१८ ऑक्टोबर, २०२४

At the Al Smith charity dinner — Trump was there, and Kamala Harris was not.

There were far more Democrats than Trump fans there, but Harris stayed away, though they let her appear as a pre-recorded video (in which she off-loaded the comedy to Molly Shannon, who deployed her old SNL Catholic schoolgirl character, and I couldn't hear any laughter in the room). 

Trump sat there — between Melania and the Cardinal — and laughed at gibes from Jim Gaffigan, who plays Tim Walz on SNL. Gaffigan is funny — and Catholic — and he handled his task well. Scroll to 2:25 to see him step up to speak as the camera pans to Donald Trump, who knows he's going to get kicked around and is sitting facing the audience, with only the Cardinal and Chuck Schumer between him and Gaffigan. But he knows he's not the one who chickened out and he knows he's going to get the last word.


Here is my selection and ranking of Jim Gaffigan's Top 7 jokes:

7.  "This room is is undeniably impressive... the prestige, the wealth, the allegations. I mean, wow, and don't feel bad if you don't have any allegations yet, okay, which reminds me Letitia James is here. She had a great year. She's just back there watching all of you. She's watching."

6. "This event has been referred to as the Catholic Met Gala. 22% of Americans identify as Catholic. Catholics will be a key demographic in every battleground state. I'm sorry: Why is Vice President Harris not here?... This is a layup for the Democratic nominee. I mean, in her defense I mean she did find time to appear on 'The View,' Howard Stern, and the long-time staple of campaigning the 'Call Her Daddy' podcast."

5. "You have to admit the Democrats have done an amazing job rebranding Vice President Harris.... The term 'Joyful Warrior' was used so many times at the Democratic Convention. I felt like I was at a yoga retreat. Let's start off in a Joyful Warrior pose and then go straight into Downward-Facing Doug."

4. "I watch that [video appearance of Kamala Harris]... I couldn't help but think of: Now I know how my kids felt when... I FaceTimed into a piano recital."

3. "I don't know if you've heard about these people who publicly say they would never vote for Trump, but then when they go in the voting booth, they do. It's a small group. They're called the Biden family."

2. "Joe Biden was our second Catholic President, right after JFK. President Biden couldn't be here tonight. The DNC made sure of that."

1. "The Democrats have been telling us Trump's reelection is a threat to democracy. In fact, they were so concerned of this threat, they staged a coup, outed their democratically elected incumbent and installed Kamala Harris."

AND NOW: Here is my selection and ranking of Donald Trump's Top 7 jokes comedic riffs:

7. "A major issue in this race is child care, and Kamala has put forward a concept of a plan.... The only piece of advice I would have for her in the event that she wins would be not to let her husband Doug anywhere near the nannies. Just keep them away. That's a nasty one. That's nasty. I told these idiots that gave me this stuff, that's too tough."

6. "When I heard that Kamala was skipping the Al Smith Dinner, I'd really hoped that she would come because we can't get enough of hearing her beautiful laugh. She laughs like crazy. We would recognize it anyplace — in this room."

5. "You can't do what I just saw on that screen, but my opponent feels like she does not have to be here, which is deeply disrespectful to the event and in particular to our great Catholic Community.... The last Democrat not to attend this important event was Walter Mondale, and it did not go very well for him.... Shows you there is a God.... I understand the real reason that she's not here is she's hunting with her running mate — spending a lot of time hunting...."

4. "It's a true pleasure to be with you this evening — amazing pleasure... really a pleasure to be anywhere in New York without a subpoena.... Anytime I don't get a subpoena, I'm very happy. They've gone after me. Mr. Mayor, you're peanuts compared to what they've done to me. And you're going to be okay."

3. "All polls are indicating I'm leading big with a Catholic vote. As I should be. But I don't think Kamala has given up yet.... Instead of attending tonight she's in Michigan receiving communion from Gretchen Whitmer."

2. "If Democrats really wanted to have someone not be with us this evening they would have just sent Joe Biden."

