५ नोव्हेंबर, २०२६

"What if the dilettante’s perpetual movement from one thing to another is not a failure of nerve but a different and defensible way of being..."

"... one whose exploratory zeal turns out to be just what a hyper-specialised, over-optimised and all-too-serious world needs most? Then the dilettante would turn out to be not a capricious buffoon but a kind of modern anti-hero. That, I argue, is a dilettantism worth defending...."

Writes Nigel Warburton, in "In praise of the dilettante/A wayfaring cosmopolitan who never gets stuck, the dilettante is the right anti-hero for our hyper-specialised age" (Aeon).

I was moved to make a tag for "dilettante"! It seemed absurd, at first, but once I saw the old posts to which I could add it, I liked it:
1. "But 'dilettante' is one of those words which deter people from taking up new pursuits as adults."

2. "And so if what you're trying to do is micromanage and solve everything then you end up being a dilettante but you have to have enough knowledge to make good judgments about the choices that are presented to you." 
3. "One moment they are a king, the next a murderer, a jaded dilettante, a passionate and forsaken lover...." 
4. "It must gall Biden to know that his predecessor... actually installed his dilettante daughter and-son-in-law at the highest level of policymaking...."

5. "[S]he is a millionaire dilettante, despite the fact she drives a Prius and lives in a modest Madison home...."

6."The mountains are the artifice of a clever scene painter... it is as if the whole region were an album, the mountains drawn on a blank page by an adroit dilettante for the lady who owns the album...."

7. "It is precisely at times of chaos that morally informed but tough-minded triage decisions must be made, otherwise morality is simply a dilettante’s luxury and a mere intellectual puzzle for the philosophy classroom, but irrelevant on the street."

8. "He's no dilettante. He's the real deal when it comes to being a celebrity judge... He's an ardent and opinionated fan of the show.''

३७ टिप्पण्या:

Jaq म्हणाले...

If you want to be a dilettante, it helps to be comfortably a millionaire. Otherwise, I would guess, you’re just a hobbyist. Am I a dilettante piano player, or is playing piano my hobby? As I like to say that all taxonomy is political, and what is name calling but a form of taxonomy?

Wilbur म्हणाले...

AI says:
Original Meaning: Historically, the term was neutral or positive. Borrowed into English in the mid-1700s from the Italian word dilettare (meaning "to delight or amuse"), it originally described a true lover or admirer of the arts. It shifted to a negative connotation as professions and trades became formal, specialized institutions in the 18th and 19th centuries.

Eric the Fruit Bat म्हणाले...

The internet informs me that dilettante and arriviste come to us from the French.

The internet also informs me that "No — using 'the' before a language name is not snobby; it’s a standard, correct English usage in certain contexts."

Lem Vibe Bandit म्हणाले...

I had the word closely related to dumb.

Mr. D म्हणाले...

For my screen name, the D stands for dilettante. Has for 20 years now, which belies the notion of dilettantism.

Jaq म्हणाले...

Was Einstein a dilettante when he made all of those discoveries as a patent clerk?

Kassaar म्हणाले...

It's interesting to see how the British follow the Italian pronunciation, the Americans the French.
https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/dilettante

Lem Vibe Bandit म्हणाले...

"Shakespeare... may teach us how to overhear ourselves when we talk to ourselves."
I like the sound of that.

james म्हणाले...

Polymath?

RCOCEAN II म्हणाले...

She was a young dabbler,
A trifler.

She was Samatha Smattering
A dilettante debutant.

RideSpaceMountain म्हणाले...

A "versatilist" can be a dilettante, but a dilettante can never be a versatilist.

RCOCEAN II म्हणाले...

The problem with dilettante's is when you give them power and the dilettante's power is combined with egotism. You end up with somone like FDR who liked to make all the decisions - but didn't have the knoweldge or brains to make good ones.

Mike (MJB Wolf) म्हणाले...

Is “wayfaring cosmopolitan” really a useable concept for “dilettante?” Sounds like a city dweller bestowing bumpkins with his sophisticated approach to problems. While the common uses suggest a dabbler or poser. YMMV

Mike (MJB Wolf) म्हणाले...

Ah so RCO and I both landed on dabbler. Interesting.

rehajm म्हणाले...

“It must gall Biden to know that his predecessor…”

That’s cute they think Biden matters…what’s a gall, ya pony faced dog soldier!?!

Mike (MJB Wolf) म्हणाले...

When I was growing up dilettante was usually applied to wealthy wives or offspring who donated to the arts and chaired meetings for charity. As my wife pointed out dilletantes and debutants came from the same families.

RideSpaceMountain म्हणाले...

#7 provides an answer to the "dilettante's dilemma" in #2.

rcommal म्हणाले...

There's value in both depth and breadth.

Lem Vibe Bandit म्हणाले...

#6 "For it is by self-forgetting that one finds." -- St. Francis

Lazarus म्हणाले...

