२१ नोव्हेंबर, २०२६

"We could end up with great healthcare in our country."

१७४ टिप्पण्या:

Peachy+2 म्हणाले...

Yeah - 2 failing socialized gov run health care systems - those in UK and Canada are failing, broke and unpopular.
Lets do it.
If Trump goes full commie care - he can F right off.

Aggie म्हणाले...

Oh, really Bernie? Why don't you name a few for us, so we can do an factual comparison?

Peachy+2 म्हणाले...

How to kill the GOP and any political balance in our nation, once and for all. With this one neat trick. Bonus - the GOP can also sign on to mass amnesty.

Joe Bar म्हणाले...

In my one encounter with nationalized healthcare, in Germany, I was not impressed. People do not know how good we have it here, right now.

Bob Boyd म्हणाले...

Medical Assistance in Dying

bagoh20 म्हणाले...

This will definitely be a good thing. The government and the Democrats in particular have an unbroken record of solving problems, getting things done, and running complex institutions like a well-oiled machine.

Now pass that crack pipe back. You've been bogarting, dude.

Spiros Pappas म्हणाले...

I'd like to see a public option and more medical schools. The military academies are a good place to start.

RCOCEAN II म्हणाले...

TRump wanted to do this in the 1st term, and the Democrats called him a Racist, and flounced off. So maybe something will be done.

some people may not realize that Big Business wants to go from health care being tied to your job, to one based on Govrnment taxes. It will save them zillions.

Big Mike म्हणाले...

“People do not know how good we have it here, right now.”

Some of us do. I’m 80 years old and a heart monitor and echocardiogram showed me in need of a pacemaker. In the UK I’d be told to wait or one until after I’m dead. In Canada they’d start pushing MAID at me. Rahm Emanuel’s brother Zeke argues that 75 is old enough for anyone. How about it Althouse? Are you ready to call it quits?

Bob Boyd म्हणाले...

"Our job now is to do what every other major country does:" MAID.
Your human right to healthcare is not a right to whatever healthcare you want. Your human right to healthcare can be met with an offer of MAID.
MAID is healthcare. Box checked.
This is what you voted for when you were "sending Trump a message." Trump is not ideological. The message Trump received was that you want what the party you elected is offering.

bagoh20 म्हणाले...

"I'd like to see a public option..."

I'd like to see a private one.
When I need something, the last place I want to go for it is some government bureaucracy. I can get virtually anything in 24 hours in the free market, at a competitive price, and the quality level I choose. The less the government is involved, the cheaper and faster it is. The choice in quality is nonexistent.

bagoh20 म्हणाले...

One of the big divides in the country is between people who want to take responsibility for themselves and those who want someone else too. The population in each group has shifted dramatically. The problem with socialism is you eventually run out of grown ups.

Arashi म्हणाले...

I say we have all of congress, their staffs and families go on the proposed health service for the next two years as a trial run. No more Walter Read and the absolute best medical care for them. They get the standard they so desire for the rest of us now to test it out. Be the beta testers for it. At the end of two years, with most of them dead, we can have some honest conversations about how to actually lower the costs of health care. I think it would mean getting hte government out of the business altogether.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"I can get virtually anything in 24 hours in the free market, at a competitive price, and the quality level I choose. "

Even when you are unconscious in an ambulance?

"I’m 80 years old and a heart monitor and echocardiogram showed me in need of a pacemaker. "

So you're not on Medicare? What kind of private insurance do you have and how much do you pay for it?

Michael Fitzgerald म्हणाले...

Do Americans have the right to healthcare in every other major country in the world? Free for me in Canada or Mexico?

Michael Fitzgerald म्हणाले...

"I'd like to see a public option"
Funny, I thought there was one. A Christmas Eve gift that the Democrat Party gave America years ago. Something about a "Big fucking deal" during the glorious reign of Obama.
Am I hallucinating?

William म्हणाले...

It's no big challenge to guarantee shabby care for all.which, as I understand it, is what happens with universal health care. I suppose for some people that's better than no care, but if you have decent insurance, that's not an improvement. The best bet is to stay healthy and not need any care at all. Lots of luck with that after you turn eighty......In the England most people hate the Natl Health Care service and will fight to keep it.......If you let in twenty million immigrants shouldn't a certain percentage of them be nurses, ER doctors, X-ray techs, and orthopedic surgeons. Shouldn't they also bring the proper equipment with them when they enter?

Peachy+2 म्हणाले...

Communists(D) and a-hole GOPers will make private plans illegal.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"In my one encounter with nationalized healthcare, in Germany, I was not impressed."

Did you live there? For how long? I lived in England and Germany and preferred their system to ours. England was especially revealing as I woman I worked with there came over at the same time. Back home, her husband was dealing with $500 K in medical debt, trying to figure out how to avoid bankruptcy (their daughter died at 18 after a long illness). She used her time in England to take advantage of the NHS and get a whole lot deferred medical care taken care of. She, in particular, was a huge fan of the NHS. That was 2010-11, and both parties were starving the NHS, so it might not be the same anymore.

In 1997, I tore my ACL at Whistler in BC. My ER bill was CDN $400. A few months later, back in the States, I had a bicycle accident and ended up in the ER. The only real difference in treatment was I got a CT scan at the latter. The bill was $4000.

Aggie म्हणाले...

You liked it so much, you didn't stay there - right?

Peachy+2 म्हणाले...

Bernie will go to his tax payer funded grave NEVER having to use his own government plan.

Aggie म्हणाले...

I have quite a few friends in the medical industry, from pharmacists to surgeons and in between. They are overworked because they are over-administrated. Like higher education, the budgets have been grown, but a lot of that growth has been administrative. If you notice, go into any modern hospital or health facility, and one of the smoothest running things is admittance and bill paying.

Peachy+2 म्हणाले...

Government care is rationed care.
But the cultists understand - it's free because someone else will pay.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"Free for me in Canada or Mexico?"

Not in Canada, but a hell of a lot less than an E.R. visit in the U.S. In England, it is indeed free.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"You liked it so much, you didn't stay there - right?"

My contract ended, and guess what, I like having a job.

Peachy+2 म्हणाले...

The NHS has serious, well-documented problems with public satisfaction over performance (especially waits) and with finances/capacity.
Circa NOW.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"The NHS has serious, well-documented problems with public satisfaction over performance (especially waits) and with finances/capacity."

Like I said, in the last fifteen years, NHS has been raided by both Conservative and Labour governments alike. Even I when I was there, there were constant complaints about how it was underfunded (hanging on in quiet desperation is the English way). But I could call my primary care doctor and get an appointment in less than a week.

Peachy+2 म्हणाले...

We need to sure up our problem with mass-economic illiteracy.

We need to sure-up Social Security, Medicaid and Medicare. That's not happening. The wisdom in building more government mandated welfare? Our deficit is what? I thought leftists cared about our unsustainable deficit?
Democrats are also demanding mass amnesty - so illegals can have OUR welfare.
btw - the last time we had a federal balanced budget was under Bill Clinton and Newt Gingrich.

bagoh20 म्हणाले...

"Even when you are unconscious in an ambulance?"

In a private system, you buy a plan with the things you want and are willing to pay for, including emergency care. And having a private option does not mean you have to throw out public systems and safety nets. The idea that someone like me who can afford it should have everyone else pay for me is just unfair. See, I'm a grown up - not a child.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

The U.K. spends about 12% of its GDP on healthcare, we spend 18%.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"When I need something, the last place I want to go for it is some government bureaucracy."

