४ डिसेंबर, २०२२

"The idea that human rights encompass a right to self-destruction, the conceit that people in a state of terrible suffering and vulnerability are really 'free'..."

"... to make a choice that ends all choices, the idea that a healing profession should include death in its battery of treatments — these are inherently destructive ideas. Left unchecked, they will forge a cruel brave new world, a dehumanizing final chapter for the liberal story."

Writes Ross Douthat in "What Euthanasia Has Done to Canada" (NYT). 

I'll put the next sentence after the jump because it's a surprising change in topic (but I bet you can predict it if you know how these things go these days):

For anyone on the right opposed to Donald Trump and the foulness around him (most recently at his Mar-a-Lago dinner table), the last six years have forced hard questions about when it makes sense to identify with conservatism, to care about its direction and survival.

Donald Trump! What does he have to do with Euthanasia in Canada? 

Euthanasia in Canada... it made me think of "Trout Fishing in America," and I felt wistful about the old days when everyone loved books by Richard Brautigan. 

I searched his name in the New York Times and came up with his obituary, from 1984, which has a funny/sad mis-scanned headline: "RICHARD BRAUTIGAN, NOVELIST, A LITERARY IDOL OF THE 1060'S." 

Richard Brautigan, a literary idol of the 1960's who eventually fell out of fashion, was found dead Thursday at his secluded house in Bolinas, Calif. The Marin County coroner's office reported that the author of ''Trout Fishing in America'' and ''So the Wind Won't Blow It All Away'' apparently died of a self-inflicted gunshot wound four or five weeks ago. He was 49 years old.

''He told everybody he was going away on a hunting trip''....

[T]he sincerity and the disconnected, elliptical style that so charmed critics and readers... eventually began to pall. For example, reviewing ''The Tokyo-Montana Express,'' a Brautigan novel published in 1980, Barry Yourgrau, a poet, wrote in The Times Book Review, ''He is now a longhair in his mid-40's, and across his habitually wistful good humor there now creep shadows of ennui and dullness, and too easily aroused sadness.''

Fishing, hunting, killing yourself.

Here's the memoir written by his daughter, Ianthe Brautigan: "You Can't Catch Death."

Must I get back to Douthat and his linkage of Canadian euthanasia and American Trumpism? It's become a joke the way everything gets connected to Trump, but euthanasia?! Have we reached peak Trump Derangement Syndrome yet? Or... I guess peak Trump Derangement Syndrome would have you relocating to Canada... relocating to Canada and embracing the Canadian freedom of offing yourself medically. Medically, not with a gun, guns being so... so... right wing.

I think Douthat's point is that Americans need conservatism — real conservatism, his kind of conservatism — to fend off Canadian-style freedom to abscond from life itself.

५५ टिप्पण्या:

wendybar म्हणाले...

They are killing off people. They want to kill off a Veteran because she complained about how long it was taking to get a stair lift installed at her home. Progressives are mean, nasty, hateful ghouls. They have euthanized people for loneliness, homelessness, and mentally disabled. Abortion is accepted as normal, so now they are going after the living. What do you expect, when Bill Gates says they want to extinguish 10-15 percent of the population?? That's why the vaccine is their salvation!!!

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11497589/Paraplegic-Canadian-veteran-says-government-caseworker-offered-euthanasia.html

Ann Althouse म्हणाले...

I wrote "I felt wistful" before I dug up the obituary and made a excerpt that happened to contain the word "wistful" — "his habitually wistful good humor." I only noticed the reappearance of the word after I put up the post.

I'm also noticing "He is now a longhair in his mid-40's." Back in the 80s, people from the 60s seemed quite old if they were in their 40s.

I remember when I crossed that line into my 40s. Now, my younger son is about to cross that line. And I feel much younger now (to quote a 60s line).

gspencer म्हणाले...

"... to make a choice that ends all choices, the idea that a healing profession should include death in its battery of treatments — these are inherently destructive ideas."

Yet we are endlessly told that ABORTION is health care!!!

Jefferson's Revenge म्हणाले...

