২১ সেপ্টেম্বর, ২০২৫

"My husband Charlie — he wanted to save young men just like the one who took his life.... That young man — I forgive him."

"I forgive him because it was what Christ did and is what Charlie would do." That was the strongest moment of the 5-hour memorial, the widow forgiving the murderer — because it is what Christ did.

The other exceptionally strong statement of Christianity came from Marco Rubio:

৬৯টি মন্তব্য:

Roger von Oech বলেছেন...

Erika Kirk’s eulogy was quite amazing. So much poise. And what a powerful message she shared.

Inga বলেছেন...

I hate my opponent and I don’t want the best for them…I can’t stand my opponent.

n.n বলেছেন...

Erika and Marco were on point, offered a memorable tribute, and an inspiration for our Posterity.

#HateLovesAbortion

Once written, twice... বলেছেন...

Both offered beautiful descriptions of Christ's path.

Disparity of Cult বলেছেন...

Trump's admission of his human weakness was a tribute to Kirk, by way of contrast.

n.n বলেছেন...

"He did not hate his opponents. He wanted the best for them. That's where I disagreed with Charlie. I hate my opponent and I don't want the best for them. I'm sorry. I am sorry Erika."

Trump acknowledges his own imperfection, and honors the effort led by Charlie to realize his Christian principles.

To overcome Diversity and strife.
To overcome adversity through personal responsibility and charity.
To overcome hate's love of abortion.
To honor his Father, follow His religion (i.e. behavioral protocol or model), with faith (i.e. trust) and fidelity.

Inga বলেছেন...

I doubt Trump sees his hate of his opponents as an imperfection. I suspect he sees it as his strength. He’s sorry that he had to disagree with Erika and Charlie Kirk, but I doubt that he is sorry for harboring all that hate in his heart. It was shocking hearing the POTUS spout such dark shit at a memorial.

Inga বলেছেন...
এই মন্তব্যটি লেখক দ্বারা সরানো হয়েছে।
Mason G বলেছেন...

"I hate my opponent and I don’t want the best for them…I can’t stand my opponent."

His opponents tried to kill him, you fucking imbecile. If you wanted to encourage him to have concern for your well-being, maybe you shouldn't be supporting the people who did that.

Breezy বলেছেন...

Such a horrific, senseless loss. RIP Charlie Kirk. Long live Charlie Kirk.

Wince বলেছেন...

"Persecutors" would have been a more accurate word for Trump to use in connection with "hate" than "opponents."

Trump has demonstrated an incredible ability to bury the hatchet with opponents when it moves things forward.

Original Mike বলেছেন...

"I doubt Trump sees his hate of his opponents as an imperfection."

I hate the scum who did this too. And I don't consider that an imperfection; I consider it a reasonable response.

Original Mike বলেছেন...

"His opponents tried to kill him, you fucking imbecile."

Yes they did.

n.n বলেছেন...

It's on Trump. He's not required to take a knee to men. If he's right, there will be a positive outcome. If he's wrong, his fate is sealed. He advises people to follow Christ, and that message was reinforced by Charlie.

#HateLovesAbortion

Inga বলেছেন...

“I hate the scum who did this too.”

Trump used the word “opponent”. If he meant that he hated the killer, it would’ve been more understandable, but he used the word opponent. He again vilified and denigrated people on the left, half of the US. “Radical left lunatics”, Trump stirred the shit pot of hate at a memorial for pity sake! Ugh.

Beasts of England বলেছেন...

‘His opponents tried to kill him, you fucking imbecile.’

History begins anew each day for the left.

n.n বলেছেন...

Hating your opponent is an imperfection. Self-defense is also an imperfection. Some imperfections are less imperfect than others. There is no commandment that requires people to take a knee to other men, but rather an imperative to strive for principled reconciliation. Is that plausible, is that probable, time will tell. Denying the fitness of reality is not a good faith opening. So, Trump is not wrong.

Breezy বলেছেন...

Radical left lunatics haven’t exactly shown love for Trump, or Kirk. The reason we voted for Trump was because he knows how to fight these lunatics. Calling them out at a memorial service was/is an easy troll-trigger it appears.

n.n বলেছেন...

Trump knows his enemy... opponent and himself.

Inga বলেছেন...