1. "A good job tradition holds that I'm supposed to tell a few self-deprecating jokes this evening, so here it goes. Nope, I've got nothing I've got nothing. There's nothing to say. I guess I just don't see the point of taking shots at myself when other people have been shooting at me for a hell of a long time. They shoot, right? You know, they say about presidents, they say that Andrew Jackson was the President that was the most meanly treated. His wife died, she died of heartache. She was heartbroken at the way they treated him. And they say that second was Abraham Lincoln, but he was in charge of the Civil War, you know, so but those were the two... up until me. Now, they say it's not even close. There's never been a president that's been treated so badly as me. And now, people aren't happy about it, but I was treated a little bit rough, but I don't mind it somehow, and I think it's just part of the game."

८० टिप्पण्या:

Kate म्हणाले...

I would rank "Downward-Facing Doug" a lot higher.

Goetz von Berlichingen म्हणाले...

It was interesting seeing Gaffigan slamming the Democrats. He's been known to have recurring TDS, so this is a big switch. Some folks onlline suggest that JG had a moment of enlightenment when Joe Rogan shared with him all the evidence of Federal collusion in the Jan6 events.

Kamala's video was awful; the mostly-Democrats audience refrained from laughing and what applause there was at the finish was, to my ears, restrained.

Trump's line about the White Guys for Kamala not worrying him was the best line of the night.
MfG
Goetz von Berlichingen

Breezy म्हणाले...

Aside: Whoever was driving the camera there did a terrible job.

tim in vermont म्हणाले...

Kamala told us just last week that the only reason that a campaign would hide away its nominee would be to hide the nominee's weakness and unfitness for office.

Aught Severn म्हणाले...

Ranking the Gaffigan quotes in order of chuckles, from most to least, on my initial read through, I got: 4, 5, 1, 2, 3, 7, 6

tim in vermont म्हणाले...

The entire argument that it was impossible that J6 was a false flag relies on the belief that the United States is built on "magic dirt" where the same techniques that ruling classes have used to manipulate populations for thousands of years can't happen here.

Once you concede the point that it's possible, you have to look at the evidence, and well, we all know where that leads, and it's not to a Harris victory, so we aren't going to concede the point.

Eric the Fruit Bat म्हणाले...

Jim Gaffigan laid down some first-rate material but I have to admit I was surprised to see RFK, Jr. sitting next to that actress from Modern Family.

KJE म्हणाले...

The proverbial emperor cannot stand to be the brunt of humor; it reminds everyone once again that they have no clothes.

Aught Severn म्हणाले...

That Letitia James quote reminded me of Roz from Monsters Inc: I’m watching you, Wazowski. Always watching. Always.

rehajm म्हणाले...

Letterkenny, too…

Big Mike म्हणाले...
ही टिप्पणी लेखकाना हलविली आहे.
Big Mike म्हणाले...

As usual, Victor David Hanson summarizes perfectly:

Instead, [this election] has become a larger contest between those who talk down to their fellow Americans and those who are increasinglsick and tired of being lectured.

I think Gannigan’s joke that Althouse labeled #1 reflects that a bit.

Iman म्हणाले...

That was Griselda Blanco, you idiot!

My name goes here. म्हणाले...

Trump's jokes were good. Someone else wrote them because he was reading them and he sorta flubbed one or two on delivery.

Observant people would conclude at least two things from this. Trump allowing someone else to write for him, and his non-ad libbing are an indication that he is much more disciplined this election cycle.

The fact that his jokes were the best of the night indicates that his campaign has managed to find good talent and let them do their jobs. Something the Wizards of Smart have told me relentlessly never happens.

rehajm म्हणाले...
ही टिप्पणी लेखकाना हलविली आहे.
rehajm म्हणाले...

Jokes about Daddy Warbucks are a sign its time to step off the stage…

Krumhorn म्हणाले...

I liked Trump’s line that after he wins, Schumer still has a shot at being the first woman president. The line about the White Men For Harris was outstanding!

- Krumhorn

rehajm म्हणाले...

Trump’s quip about the teleprompter fell flat but holy carp! don’t you think some dolt told him he couldn’t use the teleprompter in hopes it would trip him up, as if Kamala’s fatal flaw was also Trump’s?

Leland म्हणाले...

It is nice to see bipartisan ability to laugh at jokes.