Yo me the first sign that you crossed the line is needing reading glasses. I remember one night we were at a restaurant with 2 other couples, all about 42 to 45 years old. We got the menus and suddenly 4 of us realized we were having a hard time reading them. One person had reading glasses (readers) that he passed around. In our supreme confidence in our eternal youth, none of us had considered needing such a contraption in our lives before.

It was our first realization that the life arc had flattened and was starting to turn in the wrong direction. Look out below!

Mr Wibble म्हणाले...

The "real conservatives" failed utterly to stop the advance of euthanasia throughout the western world, or even turn back the growing socialization of medicine here in the US. Their failures are why the base voted for Trump.

Douthat can blow it out his ass.

Dave Begley म्हणाले...

Humans consume fossil fuels.

Fossil fuels are destroying the planet.

Ergo, suicide is a good thing and will save the planet.

Another old lawyer म्हणाले...

Douthat has always been a columnist who could be counted on to write something unexpected and thought-provoking. Increasingly the thoughts provoked are of a different nature, though.

Mr Wibble म्हणाले...

I'm also noticing "He is now a longhair in his mid-40's."
-----

The song "Old Hippie" keeps coming up in rotation on my Pandora station and there's a line about, "he turned 35 last Sunday, in his hair he found some gray..." that's hitting me hard now that I've just turned 40.

Kevin म्हणाले...

Progressivism: if you don’t like it, go kill yourself.

Howard म्हणाले...

Douchehat isn't wrong. We need a responsible conservative party that keeps the left in check. Getting rid of the svengali criminal conman traitor is the key to our return to normalcy.

James K म्हणाले...

Then there is this story:
Canadian veteran suffering from PTSD and a traumatic brain injury was offered EUTHANASIA when he called Veteran Affairs Canada hotline for help

Baceseras म्हणाले...

Commercialized suicide. For starters, here's an ad for enders -- in the disconnected, elliptical style. Eventually? It begins to pall. Soon enough, when everyone is presumed to be comfortably numb, the foulness around it will creep out of the shadows. The fish doesn't feel the hook. So we are tolled.

BUMBLE BEE म्हणाले...

I would say the staggering number of abortions demonstrates Ross Asshat's cold, brave new world has been around awhile, and the democrats own that.
I'm so old, I remember when abortions were for cases of rape and incest. Likely as many Gosnells out there as pregnancies from incest.

michaele म्हणाले...

Talk about an example of false advertising...it should not be believable that a person who is that loved and embraced (figuratively and literally) by so many others would not have those friends and family fight for her continuing to live. This is brain priming to encourage the acceptance of suicide as something to celebrate.

Mike Sylwester म्हणाले...

Richard Brautigan went to high school in Eugene, Oregon -- where I likewise went to high school, but at a different time and school.

After his death, the Eugene newspaper published a feature article about his life. His mother still lived in Eugene, and so the reporter had interviewed her for the article.

What I remember about the article is that Richard Brautigan disdained his mother. He left home right after high school and never communicated with her again -- despite her attempts to communicate with him.

In that part of his personal life he was not a nice, charming guy.

I used to see that book in bookstores all the time, but I never bought and read it.

gilbar म्हणाले...

there are Many studies, showing that progressive people have more mental illness than others
there are Many studies, showing that progressive people have more depressed than others
there are Many studies, showing that progressive people are about 15% of the population
there are Many studies, showing that 15% of the population NEEDS to be removed. For the Common Good
there are Many studies, showing that mentally ill, depressed people would be happier dead

I'll let the reader draw their Own conclusions

Mike Sylwester म्हणाले...

"that book" = Trout Fishing in America

NorthOfTheOneOhOne म्हणाले...

Euthanasia In Canada was headlining at CBGB's back in 1982.

Mr Wibble म्हणाले...

We need a responsible conservative party that keeps the left in check. Getting rid of the svengali criminal conman traitor is the key to our return to normalcy.

I want a party that actually advances the issues I care about, not simply "keeps the left in check." Doing the latter means treading water until things are good again, at which point voters will vote you out of office in favor of leftwing promises, and the ratchet continues to slowly turn every leftward.