You do know that government healthcare programs (Medicare, Medicaid) have much lower administrative costs than private insurance.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"you buy a plan with the things you want and are willing to pay for, including emergency care"

So when the ambulance shows up at the accident and says, "we can't take him, he is not part of our network", that is okay with you?

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"The idea that someone like me who can afford it should have everyone else pay for me is just unfair."

You do know that you have just told us exactly the whole point of insurance..

Peachy+2 म्हणाले...

Freder - not that I take much of anything you say at face value.
The left have been forcing private insurance and hospitals to dance to their mandates - for the ultimate goal of collapse and failure. Read Bagoh's post @ 10:31. Leftists forget how insurance actually works. Again - mass leftist economic illiteracy.
It's already been happening as we lose good nurses and doctors.

Leftists assume medical professionals want to work for free.
Leftists assume they want to spend all their time dancing to Bernie's 8" thick binder of mandates.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"Government care is rationed care."

Isn't private care rationed care based on a person's ability to pay for it?

bagoh20 म्हणाले...

"That was 2010-11, and both parties were starving the NHS, so it might not be the same anymore."

This is the inevitable path. People using things they don't pay for or contribute to is always unsustainable. You want it to be free or cheap. Nobody is demanding the right to pay for what they get, to fairly pay the people who provide it. I am. The U.S. system sucks too. They are overpaid, because the system separates the customer from the provider. You never even know the price until it's way past any choice by you, so why should they control costs. Both systems are unfair, because they take you out of the process. People who don't want to be responsible like that.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"Read Bagoh's post @ 10:31. Leftists forget how insurance actually works. "

Apparently Bagh2o doesn't know how insurance works either. And since you cited his post, you apparently don't either.

Mason G म्हणाले...

"Do Americans have the right to healthcare in every other major country in the world? Free for me in Canada or Mexico?"

I don't know why they shouldn't. Citizens of other countries get free health care here.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"People using things they don't pay for or contribute to is always unsustainable. "

You do realize that the NHS is paid for through taxes. Everyone pays or contributes to it.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"Citizens of other countries get free health care here."

No they don't. Maybe getting stabilized in an emergency, but that's it. There are always stories in England about people getting sick on vacation in the U.S. and end up with hundreds of thousands of dollars in medical costs.

Peachy+2 म्हणाले...

Explain how insurance works - Freder.

n.n म्हणाले...

Healthcare, not health care. Planned Parenthood... Personhood, perhaps, is a viable Choice.

Indefinitely Extended Excursion™️ म्हणाले...

It’s entertaining watching Rubio and Vance try to maintain as straight a poker face as possible in response to Trump’s comments. Vance was given the opportunity, on national television and right in front of Trump, to say, “I support the Iran war.” Instead, he said, “It’s my job to support the president.”

His job.

Vance seems to be trying to distance himself from Trump without actually appearing to distance himself from Trump. That’s quite a balancing act, and it’s going to be very entertaining to watch.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"Explain how insurance works - Freder."

You have a computer and the internet. Look it up your own damn self.

bagoh20 म्हणाले...
ही टिप्पणी लेखकाना हलविली आहे.
bagoh20 म्हणाले...

I know how it works, Freder. I've paid for, negotiated, and managed the health insurance for a couple thousand people in my career. You have a keyboard.
I'm not advocating for our current system. I want something entirely different. I want people to choose. Neither system allows that. A truly private system could have taxes subsidize the poor, but the important thing is to get the customer making choices rather than somebody who puts other things above your interests and choices. If providers know you won't pay for one thing, but will pay for another. You get the thing you need at the price you are willing to pay.

Peachy+2 म्हणाले...

Leftists lie.
Most or all Blue States have bloated budgets due to illegal immigrant healthcare spending.

Colorado:
Colorado’s Cover All Coloradans program (created by a 2022 bill Polis signed) provides Medicaid-like full coverage to low-income undocumented children and pregnant/postpartum people. It is state-funded (not federally matched like regular Medicaid for eligible citizens/lawful residents).
Costs exploded far beyond projections—from roughly $15 million expected to over $100 million (reports cite ~$104–105 million, about 7x estimates), with enrollment reaching tens of thousands (mostly children). This contributed to broader budget pressures amid a projected ~$1.5–1.6 billion shortfall. "
-------------------------------------------------------------GROK


Again - States are already in the red - and the left want to raise taxes, kill jobs and businesses - all for their grand plan of Canada care.

"Canadian Medical Association (CMA) leaders have repeatedly called the situation a crisis. Former CMA president Dr. Joss Reimer stated it was “very clear that the system is still in crisis,” citing frequent ER closures, record-high wait times for surgeries and diagnostics, and more than six million Canadians without a family doctor.
CMA materials have referred to the public system as “teetering on the brink of collapse” amid long surgical waits, ER closures, and staff shortages, while noting ~6.5 million people lack a regular primary care provider."

Achilles म्हणाले...

As long as I can opt out of the public option and not have to pay for sex changes and fat asses you all can have a public option.

But we all know that the public option is really about taking my money and giving it to the average 5'3" 170 pound woman who wants free birth control and abortions and hates men so much she turns her sons into eunuchs.

Free Health care is slavery.

People want to force you to give them stuff for free.

Especially lazy pieces of shit that produce nothing anyone wants.

Indefinitely Extended Excursion™️ म्हणाले...

A Medicare opt-in, or buy-in, is arguably a more politically and practically feasible path toward broader health coverage than immediately transitioning to Medicare for All.

Rather than asking Americans to embrace a complete overhaul of the health care system, Democrats could offer a public alternative and let its performance make the argument.

That may be a more pragmatic route toward universal coverage, even if it doesn’t necessarily lead to Medicare for All.

There’s another issue that needs serious attention: Medicare Advantage.

Medicare Advantage has become a lucrative business for private insurance companies, often at considerable additional expense to taxpayers. It’s time to rein in this privatization experiment and put the focus back where it belongs: patient care, not corporate profits.

I’ve yet to meet anyone who thinks the “Advantage” is worth the trade-offs

Peachy+2 म्हणाले...

No Freder - you Need to do it. Explain it.
You just stated above that we don't understand it.
You are wrong - YOU clearly do not understand how insurance works.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"If providers know you won't pay for one thing, but will pay for another. You get the thing you need at the price you are willing to pay."

So, you think everyone knows, or at least needs to know, what medical care they need?

Peachy+2 म्हणाले...

IUD - come for the bot, stay for the bad ideas.

Achilles म्हणाले...


Freder Frederson said...

"Explain how insurance works - Freder."

You have a computer and the internet. Look it up your own damn self.

Freder is a fucking moron who thinks that healthcare grows on a tree.

You can just walk out in the back yard and pick health care like fruit.

They don't know how anything actually works or how any of these services are actually created. They think MRI machines appear magically in hospitals when unicorns fart.

Freder thinks doctors and nurses are his slaves. He wants to tell them how much they get paid and who they have to help.

Freder also wants to deny health care to people who don't take the COVID shot or vote for the wrong party.

Indefinitely Extended Excursion™️ म्हणाले...

Give Americans a choice. Those happy with their employer-sponsored or private insurance can keep it. Those who prefer Medicare can opt in.

Rather than forcing a complete overhaul of the system, let Medicare compete with private insurance and demonstrate its value. Expand access, preserve choice, and let the results make the argument.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

This is from the Metlife website.