A&L म्हणाले...

no Kamala doesn't get a participation trophy

MartyH म्हणाले...

I'm sure Gaffigan studied Walz closely as prep to play him on SNL. Gaffigan probably realized what a knucklehead Walz really is and adjusted his perception of Harris and the Democrats accordingly.

Yancey Ward म्हणाले...

I still find it astonishing that Harris would dodge this event. I can't think of any other explanation other than that she is afraid of being mocked to her face. The Democrats should have sent Biden in if Harris wasn't going to make an appearance in person.

RideSpaceMountain म्हणाले...

Trump wasn't afraid. He's got showbiz experience and he's been roasted several times before. Harris has been roasted too. Spit-roasted.

Tina Trent म्हणाले...

The cowardice of Harris did not help with Hispanic Catholics.

Shoving Molly Shannon in their face. A twofer.

Kate म्हणाले...

I think she had no idea what the Al Smith dinner was and she (or her ignorant staff) turned it down. After realizing what a mistake she'd made, she doubled down.

Or, she's an anti-Catholic bigot.

Narayanan म्हणाले...

I would have advised Harris could have shown up in sari and dot mark forehead to dare catholics

Dude1394 म्हणाले...

Very nice event. I loved the joking with Mayor Adams about how they are coming for him for daring to talk about immigration. And the joke about men for harris was hilarious.

Dixcus म्हणाले...

His dig at Kamala getting oral - Lesbian Dorito Communion - from Gretchen Whitmer was off the charts.

Jersey Fled म्हणाले...

I thoughtTrump was much funnier. He’s not a polished stand up comedian, but he does have a good sense of humor. And he read his lines with conviction. Kudos to his writer also.

Martin म्हणाले...

You have to participate to get one of those. She literally mailed it in.

clint म्हणाले...

Bad enough she sent a video, but how tone deaf do you have to be to feature SNL's anti-Catholic caricature in your video for a Catholic audience?

RideSpaceMountain म्हणाले...

"Their wives and their wive's lovers will be voting for me" - Trump

That was one of the best "Don't talk to me or my wife's son ever again!" style jabs I've ever heard.

gilbar म्हणाले...

why is ANYONE surprised Kamela didn't show up?
i'm Sure her handlers forbid her.. they Did serve free drinks at the event didn't they?
imagine (just imagine) Kamela "joking" after an hour of free drinks?

Disparity of Cult म्हणाले...

Shannon had the other character, the joyologist, but no joy left in this campaign.

wildswan म्हणाले...

Just wanted to let the Dem commenters know about an opportunity. The offer below was made to me but perhaps Rich or Inga would have been more interested. (Only the name has been changed to XXXX protect the innocent.)

" Hello XXXX, it’s Carl from WI Neighbor Network.
This November, we have a pivotal opportunity to defend our democracy and protect our freedoms. Harris and Walz are key to revitalizing the middle class and restoring reproductive freedoms nationwide. Your voice is crucial, and we’d love for you to help us make a lasting impact
As a Community Mobilizer, you can safeguard our democracy from the comfort of your home—and earn $250+ simply by talking to friends and family about voting. 🗳️
Here’s why you should get involved:
✅ Flexible, work-from-home role
✅ Quick, easy online training
✅ Earn money while standing up for our future
Ready to make a difference for Wisconsin? Let’s keep our democracy strong. Are you with us?
Reply STOP to opt-out.

I also got a text message, allegedly from a "former Trump voter in Wisconsin," a Christian. He will not be supporting Trump any more because Trump has divided the country. End of text. The phone number has an Arizona area code. So you see how easy it is to get that $250, your share of the $1 billion raised by Joyjoy Harris, the well-known Dem joytoy puppet.

NorthOfTheOneOhOne aka Doug Emhoff's Pimp Hand म्हणाले...

I think it's more to do with attendance at such an event setting off her pro-abortion, pro-Hamas base than bigotry.

Phaedrus म्हणाले...

I watched the whole thing on Fox. Didn’t intend to, just happened to switch over to watch Gutfeld and just rewound to the beginning to where it started in Hannity’s slot.

Honestly, I kinda think Gaffigan might be a Trump supporter. He had some glancing blows on Trump but he was pretty hard on the crowd and vicious with Harris.