Kirk Parker म्हणाले...

"What do you expect, when Bill Gates says they want to extinguish 10-15 percent of the population?? "

What I expect is that he's lying and his true target is an 80-95% die-off.

RideSpaceMountain म्हणाले...

"Left unchecked..."

Why yes. Yes it is.

Temujin म्हणाले...

As a college student, and, I confess, again today, I was and am an unabashed fan of Richard Brautigan. I had a writing prof in college excoriate me once for turning my writing into a 'junior Brautigan style' and that I needed to find my own voice. Yikes. That stuck with me.

Even today, I have an old copy of "Revenge of the Lawn" and "Trout Fishing in America" on my bedside table (along with many other books) to just browse through when I feel the need to read that style of creative prose.

I remember it didn't surprise me when he was found to have killed himself. His life had not seemed happy, though his books did generate millions of smiles.

Anyway, I'd rather think about Brautigan and those books than talk anymore about Trump, or euthanasia becoming the next hot thing in Canada.

I remember when our Canadian friends were the free and common sensical ones in North America. Happy, friendly, and loving of freedom. Did a former snowboard instructor change all of that?

William म्हणाले...

I read a couple of Brautigan's books, but there's nothing from them that sticks in the memory. I looked him up on Wiki. He had a terrible childhood: poverty, abandonment, abuse, neglect. To be wistful about anything after such a childhood is a triumph of the will......Euthanasia is a slippery slope, but intractable pain in the midst of a terminal illness is a conveyor belt that many people would just as soon hop off.

Dear corrupt left, go F yourselves म्हणाले...

Anyone and everyone (center left and left) who write for a living in the political sphere - must disavow Trump first, to prove bonafides, and virtue signal to their usually leftist base of readers. (and shed the ick)

ie:

"First - get this straight -I hate Trump and everything he stands for.. blah blah blah - but conservatives have a point on this issue."

Andrew Sullivan does it ALL. THE. TIME.

Part of it is cowardice. Some of it is the fact that Trump is such a political dick-stepping klutz - it is understandable. But make no mistake, it's predictable. Trump sharing a dinner table with complete nutters makes it even easier for writers to disavow.

Kate म्हणाले...

As is often the case, Douthat won't confront the truth. Getting old is miserable. Caring for someone elderly is difficult. The old one is ashamed to be a burden, and the younger ones are overwhelmed by the task. That suffering has an inherent worth -- general, regular, not agonizing -- must be admitted by society. Douthat knows this, so his elitist bowing is even more despicable to me.

Carol म्हणाले...

Years ago my brother was so exasperated at my father's longevity that he said people should be ready to check out at 80 latest.

Well brother is 83 now and not going anywhere soon.

They're all so cavalier when it's far in the future, or someone else.

Bob Boyd म्हणाले...

"The sun was shining on the sea,
Shining with all his might:
He did his very best to make
The billows smooth and bright —
And this was odd, because it was
The middle of the night…”

Michael म्हणाले...

Well there is a connection. Perhaps when Trump wins again the lefties will actually move to Canada to end their suffering.

Bob Boyd म्हणाले...

Fishing, hunting, killing yourself.

Have you noticed, no one ever kills themselves with a fishing pole? Not even in Canada.

Lem Vibe Bandit म्हणाले...

I will admit here and now: I've had the thought of Trump getting what Reagan got at the hands of Hinckley, so that Trump would recover and sail to the White House once again via the Fetterman sympathy vote. The obvious problem with that is sympathy for Trump is like sympathy for the devil... the devil we know. It's a bridge too far.

Lem Vibe Bandit म्हणाले...

btw. The first sentence led me to believe this post was to trans or not to trans, that is the question.

Tina Trent म्हणाले...

Douthat's GOP betrayed and belittled the base on every one of our key issues: immigration, crime, public education, political correctness' suppression of speech, religious freedom, and reverse discrimination.