"Defensible ways of being"? Is Nigel Warburton a judge on "Justify Your Life"? There is so much information in the world, that one either dives deeply into one small field or one skims the surface of different fields. Some of us are specialists in one thing. The rest of us are dilettantes in everything. Muddle through as best as you can. No need to defend your existence.

I would demand that Nigel Warburton's parents defend that name that they gave him though.

OnwardandUpward म्हणाले...

Dabbling species of ducks are dilettantes then!

RCOCEAN II म्हणाले...

Interesing contrast. Cowan moaning about the X-burt Economists no longer having "respect" , and now someone saying we need more diletttantism. Well, when the x-burts fail, the dilettantes ride to the rescue.

Lem Vibe Bandit म्हणाले...

I'm interested in the connections things have, which only become apparent upon close attention/observation.
"Pythagoras plucked a string 2,500 years ago and wondered whether the whole universe was built like music." -- "The most beautiful idea in physics..."

Caroline म्हणाले...

The word “dilettante” carries a negative connotation. GK Chesterton has persuaded me that the the feminine nature is naturally so suited, but he calls it “universalist”, in contrast to the male nature, which he calls “specialist.” Decades of observing Homo sapiens in the field confirms this. Women, when ordered to motherhood and domesticity, do indeed fill many roles— healer, nurturer, hostess, educator, artist, environmentalist, manager, musician, seamstress, cook, photographer, archivist. I have been known to lament that I do none of them to mastery, but then again, the young people I know think I am the most creative person they know and keep urging me to “monetize” this or that. I reject the term dilettante. I do many things well! In the doing, I enrich my life as well as my family’s.

Ann Althouse म्हणाले...

The etymology point is in the linked article: "From the Baroque-era Italian dilettante, the term originally referred to someone who pursues an interest, particularly an artistic one, for the sake of pleasure, or ‘delight’. Even as the term evolved, it stayed largely neutral, distinguishing enthusiasts from professionals in a given practice. The pejorative connotation familiar to us today is more recent, shaped by what I’ll call a ‘deficiency’ model, in which amateurism is viewed negatively as a lack of something: skill, seriousness, focus, expertise. This is the meaning ascribed by cultural gatekeepers like Theodor Adorno, who in 1929 dismissed the dilettante as one ‘unable to establish any standards.'"

Fritz म्हणाले...

"Jaq said...
Was Einstein a dilettante when he made all of those discoveries as a patent clerk?"

He was a dilettante patent clerk.

RideSpaceMountain म्हणाले...

@Caroline:

“A human being should be able to change a diaper, plan an invasion, butcher a hog, conn a ship, design a building, write a sonnet, balance accounts, build a wall, set a bone, comfort the dying, take orders, give orders, cooperate, act alone, solve equations, analyze a new problem, pitch manure, program a computer, cook a tasty meal, fight efficiently, die gallantly. Specialization is for insects.”

— Robert Heinlein, “Time Enough for Love”

Jaq म्हणाले...

Fritz nails that one.

Jaq म्हणाले...

IIRC, the characters in Time Enough for Love lived for centuries, so not picking up a few skills along the way would be a horrible waste.

Jaq म्हणाले...

Was that lady in The Big Lebowski an artist or a dilettante? For that matter, which of the Lebowskis was the big one?

William म्हणाले...

I lack sufficient motivation to be a dilettante. I'm more of a dabbler. It takes some commitment to learn how to play the piano poorly. I do, however, sometimes listen to Mozart's piano concertos.

Howard म्हणाले...

There's nothing defensible about a dilettante. What we need more of are Jacks of all Trades.

A dilettante is a person who has a superficial or casual interest in an art, science, or field of knowledge without serious study, commitment, or professional expertise.

Howard म्हणाले...

"A human being should be able to change a diaper, plan an invasion, butcher a hog, conn a ship, design a building, write a sonnet, balance accounts, build a wall, set a bone, comfort the dying, take orders, give orders, cooperate, act alone, solve equations, analyze a new problem, pitch manure, program a computer, cook a tasty meal, fight efficiently, die gallantly. Specialization is for insects."
Robert A. Heinlein

RideSpaceMountain म्हणाले...
ही टिप्पणी लेखकाना हलविली आहे.
stutefish म्हणाले...

To be a dilettante is to waste not only your potential, but also your privilege.

Howard म्हणाले...

Yeah I don't get it. He says human not man even.

john mosby म्हणाले...

Anyone else immediately think of Bryan?

Serpentine sleekness
Was always my weakness
Like a simple tune
But no dilettante
Filigree fancy
Beats the plastic you
***
Oh mother of pearl
So, so semi-precious
In your detached world....&c. CC, JSM

टिप्पणी पोस्ट करा

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 4 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith. Also: No italics, even briefly. Use asterisks for emphasis. And don't play with the format by changing fonts or using boldface or all caps. Never include more than one extra line break between paragraphs.