha. The euros in my horology group think the American fixation on it is silly…

RideSpaceMountain said...

"Help me, Obi-Jon Kenobi. You're my only hope."

May the farce be with you.

mtp said...

"occasionally resorted"

Nonsense. Every joke under Stewart was clapter.
Almost every joke was some version of "heh. 'publicans is stoopid".

I watched the Daily show for over a decade. I turned it off when I realized all it was was clapter. I realized that when I fell out of the target audience and stopped clapping.

Scott M said...

Punching down is one of the worst things to happen to comedy in general...ever.

Jersey Fled said...

It’s harder to make people laugh. That’s why clapter comedy. It takes next to no effort.

Joe Smith said...

Liberals are trained seals.

Even they know it...

Robert Cook said...

"Eff John Stewart. There. I said it."

And? So?

MadTownGuy said...

You can't save democracy by doing all you can to destroy it.

Dave D said...

Gutfeld is a "clapter" device, IMO. The difference is that his show actually will make fun of an ally when they deserve it. Totally taboo on the "comedy" shows like SNL or DS.

Lilly, a dog said...

I'm so old that I remember the days when we didn't know the political views of late-night hosts. Strangely, it correlates to the last time late night shows were wildly popular.

n.n said...

Contemporary left-wing ideology bitterly clings to the twilight fringe of the democratic/dictatorial duality.

Saint Croix said...

I thought claps were out and it's snaps now.

Snapter.

Saint Croix said...

I always found Stewart more interesting because he's a bit more open-minded than your usual prog.

"Maybe it's the fucking chocolate factory!"

Bob Boyd said...

There is no ethos against punching down. It's just political correctness ruthlessly enforced. It's fine to punch down at poor whites, for example.

Deep State Reformer said...

Yah. "Clown nose on, Clown nose off" Stewart (nee, Leibowitz) can indeed go "eff himself" as a previous commentor said first, IMHO. And the limo he rode in on too. JS is just another noisy, grating vuvezela in the Democrat's noise machine nowadays. Definitely nothing special. Kids today see him as just another establishment ass clown with a cable show. At least that's what my grandchildren tell me.

Iman said...

They don't make them like Jon Stewart anymore… but just to be on the safe side, he should be castrated anyway.

Ice Nine said...

>R C Belaire said...
Eff John Stewart. There. I said it.<

Actually, you didn't.

Iman said...

If you gave Jon Stewart an enema, you could bury him in a matchbox.

Mr. D said...

I'm in with the in crowd (Do-do-do)
I go where the in crowd goes (Do-do-do)
I'm in with the in crowd (Do-do-do)
And I know what the in crowd knows (Da-da-da-da)


Dobie Gray in 1965, Jon Stewart in 2024. Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose, especially when it concerns dispatching loudmouth dudes from Queens.

Mason G said...

"I watched the Daily show for over a decade. I turned it off when I realized all it was was clapter."

I started watching near the end of the Bush administration. Lots of mocking of Bush and Cheney, but hey- those in power often deserve it. I was curious when Obama was elected how they'd deal with him. As it turned out, with lots of mocking of Bush and Cheney. I stopped watching and never went back. Comedy is entertaining, propaganda not so much.

rcocean said...

An annoying sentence in the article:

Paraphrase: Visiting the old Daily show was like checking in everynight with your smartest friend.

that's the problem with Libtards, they really are impressed by Jon Stewart. They really truly think they're "smart" for reading the NYT's and watching the Daily Show. The midwittery is extremely pathetic.

My break with the Daily show came in 2004. I truly believed Stewart was a "reasonable liberal" willing to skewer both sides and go after the pompous nitwits in power.

So, when Rathergate came along with Dan Rather pompous absurd defenses and lies about his fake documents [Lucy Rameriz (!)] I thought this is something Stewart will mock and satirize. And...Stewart didn't touch it. Said nothing about it for weeks, then made a mild "both sides are bad" joke. And that was that.

And I assume this will be his pattern till election day 2024. All the easy targets Hunter Biden, Biden's lies and half-truths and corruption, will be passed over in favor of few mild "Gosh, biden is such an old geezer" or "wow, did you hear about Biden's gaffe?" while Trump and his supporters will be mocked and attacked and painted as stupid, criminal, and racist.

The New Yorker author also discuses Late nite comedy which no one watches anymore.

rcocean said...

BTW, one can do lots of fun comedy without "punching down". you just have to make fun of leftist, democrats, and the rich and powerful.

Which most TV comedians cant do. They can only go after the safe targets: Trump, Republicans, Christianity, etc.

Earnest Prole said...

The ethos against punching down must be the reason "political comedy" doesn't make fun of that nice old man with failing memory, grandpa Joe.