Meanwhile, he and peers vacuumed Conservatism Inc's big bucks to sow divisiveness and lies, to humiliate and demoralize people who do the real work to preserve a real conservative agenda. We have quite a few of these types in Georgia, such as embittered former Lt. Governor Geoff Duncan and the erstwhile, though seemingly improving Erick Erickson (we'll see if he submits to AFP's big cash infusion designed to control his messaging and silence any discussion of illegal immigration on his show).

Who euthanized conservatism? Douthat and the greedy, lying whores like him. I'd like to see him disclose every dime he's made from the CfG's ideological liars and all their tentacle peers, from National Review to George Mason.

Michael K म्हणाले...

Howard as usual. Getting rid of the svengali criminal conman traitor is the key to our return to normalcy.

You lefties voted for "normalcy" in 2020 and got your ideal governing junta. Don't tell me you are disappointed with Brandon and his crew of Harvard grad students. Economics was not their, or your, strong suit. Now, as we hurtle down the path to disaster in the name of a scam called "Climate Change" are you having second thoughts? Tell us how you got through Winter next spring.

Tom T. म्हणाले...

I think the point of calling him a longhair in his forties was not just that he was getting older, but that he was still trying to hold on to the ways of a young man, rather than accepting the inevitability of change.

I can understand why someone from an abusive childhood would cut off contact with his parents. It sounds like he never fully got away from that old pain.

Gospace म्हणाले...

Euthanasia in Canada... it made me think of "Trout Fishing in America," and I felt wistful about the old days when everyone loved books by Richard Brautigan.

So much reminds me of the quote by Pauling Kael, which is a litle different then what most thing it is: "I live in a rather special world. I only know one person who voted for Nixon. Where they are I don’t know. They’re outside my ken. But sometimes when I’m in a theater I can feel them.”

Were it not for this post I'd have gone through life not having a clue who Richard Brantigan was. I don't have to ask my wife- I'm certain the same is true of her. Except she doesn't read Althouse so will continue on in ignorant blss unaware of his existence in this world.

As for his cutting off contacts with his parents, so what? Not all that uncommeon. A significant number of enlisted men are running away from home in a socially approved manner. I doubt there's a CO who hasn't during his career had a congressional inquiry letter "Mr. and Mrs.Smith haven't heard from their son...." The one I was assigned to answer as a career counselor we called Seamn Smith in, talked to him, and all we found out was he wanted no contact, and no, wouldn't explain why. And that's the letter the congresscritter got back. Contrary to popular belief we cannot order a family reunion, much less a happy one.

In a similar vein I haven't had any contact with my sister in more then 3 decades. If she chooses to reestablish contact, well, maybe I'll consider it. I was done on my part more then 3 decades ago. I google search her name every few months to see if I can find an obituary,

n.n म्हणाले...

Elective abortion, self-abortion, in darkness, is indeed his or her Choice. State sanction, celebration, elation is a progressive path and grade.

Yancey Ward म्हणाले...

Ross Douthat can go fuck himself sideways. "Real Conservatism" has conserved literally nothing in the 56 years of my life, and nothing appears to be changing for the better.

Lurker21 म्हणाले...

Yes, time was when you couldn't walk into a bookstore and see Trout Fishing in America, In Watermelon Sugar, and The Confederate General From Big Sur on the shelves. The Abortion: An Historical Romance 1966 came out a year or two before Roe v. Wade. I never read any of them.

I do wonder, though, why Brautigan isn't better remembered. It seems as though all of the postmodernism writers have been celebrated for over the last 50 years was already there in the Sixties and Seventies. From the descriptions of Brautigan's books, maybe David Foster Wallace was rewriting them only on Adderall?

Strange times. I still remember my young self going to the local bookstore in those years and seeing not only much Brautigan on the relatively empty shelves but also, there next to Mao and Ho, a volume of Joseph Stalin's works.

cassandra lite म्हणाले...

My favorite Brautigan book was Sombrero Fallout: A Japanese Novel. Read it multiple times.

Thanks for being reminded of him and passing that on.

Clark म्हणाले...

"In watermelon sugar the deeds were done and done again as my life is done in watermelon sugar."

I had an English teacher in high school who loved Richard Brautigan. I came to really love his writing, even while being aware that it could easily be dismissed as not serious. Thinking of it has triggered a nostalgia attack!