"To put it simply, you pay a premium (usually in the form of a monthly payment) to your insurance company, and in exchange, the company will help pay for any covered accidents, routine wellness visits, and many other situations. Once you’re enrolled in your plan and it has taken effect, you’re covered until you stop paying your premiums or your policy ends. Whether you go to a routine doctor’s visit, experience damage to your home or car, or just need your teeth cleaned, your insurance company will help pay for services that fall under the scope of their coverage — either by reimbursing you directly or paying the service provider."

Achilles म्हणाले...

Freder Frederson said...

"If providers know you won't pay for one thing, but will pay for another. You get the thing you need at the price you are willing to pay."

So, you think everyone knows, or at least needs to know, what medical care they need?

Freder knows exactly how much health care you need.

Freder decides, not you.

Freder decides, not a doctor.

If you and a doctor want to make a mutual arrangement for services fuck you and fuck that doctor. That doctor is Freder's slave and Freder will tell that doctor whose turn it is to see the doctor. You didn't vote for the right party. That health care is needed by some invader who just snuck across the border and votes for democrats.

Rabel म्हणाले...

Of course that's deliberately misleading. What he said was that (1) he would use his veto power until they came up with something he could agree to and (2) that some of the Republicans like Massie were worse than the democrats.

1 is classic Trump dealmaking, including flattering the other side, and 2 is absolute truth and a large part of why we now will have a Democrat Congress.

Achilles म्हणाले...

Freder Frederson said...

This is from the Metlife website.

Funny how Freder is a corporatist now too. When Freder is too busy to decide who gets health care he wants to leave it up to Metlife to decide who gets health care.

Achilles म्हणाले...

Indefinitely Extended Excursion™️ said...

Give Americans a choice. Those happy with their employer-sponsored or private insurance can keep it. Those who prefer Medicare can opt in.

Rather than forcing a complete overhaul of the system, let Medicare compete with private insurance and demonstrate its value. Expand access, preserve choice, and let the results make the argument.


Yeah, you can opt out of the shitty care. You have choices!

But you don't get to opt out of paying for it.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"he would use his veto power until they came up with something he could agree to"

Yeah, his plan (or at least a concept of a plan) will be released in two weeks.

Indefinitely Extended Excursion™️ म्हणाले...

Americans should have a genuine alternative to private insurance and that the existing system shouldn't be immune from scrutiny simply because some people are satisfied with their coverage.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"Yeah, you can opt out of the shitty care. You have choices!"

Weren't you advocating, just a few days ago, for the government to cover all medical care over $100,000.

Rabel म्हणाले...

"Yeah, his plan (or at least a concept of a plan) will be released in two weeks."

You seem confused about the process.

Humperdink म्हणाले...

Good Freder, check out the wait times elective surgery (read: heart bypass) in free healthcare in Canada.

We were exposed to free national healthcare in Belize. It was disgraceful.

An acquaintance of mine had a cardiac episode while in flight. Plane landed in Toronto, rushed him to the hospital …. and there he laid on the gurney for 2 hours before even being checked out by any hospital personnel.

P.S. I thought Obamacare was going to fix all this. Freder, I’ll bet you were on board with that fiasco also.

Achilles म्हणाले...

Freder Frederson said...

"Yeah, you can opt out of the shitty care. You have choices!"

Weren't you advocating, just a few days ago, for the government to cover all medical care over $100,000.

Of course.

Everything under 100,000 would be a cash system and unregulated supplemental insurance.

This is completely opposite functionally of all the retarded things you are pushing for.

Humperdink म्हणाले...

“Good grief Freder”

loudogblog म्हणाले...

Yeah, you can tell that Trump is really pissed at the Republicans in congress.

The thing about healthcare in the US is that it does need major reforms to work correctly. The problem is that lawmakers are afraid of doing anything because of the complexity and importance of the healthcare systems. It's like working with a stack of Jenga tiles; you never know which tile might bring the whole thing down if you try to move it.

Peachy+2 म्हणाले...

Canadian officials in charge of the government run system in Canada are openly saying it's in a state of collapse.
American left: Yay! Lets do this!

Indefinitely Extended Excursion™️ म्हणाले...

A Medicare opt-in doesn't mean taxpayers automatically pay everyone's health care bills.

People who choose the program contribute through premiums, employers can contribute as they do today, and taxpayers subsidize those who need assistance.

The fundamental question isn't simply how much Medicare opt-in would cost taxpayers. It's how much it would cost relative to what taxpayers, employers and individuals already spend on private health insurance.

bagoh20 म्हणाले...

One simple question: Should everyone, every single person, be entitled to the best medical care available at no cost? 1 million in end of life care? 1 million for for their third liver transplant. State of the art everything. If so, how is it paid for, if not, who decides?

bagoh20 म्हणाले...

We don't have a private system. We have a government controlled system written into law designed by insurance companies and donors from the medical industry to benefit them first and you last. The only alternative is not another government controlled system designed by the same people for the same purpose. Or do you think the Democrats are going to deny all that donor money because they love you that much?

bagoh20 म्हणाले...

Remember, the system we have was written and put in place solely by Democrats with no votes from Republicans in the middle of the night, and after telling you bald-faced lies about what you would have after they passed it and before they read it. "We have to pass it to see what's in it." ~Pelosi
Now were are going to let them do that again?

n.n म्हणाले...

Obamacares was a healthcare scheme and a first-order forcing of at least one affirmative action to entertain abortive ideation.

Aggie म्हणाले...

We do have the benefit of seeing this experiment play out in real life and real time, a few more miles down the road that our politicians are kicking the can along. It's Canada, where instead of providing life-saving treatment for serious medical problems, their socialized medical system takes a careful look and offers you the needle of death, instead. It sounds bad, but they're very pleasant about it, I hear. The bottom line is, well, the bottom line. It's not rationing, per se, because there's plenty.

bagoh20 म्हणाले...

The current system was designed with two objectives:
1) To piss you off, so you would ask for socialized medicine.
2) To make as much money for the Insurance industry as possible before that.
Mission accomplished.
The insurance industry was the frog - the Dems were the scorpion on it's back

grimson म्हणाले...

First, I want the plan detailed, not just a marketing name like "Medicare for all" tossed around.
And second, why can't this be delegated to the states; blue states could pursue a blue model and red states a red model.
Maybe Because several blue states have already rejected single-payer ballot proposals by wide margins--support was only 21% in Colorado, 27% in California, and 20% in Oregon.
And while Vermont did pass one, it was abandoned because it would have required a 151% increase in total state taxes.

n.n म्हणाले...

A human rite like Planned Patienthood (PP)? There are Diverse precedents. #HateLovesAbortion

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"One simple question: Should everyone, every single person, be entitled to the best medical care available at no cost?"

And I've got one for you: Should the quality of medical care be based solely on a person's ability to pay for it?

"Everything under 100,000 would be a cash system and unregulated supplemental insurance.

This is completely opposite functionally of all the retarded things you are pushing for."

Well, if you can't see how they are not completely opposite, you are dumber than I thought.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

I notice that 80 odd comments in, no one has suggested that government has no role to play in health care.

bagoh20 म्हणाले...

I think a Constitutional Amendment forcing Congress to follow the same rules and systems as the populace would have overwhelming support. The sad thing is that there would be millions who would disagree, and the press would have people on TV daily telling you how unfair that would be.

Rabel म्हणाले...

"A Medicare opt-in doesn't mean taxpayers automatically pay everyone's health care bills.

People who choose the program contribute through premiums, employers can contribute as they do today, and taxpayers subsidize those who need assistance."