“His opponents tried to kill him, you fucking imbecile. If you wanted to encourage him to have concern for your well-being, maybe you shouldn't be supporting the people who did that.”

No, his “opponents” did not try to kill him. Why do you assume every person on the left supports assassination? You see, this is where you folks have gone too far. You are too immersed in hate to see what you’ve signed onto. Half of the US will not just stand there and accept blame for Kirk’s death, no more so than half of the US not accepting blame for the death of Melissa Hortman and her husband and the shooting of John Hoffman and his wife.

There is a very dark feeling that is coming from the right. You are showing the hate we on the left always knew was there. I am under no illusion that the POTUS has any concern for half of the US.

Wince বলেছেন...

Inga said...
He again vilified and denigrated people on the left, half of the US. “Radical left lunatics.”

Trump didn't "vilify and denigrate people on the left, half of the US" as “radical left lunatics.”

You just did.

Original Mike বলেছেন...

"Hating your opponent is an imperfection."

Only if you're a believer. I can respect those who turn the other cheek. I am not compelled to emulate them.

Inga বলেছেন...

“Trump didn't "vilify and denigrate people on the left, half of the US" as “radical left lunatics.””

Oh yes, he certainly did. Weren’t you listening to his speech at the memorial?

“Trump noted at one point that Kirk referred to his political rivals as “the left,” adding that he preferred the term “radical left” or “radical-left lunatics.””

https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/5515013-trump-attacks-opponents-charlie-kirk/

Original Mike বলেছেন...

"Why do you assume every person on the left supports assassination?"

Not every person, no. But a lot.

Beasts of England বলেছেন...

The resolution for Hortman passed unanimously. The resolution for Kirk had 96 Dems vote nay or abstain. The hate from the left is quantified and documented.

Maynard বলেছেন...

I really do not need to read Igna's posts to know that her hysteria is acting up again.

Of course, she knows what Mueller knows.

Larry J বলেছেন...

Inga said
“No, his “opponents” did not try to kill him. Why do you assume every person on the left supports assassination?”

Because we hear so much hate from Leftists. “Every” is a strong word, but like with lawyers, 99% of Leftists make the rest of you look bad.

How many people were murdered because of Charlie Kirk’s murder?
How many riots took over place because of Charlie Kirk’s murder?
How many buildings were looted, burned, or occupied because of Charlie Kirk’s murder?

We are not the violent ones…but that can change quickly if the radical Leftists aren’t reined in. And we’re the side with a lot more guns and veterans who know how to use them.

Inga বলেছেন...

“How many people were murdered because of Charlie Kirk’s murder?”

How many people were murdered because of Melissa Hortman and her husband’s murder?

“How many riots took over place because of Charlie Kirk’s murder?”

How many riots took place because of Melissa Hortman and her husband’s murder?

“How many buildings were looted, burned, or occupied because of Charlie Kirk’s murder?”

How many buildings were looted, burned, or occupied because of Melissa Hortman and her husband’s murder?

Leland বলেছেন...

Are you trying to incite people to riot against Tim Walz appointing Melissa Hortman's murderer?

Inga বলেছেন...

“We are not the violent ones…”

January 6th disproved that.

Original Mike বলেছেন...

Let me guess; gophers are responsible for the Minnesota murders.

Peachy বলেছেন...

Jan 6th - who was killed - Inag?

Peachy বলেছেন...

You are such a liar - Inag.

n.n বলেছেন...

I am not suggesting to "turn the other cheek". An imperfection may be of self, other, or circumstance. We have the capacity to judge and choose our action.

Inga বলেছেন...


“Let me guess; gophers are responsible for the Minnesota murders.”

🐿️ gophers or possibly rabid squirrels.

Mason G বলেছেন...

"No, his “opponents” did not try to kill him. Why do you assume every person on the left supports assassination?"

I didn't say "all his opponents". "Every person on the left" are words you're using to construct a strawman.

Do you agree that someone who tries to kill you is your opponent? Yes or no.

AMDG বলেছেন...

Erika Kirk and Marco Rubio were speaking at a funeral. Trump was speaking at something akin to the Paul Wellstone celebration which is credited with electing Norm Coleman to the Senate.

Peachy বলেছেন...