Two things that made me lean into that more than just the light jibes at Trump (3 if you count ommissions)
He was exceptionally gracious about Melania
His joke on himself about his career on how he jokes about Trump was spot on
His omission(s) of election denial/Jan 6 is interesting.

I doubt that’s the case but he did very. Very good. I’m really looking forward for you Top Trump jokes

Leland म्हणाले...

"She literally mailed it in." Did she? It is a charity event. Did she at least mail in a check?

Ice Nine म्हणाले...

I kept waiting to get a belly laugh out of Gaffigan - never happened. He was occasionally mildly amusing. What I liked about him was that he pointedly abused Harris much more than he did Trump. Sort of like what is done to Trump all the time. The turnabout was a refreshing surprise.

Democratic Paychecks for Perks/ Dems for Demolition of Democracy/ fake-cares 4-U म्हणाले...

wow. 3 and 1... lolz.

Democratic Paychecks for Perks/ Dems for Demolition of Democracy/ fake-cares 4-U म्हणाले...

She yelled "Donald Trump" so many times in the Bret Fox interview - she had no voice left.

Will Cate म्हणाले...

Gaffigan was great, and Trump crushed it.

Kamala apparently thought it'd be a good idea to make fun of Catholics, in her phoned-in video clip. Another fine example of how her campaign makes every bad decision possible.

Michael म्हणाले...

The Dem candidate for President doesn't attend the Al Smith dinner? WOW. That's like the Pope phoning it in on Easter Sunday.

Democratic Paychecks for Perks/ Dems for Demolition of Democracy/ fake-cares 4-U म्हणाले...

The collective hivemind left love lecturing and lying... lying and lecturing.

Drago म्हणाले...

Trump explicitly mentioned how the jokes had been written for him and made comnents about that which were also amusing.

RideSpaceMountain म्हणाले...

Sadly, the current "pope" is just that kind of guy.

gspencer म्हणाले...

Heels-Up could easily have made this event. Her excuse that she was busy “campaigning” was an obvious falsehood since her appearance would have given her an opportunity to reach/campaign to millions, far surpassing the number of voters attending her "previously scheduled event." What she feared was embarrassment to her delicate ego.

tommyesq म्हणाले...

Agreed. Molly Shannon? Was Phyllis Diller not available?

AMDG म्हणाले...

Or it could be that he is a comedian who goes where the jokes are.

JES म्हणाले...

I can't listen to Trump, but he looked good, even like a nice human being. Maybe even presidential. Made my heart feel a little lighter.

Original Mike म्हणाले...

My favorite part was watching Bloomberg absolutely stone-faced while Trump was speaking. Some of these people act like middle-schoolers.

tommyesq म्हणाले...

Gaffigan reminded me of Ricky Gervais at the Oscars.

traditionalguy म्हणाले...

NYC is Trump’s briar patch. He’s spent 60 years making friends there and beating enemies there. Maybe Kammie was wise to avoid that community.

AMDG म्हणाले...

Harris is an anti-Catholic bigot. She questioned the fitness of a judicial nominee because he was a member of the Knights of Columbus.

tommyesq म्हणाले...

Trump's #2 was brutal (and very funny)!

tommyesq म्हणाले...

By the way, was it just me or was the Harris "skit" filmed in front of a green screen just like her current boss filmed things in a fake "Oval Office" set? Is anything real with the dems these days?

Mason G म्हणाले...

"restoring reproductive freedoms"

Because "maintaining existing freedoms to avoid reproducing" isn't nearly as catchy, or what?

Democratic Paychecks for Perks/ Dems for Demolition of Democracy/ fake-cares 4-U म्हणाले...

Love it. I'm glad Trump mentioned the Mayor of NYC. He is being rail-roadbed by the same corrupt Merrick DOJ/a-hole FBI cretins.

Democratic Paychecks for Perks/ Dems for Demolition of Democracy/ fake-cares 4-U म्हणाले...

The corrupt left plan on cheating. So why would she need to bother?

Sydney म्हणाले...

I think she's both an anti-Catholic bigot and afraid of offending her pro-abortion base. When she was AG in California she went hard after the people who made the undercover abortion videos showing Planned Parenthood selling baby parts.