A Medicare equivalent private insurance plan for two 40 year olds will cost them roughly 28k annually.

That's going to need a lot of subsidizing.

Josephbleau म्हणाले...

You would have to be a moron to think that Antifa and DSA are rioting to give all Americans quality health care. Slotkin wants to keep young republicans from being able to get jobs, much less healthcare.

“I did not see you at the riot the other day comrade, I hope your wife and kids don’t get sick, there may not be room for them at the hospital.”

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"A Medicare equivalent private insurance plan for two 40 year olds will cost them roughly 28k annually."

How much do you think private insurance costs--and don't forget your employer contribution? Also don't forget that your employer contribution is not taxed.

Mason G म्हणाले...

"Funny how Freder is a corporatist now too. When Freder is too busy to decide who gets health care he wants to leave it up to Metlife to decide who gets health care."

Not that long ago, the left celebrated the execution of health care executives.

Rabel म्हणाले...

"How much do you think private insurance costs"

I just gave you that number. 28k for two 40 yo's.

Try to pay attention.

Indefinitely Extended Excursion™️ म्हणाले...

𝘚𝘩𝘰𝘶𝘭𝘥 𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳𝘺𝘰𝘯𝘦, 𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳𝘺 𝘴𝘪𝘯𝘨𝘭𝘦 𝘱𝘦𝘳𝘴𝘰𝘯, 𝘣𝘦 𝘦𝘯𝘵𝘪𝘵𝘭𝘦𝘥 𝘵𝘰 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘣𝘦𝘴𝘵 𝘮𝘦𝘥𝘪𝘤𝘢𝘭 𝘤𝘢𝘳𝘦 𝘢𝘷𝘢𝘪𝘭𝘢𝘣𝘭𝘦 𝘢𝘵 𝘯𝘰 𝘤𝘰𝘴𝘵?

You’re presenting a false choice: unlimited medical care at any cost or leaving the current system alone.

Every health care system, including Medicare and private insurance, makes decisions about medical necessity, effectiveness and cost. The real question is who makes those decisions and whether access to necessary care depends on someone’s ability to pay.

Universal coverage doesn’t mean unlimited care. It means access to medically appropriate treatment without facing financial ruin.

I favor a Medicare opt-in. It offers people a choice without requiring everyone to abandon private insurance or promising unlimited government-funded treatment.

bagoh20 म्हणाले...

"I notice that 80 odd comments in, no one has suggested that government has no role to play in health care."

It's nice talking to reasonable peoples, isn't it.
Nobody even called you a racist or suggested you be prosecuted.

Josephbleau म्हणाले...

The way Medicare works is to collect a tax on everything you earn your whole life to partially pay for hospital care for your last 15 to 25 years. But that is just Medicsre part A hospital care, you still have to pay Medicare part B out of pocket to get real insurance for doctors care. And we can’t even pay for social security past 2030. This is a pipe dream.

D.D. Driver म्हणाले...

Trump working with Chuck Schumer and Nancy Pelosi to fix American healthcare....what could go wrong? This is what you voted for, MAGA.

bagoh20 म्हणाले...

"You’re presenting a false choice: unlimited medical care at any cost or leaving the current system alone."

I'm saying there is no solution to the problem of some medical care being unavailable to some people, regardless of the system, but advocates of socialized care pretend there is. One system says it will bankrupt you. The other says you will not get it, but they both say it very quietly, so quietly, you can't even hear it.

Hey Skipper म्हणाले...

Freder: "How much do you think private insurance costs--and don't forget your employer contribution? Also don't forget that your employer contribution is not taxed."

This has been an eternal mystery to me.

Employer paid health insurance is a deductible business expense. Yet if I pay for the exact same coverage out of pocket, then it will cost some 20% more because I paid for it from post-tax income.

This makes no sense.

Josephbleau म्हणाले...

If there is a Medicare opt in Congress will be paid off to allow corporations to drop private health care like eliminating pensions and going to 401ks. It will be a race to the bottom.

The reason it is not happening now is that Obama Care is just too shitty to make it feasible. And universal health care will have to be means tested where middle class people pay progressively higher rates, and certainly higher taxes, under a progressive income tax.

rehajm म्हणाले...

…like most other socialist nations, us healthcare will be a complete disaster. During the Obama administration we rehashed all the 19th century fundamental reasons why socialism fails. Obama was going to cap doctor salaries at a fixed dollar amount, hire with dei, ‘force’ drug companies and other medical suppliers to accept take it or leave it single payer pricing…and that’s just for openers…

Humperdink म्हणाले...

Has anyone the league leaders in skyrocketing costs.are healthcare and higher education? Gee why is that? Could it be the Feds have their fingers in it? Make that the whole arm, all the way down to the rectum?

Hey Skipper म्हणाले...

"The NHS has serious, well-documented problems with public satisfaction over performance (especially waits) and with finances/capacity."

Freder: "Like I said, in the last fifteen years, NHS has been raided by both Conservative and Labour governments alike. Even I when I was there, there were constant complaints about how it was underfunded."

Wrong.

According to AI: "Since 1995, per capita NHS funding in the United Kingdom has risen substantially in real terms overall, though growth has moved through sharp expansionary phases, periods of restraint, and a COVID-19 surge. In 2024/25, public health spending per head reached £3,462 in England, £3,539 in Scotland, £3,659 in Northern Ireland, and £3,758 in Wales (with total DHSC spending in England at £3,492 per person), while total UK healthcare expenditure—including private spending—reached roughly £4,966 per person in 2025."

"In my one encounter with nationalized healthcare, in Germany, I was not impressed."

Freder: "Did you live there? For how long? I lived in England and Germany and preferred their system to ours."

I lived in England for seven years. I had one experience with the NHS, around 1990. My grandmother slipped and fell on our driveway, breaking her wrist. Three hour wait in the empty Oxford ER.

More recently, I lived for five years in Düsseldorf. My wife came off her bike and did a number on her right shoulder. Surgery was good, facilities shabby. Happened during a week in the 90's. No AC, no fans. I had to bring one from our apartment, fortunately only a five minute walk. Oh, and no ice.

Oh, and both England and Germany pay a 20% VAT on the vast majority of purchases. Free health care isn't so free, is it?

rehajm म्हणाले...

“Oh, and both England and Germany pay a 20% VAT on the vast majority of purchases. Free health care isn't so free, is it?“

..he’s got you there, commie…

Josephbleau म्हणाले...

About 53.5% of Americans have employer-sponsored private health insurance, according to the latest Census Bureau figures for 2025. On average corporations pay $20,800 per family, and the family pays $7400. So the tax deduction is just a way to keep that going and it is unfair to individuals. Like the whole tax system is unfair because I can’t depreciate the cost of my new roof over 20 years and deduct part of it in my taxes.

Individuals are not allowed to do a lot of things on taxes that companies are, I suppose to encourage people to start companies or that companies pay off Congress more than regular people do. Corruption hurts us all, it’s theft from the taxpayers, no one in Congress should be proud of themselves.

Hey Skipper म्हणाले...

Bernie: "Our job now is to do what every other major country does: guarantee healthcare to all as a human right and substantially lower the cost of prescription drugs."

You ignorant socialist slut.

You make healthcare a right, then providing healthcare becomes an obligation. That is exactly how socialism ends up in slavery.

Hey Skipper म्हणाले...

Oh, forgot: "... and substantially lower the cost of prescription drugs."

How?

Peachy+2 म्हणाले...

Nothing is free. It's all a shell game.
with bonus grift for those in charge.

rehajm म्हणाले...