I take it you failed to do your homework in preparation for class discussion of Jon Stewart’s political comedy: actually watching Jon Stewart’s political comedy. The whole thrust of the most recent Daily Show is Joe Biden’s failing memory.

Patrick Driscoll said...

Clapping seals and redditards rejoice!

Earnest Prole said...

If you can't smell the globalist desperation in bringing Mr. Stewart-Leibowitz back, you're nose-blind.

Say more about the Hebrew Space Lasers.

Howard said...

Stewart is magician. Can turn big phat Trumpers into melting snowflakes, even if they don't watch him. Political quantum entanglement.

MountainJohn said...

Bring back Craig Kilborn!

RideSpaceMountain said...

"Say more about the Hebrew Space Lasers."

Correction: "it's damage control directed at Earnest Proles"

My mistake.

Iman said...

You know, Howard may think like an idiot and - as witnessed - he can write like an idiot, but don't let that fool you.

He really is an idiot.

Iman said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Static Ping said...

The format was an excess in itself. It became the go-to news source for many people, despite it being a comedy show. Mr. Stewart would play the game that other people have described as "clown nose off, clown nose on" where he would act as a serious, albeit heavily biased and joke filled, news source and then when called out on would claim he is just a comedian.

You are what your audience says you are.

Quaestor said...

Kate writes, "The diaresis makes me stabby."

I agree with Kate, but not in degree. Those dots make me slashy across the windpipeÿ.

What a slothful hipster affectation is diaeresis, or diaëresis, or better still, diæresis where English has been quite happy without them. A monocle would be far more respectable. Firstly, you'd have to find one. That takes effort, whereas the un-needed diacritic is as easy as macOS. Sẽě? I cán adűtęrætê mý vœwëls with nary an escape code. If writers for Duh Nooyawkuh used Gates' Grotesque or the übernerdisch Linux, they wouldn't touch them flyspecks with a ten-foot ellipsis. Those tasks are a smidgen too technical for their busy-busy posing schedule to permit.

Brontë is often cited as an example of diaeresis in English, along with naïve. However, naïve is French and Brontë is a complete pretense on the part of the famously ink-smeared sisters' daddykins who felt shortchanged by his actual surname, Brunty.

Not only is preëxisting an affectation, it's stupid. How can a bore like Stewart pander to beliefs that do not preexist his feeble philippics? Do you want to what really going on? Preëxisting belief is Inkoo Kang trying to avoid the appropriate word, bigotry, which the stylebook forbids application to anyone inclined to vote Democratic

Quaestor said...

"Stewart is magician."

The rest of us are assured Howard will be watching Jon Stewart and obediently giggling on command, that is when he can find his monocle.

Note to Howard, simpleminded witticisms are more simpleminded than witty when one neglects his articles. Or perhaps you were going for the Boris Badenov feckless villain effect? If so, Fearless Leader is unimpressed, considering liquidation.

Jake said...

Hollywood Reporter has a story about backlash against Stewart with some critics accusing him of being like Bill Maher. (https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/tv/tv-news/jon-stewart-biden-criticizing-white-house-1235824591/):

"A self-described Democratic activist tweeted, “Jon Stewart retired and came back as Bill Maher. I had a Jon Stewart for President shirt and rarely missed a show. So disappointing.” (And, yes, apparently Stewart being on Apple TV+ for his recent show The Problem is basically like being retired)."

Makes me recall Maher's statement - when people criticized him a while back - that he hadn't changed. (https://deadline.com/2022/01/bill-maher-fires-back-says-his-politics-have-not-changed-1234922380/) I think that's true.

The problem, it seems, is our tribalism. Quit fighting for your team, and start fighting for principles.

Rich said...

What I like about Stewart is that while he’s unabashedly liberal on the issues he has never been a partisan tool. He’s tough on Republicans but If the Democrats deserve ridicule he is more than happy to dish it out.

He’s always been an incisive observer of the political scene. Maybe he’s trying to tell us something that Democrats don’t want to hear.

walter said...

Will he bring back the chop socky editing and to the camera mugging Howie so loves?
Back in the day, young liberals got their news from Stewart.

lonejustice said...

The problem with humor in 2024 is that if you are a left wing Democrat, then all humor must be directed against Trump and the Republicans. And if you are a right wing Republican, then all humor must be directed against Biden and the Democrats. I am so old that I remember when comics used to skewer both sides, like Johnny Carson and early Jay Leno. But I guess those days are long gone. Now all humor and entertainment has to be politically correct -- left wing if you are a Democrat, and right wing if you are a Republican. We all lose when this is what happens.

Hassayamper said...

I am so old that I remember when comics used to skewer both sides, like Johnny Carson and early Jay Leno.