Earnest Prole म्हणाले...

Now that’s a happy warrior.

Michael म्हणाले...

Trump was good, but the all-time masters at the Al Smith dinner were Reagan and Clinton. They both new how to deliver a line.

rhhardin म्हणाले...

Trump is mocking his own jokes. Charisma at work.

Yancey Ward म्हणाले...

I was thinking the same thing watching Trump's bit just a few minutes ago- he can't hold a candle to either Reagan or Clinton.

AlbertAnonymous म्हणाले...

He ripped into Shumer too. “Chuck, your party’s so woke. Don’t worry, if Kamala loses you can still be the first woman president Chuck”

Big Mike म्हणाले...

No one was treated as badly as Trump since Honest Abe Lincoln? Everyone in Washington hated Dick Nixon except his family (and I’m not so sure about Pat).

RCOCEAN II म्हणाले...

I thought Joke 3 was funny.

Its insulting the way kamala doesn't campaign or give tough interviews (except one). But I guess 'muricans don't care. Has she talked to the editorial board of the NYT/WaPo - or are we past the fiction these people are objective? She wont attend this dinner because she's too busy. Busy doing what? She's VP and she's not campaigning. At least Joe Biden had an excuse, he was senile.

Michael म्हणाले...

I assumed the "Downward Facing Doug" was a reference to Walz being a total bottom.

RCOCEAN II म्हणाले...

And of course She's an anti-Catholic bigot. She's an anti-Christian bigot. How many practing Catholics has she known in her life? She went to Howard and UC in San Francisco. And lived in the Bay area. She probably knows more poeple who are IV positive than practicing Catholics. She's certainly gone to more Jewish Sedar's than Catholic Masses.

RCOCEAN II म्हणाले...

Speaking of Anti-Catholic bigots. Just read a book that showed that in 1960 both Eleanor Roosevelt and Truman were against JFK being POTUS because he was Catholic. All the stuff about Joe Kennedy and being too young was just cover for the real reason. They shared that between themselves, and didn't make it public for obvious reasons. Suprising No?

rhhardin म्हणाले...

In a statement, Ammar Moussa, rapid response director for Harris's campaign, said: "Donald Trump struggled to read scripted notes written by his handlers, repeatedly complaining that he couldn't use a teleprompter.

"He stumbled over his words and lashed out when the crowd wouldn't laugh with him. The rare moments he was off script, he went on long incomprehensible rambles, reminding Americans how unstable he's become. And of course, he made it all about himself."

Yancey Ward म्हणाले...

Damn it, rhhardin- you are pre-empting Inga's comment coming later today.

rhhardin म्हणाले...

Trump is at a higher level. He's mocking the assumptions backing every lecture, that there's something to be learned that you don't know that can be learned by listening. He mocks in service of the ordinary. It's Trump at the black barber shop when he's at the Al Smith dinner.

David53 म्हणाले...

My favorite Trump joke,

"There's a group called 'White Dudes for Harris' but I'm not worried about them at all, because their wives and their wives' lovers are all voting for me."

The rule of Lemnity म्हणाले...

My favourite Trump joke I heard this morning on the radio: it’s good to be in New York, anywhere in New York without a subpoena to appear.

Glenn Howes म्हणाले...

I laughed out load at Gaffigan‘s saying Mayor Adam’s was brought to you by Turkish Airlines. I don’t think Trump was particularly funny, he is much more an ad lib speaker.

Glenn Howes म्हणाले...

Also, there were shots of RFK Jr and his wife being what appeared to be genuinely affectionate and I hope it was genuine, both of them have had a lot of external and internal stress put on their marriage and I’d like to think marriages work out.

Milwaukie guy म्हणाले...

I loved Trump's routine. "Everyone" hated Nixon but Nixon never faced a Schedule F "Resistance," two impeachments and ruthless lawfare, etc.

The rule of Lemnity म्हणाले...

👆🏽 Leland for the win.

Eva Marie म्हणाले...

When Trump was doing the Schumer joke he reached out and gently shook Schumer’s shoulder. Only Trump could do that. What an amazing person.