…corporate taxes, ‘company’ taxes are pass through taxes. They result in higher costs for goods, lower wages and benefits for workers, fewer job opportunities for workers and lower returns for investors, including 401k and pension fund investors. Corporate taxes are not free money for ‘people’…

Hey Skipper म्हणाले...

rehajm: Corporate taxes serve only to hide the cost of government.

Freder: "The U.K. spends about 12% of its GDP on healthcare, we spend 18%."

First, tell me what comes under the heading of "healthcare."

For example, it is certain that Americans pay far more for orthodontists than the UK citizens. How about cosmetic surgery?

Also, perhaps the biggest reason Americans pay a greater portion of per capita GDP is ours is 56% more than the UK.

Hombre म्हणाले...

Not likely. But Trump’s boorishness calls him to retaliate and Republicans deserve it.

Achilles म्हणाले...

loudogblog said...

Yeah, you can tell that Trump is really pissed at the Republicans in congress.

He should be. They are all cowardly pieces of shit.

The thing about healthcare in the US is that it does need major reforms to work correctly. The problem is that lawmakers are afraid of doing anything because of the complexity and importance of the healthcare systems. It's like working with a stack of Jenga tiles; you never know which tile might bring the whole thing down if you try to move it.

This is a consequence of letting every retard in the world vote.

Social Security fundamentally changed our government from a Republic to a greedy tribal spoils system where old people vote to take young people's money.

At that point we are squabbling pigs at the trough voting to take each others money.

Mason G म्हणाले...

"Oh, forgot: "... and substantially lower the cost of prescription drugs."

How?"

Spoiler alert: By force- it's that 'slavery' thing again.

Achilles म्हणाले...

Freder Frederson said...

"One simple question: Should everyone, every single person, be entitled to the best medical care available at no cost?"

And I've got one for you: Should the quality of medical care be based solely on a person's ability to pay for it?

Yes.

The alternative is slavery. Explain how you are going to give people health care they don't have to pay for without slavery.

But Freder is a democrat and slavery is a foundational principal of Freder's world view.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"Also, perhaps the biggest reason Americans pay a greater portion of per capita GDP is ours is 56% more than the UK."

That makes no sense at all. Shouldn't our higher GDP mean less, not more, spending on healthcare?

"I just gave you that number. 28k for two 40 yo's."

And as it turns out, Josephbleu did his research and found out that is almost the same as what we (our employers and ourselves) are already paying for healthcare.

Achilles म्हणाले...

"Everything under 100,000 would be a cash system and unregulated supplemental insurance.

This is completely opposite functionally of all the retarded things you are pushing for."

Well, if you can't see how they are not completely opposite, you are dumber than I thought.

LOL!

Freder doesn't even understand the foundational concepts we are discussing.

That is why Freder supports slavery and doesn't even realize it.

Let me help you retard. Nobody wants to be a doctor in Canada for what it pays. That is why it takes months to see a doctor.

So now they are pledging to import millions of people from India because they will be good little slave doctors.

This will only happen every single time you retards are put in charge.

john mosby म्हणाले...

Mason: "substantially lower the cost of prescription drugs."/How?"/Spoiler alert: By force- "

Well, Rx drugs are spawn of force. The patents are monopoly grants backed by government force. So is the prescription requirement.

If you turned them all into OTC meds, with only trade-secret protection available to the manufacturer (see Coke), that would be rolling back force, not imposing force.

Not saying any of that would give you great policy results. Just saying what direction the arrow of force actually points.

Sort of like when socialists say tax cuts give people money. CC, JSM

ForestwithouttreeS म्हणाले...

Sanders says health care is a human right as if that is some profound insight. Is housing a human right? Education? What about food? I don’t understand the point.

rehajm म्हणाले...

…going by their supporters Maybachs are a human right…

Rustygrommet म्हणाले...

Then I suggest you go to the UK for your healthcare.
The average wait time for an MRI is 4 to eight weeks.
The average wait time for a hip replacement is 28 weeks.
I'm on Medicare. I waited two days for an MRI. If a went to a private clinic I could of had one in a couple of hours. My wait for my hip replacement was 3 weeks. If I was on private insurance I could of had it done in a week. The wait times are even longer in Canada.

I pay for Medicare out of my SS. I also have supplementary health insurance that I pay for out of pocket.

Rustygrommet म्हणाले...

Nothing that someone else has to pay for is a right.
The problem we are having with health insurance is that nobody knows where the floor is. There are so many third parties involved. Find the base and go from there. The free market for healthcare doesn't exist.

rehajm म्हणाले...

“…and substantially lower the cost of prescription drugs. How? Spoiler alert: By force…”

…in the end perhaps yes, it means workers are forced to manufacture drugs if the state demands they do but the economic reasoning the commies use is even dumber that that- their claim is drug costs will be lower because the only customer will be the state. Therefore the state has ultimate pricing power!!!! Ignore the short term truth that drug makers will choose to stop producing drugs and stay home since there’s no financial incentive to endure the economic risks…

Rustygrommet म्हणाले...

Freder Frederson said...

"One simple question: Should everyone, every single person, be entitled to the best medical care available at no cost?"

No.

Rustygrommet म्हणाले...

Peachy+2 said...
Yeah - 2 failing socialized gov run health care systems - those in UK and Canada are failing, broke and unpopular.
Lets do it.
If Trump goes full commie care - he can F right off.

Peachy, darling girl, Trump is a moderate Democrat. He's always been a moderate Democrat.

Aggie म्हणाले...

It would seem that Freder has serious problems with everybody else's views on this subject, but even more serious problems with just articulating views of his own.

Maybe Freder is over sensitive to criticism. Or maybe he doesn't have any actual views. Maybe he's just here to sow a little confusion.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"I pay for Medicare out of my SS. I also have supplementary health insurance that I pay for out of pocket."

So, you have government provided healthcare? What is your point?

"..he’s got you there, commie…"

Gee, government funded healthcare isn't free!? You have to pay for through your taxes?!

How come no one ever told me that?

Ignore everything I have said on this subject.

n.n म्हणाले...

The issue is price progression forced by monopolistic, redistributive schemes that occurred with education, homes, etc.

Hey Skipper म्हणाले...

"Also, perhaps the biggest reason Americans pay a greater portion of per capita GDP is ours is 56% more than the UK."

Freder: That makes no sense at all. Shouldn't our higher GDP mean less, not more, spending on healthcare?

No, for two reasons.

First, Americans have a lot more disposable income than do the British: per the OECD, the US household disposable income is $62,000/year, British, $38,000. So, Americans have a lot more to spend on everything — compare an average American house to a British one — including healthcare.

Second, it depends on what you mean by "healthcare". I wouldn't be the least surprised if there are no orthodontists in the UK, but orthodontia here is nearly a right of passage.

And that isn't the only example of something coming under the heading of healthcare, but is far less common in the UK because it is generally optional and the Brits don't have the disposable income to afford it.

A better question to ask would be more specific: how much does a specific instance of healthcare, say, hip replacement, cost in the US, compared to the NHS?

I can't remember where I read it, but of three characteristics of healthcare — readily available, high quality, and low cost — choose two.

bagoh20 म्हणाले...

I'm willing to pay for 100% of the healthcare I want either through direct purchase or insurance.

Who's with me?

That's what I thought.

Achilles म्हणाले...

bagoh20 said...

I'm willing to pay for 100% of the healthcare I want either through direct purchase or insurance.

Who's with me?

That's what I thought.


Me.

