July 29, 2021

"In the first study, nursery school children watched an adult heaping verbal and physical abuse on an inflatable Bobo the clown doll..."

"... punching it in the nose, kicking it, hitting it on the head with a mallet and throwing it around the room. When the children were then given a chance to interact with a similar doll, they copied the adult’s abusive behavior and produced additional forms of abuse that they thought up on their own. In contrast, children who watched an adult interacting peacefully with the doll, or who were not shown a model at all, were significantly less aggressive.... Later studies indicated that just showing a film of an adult acting aggressively could produce similar results. And the children’s response to the adult model could be influenced by whether the aggressive behavior was rewarded or punished.... The results of the Bobo doll experiment were at odds with behaviorism and conflicted with the reigning mental health theory of the time, psychoanalysis, which held that vicarious aggression — watching a violent film, for example — would provide a catharsis, diminishing the need to act out aggressive impulses."

From "Albert Bandura, Leading Psychologist of Aggression, Dies at 95/He was most known for his Bobo doll experiment, in which children mimicked adults in attacking an inflatable doll. The work challenged basic tenets of psychology" (NYT).

1 comment:

Ann Althouse said...

LA_Bob writes:

""In contrast, the Bobo doll studies demonstrated what any parent or schoolteacher knew: that children also learn from observing other people’s behavior."

"Decades ago I read B.F. Skinner's "Beyond Freedom and Dignity" and found it as dull as it seemed dumb. Skinner seemed to tell me I really didn't think and feel what I thought I thought and felt. With behaviorism, it's all an illusion. Why do we feel anything?

"Yes, children learn from and mimic the behavior of others, especially trusted caregivers. But they also pick and choose what they want to mimic (picky eaters, anyone?), and their "choosiness" increases as they get older.

"When he was five or six, I showed my grandson a DOS video game called "Whip the Worker". You (as "boss") press a number of keys and slap or punch a goofy-looking employee in front of you. The kid loved it. Then he stopped and applied the lesson he had learned at school. "This isn't nice", he said. And went right back to beating the tar out of the hapless worker. Kids are interesting.

"Regarding the effect of TV and motion picture violence on children, consider also that a trusted caregiver's reaction to such violence might play a role in the children's responses. And the children's real-life experiences play a role as well. Both the behaviorists and Dr Banduro undoubtedly over-simplified what really goes on."