July 8, 2023

"I’ve worked with far lesser actors who would leave me to read with an assistant when they’re off-camera."

"But Tom does not play that way at all. At one point, his face was literally smashed against the [side] of the camera, to get in my eye line as much as possible, even if I could only see the corner of his eye. He was like, 'What do you need, what can I do, how can I help you?'" 

Said April Grace, about making the movie "Magnolia" with Tom Cruise, quoted in "Tom Cruise is here to help/For more than four decades, the actor has attained near-mythic status by giving us what we want — including seven ‘Mission: Impossible’ movies." (WaPo).

The article, written by Ann Hornaday, a film critic, continues:
It’s easy to be cynical about Cruise’s messianic energy, his zealotry on behalf of an art form that, when he practices it, looks less like a profession than a holy vocation (is it any coincidence that he once contemplated becoming a Franciscan priest?).

Why be "cynical" about "a holy vocation"?! 

Tilt the lens, and even his most admirable qualities take on the contours of overcompensation: his obsession with satisfying the audience as an extension of him bringing joy and diversion to his mother and sisters after his parents split when Cruise was in sixth grade; reading everything in sight after overcoming dyslexia — with the help, he has said, of the Church of Scientology, which he joined in 1986....

That's an astonishingly long sentence. I'm thinking of making a holy vocation out of diagramming sentences.  

Constantly scraping his environment and audience expectations for data, he adjusts and improves, ultimately achieving the perfect Zen balance of mega-celebrity: near-constant ubiquity and inscrutable remoteness....

Just toss the religions around. He's Catholic. He's Scientologist. He's Zen. But of course, for the purposes of attack, the correct religion to ascribe to Tom Cruise is Scientology. This comes up next:

“I happen to have a huge body of facts, particularly with regard to his and Scientology’s treatment toward women, that for me makes it very hard to excuse his continued adulation,” says Maureen Orth, who wrote a troubling article about Cruise’s relationship with the actress and activist Nazanin Boniadi for Vanity Fair in 2012. “Not just because of him alone, but [because] he’s the second most important person in Scientology, next to [church leader] David Miscavige. … The press has fallen down on its job, too. He always gets a free pass. He never gets asked about this stuff anymore.” Indeed, by the time Golden Globes host Jerrod Carmichael made a pointed joke about Cruise and Scientology this year, the jibe landed but didn’t gain purchase. (Carmichael suggested they trade in the Globes Cruise returned in protest for “the safe return” of Miscavige’s wife Shelly, who has not been seen in public for several years.)

He's so dedicated and successful that the effort to leverage religious bigotry doesn't work anymore. 

Here's the Vanity Fair article from 11 years ago: "What Katie Didn’t Know/In the fall of 2004, an accomplished, gorgeous Scientologist named Nazanin Boniadi was allegedly selected by officials in the organization to be Tom Cruise’s next girlfriend. Her never-before-told story—of the months inseparable from the star (and his watchers), before she fell out of favor—reveals a complex dynamic that also affected Cruise’s relationships with Nicole Kidman, Penélope Cruz, and, now, Katie Holmes. Maureen Orth investigates."

I looked back into my archive to see if I'd blogged that Maureen Orth piece. I didn't, but I see I did blog about Cruise and Holmes in the year 2012. Holmes was fighting for sole custody of their child and, in that context, made an issue out of his Scientology. Except from my post (after a quote from a news article that supported assuming what I assume):

If we assume, for the purposes of discussion, that Cruise follows a religion-based approach to child rearing, involving maximum autonomy, and Holmes now objects to that and wants to raise the child according to more conventional decision-making and discipline by the parent, how much of a factor should that play in determining custody? Should Cruise's ideas about child-rearing have more weight or less weight because they are premised on religion?

That is, imagine Cruise2, a man with the same approach to child-rearing, arrived at through religion-free thought processes — philosophy, common sense, personal experience.... While you're at it, imagine Cruise3, with the same notions of child-rearing, premised on religious beliefs, with a much more conventional religion. Let's make Cruise3 a mainstream Protestant who has come to a serious conclusion about children, individual autonomy, and free choice based on a deep commitment to the teachings of Jesus.

33 comments:

Kate said...

He's a weird dude. So what?

He was born handsome, otherwise he'd be the pimply AV guy that snobs have laughed at since time immemorial. Enthusiasm, for some reason, is always mocked.

RideSpaceMountain said...

"What Katie Didn’t Know/In the fall of 2004, an accomplished, gorgeous Scientologist named Nazanin Boniadi was allegedly selected by officials in the organization to be Tom Cruise’s next girlfriend."

"I just want everyone to know that I was doing the sex-cult-as-self-help thing before it was Scientology." - Keith Raniere, founder of NXIVM

Tina Trent said...

The main difference between a cult and a religion is you're not the Jesus in a religion. Cults follow a particular financial, familial and force paradigm to blackmail, groom, and control members.

Dogma and Pony Show said...

Why should people care about Tom Cruise as a person? Sure, if Hitler or Ted Bundy made pictures as a side gig, I admittedly wouldn't watch them. But Cruise is just a weird Hollywood type, not a murderer. Hell, I even enjoy Roman Polanski's work (even though I think he should be in prison).

Political Junkie said...

Maureen Orth....Loved her husband. Back when a media democrat loved the country, respected religion, and had some conservative cultural values. Big Russ produced a great man in Tim.

Lars Porsena said...

He has total remission of all sins in this life for making "Top Gun: Maverick".

hombre said...

Cruise is a great entertainer. He is too big to be destroyed by leftist pygmies.

The media's unhealthy need for icons fuels its iconoclasm. Progressivism is the only acceptable religion. Icons are not permitted to follow another.

Dude1394 said...

Dude works his rear end off and seems to be a pretty normal dude. But he's not a democrat lackey so let's hate him.