Inag - your corrupt evil vile party tried to kill trump, bankrupt him, and imprison him. All based on lies. You and your vile party can fuck right off.

Oso Negro বলেছেন...

Inga - at this moment 9 of the 35 responses to this post are yours. Do you ever think you should keep it to yourself?

Oso Negro বলেছেন...

I would rather image that Democrats are more like Stephen. You make it difficult

Inga বলেছেন...

“Inga - at this moment 9 of the 35 responses to this post are yours. Do you ever think you should keep it to yourself?”

Oh don’t worry, Peachy will surpass that soon enough.

n.n বলেছেন...

January 6th was a Pelosi-rrection with elements of Whitmer conspiracy. A woman escaping a police-induced riot was summarily aborted in a prone position, in cold blood. Another was kicked while lying incapacitated on the ground, no longer viable. There were self-abortions thereafter while citizens were incarcerated indefinitely, under threat of witch hunts, warlock trials, affirmative actions of American civil liberties unburdened, a chilling effect, an Arctic Frost, a first-order forcing of catastrophic anthropogenic climate change.

Original Mike বলেছেন...

You know who doesn't think Melissa Hortman's murderer was of the right? The media. These murders quickly disappeared from their pages.

Peachy বলেছেন...

"Catch this, fascist"
Is leftist.
Indisputable leftist.
- inspired by the non-stop "every MAGA is a Fascist" talk we hear day in and day out from top democrats in power and in the media.
His parents and friends said he shifted left.
There will be more.

Peachy বলেছেন...

The leftist assassin lives with a furry trans.

Peachy বলেছেন...

Inga - still waiting for you to provide the J-6 Trump quote that inspired all those FEDs in masks to instigate the crowd in front of the Capitol.
"You must go into the capitol" says fed. you must.

Quayle বলেছেন...

Inga: "You see, this is where you folks have gone too far."

The "you folks" is the tell. The true sin is in manifest in the division of people that one carries in your head. This is the line of good and evil. Those that say "you folks" versus those that say "we all."

What is the truth? We all go too far, Inga. I work hard against my 'natural man' instincts to never see "you folks", anywhere. I try always to see "we all."

Quayle বলেছেন...
এই মন্তব্যটি লেখক দ্বারা সরানো হয়েছে।
Paul বলেছেন...

Inga, I do not hate my opponents... but I do study them to know how to defeat them if they try to harm me or the people around me. I believe in Christ but I also study Sun Tzu and Go Rin no Sho.

Quayle বলেছেন...
এই মন্তব্যটি লেখক দ্বারা সরানো হয়েছে।
Peachy বলেছেন...

Inag cannot stand that anyone criticize her precious evil party.
A party that assassinates.

(No different from any other dedicated party cultist.)

Inga বলেছেন...

“What is the truth? We all go too far, Inga. I work hard against my 'natural man' instincts to never see "you folks", anywhere. I try always to see "we all."”

Did the left blame ALL right wingers for the death of Melissa Hortman and her husband like the right is blaming ALL the left for Charlie Kirk’s murder? You can’t possibly say you haven’t seen the numerous comments by Achilles and others here who blame the ENTIRE left for Charlie Kirk’s death?

Original Mike বলেছেন...

"Did the left blame ALL right wingers for the death of Melissa Hortman…"

Nobody's buying it, Inga.

Beasts of England বলেছেন...

Just a few days ago Inga and several of the lefties here were - against all logic - desperate to claim that Kirk’s murderer was on the right.

Jim at বলেছেন...

It was shocking hearing the POTUS spout such dark shit at a memorial.

Yeah. Shocking the guy doesn't like the people who are trying to kill him. Just shocking.

Take your outrage and shove it.

Jim at বলেছেন...

Trump was speaking at something akin to the Paul Wellstone celebration which is credited with electing Norm Coleman to the Senate.

Paul Wellstone was assassinated by a conservative? I must've missed that.

Some services are more equal than others, I guess.

Oso Negro বলেছেন...

Maybe Althouse can just do a daily "Special for Inga" post and you can use it like your very own blog. A compendium of wit and wisdom so attractive to comment that Althouse will soon wonder why she didn't create it years ago.

kcl766 বলেছেন...

Inga, you could post 10 times more than Peachy and I will still skip yours to read hers. She makes sense. You are a leftist moron.