Early Jay Leno, you say? Hmph. It's been a while now, but I don't remember it that way. Leno retired way too soon, in my opinion, but I seem to recall good-natured mockery of both parties right up to the end.

His was the last late-night television show I ever watched regularly. Stewart and Maher each got one viewing before I quit tuning in, and I never once bothered to switch on Oliver or the Jimmys.

Howard said...

I love the sound of snowflakes melting in the morning...

Howard said...

Forget it, Jake... it's Chinatown

Jim at said...

And if you are a right wing Republican, then all humor must be directed against Biden and the Democrats.

Well, I can only speak for myself but I prefer my comedy without any politics. But you keep reading minds. You're good at it.

chuck said...

One of the advantages to not having a TV for the last 20 years is that I miss all the shows.

RideSpaceMountain said...

"while he’s unabashedly liberal on the issues he has never been a partisan tool."

Lmao Rich...that's so you it's wealthy!

Butkus51 said...

half his "humor" is mugging for the camera.

Hell, bring back Andrew Dice Clay too.

Rusty said...

Is he going to be funny this time?

rcocean said...

Yeah, the problem is BOTH SIDES are stuck in Tribalism. LOL. No, the problem is you have a small group with views reprsenting maybe 35 percent of USA in total control of the MSM and Entertainment Industry.

Anyway, back in the old days Stewart went on Crossfire and spent the entire show attacking Tucker Carlson, y'know the CONSERVATIVE. He didn't attack "Both sides". But he is a rich old Hollywood Jewish guy, so he will attack the Democrats if they don't suport Israel or Ukraine or Stewart thinks they're trying to "soak the rich" and attack Big Business. After all, HE"S rich.

And he will also mock/attack the Democrats if they do something crazy like refuse to jail criminals or push for something far outside the current "NYT/WaPo Party Line". I'm sure he will make fun of AOC or Rev. Sharpton or Bernie.

But that's it. His prefered targets will/are small town/rural whites, Republicans,Christians, and social conservatives. IOW, the same people the New Yorker or the NYT/Wapo doesn't like.

He's not going to attack Biden on anything other then "Hey, he might be bad for Democrats, maybe we can nominate someone else" or "Hey, look at Good ol' Joe, forgot what year it was, or made a funny gaffe, hoho".

rcocean said...

And the problem with comedy isn't that you cant "Punch down", its that you cant attack people the Left think are "protected classes". So, no gay jokes. No trans jokes. No women jokes. No Black/Hispanic/jewish jokes (unless you're of that group). No Islam jokes.

You can make fun of white men. And Christians. And rednecks and hicks. In other words, you can pretend its still 1975, and you're George Carlin or Richard Pryor mocking the powerful. Weirdly, you can still make fun of Russians. Since they're back to being the bad guys.

rcocean said...

Yeah, the problem is BOTH SIDES are stuck in Tribalism. LOL. No, the problem is you have a small group with views reprsenting maybe 35 percent of USA in total control of the MSM and Entertainment Industry.

Anyway, back in the old days Stewart went on Crossfire and spent the entire show attacking Tucker Carlson, y'know the CONSERVATIVE. He didn't attack "Both sides". But he is a rich old Hollywood Jewish guy, so he will attack the Democrats if they don't suport Israel or Ukraine or Stewart thinks they're trying to "soak the rich" and attack Big Business. After all, HE"S rich.

And he will also mock/attack the Democrats if they do something crazy like refuse to jail criminals or push for something far outside the current "NYT/WaPo Party Line". I'm sure he will make fun of AOC or Rev. Sharpton or Bernie.

But that's it. His prefered targets will/are Southerners and small town/rural whites, Republicans,Christians, and social conservatives. IOW, the same people the New Yorker or the NYT/Wapo doesn't like.

He's not going to attack Biden on anything other then "Hey, he might be bad for Democrats, maybe we can nominate someone else" or "Hey, look at Good ol' Joe, forgot what year it was, or made a funny gaffe, hoho".

Drago said...

Quaester: "The rest of us are assured Howard will be watching Jon Stewart and obediently giggling on command,.."

Howitzer Howie knows his place and follows the directives of his betters like the trained poodle he is.

RMc said...

I truly believed Stewart was a "reasonable liberal" willing to skewer both sides

The thing is, you can't "skewer both sides" and be popular, because then both sides are p!ssed at you. In today's media landscape, it's much better to attack only one side, the side that your audience and bosses and advertisers hate.

Goldstein's waiting.

Robert Cook said...

"half his 'humor' is mugging for the camera."

Mugging for the audience is among the "Five Essentials For Guaranteed Laffmaking and Sidesplitting" that every board-certified comedian is required to have mastered.