Yancey Ward said...

I just scanned the list of movies he has made- most great actors appear in a lot of awful movies in the course of a 40+ year career, but in that list (and I have seen almost of them) there are only a couple that I would say were bad movies, but none that are dreck. Whatever else you can say about him, he has particularly good taste in picking with which movies to get involved.

Narr said...

I stopped at MI2 or 3 and haven't looked back. Never was that big a fan of "Tom Thumb" Mapother, or his cult(s).


Narr said...

I stopped at MI2 or 3 and haven't looked back. Never was that big a fan of "Tom Thumb" Mapother, or his cult(s).


Anthony said...

I have come to respect him a lot as a professional, though most of his movies don't appeal to me that much. Back during Covidiot times there was a leaked video of him berating people on the crew of a movie for not wearing their masks. At first I thought "F*** you, Cruise, they don't work anyway, you mindless zealot" but then after actually listening to the rant, it was clear he was being zealous because this was one of, if not the, first movies started up during the Covids and everyone was watching what they were doing, and if they didn't at least make a good show of being diligent it would be shut down and a lot of people would not be working again.

I really liked Edge of Tomorrow though. One of my favorites.

walter said...

"Tom Cruise unleashes expletive rant over social distancing breach on ‘Mission: Impossible’ set
In audio released by the Sun tabloid, the 58-year-old Hollywood star can be heard warning that anyone caught not following the rules to stay at least 2 meters (more than 6.5 feet) away from others will be fired."
--
Dick.

Tom T. said...

Insider accounts are pretty clear that Scientology's approach to child-rearing is a mix of poverty, neglect, and child labor. Suri presumably would get special treatment because Cruise is their golden child, but in general you shouldn't believe their bullshit about "autonomy."

Breezy said...

Can’t help but give him 100% respect after watching that ten minute video on creating the stunts for his latest movie. He’s an amazingly focused and gifted tactician.

William said...

It only happened briefly, but he let the mask slip. There were those interviews where he babbled like an idiot and almost destroyed the Top Gun persona. All is okay now. Maybe he's an idiot savant whose sole talents are choosing good scripts, good directors, and giving a good performance. We should all be so limited in our talents...I don't know about the Scientology. It works for him and Travolta apparently. Some people win the lottery and some people benefit from their cult membership....I think he has a higher percentage of good movies than any other actor of his generation. You don't really bond with him though the way you do with Costner or Harrison Ford.

Andrew said...

The greatest part of "Top Gun: Maverick" was the very beginning, where Tom Cruise welcomed and thanked the audience, and hoped they enjoyed the show. Talk about a breath of fresh air.

mccullough said...

Tom Cruise is short and has a nose that’s larger than average. Until he came along, no one considered a guy like that Movie Star Handsome. He had a minor role in The Outsiders and didn’t stand out.

What he has is charisma and passion.

That’s why he’s Handsome.

And he’s by far the most apolitical Hollywood Star ever.

Neither Progressives nor Conservatives align themselves with the guy. Perhaps Scientology is a factor.

Mostly it’s because he is apolitical.

JaimeRoberto said...

A friend of my brother used to pilot for Cruise, and allegedly he's a nice guy, who sent a wedding present when the friend got married.

lonejustice said...

Tom Cruise doesn't seem to age. I wish I knew his secret.

jim5301 said...

It isn’t necessarily religious bigotry to criticize Scientology or any other religion for that matter. Religions get many benefits in our society they shouldn’t have. They don’t have to pay taxes though they use government services. In Minneapolis mosques can blast their loudspeakers at 4 am. But if I criticize I’m a bigot? Nice gig if you can get it

The Godfather said...

I liked Cruise in a few of his early movies, not so much in most of his more recent ones, but "Maverick" was very good. However, if you're interested in movie-making, I recommend Michael Caine's "Blowing the Bloody Doors Off". He made a lot of movies, good, bad, and ugly -- as he readily admits -- and that makes for enlightening reading.

The Godfather said...

I liked Cruise in a few of his early movies, not so much in most of his more recent ones, but "Maverick" was very good. However, if you're interested in movie-making, I recommend Michael Caine's "Blowing the Bloody Doors Off". He made a lot of movies, good, bad, and ugly -- as he readily admits -- and that makes for enlightening reading.

phantommut said...

Whatever else Tom Cruise is, he's a consummate professional in his trade. For whatever reason, our cultural elite seems to loathe professionals.

Valentine Smith said...

The guy is a bloody genius. End of story.

Big Mike said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
walter said...

Valentine Smith said...
The guy is a bloody genius. End of story.
--
Story includes being duped into a cult.
Some genius.

Big Mike said...

Apparently my take is a bit different. With all the junk Hollywood has been producing lately, I just think it’s great that an actor who reportedly makes $20 million and up per movie actually cares whether the film on the whole is good entertainment.

Gahrie said...

Story includes being duped into a cult.
Some genius.


While I think Scientology is ridiculous, it's not a lot less ridiculous to believe in a cult surrounding a zombie. Christianity was a cult once too.

Narr said...

One definition of genius is the ability to create your own occupation and become a success. By that definition then TC is a genius.

He has invented the character "Tom Cruise" and plays it to the hilt.



Narr said...

The main differences between cults and religions are about 100 years and 10 million followers.

walter said...

Gahrie,
See Tina Trent's post.
There are some good interviews with folks who struggled to exit Scientology.

JPS said...

"Magnolia" is a movie I immediately mention in protest when people say Tom Cruise can't act.

I mean, if you ask me who's the better actor, him or the late Philip Seymour Hoffman, of course I'd say Hoffman. But he moved Hoffman to tears on camera and they rolled with it.

Then there's "Collateral." His performance as Vincent was complex, charming and chilling.