Anthony म्हणाले...

William said...
. . .Euthanasia is a slippery slope, but intractable pain in the midst of a terminal illness is a conveyor belt that many people would just as soon hop off.


Yeah. . . .I'm conflicted. People in that situation should be able to do it. But it will be thoroughly abused.

Larry J म्हणाले...

Under socialized medicine, doctor assisted suicide starts as a choice but ends up as an obligation. Health care is expensive, but life-ending medication is cheap. It all comes down to money in the end.

Sebastian म्हणाले...

"The idea that human rights encompass a right to self-destruction, the conceit that people in a state of terrible suffering and vulnerability are really 'free' . . . these are inherently destructive ideas. Left unchecked, they will forge a cruel brave new world, a dehumanizing final chapter for the liberal story."

Hey Ross, what do you mean, "left unchecked"? On what basis would they be checked? Who would do the checking? Who besides some uncouth deplorables wants to check anything? "Human rights" have no limits. Progs recognize no limits. Their philosophy cannot produce any limits. Never enough is their motto. Hence, destruction.

"Donald Trump! What does he have to do with Euthanasia in Canada?"

Everything. Douthat illustrates the dynamic of the destructive ideas he claims to lament. His compulsive need to involve Trump demonstrates prog hegemony: eager to be taken seriously by progs as he criticizes the evil they foster, he must involve Trump as the greater evil.

Narr म्हणाले...

What a tiresome noob is Douthat, and I always found Brautigan unreadable.

Suicide to me is like abortion or other forms of violence: generally regrettable, but sometimes it can leave the survivors better off.

As for staying in touch with family, a lot of lives would have been a lot better in my family if my older brother and his pathetic wife had never existed, or had the decency to try to make it on their own and left us alone.

Brian McKim and/or Traci Skene म्हणाले...

My high school honors English teacher pushed Brautigan on me. It's one of the reasons I despise poetry.

Leora म्हणाले...

Based on the opening lines I thought he was going to talk about allowing the mentally ill to live on the streets. I stopped reading the man because of his TDS sometime in 2017.

Euthanasia is the end point of utilitarianism.

JK Brown म्हणाले...

Socialist always get back to their belief that people are like cattle

Free Thoughts interview [How Mao Broke China (with Frank Dikötter) Oct 2019]

18:00 Frank Dikötter: The key point about the Great Leap Forward is really… I mean, Li Rui, Mao’s secretary, put it… He passed away earlier this year, wonderful man, I think he lived to the age of 100. He said it in a review of Mao’s Great Famine, my book, he said, “The core reason of all this is because human beings didn’t treat other human beings like human beings, they were treated just like cattle.”

Misinforminimalism म्हणाले...

Did someone say Trout Fishing in America? Throw 'em out the window!

https://youtu.be/hNoXsV2X7bs

Misinforminimalism म्हणाले...

Did someone say Trout Fishing in America? Throw 'em out the window!

https://youtu.be/hNoXsV2X7bs

Joe Smith म्हणाले...

They can all kill themselves as far as I'm concerned.

But they are really nice and are good at hockey, so I will miss that.

n.n म्हणाले...

Self-abortion like elective abortion like murder generally happen in darkness. While we cannot reasonably prevent their occurrence, civilized society has compelling cause to discourage their progress.

Mikey NTH म्हणाले...

"Gas the Geezers" - a progressive plan to save pensions and health care monies. The worn out useless eaters will be culled for the greater good.

It's Progressive!

Kirk Parker म्हणाले...

Brian and/or Traci, William:

"When you take your pill
it's like a mine disaster.
I think of all the people
lost inside of you."

The title poem from The Pill Versus The Springhill Mine Disaster.

Rollo म्हणाले...

Sometimes "humane" or "humanitarian" policies are only adopted because they are convenient or profitable for those in power, or because those in power just want to show that they have power.

P.S. Let me know when you have a Rod McKuen retrospective and reevaluation.

glacial erratic म्हणाले...

Six degrees of Kevin Bacon.

One degree of Donald Trump.

Trump wins.