But we are part of the small group of people that make all of these demands for free things by lazy retards who don't know how anything works possible.

bagoh20 म्हणाले...

""We could end up with great healthcare in our country."

If only that was the goal.
The only thing in our favor is that the current Democrat designed system is so bad that it would be hard to make it worse.
Nobody likes it. Not the customers, not the providers and amazingly, not even the people who gave it to us. Remember, after passing it, they opted out themselves. That should make you trust them to do it again.

Achilles म्हणाले...

Freder Frederson said...

Gee, government funded healthcare isn't free!? You have to pay for through your taxes?!

How come no one ever told me that?

Ignore everything I have said on this subject.


A retard who thinks the government can produce health care.

A lazy dumb piece of shit who doesn't even know where the food in the grocery store comes from and thinks Mamdani will make it free in City run grocery stores.

These people are just completely retarded and worthless. They don't know how anything is actually built or how wealth is actually created.

We would be better off without all of the Freder's begging for free shit.

Freder should go to Afghanistan and tell the people there Health Care is a right. The people of Afghanistan have a better idea of where things come from than Freder does.

Christopher B म्हणाले...

Trump will get more legislation passed with Democrats in charge than with the do-nothing GOPe running things. Maybe even more judges

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...


"I'm willing to pay for 100% of the healthcare I want either through direct purchase or insurance.

Who's with me?"

Until you are down to your last penny? Then what happens, they dump you on the street and let you die?

"Me."
Well, no you aren't. You are only willing to pay for the first $100,000. After that, you want the government to pay for it.

Iman म्हणाले...

Spot the difference…

Capitalist Maker Elon:

$3.3 trillion in value with Companies
Pays salaries of 160,000 people
Lives in a trailer

Communist Taker Bernie:

$36 trillion of debt while in Congress
Pays salaries of 0 people
Lives in multiple homes

The Creator vs The Grifter.

https://x.com/c_3c_3/status/2123575905704382510?a=OMai486DP4a9a_XZ3lQ&s=46

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

A better question to ask would be more specific: how much does a specific instance of healthcare, say, hip replacement, cost in the US, compared to the NHS?

When my niece was born in the UK, she weighed two pounds. Her grandparents are American, and they just couldn't wrap their head around the fact that there were no unpaid medical bills to pay. My brother kept having to remind them that they didn't have to send them money.

And I can't speak to England but I can give you an example from Germany, but I will give you a direct comparison. My ACL repair (see above for how much an ER visit cost in Canada compared the U.S.) in 1997 cost $40000. In 2010, my friend (U.S. civilian working for the Air Force in Europe) tore her ACL. She got her ACL repaired at a German hospital (krankenhaus--literally "sick house"). She had to pay out of pocket and then make a claim with her insurance company in the states--$10000

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"Lives in a trailer"

He does not.

Spiros म्हणाले...

By public option, I'm not thinking of an alternative to traditional insurance policies. Instead, Americans would have the option to buy into a program that covers catastrophic medical expenses, let's say above $ 50,000. I want the government to provide protection against financially ruinous medical expenses. Americans would still pay for most care themselves or buy private coverage for those costs.

A private insurance company can provide that sort of coverage for around $2,000 a year. The federal government might be able to get that cost done to $ 1,500 per year since it won't have to pay for administrative expenses, profits, CEO salaries, advertisements, etc.

I know this sort of insurance is terrible for most people but it is still better than nothing.

Spiros म्हणाले...

Also universal catastrophic coverage is not socialism. It is something, like Obamacare, that has its beginnings in GOP circles. Ronald Reagan's chief economist, Martin Feldstein, was the first guy to propose it. I think it's time has come and Trump is the man to get it over the finish line.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"let's say above $ 50,000. I want the government to provide protection against financially ruinous medical expenses. Americans would still pay for most care themselves or buy private coverage for those costs."

Oh yeah, let's pretend that $50,000 or $100,000 dollars in medical bills is not "catastrophic". Do you really believe that the crisis in medical care is that people cannot or are unwilling to pay $50,000 in medical bills? The problems arise when you have a serious or rare illness that ends up costing north of a million dollars. There would be no debate if paying more than $50 K for medical bills was rare. By the time my mother-in-law died her medical care (and she had excellent insurance) cost her over $700,000 out of pocket.

Big Mike म्हणाले...

“Ignore everything I have said on this subject.”

We certainly have to, Fredo, because if you had a clue it would be the first clue you’ve ever had. You had a good experience with Canada’s healthcare. Lucky you. As far as I’m concerned Canada’s healthcare system tried to kill me.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"Also universal catastrophic coverage is not socialism."

Just because you unequivocally state something, does not make it true.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"We certainly have to, Fredo, because if you had a clue it would be the first clue you’ve ever had. "

You didn't answer my question about whether you are on medicare.

n.n म्हणाले...

Without Democratic dissonance, we'll have great Republican support. There is division in Diversity.

Lazarus म्हणाले...

The last time I was in Germany, health care (in a university town) was quite impressive, but quality and prices vary over time, so your experience may vary. The world isn't what it was 40 years ago.

I would be wary of government assuming any more mandates, until we dig ourselves a bit out of the whole we're in, though.

Indefinitely Extended Excursion™️ म्हणाले...

I think a comprehensive single-payer system is unlikely to become a reality anytime soon. The financing challenge alone will be enormous.

Healthcare reform should be about delivering better, more affordable care, not simply shifting the bill to taxpayers and expanding government.

Good intentions are not a financing plan.

A more realistic path is a compromise involving expanded Medicare eligibility, a public option and stronger regulation of private insurers. That regulation should address genuine abuses and inefficiencies without creating so many requirements that it drives up premiums or reduces competition. Those trade-offs matter, too.

The goal should be better healthcare, not simply bigger government.

Rabel म्हणाले...

"A private insurance company can provide that sort of coverage for around $2,000 a year."

"Bronze is usually the lowest-premium plan available to anyone (unlike Catastrophic, which is restricted to people under 30 or those with a hardship exemption).

Obamacare. It's the law.

bagoh20 म्हणाले...

Imagine if Congress were full of intelligent, competent people who cared about doing what is best for Americans regardless of the political cost. Maybe such a group could come up with a good system, but it would be very hard, because it's a tough, complicated problem that requires leaving a lot of people dissatisfied.

Now imagine the real Congress trying it. Elections matter.

Mason G म्हणाले...

"Americans would still pay for most care themselves or buy private coverage for those costs."

You lost all the leftards right there. They think healthcare should be free.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"Instead, Americans would have the option to buy into a program that covers catastrophic medical expenses, let's say above $ 50,000. I want the government to provide protection against financially ruinous medical expenses. Americans would still pay for most care themselves or buy private coverage for those costs."

And this is different from "socialized healthcare" how? And remember, of those routine medical expenses less than $50,000, a lot of them (e.g., prescriptions for chronic illness, mammograms, PSA tests, colonoscopies, routine checkups, etc.) are exactly what prevents (or at least lowers) the risk of your need for "catastrophic expenses".

n.n म्हणाले...
ही टिप्पणी लेखकाना हलविली आहे.
n.n म्हणाले...

Health care begins with personal responsibility for Choice... uh, choice. Human rites are the final, wicked solution of socialist regimes armed with liberal license following progressive pathologies.

Aggie म्हणाले...