Mason G বলেছেন...

"Maybe Althouse can just do a daily "Special for Inga" post and you can use it like your very own blog."

More copy & paste crap from Gemini? Cool.

MikeD বলেছেন...

I'm disheartened as our hostess did not once express any personal support/tribute/or disagreement with Charlie Kirk's life or denigration of his murder. BTW, I don't accept saying another's celebration of his life was "good" talk is anything but today's Schumer on commie Mahndami weasel words.

Kakistocracy বলেছেন...

Charlie Kirk's funeral was an uneasy blend of mourning and fascism. It was also such a weird mix of cult and multi-level marketing.

Sweet mourning pyrotechnics though!

Mr. D বলেছেন...

You can’t possibly say you haven’t seen the numerous comments by Achilles and others here who blame the ENTIRE left for Charlie Kirk’s death?

Achilles speaks for Achilles. Beyond that, speaking for myself, I don't blame you for Charlie Kirk's death. I do note that you and many (not all) people on the left have been singularly ungracious on this topic. No one on this board is likely to change your worldview.

Jim at বলেছেন...

You can’t possibly say you haven’t seen the numerous comments by Achilles and others here who blame the ENTIRE left for Charlie Kirk’s death?

You - and others like you - keep peddling this lie.

We are not blaming the ENTIRE left for Kirk's murder. But to deny the constant vilification and outright hatred - thus creating the environment where the assassin felt it necessary to act - there must be some culpability on your part for creating it.

In addition and to make it crystal clear, I'm going to bold this so there's no mistake.

We are calling out the thousands and thousands of leftists who celebrated his murder.

No, they didn't pull the trigger. They're orgasmic because somebody else did.

Got it?

Inga বলেছেন...

“I do note that you and many (not all) people on the left have been singularly ungracious on this topic.”

I guess you don’t remember me trying to comfort the grievers here with a few Bible verses that comforted me at the time of my son’s death. I never said one word against Charlie Kirk and I made a point of acknowledging that he was much loved by people here and elsewhere. I don’t know where you ever saw me being ungracious, except maybe for rejecting blame put on the entire left for Kirk’s death.

Peachy বলেছেন...

The left in a nutshell

Mark Nielsen বলেছেন...

Beasts of England said: "Just a few days ago Inga and several of the lefties here were - against all logic - desperate to claim that Kirk’s murderer was on the right."

Yes, maybe I just missed it, but I was anxious to see if Inga would officially apologize for pushing the "Groyper" fantasy and admit the fact (obvious to most of us from the earliest hours) that the shooter was motivated by leftist sentiment.

No, not all of our fellow-citizens on the left are to blame for this, but anyone who stated, repeated, or reposted anything about Trump being a fascist or a Nazi should think hard about their contribution to the cause.

Peachy বলেছেন...

Russia Russia Russia + the other Soviet-like lies - come home to roost.
Especially after your party assassinates people.

Peachy বলেছেন...

After the Mar-a-lago would be Trump assassin assassination attempt was thwarted. Inga ran out of the gate with fake manufactured links and fake facebook posts of a young man NOT the suspect. She was screaming like she always does - the the perp was a REPUBLCIAN.

Prof. M. Drout বলেছেন...

I lack the ability to understand how anyone could possibly find pasting unoriginal copy-pasta into a blog comments section to be a fulfilling activity. Unfortunately, the combination of cheap crappy "AI" and disseminated talking-points/prompts has seemingly made creating the comments take almost as little effort as scrolling past them does.

I've been reading this blog and its comment section for over 20 years because that has been interesting and enjoyable. I've been commenting a little here and there over the last few years because writing MY OWN ideas down is both fun and good intellectual discipline. Maybe pasting is just one of those hobbies that outsiders just don't get, but to me it just seems like such a waste of a person's time.

একটি মন্তব্য পোস্ট করুন

Please use the comments forum to respond to the post. Don't fight with each other. Be substantive... or interesting... or funny. Comments should go up immediately... unless you're commenting on a post older than 2 days. Then you have to wait for us to moderate you through. It's also possible to get shunted into spam by the machine. We try to keep an eye on that and release the miscaught good stuff. We do delete some comments, but not for viewpoint... for bad faith.