You could solve a lot of health care problems by just forcing medical institutions to show price transparency in billing, where patients could actually understand what they're being charged for, item by item, in plain English, so they can dispute it before they pay it. Laws forcing hospitals to do it or pay immediate crippling fines. What is preventing Congress from passing this kind of legislation, one might wonder. Especially with the professional concern goblins like Elizabeth Warren, who is always telling us how much she cares about consumers and wants to protect them.

Aggie म्हणाले...

'You didn't answer my question about whether you are on medicare. ...'

Fredo, you haven't disclosed a single personal view on this subject yet, and I count over a dozen posts under your name. Why the Big Secret? What do you think healthcare should look like, a person with your wealth of international experience? Surely you must have formed views, yet you seem confined to disputing, arguing, criticizing what others that have stepped up and articulated. How come you won't?

Hey Skipper म्हणाले...

Hey Skipper: "A better question to ask would be more specific: how much does a specific instance of healthcare, say, hip replacement, cost in the US, compared to the NHS?"

Freder: "When my niece was born in the UK, she weighed two pounds. Her grandparents are American, and they just couldn't wrap their head around the fact that there were no unpaid medical bills to pay. My brother kept having to remind them that they didn't have to send them money.

And I can't speak to England but I can give you an example from Germany, but I will give you [an indirect] comparison: My ACL repair (see above for how much an ER visit cost in Canada compared the U.S.) in 1997 cost $40000. In 2010, my friend (U.S. civilian working for the Air Force in Europe) tore her ACL. She got her ACL repaired at a German hospital (krankenhaus--literally "sick house"). She had to pay out of pocket and then make a claim with her insurance company in the states--$10000."

——

I think you are confusing cost with price.
When I got my hip jobs — I collected the entire set — five years ago, they were $13,000 a whack, and seems very reasonable for the facilities and training involved. Less than a month between thinking I need to see the doc to the replacement.

In the UK, a *private* hip replacement costs $15,000 to $20,000. On the NHS, who the hell knows, except it isn't free. Oh, and wait times can exceed a year. (Oddly, AI says the hospital stay is typically 2-3 nights. On each of mine I checked in at 0900, and was out under my own power — with a walker, of course — same day at 1600.)

The point being that procedure costs likely aren't all that different between the US and UK, outside the NHS. Of course, a hip replacement on the NHS isn't free, and it is likely no one knows how much it really is. (Nor was your niece's NICU.) AI sure didn't.

Hey Skipper म्हणाले...

Spiros said...
"
By public option, I'm not thinking of an alternative to traditional insurance policies. Instead, Americans would have the option to buy into a program that covers catastrophic medical expenses, let's say above $ 50,000."

I'm not sure which is the biggest problem with universal health care, but dependency has to be near the top of the list. *Nothing* is required to receive an entitlement. Imagine single payer housing, or single payer food.

Oh, wait, that has been tried, hasn't it?

We already have HSA's. Perhaps augmenting that with a similar account to be used solely for single catastrophic events, which could build to a fairly high limit, then catastrophic medical above that.

Problems: Participation, risk pricing, and pre-existing conditions. What to do about those who won't pay, or who present a high-risk of significant future claims, or decide to participate only on receiving bad news?

So far as I can tell, there is no evidence that single payer reduces healthcare costs, but it sure as heck stifles innovation, encourages dependency, and explodes wait times.

Guaranteed catastrophic coverage would be a good start.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"I think you are confusing cost with price.
When I got my hip jobs — I collected the entire set — five years ago, they were $13,000 a whack"

I wasn't confusing cost with price. I specifically told you that I could not offer a direct comparison with the U.K. I just thought I would relate the difference between the U.S. and U.K. I know that her cost wasn't "free". But if you have a child in NCIU for over three months, knowing that you don't have to worry about bills is a blessing in an already probably the most stressful time of your life.

My concrete example was the difference between an ACL repair in Germany and the U.S. My friend was billed as though she was paying cash (which technically she was, the Germans don't care how much the insurance in the U.S. is going to pay). Fourteen years after I had my ACL repaired (and yes, it was covered by insurance) her repair cost about 1/4 of what my bill was.

btw, if you got your hip replacement for $13000 a whack, please send me the name of your doctor. My wife had a knee replacement ten years ago and it cost (covered by insurance) a whole lot more than that. I don't remember the exact cost, but it was well over $50,000.

Hey Skipper म्हणाले...

"Instead, Americans would have the option to buy into a program that covers catastrophic medical expenses, let's say above $ 50,000. I want the government to provide protection against financially ruinous medical expenses. Americans would still pay for most care themselves or buy private coverage for those costs."

Freder: And this is different from "socialized healthcare" how? And remember, of those routine medical expenses less than $50,000, a lot of them (e.g., prescriptions for chronic illness, mammograms, PSA tests, colonoscopies, routine checkups, etc.) are exactly what prevents (or at least lowers) the risk of your need for "catastrophic expenses".

——

I'm not sure why the government needs to get involved, other than requiring companies participating in the health insurance market to provide such coverage.

Kind of like requiring fire insurance as a condition of getting and keeping a mortgage.

I have no idea how common catastrophic health events are, but of all the people I can think of off hand, I know one. So long as the risk in the insurance pool is low, so should cost. Let the market sort it out.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"Kind of like requiring fire insurance as a condition of getting and keeping a mortgage."

In some places, so is flood insurance, which is covered 100% by the U.S. government.

"I have no idea how common catastrophic health events are, but of all the people I can think of off hand, I know one. "

Well then, you are truly blessed, as are all the people you can think of (except of course, for that one).

I would consider a double hip replacement is pretty damn close to a catastrophic health event

Humperdink म्हणाले...

I get it now. The Commies are going to claim their plan will make healthcare affordable, you just won’t get any. But hey it will be cheap.

Jim at म्हणाले...

*One of the big divides in the country is between people who want to take responsibility for themselves and those who want someone else too. *

Yep. The measles thread from the other day is a prime example.

rehajm म्हणाले...

Instead of a wrestling rematch …it’s all right here in this helpful little pamphlet that was thrown in the bin. We’re probably closer to this now than before the ‘election’…

Rustygrommet म्हणाले...

Ignore everything I have said on this subject.

No problem.

Jim at म्हणाले...

*I notice that 80 odd comments in, no one has suggested that government has no role to play in health care.*

I notice that 80 comments in, you've made nearly half of them and you still don't know what the fuck you're talking about.

Mason G म्हणाले...

Do any of the people who insist that paid-for-by-others healthcare is a right also insist that the government provide people with guns?

Because possessing them is a right, too. One that is explicitly noted in the Constitution.

Jim at म्हणाले...

*I can't remember where I read it, but of three characteristics of healthcare — readily available, high quality, and low cost — choose two.*

Back when Washington state passed their own version of HillaryCare (1993-94) we warned the Democrats it wasn't going to work simply because of the point you refer to. We called it the three-legged stool. You can have affordability and access, but not high quality care. You can have high-quality care and access, but it's going to cost you out the ass. And so on.

When we got the majority two years later, we repealed that steaming pile of shit, but the damage was done.

The individual insurance market fled the state and - more than 30 years later - has yet to return.

It's a very simple concept ... which explains why some people still don't understand it.

Rustygrommet म्हणाले...

I would consider a double hip replacement is pretty damn close to a catastrophic health event

Really? It's an outpatient procedure.

tcrosse म्हणाले...

As P.J. O'Rourke noted, if you think healthcare is expensive now, wait 'til it's free.

Hey Skipper म्हणाले...

Freder: “ I would consider a double hip replacement is pretty damn close to a catastrophic health event.”

Outpatient. In response to the slow advance of arthritis. Hour long surgery. No PT. In three weeks, my post-surgery discomfort was less than the minimal arthritis pain I went in with. $26k total.

Pretty much the opposite of sudden or catastrophic.

Also, hip replacement is an absolute doddle compared to knee surgery.

The point, though, is comparing costs. Countries with single payer have *identifiable* costs to those without. NHS makes it impossible to know what the same surgery costs them, and they don’t have to make a profit.

We are learing that can lead to corruption.

Hey Skipper म्हणाले...

Hey Skipper: "Kind of like requiring fire insurance as a condition of getting and keeping a mortgage."

Freder: “In some places, so is flood insurance, which is covered 100% by the U.S. government.”

You do realize that is an admission against interest, don’t you?

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

"Outpatient. In response to the slow advance of arthritis. Hour long surgery. "

I find that very hard to believe. When my wife had her knee replaced, there were other people getting their hips replaced. They told everyone to plan for a week in the hospital for post surgery recovery and P.T. My wifes procedure went very well so they let her go after three days. But then there was 8 weeks of physical therapy (which friends we made at the hospital who got hip replacement had pretty much the same regimen). When I had an ACL repair, much easier than a knee replacement, I had to stay at the hospital overnight. Technically, I was not "admitted" because they kept me there a couple minutes short of twenty-four hours. I had ten weeks of PT before I regained normal range of motion.

"You do realize that is an admission against interest, don’t you?"

How so? I was merely pointing out that mortgages in certain areas require flood insurance as well as general homeowners (read your policy, it specifically does not cover flooding). The only entity that writes flood insurance policies in the U.S. is the federal government. Your insurance company will handle the policy for you and bill you, but premiums are paid directly to the U.S. government, and it is responsible for paying out claims. I am not even sure if your insurance agent receives gets a commission for acting as an intermediary. But if he or she does, the government pays that, not you.

Peachy+2 म्हणाले...

Jim At~
*I notice that 80 odd comments in, no one has suggested that government has no role to play in health care.*

This!

Peachy+2 म्हणाले...

Forcing everyone to have it is the tell.

I don't want it. I will pay my own way in life.

Just an old country lawyer म्हणाले...

As a 77 year old retired lawyer and Republican, I don't want to learn about their plans for my geriatric care the hard way. Maybe involuntary MAiD service.

Kurt Schuler म्हणाले...

Two main factors make the current U.S. health care system so complex. One is that health insurance paid by employers is not taxed. That dates back to World War II. It means that anyone trying to get individual health insurance has to pay for it in more expensive post-tax dollars. The other factor is the extensive involvement of the federal government.
Other insurance markets are simpler and work better because they have neither factor. Automobile insurance is not tax deductible when provided by an employer and the federal government does not provide it for millions of people. Poor people and old people get welfare payments and if they want to buy automobile insurance they go into the same market as everyone else.
John C. Goodman (the economist, who uses his middle initial to distinguish himself from the famous actor) has written extensively about how to get from the current system to a more efficient one that makes greater use of markets. Here is one of his writings on the Web site of his think tank:
https://www.goodmaninstitute.org/our-priorities/the-worlds-greatest-healthcare-plan/

Iman म्हणाले...

Musk “lives in a trailer"

Fredo said, “He does not.”

Per Google…
“Yes, Elon Musk has temporarily stayed in an Airstream trailer, though it is not his permanent home.
• The Trailer Arrangement: Musk confirmed during an appearance at the All-In Summit that he has been living in an Airstream trailer in Memphis, Tennessee.
• Why He Is There: He parked the trailer near xAI’s "Colossus" data center buildout so he could sleep steps away from the servers while overseeing the project.
• Permanent Residence: His primary long-term residence remains a modest, ~400-square-foot prefabricated Boxabl home valued at around $50,000 near SpaceX's Starbase facility in Boca Chica, Texas.“

Iman म्हणाले...

Perhaps you should seek “confidence reduction” surgery, Fredo.

Hey Skipper म्हणाले...

Hey Skipper: "Outpatient. In response to the slow advance of arthritis. Hour long surgery. "

Freder: "I find that very hard to believe. When my wife had her knee replaced, there were other people getting their hips replaced."

——

Are you calling me a liar?

Although, to be fair, I only have first-hand experience to go on.

Pretty much how it went for me, twice. Similar to her, I was 66 and 67.

At my post op meeting with the surgeon six weeks later, I said: "I feel like I have the hips of an 18 year old."

His response: "And you will die with the hips of an 18 year old."

There are untold number of innovations that created that result. *None* of them the consequence of single payer healthcare, or socialism in any form.

——

Hey Skipper: "You do realize that is an admission against interest, don’t you?"


Freder: "How so? I was merely pointing out that mortgages in certain areas require flood insurance as well as general homeowners (read your policy, it specifically does not cover flooding). The only entity that writes flood insurance policies in the U.S. is the federal government."

Two words: moral hazard.

The same kind of moral hazard attending single payer healthcare: life choices have no financial consequence.

Rustygrommet म्हणाले...

Freder Frederson said...
"Outpatient. In response to the slow advance of arthritis. Hour long surgery. "

I find that very hard to believe. When my wife had her knee replaced, there were other people getting their hips replaced. They told everyone to plan for a week in the hospital for post surgery recovery and P.T. My wifes procedure went very well so they let her go after three days.

Where were you? In the 1980s. A butcher shop?
The surgery takes about an hour. When you wake up you're expected to stand up and , with a walker, walk up and down the unit. Then you go home. Six weeks of PT. I had no post surgery pain at all.
Knees are about the except for 12 weeks of PT. Also outpatient.
Maybe get better Drs

Hey Skipper म्हणाले...

Rustygrommet: Total agreement, save for one thing: none PT.

Freder Frederson म्हणाले...

“Yes, Elon Musk has temporarily stayed in an Airstream trailer, though it is not his permanent home."

You left a lot out. Like how his companies own $40 million worth of residential properties for his personal use. Or that he is building a huge compound for him, his children, and their mothers.

If Musk decides to do some performative PR where he spends a couple nights in an Airstream or claims he is sleeping in his office, it is not because he needs to, but because he wants to. Apparently to impress dullards like you.

Big Mike म्हणाले...

@Fredo, a lot depends on the surgeon (how current with best practices) and when. My first total knee replacement was in 2008. I woke up in the hospital bed with my knee KKK t swollen to approximately the size of a rugby ball., except it was black and purple, with swatches of a sickly yellow-green where traces of surgical soap remained. I did some therapy in the hospital and was released but directed to stay home. A therapist visited me at home forcing me into painful exercises to break up scar tissue and prevent new scar tissue This was followed by weeks of 3 times a week therapy sessions at a therapist affiliated with the hospital. But in the end I could walk as far as my cardio fitness would let me, and basically get on with my life.

The second knee was replaced 6 yesrs later, and I woke up in the hospital recovery room. I was moved onto a gurney, wheeled to my room, helped off the gurney there in the doorway, given a walker, and told to walk to my bed. My three days this time involved very little watching TV from my bed but a lot of walking up and down the hospital corridors mixed with therapy sessions focused on getting up and down from chairs and sofas, climbing stairs, and getting in snd out of cars. I had about 4 weeks of therapy sessions and was pretty much as good as new well before the end of those weeks.

टिप्पणी पोस्ट करा

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 4 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith. Also: No italics, even briefly. Use asterisks for emphasis. And don't play with the format by changing fonts or using boldface or all caps. Never include more than one extra line break between paragraphs.